r/bangtan•
minmang

Question for new BTS fans: First impressions

Discussion

It hasn't dawned on me until recently that there really are a lot of new BTS fans that are also new to kpop. Although BTS wasn't my first group bias, kpop definitely made an interesting impression on me (as someone who was a 1d fan years back) that kept me hooked long enough for me to discover BTS, as well as other amazing korean artists.

​

What are your first impressions of kpop fandoms in general, and if you're from an anything-western fandom (not sure how to call it) what are the similarities and differences you noticed? And how does it affect your involvement as an ARMY within the fandom? Do you think you would be willing to explore other artists or korean music, or just stay as an ARMY exclusively?

​

Interested in hearing your thoughts.

Posted Jan 7, 2019, 1:55 PM UTC

5341
tapdathoeHelp, I can't pick a bias•

I actually listened to Girl's Generation back in 2010/2011 (I guess when they first came out?). I remember finding the whole thing fascinating. The music videos were wild, there were SO many people in the group and I love a good choreographed dance. I didn't really stick with it because I really only liked one song (Run Devil Run). The rest was too bubble gum for me.

After that I found K-Pop pretty abrasive and that I was too old for it. But once I fell down the BTS hole, I was shocked by how much I actually loved their music and the visuals. They have so much variety to their stuff that I can literally find a song for any mood. What turned me from a listener to a rabid fan who now has a fuckin stan Twitter account is their personality. They're so humble and charming that it makes me want to support them in any way I can.

As for now, I don't think I want to explore anymore K-Pop. Loving BTS is really a full time job and I'm also annoyingly "loyal".

37
rdb42024meow meow btchez•

Wow, I can relate to this! I was into SNSD sometime in 2010 (I was in college back then) and particularly liked "Run, Devil Run" too! I also liked Sistar. But then I lost track.

God I can't believe I fell in love with Bangtan Boys so much that I cannot bring myself to look further into other kpop groups haha.

High five, OP! :p

3
tapdathoeHelp, I can't pick a bias•

Omg lmaooo. Yes I was in uni too and used Run Devil Run to study for my exams lmaooo. Twins!!

2
LastResort318Jungkook Memes•

As a new ARMY, I find that when it comes to BTS, a lot of their charm is their personality and story. With western singer and bands, it is almost solely based on music.

​

When it comes to Kpop fandoms, they seem to be really obsessed with those they like. This can go two ways, they obsession help supports those they like, but can lead to major problems with others who people start to see as enemies.

​

When it comes to me, I will occasionally listen to a song from another group. BTS remains the only Kpop group that I enjoy all their music and will support everything they do. I don't know why, but the language barrier bothers me with every other singer except BTS.

35
deep-thought42It's Jimin time•

When it comes to me, I will occasionally listen to a song from another group.

its been a year ^(it's been a motherfxckin year) and this is the same for me too... ive tried to get into other groups, and while i listen to some songs by other groups, im just not that into them... there are however a lot of solo artists i like, but i feel like that's still different, because i still don't follow them nearly as closely as i do bts

32
snakesareracist•

This is meeeeee I’ll listen to 1 song from another group but none has me hooked like BTS. I’m not a new kpop fan though cause I used to be really into SHINee just not to the same level.

5
WolfTitan99Jin's' yeongwonhi' in DNA•

Yeah thats ok you don’t have to force it, just have fun!

Sometimes it happens and sometimes it doesn’t. I don’t mind if people don’t get into Kpop as a whole and just follow BTS. But some new fans use the excuse of only following BTS to deliberately shun kpop music of any sort without listening to it, which is ironic considering where BTS came from and their nugu status from debut.

I suddenly fell head over heels for another group (Day6) after a year of not being able to get into ANY other groups, and it felt like falling for BTS all over again, and I honestly thought that would never happen.

I follow other groups super casually, and I only have 2 bias groups, but I respect everyone’s hard work in the industry!

4
deep-thought42It's Jimin time•

I suddenly fell head over heels for another group (Day6)

That's funny! I recently started listening to their music, because of Jae's twitter (and then his YT page as of last night lol)!! Yeah I'd probably look into them more, Jae's such a dork

2
WolfTitan99Jin's' yeongwonhi' in DNA•

Yeah Jaes the most relatable cause he’s from the US haha. I would recommend checking out the After School Club eps with Jae & Day6, had me dying!

