Is there progress on building a completely decentralized mesh network to replace the internet?
Everything I've seen that tries to decentralize the internet is built on the backbone of the centralized internet with projects like IPFS or CJDNS. The closest thing I could find to an actual mesh network is The Serval Project and that's only for calling and texting.
Is anyone working on creating a mesh network that can be deployed from any device? If not, why?
Posted Jan 1, 2019, 10:51 PM UTC
It's technically Extremely Challenging. Largely because Android is kind of a $@$#&#&# of an OS in some ways, and seems to ACTIVELY GO OUT OF THEIR WAY to keep us from using ad-hoc mode. Wireless needs a ton of bandwidth.
And at the application level, almost everything decentralized still kind of sucks. A lot. It's all blockchain oriented crap that doesn't perform well, or it's got some horrifyingly bandwidth intensive aspect, or it's not really decentralized, it's just federated and still has a single point of failure for any given user. There's a few good apps for special purposes, but not all that much.
We need some actually practical for average consumers apps before anyone is going to care about decentralized anything. Secure scuttlebutt literally doesn't let you delete your posts.
Sure, Facebook deletion doesn't stop anyone who saved a copy, but it's better than nothing and probably more important to the average user than fancy encryption stuff. We all know Facebook isn't private. We use it anyway because it's convenient, and because privacy isn't really everyone's top ethical concern.
If you found a random person on the street, odds are they want nothing to do with Ethereum, Filecoin, Bitcoin, or anything like that. They probably don't even use PGP, encrypt their disk, or turn on Do Not Track in their browser (I don't use any of those). No way are they going to want to deal with a cryptocurrency.
If you lose the private key, it's unrecoverable by any known means. If you lose a debit card, you get a replacement. Often at no cost, because banks understand that kind of thing happens sometimes.
And on top of that, fiber optic is REALLY fast. Decentralized tech has the best chance of success if it can use any available means of connection, including ISP fiber.
That said, there's already very practical and easy to use stuff for small scale meshes out there, so long as it doesn't have to run directly on Unrooted Android.
I still very much like the idea of decentralized applications though. Just not for the same reasons a lot of people seem to.
I think the larger part of this problem is that ad-hoc networking doesn't a) guarantee sufficient enough clock synchronisation between stations, especially across different IBSS, to ensure that nearby devices don't cause unnecessary disruption on a given channel and b) there aren't really many good ways with IBSS to select the best channel given a set of neighbours.
Apple did some really interesting work in this field - AWDL (the thing that powers AirDrop and Multipeer Connectivity etc) is quite a complicated beast, which uses well-known "social channels" to advertise and discover other services using multicast DNS-SD, and then uses some method for nodes to agree on and switch to a lesser occupied channel for actual data transmission. They also use some specific multiplexing to stop AWDL devices from "jamming" a channel. The only downside to this approach is that it only works on certain Wi-Fi chipsets that support operating across multiple channels, e.g. monitoring one and broadcasting on another.
I think Android is starting to pick up support for a thing called "Wi-Fi Aware" (or "Wi-Fi NAN"), which is actually heavily based on AWDL, because it's a much better and much more sustainable approach than ad-hoc/IBSS. It's just dependent on vendors to support it and for devices to be built with the right Wi-Fi chips.
Speak for yourself. I closed my Facebook account years ago.
Never had one from the start
Same. I tried it for a week when FB was clearly going to replace Myspace. I saw people I previously respected proudly displaying the very worst of human behavior out in the open, saw the site as a sterile, poorly designed mess, and the company itself as being untrustworthy with private information with no means of profit but to sell their users data. I still can't figure out how there are enough people using this example of awful dotcom-era dipshittery for it to have survived this long. None of its leadership knows what the hell they're doing, the company and its policies are a disaster, most of their user base is dead, no part of it makes any damn sense.