Starting again, but a question for the community

I'm excited to start playing regularly again, it's been a long time. I used to play almost daily from 2001 to 2004. I could get through all of the 9s, and cleared some 10s (apparently the difficulty is measured differently now?) DDR is what got my into a lot of things later in life, breakdance, DJing, swing dance. Every now and then if I come across a machine I'll give it go (I drew a small crowd at the Santa Monica Pier, that was exhilarating, but my old man body and tar filled lungs were exhausted after playing one 9). But my city is lame and the only machine around is a PIU machine recently put in to one of the barcades. So I decided to order a pad and get back into it. It's on the way, I'm excited.

​

That's all just backstory for the main question of this post though. As someone with moderate interest in competitive gaming, as a spectator more so than a participant, I took a look at some videos. Just a thought for discussion, but I kinda feel that using the bar, and the game even moving in the direction of difficulty requiring the bar, destroys the appeal for non-players to enjoy watching. Now I know in my time using the bar was frowned upon and this is a different time, but the game doesn't look like a dancing game anymore. Watching someone spin for ULDR just feels more exciting to watch than toe heel on the corners of the pads while leaning back. Cross over's, gallops, spins. Without the upper body movement they just don't look the same. And by not the same, I mean, not as "cool".

​

So my question ultimately is, do you think the now regular use of the bar has taken away the appeal to the game for the general public?

​

I honestly think the game would be in a better place in terms of popularity if instead they pushed doubles and maybe added some more degree of accuracy to make it harder to get perfect scores to make the game competitive instead of just cranking the speed of play.

Posted Jan 4, 2019, 1:04 AM UTC

315
gtcIIDX•

Started so strong then ended up making this another bar debate post, yikes.

I'd suggest you try out Dancerush Stardom, sounds more like your type of game.

13
billchase2•

I just discovered that on here tonight. Looks awesome!

1
trek5900•

The game has the tightest windows of any traditional arcade rhythm game in the marvelous window, so accuracy doesnt need to be messed with. Get a few Marvelous full combos on harder songs and then you can say that the game needs a change in that area.

On the bar, people don't really care what the people watching think about using the bar or not using it. People who enjoy playing the game aren't going to sacrifice their enjoyment of the game because the general public likes it. No one is forcing anyone to use the bar, and no one is forcing anyone to play singles.

12
avcueOP•

I'm all for people playing how they want. I'm not gonna crap on the guy playing on a controller because he likes the music, more power to him. I'm saying that making the bar the standard in the competitive scene may diminish the communities ability to draw in new players.

​

When kids walk by someone playing on a machine, they'd be less enticed to give it a shot themselves if it doesn't look cool. And this game has the potential to do that, but the standards have been set in a way that it's just a less appealing as an observer than it could be.

5
yahooeny•

You are not getting the point. The bar became the standard because people stopped caring about how they looked to looking in the outside and playing while holding the bar is objectively the most efficient way of playing the game.

We are not the ones that need to charge, you are the one who needs to get out of 2001.

10
avcueOP•

I'm just making a suggestion of how the game could gain more popularity, and by extension give people more places to play due to demand. No need to be an asshole.

2†
burndtcaek•

Maybe if Konami didn't have a ridiculous policy of only selling new DDR cabinets in orders of 50 minimum or something we'd see the game be more widespread. Or maybe a new home version that's arcade-true or at least close to it. These are things that would boost popularity, this matter with the bar is a non-issue tbh

9
KitTheKatz•

People think it's cool either way. Doubles look cool no matter how you play them. Bar use is standard now because it's not rational to use on harder songs. Not only is it super draining, it looks weird as hell in many cases, and new timing windows make no bar accuracy a pain.

Doubles are great with no bar, though IMO. Since you aren't locked in place, you look more smooth and quick, rather than looking like some guy having a seizure. Stamina is the same with or without the bar in my experience.

Anyways, if Konami stops being a pain and just allows single purchases, cabinets would be more widespread. More people playing doubles could attract a few people. When I play PIU or DDR, it tends to make only little kids want to play. Then they start a song and run away. Kind of a waste, but it happens so much. :/

10
implode573•

DDR is bigger now than it ever has been in the past decade. Using or not using the bar won't affect that. The people who dismiss people using the bar as less exciting to watch all around just aren't really interested in the game. The same kind of thing happens with any niche competitive activity. We don't need to put arbitrary restrictions on how we enjoy the game just to possibly make others more interested.

5
jkas641•

In my arcade, PIU attracts more casuals than DDR but I’ve hardly seen anyone play no bar... so really for me bar usage in either game is not so much of a pressing issue

3
billchase2•

I’m in a very similar place as you. Played a bunch back in like 1999-2003 and want to get back into it. I also remember the “cata” days with 9 and 10 step difficulties and have no idea what the new scoring means. Back then, bar holding was definitely frowned upon and people were typically laughed at if they were using it.

I agree with you. The game has changed quite a bit as back then, they were challenging dance competitions. People would spin and dance and doubles were awesome to watch. Now, it’s mostly super hard and requires so much technical ability that you’re no longer dancing. It’s still fun to watch in a way of course (and is very impressive), but it’s more intimidating for a spectator. They’d probably be more likely to try it out if they were just watching someone having fun.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
coldcaption•

I think it's just down to what the players want to do to enjoy themselves. Personally I play without the bar because I enjoy it, the physicality is fun, and it's how I've always played. I may have to give it up when I start playing 18s, we'll see how that turns out. That said, I can't say for sure what people will find interesting to see.

I think the untrained eye finds a lot of movement interesting, yes, but as a no bar player I mind the physical technique aspect more than I notice other people do. Not a lot of people manage their momentum and weight placement or footwork too nicely, but those players might also create more visual interest. (I'm also not saying I'm the world's top no bar player, but after enough years of it you figure some stuff out) Frankly, I think a lot of mid-level players who use the bar (people who top out at 12s or 13s) would develop some good techniques sooner if they tried playing songs without the bar now and then.

Of course, nowadays we have Dancerush (well, as long as you go to a round1) which I think realizes the original idea of DDR in a much better way. Of course, both games are a product of the time they were created, but that's why I think they coexist so nicely. Dancerush is a real crowdpleaser, I know in my case I draw a lot more interest playing it than I do playing DDR. The way people watch Dancerush feels a lot like they way they would watch DDR players in, like, 2005. The way Dancerush takes over the "dance" aspect lets both games do what they do much better, so as DDR continues to push more and more into the end of technical dance gaming, Dancerush satisfies the fun of actually dancing.

1