I remember when BTS went on ASC in like N.O. era, they were such crackheads back then, even more so bc Vmin was full of THICC ENERGY at the time lol 😆

2
minmangOP늉기•

I really think that there's a lot of misconception about kpop fandoms and even fangirls as a whole. Describing them as "obsessed" is basically removing them of being capable of rationality, like they're crazy. One of the interesting impressions I had when I first got into kpop was that the fans really know how to organize themselves. And when I watched Reply 1997 I even learned that fan organizations went back as early as 90's kpop with the first gen idols. A lot of people misinterpret this culture as obsession. I didn't see this during my time as a 1dfan. Not a lot much discussion and organized events and activities going on back then.

When you think about it, even when they have fan wars a lot of times these never go as rabid as, say, a fight between sports fans. As an ex-1d fan these fanwars (both trivial and vicious ones) are not new even in western fandoms. There will always be bad apples and I think the best we can do is to surround ourselves with a community that's responsible and mature enough to know when to hold back.

Also! I'm not forcing anyone to listen to other kpop artists, you are free to do anything you want as long as its not offensive or degrading to others. It's just that kpop fans (mostly i-fans) are multifandom. I've heard a lot say that rise of BTS's fame is not really the rise of kpop's popularity in general, just BTS-pop. As someone who had seen BTS grow throughout the years, and see them progress both in their discography and their identity as a group and their individual selves, I've always seen them as artists AND kpop idols. And I've never really considered the possibility that there are people who perceive BTS as someone separate from kpop. Its pretty interesting.

6
FakeuLarbWishlist: Jin Arirang Solo•

I'm new to BTS, but not to Kpop. I've listened to artists like 2NE1, Psy, Big Bang, Oh My Girl!, f(x), Black Pink, Momoland, Wonder Girls, Red Velvet, Twice, 4Minute, Hyuna, CL, NCT, Park Bom, Winner, Girls Generation, and others for years. My favorites were 2NE1, Psy, Oh My Girl!, and Wonder Girls' last album. I didn't find Girls Generation or Red Velvet to be that good, oddly enough, but I still listened to a couple of their songs I enjoyed.

Despite listening to the music and watching videos, I wasn't into any fandoms. I typically found Kpop marketing and fan behavior a bit shallow and cruel. For example, there's a lot of shallow articles discussing nothing but idols' appearances, weight, plastic surgery, something they're wearing, etc...and those articles would also be written in a very rudimentary, meaningless way. What was even worse was seeing hatred against idols for alleged "drug use" and making fun of plastic surgery or weight gains. My impression was that idols are held to perfect, artificial standards, and some people felt glee at tearing apart these human beings. Additionally, I hated seeing things like Hyuna and Edawn getting punished by their label for having a relationship.

This is all part of the reason it took me a while to get into BTS. I didn't want to be a part of any fandom, because I saw how awful people, including production companies, could treat Kpop stars, and I assumed BTS was a part of that machine. It took me some time to understand that they're a lot more open and free to express themselves than other idols, and that while they work very hard, they're not emotionally or financially abused by their label as far as I can tell. I also appreciated that they don't have obvious plastic surgery, meaning they weren't forced into a cookie-cutter aesthetic mold like idols who are expected, for instance, to get v-line surgery to be "pleasing."

Relatedly, I like seeing the independent, strong personalities of BTS' members, because it gives me comfort that they're not just machines for adults who are profiting off of them, and I like seeing that they speak out against how so many adults mistreat and disregard young people (though Amber from f(x) has sometimes been outspoken about some issues). This is a new thing for me to see in Kpop, and it's one of the main factors that sets BTS apart, because they want to send a message, not just entertain. Most Kpop acts only entertain because messages are risky.

Given all this, BTS is the only fandom I belong to, because I think BTS is different. All of their work is good quality, and they appeal to me on a personal level, too.

32
CoRo63No, not today.•

I agree with soooo much of this! I remember looking into it during Psy's big "hit" here, and like particular songs by various groups, but - as a "mature" listener, with a background in mental health, I struggle with the genre. I like a good bop as much as the next music lover, but I'm also strongly (read: loud and proud!) feminist. BTS has a great message and immense talent, so they are my only deep dive. Even then, I'll admit to still struggling with some aspects of "fandom." But maybe that's the Westerner in me.

7
FakeuLarbWishlist: Jin Arirang Solo•

Thanks for your comment. I have sometimes wondered if part of the reason BTS has caught on in the West is because they haven't been as controlled and sterilized as most other Kpop groups. I think it may be a cruel irony that Kpop hasn't caught on because in companies' attempts to make their groups "perfect," they've sterilized them to the point of being unrelatable to Western audiences. BTS, meanwhile, acts like a bunch of goofy brothers any person could know through school or family.

