Suggestions for .357 subs and supers for hunting rifle?

Howdy! New loader here. I've ordered the RCBS Supreme kit and a few other goodies, but I'm still doing plenty of research before I order the actual components for my loads. I'm open to suggestions for primers, powder, and pills. I have a Ruger M77/357, cut and threaded at 16.5" to be run with a Liberty Mystic X suppressor. I've run some 158-grn 38 Spl through it, and this gun is SILLY QUIET.

I'd like to develop two loads for small-medium game and pest control. One subsonic, one supersonic and about as hot as it can safely run. Ideally, I'd use the same bullet and powder for both rounds. I'm thinking 180-200 grain. The feed ramp on the M77 doesn't like wadcutters or flat-nose, and I've seen some round-nose and spitzer rounds intended for 35 Remington that look interesting. As a hunting/pest control round, accuracy is obviously as important as knock-down power. Anyone have suggestions?

Posted Jan 3, 2019, 3:41 AM UTC

215
Paladin308•

You're probably not going to be able to use the same powder for sub and supersonic loads, especially not from a rifle, not if you want them different enough to be worth having two loads. You'll be better off picking powders specific to each load.

3
what-the-frack•

For your hot load look into H110 powder. Be sure you don’t under load it though.

I have a lever action that I’ve worked a load up for with this powder, and it’s very nice. I can’t remember much about to load, but it’s in most of the manuals you can get. I had some life events over the last 4 years and haven’t been able to shoot as much as I’d like so it’s been 2-3 years since I’ve loaded these up. 357 is a great round to hunt with and it’s very versatile.

2
squigz7•

I'm not sure what hunting/pests you're shooting, but based off what you're looking for; Sierra has tournament master bullets that are 170 and 180 grain that would fit the bullet profile for feeding. I don't have my Sierra book handy, but I'm sure that there is ample data available for those bullets with many different powder choices. If you need expansion in the bullets you can go to their JHC (Jacketed Hollow Cup) or JSP (Jacketed Soft Point) in 158gr range. These will fly the same, JHC will give you all the expansion you need where the JSP will penetrate much deeper.

As far as choice of powders, w296/h110 are great for higher velocity, but DO NOT down load them, they're made to function best with a fuller case capacity as mentioned by others. Normally recommended to shoot this powder with a magnum pistol primer, but for a 357 with a narrower case column, you can get away with a standard primer.

2400 is great for mild to wild loads, unique is good for lower pressure loads, w231 is a favorite of mine to shoot low velocity loads, HS6 is good for mid level. Again, these are suggestions from previous experiences, I'm not sure if they're even book valued in Sierra; so take it at your own risk.

2
TryCoseriousOP•

That’s just what I was looking for, squigz! Thanks!

I had already been leaning towards 2400, as I’ve seen it mentioned as a versatile powder. H110 might also be good for the supersonic loads.

As far as intended targets, I’m mostly looking to take out the raccoons and coyotes that pester my rabbits. We’ve also had occasional hogs sniff up to the edge of the yard, and I wouldn’t mind taking a shot at one from the luxury of indoor cover.

If I get decent results from the hotter loads, I’d consider using them for our little Florida deer at close range.

1
EugeneNine•

I am looking at doing something similar. I want a load for Hornady XTP that I can also use the same powder for a (slower) lead bullet so I can just carry a handful of bullets and powder to the farm with me. H110 works for a fast load but doesn't have any slow load data. Accurate #9 looks like it might work http://www.accuratepowder.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/WPHandloading-Guide-7.0-Web-REV.pdf page 26.

If you using two different powders then you can find plenty of slower non-magnum powders and loads published.

I got good results with H110 and if I can get close with the #9 for the xtp fast load then I'll test it next with a slower load.

2
TryCoseriousOP•

That’s helpful, thanks!

1
jraxiomatic•

The long barrel really speeds up .357mag

factory 125 grain federal run over 2000 fps in that rifle

I think i have chronographed 158 grain flat nose around 2200 fps

the slow twist will give trouble with subsonics, especially in the heavier grain bullets

seems the higher ballistic coeficient is the more prone to tumble subsonic

I would load plated semi wadcutters or wadcutters in 38 special brass for subs and you might end up using trailboss.

I use a 125grain plated hollowpoint from berrys and a near starter load of hp-38 (LEAD DATA) to get 1250 feet per second in that rifle (800fps in pistol) with a 38special case and normal COL

its like a big .22

I don't have a the barrel threaded and I like the accuracy so I just kept the load

​

the 357 rounds do impact 3.5 inches higher at 50 yards than the 38 special.

2
HumidNutonly a little KB...•

Ok, OT, but who did you get to do the threading? Did they keep the front sight ?

1
TryCoseriousOP•

Local gunsmith, took off the front sight. I only intend to run it with the scope.

1
HumidNutonly a little KB...•

Gotchas. I don't have a good smith available, so after some research, going to use a guy recommended from some of the ruger forums. Services would be cutting back the barrel and moving the rear sight.

2
TryCoseriousOP•

Nice. I almost kept the front sight.

If you’re near the Tampa Bay Area, I can pm you the name of the smith I recommend. It’s a fun gun!

1
HumidNutonly a little KB...•

I'm a bit further north, I'm afraid. Any leads on those 35rem spitzer bullets, I'm curious as well, but didn't have anything constructive to lend to the conversation.

1
poapratensis•

First I would take the suppressor off. It's going to complicate things.

Seconds I would dispense with a rifle that won't work with flat nosed bullets--they have the best performance on game.

I've hunted whitetails with 357 mag rifles for a decade. It's highly effective, but I have always used semiwadcutters or roundnose flatpoints or jhps.

0
TryCoseriousOP•

I appreciate the input. I can talk to my smith about working on the feed ramp if it looks like I need to stick with a flatter-nosed bullet. I’m curious though how the suppressor complicates things?

1