I want to be a singer and this is making me apprehensive about hrt
So I've been singing for a while and have decided that I want to make it my career. I'm a tenor and I've been told my voice is very pleasant for male lead roles in musicals (as a little brag, Catherine Zeta Jones may have told me that I could be in Dear Evan Hansen), but if I transition I want my voice to be female. The problem is that I value my career over my transition and am worried if I even think about transitioning, I'll ruin any shot I have of going anywhere in music. Are there any trans singers you could show me or any resident trans vocalists who can either tell me not to worry or is it fine to value other things above transition if you believe they will give you happiness?
Posted Jan 1, 2019, 9:29 PM UTC
25
How is your range? Can you handle an alto range well without strain? T-blockers and estrogen won't change your voice at all. I still have a wonderfully deep bass range when singing, and have learned to only talk with the upper vocal chords, similar to head voice singing, to get closer to an androgynous range. Without surgery, that's as good as it gets.
All the best female singers, IMHO, are low altos, anyways.
So the total of my vocal experience is my freshman year I was a "bass" (talked in my fry which kept my passaggio around D4 or D#4), started getting private vocal lessons from my choir teacher who has since improved my voice to having a good tenor mix with basically no break in my voice when I'm fully rested and a very nice mix that goes to about C#5. I've still kept my bass range and on a good day I can get down to about D2 or lower. My falsetto gets up somewhere in the whistle registers but I don't use it up there and it's not usable range. So I basically have a usable range (something I don't strain and still sounds enunciated) from about E2-C#5 across various registers. The problem I guess is that I don't sound feminine in my opinion and that's what I'd be worried about most. After that, it's more about me wanting to be a musical theatre performer and the only real way to get leads these days is to be a soprano and the most feminine I can get is mimicking Carolee Carmello, which isn't that bad but I want to be someone like Barrett Wilbert Weed or Kara Landsay.
To make all that rambling short, I have a large range, but it does not sound stylistically consistent and feminine enough for the field I'm studying in college and I worry that if I transition, I won't be able to get cast as a woman with a masculine voice. This is essentially the one thing really keeping me from wanting to go the HRT route for a transition rather than living androgynously because if I can't do music as a profession, I think that'd be the worst thing to me. Even more so than living as a woman or androgynous to be able to be fluid like I want.
I mean, if that's the only concern, go on hrt when you can't get parts anymore? It sounds like you already know that music and the stage outweigh transitioning right now, for you.
Okay. I guess I just needed someone to tell me that valuing my dream career over my gender identity, at least right now, didn't devalue me being trans of some sort. It's really hard to dissect through your own thoughts with something with barely any readily available info that you end up convincing yourself of really harmful things. Thanks for helping me for the last couple hours haha
Sure, hopefully my answers weren't too terse, but it helps to break things down to what is most important, then go from there. You already seem to have that down, it's just a question of order. You got this!
Hopefully you'll find someone in industry that can speak more to that experience. Go slow, think, and realize no decision is initially permanent, and HRT can wait until you are ready!