11
minmangOP늉기•

I don't think that kpop or kpop idols are "manufactured", honed to perfection. I don't see any problem in improving your skills and talent to the best it can be. I also don't think its wrong to utilize one's potential and that includes visuals, acting, or variety skills. This sets kpop apart from western artists--having a lot of skills and being extremely good at it means that the quality of performance that you put out would be better, and there's also more variety in content which keeps fans hooked.

I also don't agree with the term "sterilized". It sets the idea that idols are soulless and have no agency of their own. They're passionate and they do experience the same or similar struggles as BTS had. They just chose not to be open about it. Whether its a company or a personal issue, its their decision how much they're gonna disclose. We're not entitled to know either. And I respect that. And just because we don't know about it that doesn't make them soulless dolls.

Yes, there are abusive companies. But they don't exist exclusively in kpop. They too exist in western entertainment, in Hollywood, in factories and companies with underpaid and overworked workers and employees. It's a systemic problem we need to recognize.

When you're in a big company, its likely that you'll have a more limited artistic freedom than idols from small companies, like BTS. This might also be the reason why that especially in 1d's first albums, there's not a lot of variety. But I think times are changing now, with artists from SM and YG producing and being more involved in their songs. (heck I just realized now how good Big Bang's Lies is and I learned it was written and composed by G-Dragon. A song released in 2008!) Kpop songs nowadays have also become more aggressive in catching up with Western trends. The only difference with BTS is that their team was much quicker in noticing these trends and incorporating them in their songs before anyone else did. Case in point would be Fire and BST.

6
WolfTitan99Jin's' yeongwonhi' in DNA•

I would actually have to outright disagree with the top comment about BTS being different from Kpop. I first started watching Kpop when I was introduced to DNA, and watched only BTS for a good 3 months. Then I started watching other kpop videos and getting into other groups/songs.

There was a part where you were talking about how “BTS don’t look like typical kpop stars in Korea” or something to that effect.

The entire goal of a kpop group formation in a company is to get as many appealing (whether in dance, looks, variety) people as possible to get revenue. People like Tae, Jin and Jungkook all fit this visual style, and the others have grown into their looks. Its unfair to say that ‘they don’t fit the model of an idol’ and praise them for it while subtly saying every other idol looks the same or has had plastic surgery.

Most people, myself included, follow BTS for their personalities and interactions with each other, and its amazing to watch. However, just because a person is emotionally attached to BTS and used to them, doesn’t mean other idols are lifeless.

5
WolfTitan99Jin's' yeongwonhi' in DNA•

You would find the ‘shallow and cruel’ news stuff even with BTS. I dont think the point there is even relevant to the idols, but more relevant to the Korean Media.

I will agree that other labels are more restrictive and I’m happy that BigHit treats them very well compared to other companies!

But even today, BTS are held to very high standards. Although its comfortable to watch them, as they get even more popular I can see pressure being put on them by fans since they’re so popular nowadays :(

3

Ok so I'm a new fan and I don't know a lot about BTS but I don't know anything about Kpop in general but the impression I gave to BTS is that they're very hard-working and talented. They treat each other like family which is very hearwarming and comforting to see.

As for ARMY, I think that they are a very protective but supportive fan base which motivate BTS a lot and don't put pressure on them to keep making music (which I think is a very considerate thing to do).

Overall, I'm very happy that I discovered BTS because I love their music (even though I have not had any encounters with anything related to the Korean culture, I think that I have successfully learnt some Korean words just from BTS songs). I understand more Japanese than Korean and I understand that it must be extremely difficult for BTS to make a song and then later re release it in Japanese which I really appreciate.

