Little Devil Zoe edit feedback request (not finished yet, would like feedback on how to make it better/cuter/etc)!

Art

I'm certainly no professional artist and frankly, well..., I kinda stink if I have to start from nothing (but I really love to take sketches people have done, in this case u/Lokk1t 's Little Devil Zoe sketch they posted on this sub at this link: https://www.reddit.com/r/zoemains/comments/acixzk/little_devil_zoe_concept_sketch_i_did/ , which obviously it's currently on the front page so you can't miss it but never the less, and edit them in my own way while paying homage to the original (not straying too far from the original if at all).

Little Devil Zoe edit by me (Original Sketch by Lokk1t, edited with permission): https://imgur.com/a/HldH31b

NOTE: It's not finished yet obviously but I'm not sure where to take the edit currently. Obviously some lines are jagged and overly THICC and colors on tail, some parts of hair, skirt, and top aren't ideal. may also make freckles more apparent. Planning to add fingernail with nail polish on finger. Shading could use better work. Heart of skirt is just slapped on... White background is not ideal. Etc etc. Point is it's halfway finished and I just want feedback - don't care about karma, if anything up-vote the original, just kinda confused on where to take this currently. Also no "movement lines" near the tail like the original BUT ANYWAY yeah suggestions?

Update
------

So, as it stands the following changes are going to be done.

Background: Burning forest

Hair: Cleaned up, Shading where need to be with burn tool (looks great from testing).

Eyes: Cleaned up, less thickness on eyes, blended colors in middle. Potential removal of checkered design (Purple inside Red Iris, Red inside Purple Iris) with just being a dark iris. Still keeping the black haze star-burst over the eyes, it's eerie and creepy and I really like it, can always release a version without it. Going to also thin out the lower part for the eye-shadow she's wearing. Finally, will add a touch of reflection from the fires (once I learn how to do so - must dig for YouTube for that, shouldn't be too hard to figure it out).

Skin: For the most part okay from feedback received here and elsewhere. Shading isn't perfect but I'm not perfect at shading so... :)

Tail: Consensus is to change the tip to dark purple and even change the other hearts to match.

Teeth: General consensus is for the one tooth to fit in line with general anime girl look, instead of devilish vampire as I have it now - which is totally fine as the original was going for the former anyway.

Other: Skirt needs slight touches of colors and top as well, as well as the general accents to the design from the original which I've left off in this WIP piece. Will need to add credits to the piece (a version without will be included) - with my name being smaller than the original persons. Finally, I've discovered her nose is in fact not a cat's nose lol so I have to fix that (and provide a version with said cat nose cause why not :D).

Lines: Lines are overly thick and shakey for ease of work-ability while this is a WIP (work in progress), they'll be changed for the final design to be crisp where needed using the line tool sets to fit curves and what not as well. Don't worry about that, I'm not an idiot it's just far easier to work this way for me so I can be pretty hectic with my ideas before solidifying them; some people are good enough to do it "right" the first time, I am not.

Thanks for ideas guys and girls, still open to suggestions mind you once I post the "final" version here. And honestly my idea is if we can get someone who is really talented to do their own version of it, I'd love that.

Posted Jan 5, 2019, 5:07 PM UTC · edited

3016
OCDkirby•

Background could be a burning village/forest, that would look amazing.

9
DerpPrincessOPTwilight Loli•

Do you have something particular in mind or?

1
OCDkirby•

Nah, just throwing an idea out there.

3
Neiyoh400,034 OTP•

What program did you use for the edit?

2
DerpPrincessOPTwilight Loli•

Photoshop

2
Neiyoh400,034 OTP•

So here's my thoughts:

​

Clearly you already know what needs to be updated and fixed about it, shading her hair is probably going to be one of the most difficult things on this piece in particular, I do enjoy the starbursts you added to her hair, they look good.

​

So a lot of the time eyes are what people spend the most time on, because they are what convey the most emotion in anime and cartoons in general, so I suggest looking up some references for different eyes and finding what works best. A lot of the time what works in black and white with pencil doesnt translate to color/digital art.

​

Another thing is notice that in the original drawing there is only one tooth out, that is a common thing in anime for younger girls and appeals to a 'cute' look.

​

Most of the rest of work that is needed will just come with you dropping time into it. Look into how to making glowing eyes as well if you do decide to put burning buildings in the background.

2
DerpPrincessOPTwilight Loli•

Thanks for this will edit more later (need nap) and look into how to do that. Can always remove the other fang would take about 5 seconds to do so, I know why they do it but just felt like a devil would have both fangs sticking out instead of just one but I’ll see what works for that once it is finished.

2
sauciestsaucepan•

My suggestion:

Save this as a .jpg, open a new Adobe Illustrator document, paste the jpg into the new document, turn down the opacity and lock the layer. Now, use the pen tool and trace over every line and be sure to keep everything organized. You will get a lot cleaner lines and it will be even easier than Photoshop to make alterations.

Need any help, PM me.

1
Deathstreet•

I like it ! Nj op

2
Explozivo12176What is the Air Speed Velocity of a Star•

So I feel like the nose and eye liner(?) are throwing me off. Like I get the nose you're trying to make it like Teemo's. Except Teemo is a Yordle and has that kind of nose to begin with while Zoe is a human so it sorta just looks like she has a bruised nose. The eye liner beneath her eyes needs to be thinned out a bit if you're using that cause it's just really off-putting. I like the color scheme of black, purple, and red but her eyes shouldn't be checkered. Like make her pupils black or a darker shade of the iris' colors. These are just my opinions and if you don't agree you don't have to comply, just keep that in mind and have fun and good luck!

1
DerpPrincessOPTwilight Loli•

Actually the nose is just from the original sketch, it’s supposed to be like that.

I can thin out things (the plan), I’ll try out multiple things for the eyes, I can always just use black for pupils but making them a darker shade sounds better.

I realize they’re opinions and luckily I can try out things quickly in photoshop (and can even release multiple versions of this) - thanks for your input!

2
Lokk1t•

Just to clarify, the shading in the nose area is supposed to be a shadow of the underside of her nose, its not like a cat nose or anything. I outlined the area before I shaded it in so it maybe doesn't come across as a shadow. Here's an example of what I mean: http://naruto.wikia.com/wiki/Naruto_Uzumaki?file=Naruto_newshot.png

​

Anyway probably my bad on visual clarity. TY for your work!

1
DerpPrincessOPTwilight Loli•

Honestly I thought it was a cat/teemo style nose based on your original sketch but I can totally fix that (but I also like how it looks like a cat nose haha) - You're welcome. I'm going to work on it some more soon just kinda got to get around to it.

2
Prometheus7568•

I would instantly get this skin, rito pls

1
ElSqicky•

Imo red colour of the tail tip don't really match rest of the skin, maybe violet would be better. For background I would go with some night or forest theme. I hope they reallt will add skin like that it's looks so awesome and cute.

1
DerpPrincessOPTwilight Loli•

I can try violet. Also going to do burning forest and add a slight red glow to the eyes (as a reflection) as suggested here.

1