28
AlyshaUchiha•

As im new, il tell you my first impressions of everything. Im going to be really honest without holding back, just know that these were an outsiders view, I was the typical instagram/gym obsessed/partying type of girl. I didnt know about this world.

i heard about KPop from Gangnam style (sigh). I looked up kpop and saw a video talking about how overworked they are, how they faint on stage, an ex-idol talking about slave contracts etc and thought no fuck all of this, this is awful it should be illegal, I wont support this, goodbye. I looked up videos and didnt understand the lyrics, heard pop music and (sorry) a cheesy video and thought oh its korean pop music, no thanks. (im sorry for my past life)

Next BTS started popping up everywhere. I saw the video of JHope coughing from fireworks in the "fainting" video which was misinformation and made it look like they were overworked so I was really annoyed by these companies and thought I wont listen to this. I also heard a youtuber talking about the "BTS ARMY" and how theyre a hardcore fanbase, you cant talk bad about BTS or theyll basically destroy you (Daz Games reacting to BTS, he said he liked them but I thought he was pretending because he was scared of the army)

Then 3 months ago on 12th October they went on the Graham Norton Show and everything changed. I was like Oh my god they're here too? They're everywhere, let me just see what all the hype is about so I watched it. They all looked the same to me, I couldnt see how they were good looking but they were funny and nice on the show so I looked up a video. Fake Love at the BBMAs came up. I saw the incredible performance and was shocked it was live singing and dancing, I'd never seen anything like it. Then I saw jungkook 😐 and really liked Fake Love. Next I found Mic Drop and LOVED it, I was shocked it was like normal rap music and not cheesy "korean pop" like I thought. I started to tell them apart and thought was I blind theyre the best looking guys Ive ever seen in my life whats going on. Then I looked into their lyrics and couldnt get my head around how deep and meaningful they were, this was completely different to what I originally thought. BST and Save me absolutely won me over.

I think I spent 3 days not sleeping and watching BTS videos, MVs, AHL, browsing the sub, downloading music, looking at lyrics, discovering the love yourself message and it changed my life im still not out of the rabbit hole.

But I told myself "its just BTS, i dont like kpop. Only BTS" but after watching all of these award shows BTS go to im starting to really like EXO's music.. Nuest W's song.. IZOne.. Blackpink. Im fully in this now.

16
kdf_333•

Ha. That sounds like me. I miss sleep. Darn youtube and twitter. Always something new i have it seen or need to look up so i can get joke. Next thing you know it is 2 am. I also blame my fave talk shows - ellen, jimmy fallon,and james corden. Sigh. Now i am on reddit reading threads, have downloaded v live, and discovered kpop entertainment news outlets online and read articles at work when i am bored. I am too old for this.

2
cinnamonteacake•

I looked up kpop and saw a video talking about how overworked they are, how they faint on stage, an ex-idol talking about slave contracts etc and thought no fuck all of this, this is awful it should be illegal, I wont support this, goodbye. I looked up videos and didnt understand the lyrics, heard pop music and (sorry) a cheesy video and thought oh its korean pop music, no thanks. 

This was me, too. Still kinda alarmed at how little sleep and rest BTS seem to get, especially lately with how tired some of them look.

2
minmangOP늉기•

This was my experience too, although for me it was mostly Girls Generation and SHINEE back in 2009-12. I'm from SEA but everyone was playing or dancing to their songs. I thought of similar stereotypes too--weird, they all look the same, etc. The first korean songs I heard were epik high's One, Loner by outsider and their sound and concept was still different than, say, Lucifer's.

​

Never fully grasped kpop until EXO, and then BTS, and all the artists in between...and the videos, pre-debut tracks and mixtapes I've downloaded at 3 am. Kind of crazy when you just hear about it but for me it kind of just occurred naturally over the years. I've never regretted it

1
WhatAFox•

I don’t have much to add...just want to say that this is basically my story as well.

1
astriditycircle room cypher enthusiast•

BTS was my first true insight into Kpop. Being in the UK the only things I'd heard about Kpop were that the girls were abused and treated terribly by their companies, forced to work etc, and that all the music was manufactured x Factor style. I had no idea of the culture, concepts, terms, industry norms or ANYTHING in kpop. My friend had to explain to me what a bias was 😅 I started out just here for BTS but as I learned more about the industry and other artists through awards shows, fandoms on twitter etc, my horizons have broadened. My kpop spotify playlist is now much more diverse and it's much less dominated by BTS lol, even though I will always have at least 10 BTS songs on it.

I've never really been part of a BIG fandom. I never liked 1D, never liked JB, didnt properly get into any other entertainment fandoms like for supernatural or Dr who. My impression of big fandoms was the crazy 1D fans who hurt each other scrambling to get under a gate to get to the boys, and the whole cut for zayn thing that happened when he left? Honestly I was so reluctant to embrace the love I had for BTS because I didn't want to become one of the crazy toxic fangirls I kept hearing about.

But honesty ARMY is a lot more docile than I was expecting. My friend has had to explain to me over and over again that every single fandom has the crazy portion but most of them are normal. I've come across plenty of delulu on stan twitter (Oh i also had to Google what a stan was) but I've settled into being a full time fangirl pretty nicely 😂 BTS and ARMY and the kpop industry in general has welcomed me with open arms. Now my musical preference is definitely Kpop and it makes up 95% of what i listen to nowadays. It's had such an effect on my life and I've only known BTS exist for under 6 months?? Crazy really. It really is a rabbit hole lol

15
minmangOP늉기•

Wow, welcome to the kpop fandom! I'm not sure how the experience will be for you, but it might be hard to get out of that rabbit hole. You'll like one artist, and then another, then another... Back then, I was shocked to see people who were kpop fans for 10 years. Now I'm a kpop fan for almost 6 years now. It might not be as crazy as I thought.

Of course BTS is different, especially with their exponential rise in fame. Back then we would still get a quiet period where there aren't really any special activities and events and during those times I'd look for other sources of content....from other idols. BTS has a lot of activities, content, news, and concert dates its hard to have a quiet period nowadays.

The fandom became a lot more organized after several challenges and misunderstandings we faced the past years. That's also the reason for the overprotectiveness, bc both the boys and the fandom suffered a lot during those times. Almost everyone hated BTS which sucked.

I'd believe that as part of fan experience its almost inevitable that we have a cringey phase and sometimes (unfortunately) that includes being toxic. But what's important is how we learn from those mistakes and change for the better

2
elbenne•

I stumbled on kdramas a few years ago a!nd fell down a hole that was worse than this one. Because the only English language drama I've watched since then is Game of Thrones. Maybe I was Korean in a previous lifetime? I just don't seem to care about watching anything else. Which meant that I abandoned the only other fandom I've ever been a part of. Of course, The Walking Dead was going to lose me anyway, the moment that they killed Glenn with a baseball bat.

Anyway, Kdrama soundtracks put Kpop into my YouTube feed. So I checked out a few videos and thought they all sounded a bit bland and kinda the same ... until I saw Fire by this group called BTS. The music had an energy and an edge and a humour that I hadn't seen yet and as former skating coach/choreographer it was the movement that really caught me. The dance practice videos led to Run BTS and that was it.

I've heard and liked a few more kpop songs since then but only a few with no B-sides or other personalities emerging. So kpop is still like a sea of vanilla for me, with BTS bursting out as something DNA vivid in the middle. I, actually, subscribe to the view that they aren't kpop at all. I see some similarities but don't hear any.

About ARMY. People are exceptionally nice here ... And smart and interesting but I stumbled across a few truly obnoxious fans during the t-shirt ordeal. I understood where they were coming from but, I'm quite new, so, to be honest, I found the experience to be unnerving. My only glimpse of kpop fandoms came through a couple of kdramas like Reply 1988. So, I had no knowledge of the extremely organized voting or stans or antis. Naive huh?

So, I love BTS music, BTS dance choreography and BTS but not kpop and, while ARMY feels pretty warm and cozy if you're careful where you go on Reddit, Twitter, Instagram and YouTube, I hesitate to go beyond that other than to vote. It's too hard not to feel protective and get drawn into nastiness. And life is too full of other things for that. So much music and old content to enjoy instead. ☺️☺️☺️

15
cinnamonteacake•

This is my story exactly, except I studiously ignored kpop until Psy came along (through OSTs I knew of a few older singers and rappers like Lee Sun Hee, MC Sniper etc whose stuff I liked, but I checked out some kpop in the wake of Gangnam Style and..... wasn't really into it, tbh). I found IU through a drama she acted in and became a fan from there, but that was it - not super interested in kpop as a general thing, even now.

I mean, I'm 34, the way kpop is marketed is simply not for me with the whole "boyfriend/girlfriend/girl crush" deal, but it's not like I don't understand fandom - I've been a Star Wars fan since age 8 and was crying in the theatre over the most recent films, was a Britney fan as a teen, and was even a staff member on a Harry Potter forum - so I get it, I really do. It's just that a lot of how kpop marketing is done does not sit right with me, with the restrictions on personal lives (I wasn't ok with it when the media was asking teenage Britney invasive questions about her personal life and body either) and all of that. I feel like western pop artist fandoms have relaxed a lot about that stuff since - it's no biggie if Rihanna or Ari or Taylor date or Beyoncé is married, it doesn't mean they don't appreciate fans. Heck even Psy and all of Epik High are now married and most have kids, and they're still legit, you know?

But yeah, on the kpop side, quite apart from the extreme youth-targeted nature of the content, a lot of people still consider it a bad thing for artists to date if they 'get caught', and using the term 'scandal' for dating news was something I couldn't support, and other than IU, BTS are the first act where I've felt like the music is good enough and speaks to me personally, enough to support them despite knowing they're living with a certain degree of trepidation about what happens if the media reports on their private lives.

7
Smol_Jams•

I'm just about a 1 year old ARMY now and BTS is what made me reconsider exploring k-pop. So what happened a year later after falling for BTS? Still only an ARMY but my music is basically all Korean now lol. I barely listen to the radio anymore. I explored and can say I like songs from a bunch of different k-pop groups, but I didn't find any group I'd like to follow like BTS. I also discovered I have a preference for k-r&b over k-pop and can listen to entire albums by solo artists repeatedly which I can't seem to do with k-pop unless it's BTS discography (and notably Stray Kids discography even though their rookies.)

As for fandoms, I don't think my life's ever felt like it's been taken over like this before lol. I've been a fan of a number of things and music artists throughout the years but not like this. There's such a pull being an ARMY and I think it has to do with how BTS just keeps giving us content and trying to interact with their fans and showing us their personalities. Like you just wanna hang out and be friends with them. My life involves a lot of checking up on any BTS news and if there's no news, then looking for content I haven't seen yet. I also like looking for discussions with other ARMY on the sub lol. I was first hesitant about becoming a fan because of all the toxic behavior I've heard about but there seems to be similar behavior from a number of fandoms. It's just this behavior is only from a small but loud part of the fandom... I discovered the more chill and rational part of the fandom is bigger and does more good out in the world and it's pretty awesome. I think it's crazy how organized ARMY can be and it's great hearing about the different regional groups around the world doing good stuff because BTS inspired them - organizing donation events, planting trees, adopting animals etc. I'm not sure if other kpop fandoms organize similar things, but hearing about the stuff ARMY does makes me proud to be part of the fandom.

11
geishaskauradon´t fight, don´t fight•

I´ve been mainly in anime fandoms, and I mostly followed indie Western musicians with small niche fandoms. So the kpop fandom in comparison is... uh... intense... It reminds me of soccer fans with all those hooligans who hate rival teams so much.

The whole kpop industry with its abuse scandals is crazy.
That´s one of the reasons why I´m not interested in following other groups, their companies treat them like disposable items. Yikes...

8
rosettalincoln•

Before I became a fan of BTS and Kpop I was completely against it. I had heard horror stories of the fanbases and found the obsession over idols to be nonsensical. I told myself, nope, I’d never be a fan. Welp, that definitely didn’t stick!

I actually became a fan/listened to BTS because I was trying to get one of my friends into music that I liked. I was a huge theater nerd (and still am, lmao) and I promised her that if she’d listen to musicals then I’d give Kpop a shot. I sent her 5 songs, and she sent five back. Funnily enough, my favorite of those five was an EXO song, with Jimin’s Lie being my second favorite (because who can resist his vocals??)

As much as I hate the YouTube algorithm, I have to give it to the, they helped in my discovery of Kpop. Because after watching those MVs, I got a bunch of BTS videos and crack vids in my recommended and the rest is history!

Side Note- if you are interested in showing your friends Kpop, I highly recommend doing the “music swap” thing that I did. You might discover new music that you like and your friend might discover Kpop themselves!

8
crazybookworm0617all the underdogs in the world•

Hello! I’m a relatively new army I’d say(?) or not? I’ve been an army since just before ly answer so I struggled with the all black haired tear era ahaha.

At first I was like oh no I’m staying away from all the crazy fans because the first few things I saw were posts bashing army on Instagram and so on... I wouldn’t call myself part of a western fandom unless you count books and such and those are very much solo activities but I did notice the togetherness of Kpop fans relative to western artists.

I’m not really active in the fandom unless you count that insane group chat I have with a few fellow armys’ but that might honestly be because of my age. The thing that really drew me to bts was the storyline throughout the albums since I’ve always loved stories. Hence, I spend a lot of my free time thinking through the theories especially since the hyyh notes have been revived 😳 and less time interacting with the more musically focused and larger part fo the fandom.

As an international student sometimes the intensity of the random really shocks me especially when you relapse those millions of views on music videos are pretty much from the same group of people. I love the dedication to the idols and bond between artist and fans that doesn’t seem to be as prominent within western music. Overall I think once you look past the initial negativity of fan wars and such it’s quite a welcoming community (especially here since most people I’ve seen are chiller than stan twitter at least 👀)

As for other Kpop groups, my playlists are dominated by bts with about 35-50% of the dogs being theirs. Initially I was quite opposed to other artists but now I’ve fallen into a few fandoms in a short period of time. I’m pretty sure bangtan will always be my ult because for me, they produce so much more than just music. (But music wise I do listen to other artists and I actively stan a few boy groups but not to the same level of devotion)

6
cinnamonteacake•

Speaking as a Star Wars/Harry Potter fan of over two decades, I think one thing in common with Armys is that the content - though very, very different in nature - speaks to a HUGE range of ages. Back when I was modding a forum a decade ago, we'd routinely see 13 year olds and we'd also see several members in their 30s, 40s, and 50s. And while my corner of HP fandom actively fought against bad talk about the then-child actors in the films, there was still a touch of obsessiveness in the general fandom about Daniel, Rupert and particularly Emma, though by the time they were in their later teens the online fandom culture was moving a bit more towards 'respect their privacy/you don't own them/they don't owe you their private lives'.

That sense of ownership is something I've seen in kpop idol fandom and cannot bring myself to be ok with, but in all fairness, it's very similar to the way a chunk of Star Wars fandom behaves when the films feature a development they don't like (e.g. neckbeards pissed off over the new Jedi of this generation being a girl who is good at things). The other big similarity is that Star Wars fans/HP fans/Army will all go really hard at new content, and spend the cash. That's one thing they definitely have in common lol.

5
lemonlibrarian•

I've only been a fan of BTS for a little over two months, but they're not my first KPOP listen. I've listened to a couple since, but none other really stuck out with me since BTS are still on rotation. The other kpop group I'd listen to is Day6, though would you call them kpop? K-rock?

BTS is a very unique group I've ever followed, and it has been a while since I've joined a fandom. My last one was a pop/rock band from the UK, McFLY, and while their music are different, they both have some sort of similarities in releasing happy, pop tunes (in my interests at least).

As for joining the ARMY, honestly I didn't know what to expect. As a slightly older fan than some, one of my first fandoms was with the Backstreet Boys, and we didn't really have social media to share things. I believe they were message boards (I guess similar to this, then!), and TRL. We'd all group together to call the show and even radio stations and vote for our favorite artists to get to the top spot. Though I've never seen such a community with so many twitter accounts, social media accounts, youtube w/ fancams, etc, that are all willing to share the latest news, performances, videos with other fans, especially if they're not in the original country (Korea) and aren't able to view locally. It's cool to see how fandoms evolved from local to global by going online. It's really cool and awesome.

It's not always that when you become a fan of a band/group, you'd have to have a favorite member. I've learned this throughout my boy band fangirl life, but I've always been that person who would rather listen to the music than fawn over little gestures the members make or their features. It's still the case right now, but...you know, there are times when you just stop and stare at your bias....

But oh! I'm also enjoying reading their music story line theories, and the books relating to them. That's probably my most favorite part since joining the fandom...except I'm still catching up and they're starting up the newer theories as of yesterday. 😫 There's also just so much content, I know I won't get through all of them, cause I'd rather be reading. It literally feels like I've joined Bangtan Academy, and I'm only a freshman in the fandom, studying for the required readings from their albums.....

3
WolfTitan99Jin's' yeongwonhi' in DNA•

YOOOOOOOO Whats UP!

I got excited because I’m obviously a BTS fan but I also rly like Day6. Thought kpop as a whole was a bit odd a first when I got into it with DNA but I got into all kinds of different groups casually!

But I got into Day6 like a month ago and love their music. When I get into a group where I like more than 10+ songs I know I’m going fall HARD for them, and thats the case with Day6 and BTS. They’re pretty much my co-bias groups now!

I usually test if I like most of the music first, and if I do, then I’ll watch variety of them and see if they’re my thing.

Tbh I dunno if Day6 is K-rock or K-pop, they definitely have a rock sound but are also under JYP, which is mostly idols, so idk.

2
lemonlibrarian•

Heeeeeey! I was a fan of Day6 since late 2016, though I'm still digging through their discography (I didn't revive my kpop interest until November of last year when I heard Waste it on Me). There is not a song I don't like from Day6, either!

3
ShruT12•

A while ago, a friend showed me a couple of songs from SNSD, Big Bang and 2PM. You know, all the hits like Fantastic Baby, Hands Up or The Boys. I thought they were catchy but way too poppy, so I didn't go any further than that.

RM's rapping in Bucku Bucku, then his mixtape was what got me into BTS. Before I knew it, I listened to their entire discography, looked up the lyrics and marathoned their other videos. So, they were the first group I ended up stanning and it's still that way. After that, I tried listening to title tracks of other groups and just like before, nothing really stuck with me. There are other Western artists and Indian singers I listen to, but BTS is the only one I really keep up with.

As for the fandom...I got involved in the fandom before I knew it, lol. I was a Pentaholic (Pentatonix's fandom) and that was it. I've heard kpop fandoms can be obsessive to the point of stalking their idols, so I wanted to stay far away from that. After seeing all the hate BTS got and the fandom being so supportive, I couldn't help but join.

Of course the fandom isn't perfect, but I personally think the bandwagon hate is excessive. Some ARMY's can be toxic, but the majority I've met are warm, funny and welcoming. It's also the first time I've seen a fandom literally beg an artist to let them pay for free music, lmao.

I guess I'm a casual listener of other groups and artists, but I'm only an ARMY. It's not for lack of trying too lmao...just that no other artist resonates with me like BTS do.

3
vyduanyou can watch it on the internet•

Prior to BTS, the only thing I had heard of kpop was PSY’s Gangnam Style, which I LOVED. I frequent a lot of boba shops so would see Kpop music videos a lot - but mostly from girl groups and I am not a fan of cutesy concepts so I was meh about it. Then, I switched to a boba shop that played 80% boy groups and I got hooked.

Around Feb/Mar 2018, I started researching on YouTube for Mandarin versions or bands like the kpop boy groups because I bilingual homeschool my four kids in Chinese/English. I know the power of media to make things cool so I wanted my kids to find something awesome like Kpop but in Mandarin so they could have more exposure to Mandarin.

Thanks to YouTube, I found EXO-M and then due to the recommendations, found Got7 and NCT and BTS. To be honest, I wasn’t a huge fan of BTS at first except of their Mic Drop Remix. I thought DNA was weird and too bright and colorful and it wasn’t my jam. I far preferred EXO.

But somehow, I got caught up in the fan videos of BTS and their dance practices and I gradually started to get to know them. Then Singularity came out and Fake Love and I was ensnared and dove down the rabbit hole and am full ARMY and have converted my kids into mini-ARMY.

Thanks to RM and a lesser extent, Suga, I have listened to the groups they love and now hardcore love NELL, and am on the way to stanning Epik High, too.

It helps that I’m 40 and have experienced many types of fandoms (in particular, Alias and Buffy the Vampire Slayer) so it’s not my first rodeo and already knew a lot of terms. Lol.

It’s been awesome and I am never looking back.

3
[deleted]•

The K-Pop industry actively goes against my ideology; it comes across to me as late stage capitalism. But, I noticed something different in BTS. They actively put themselves into political positions; promoting the end of violence, critiquing the Korean government, and sometimes critiquing the K-Pop industry in earlier songs. Another thing I love about them and particularly Namjoon is the ability to change. His attitude from 2013 to onwards switched for the better; and that is incredible - the ability to realize that you were wrong. After Namjoon’s UN speech, I was extremely inspired by him. He’s truly world leader material.

On the other hand, my first impression of BTS when watching my first music video (BST) was that Jimin was so beautiful. Like... painstakingly beautiful. He’s perfect. And so talented. And then I saw more videos. And I fell in love with the rest. And now I’m a full-on Army.

Edit: Oh, forgot to mention, I come from a hip-hop background when it comes to being a fan. BTS was a change in personality and content; but my music taste continues to be the same. The rap line and Tyler the Creator sit at the same table. Definitely a change in fans. Mainly demographic wise, as fan behavior never really changes unless you look at it in a biased perspective. BTS are much more active than western artists... I was a Frank Ocean stan once... and their content is much more fun. Run BTS is something that brings a smile to my face every time. And as much as I love Brockhampton Instagram lives, they can’t compare to Jimin putting salt in Yoongi’s Coke.

2
groundscreamingbts on ts7 at midnight•

i've been in online fandom since early 1d (primarily tumblr until 2016) so i was always aware of kpop fandoms. it was common for big bang/exo/2ne1/girls generation to pop up on my dashboard, but my first introduction to bts was in 2016 when someone i followed on twitter retweeted a wings teaser/music video onto my timeline. i watched like 10 seconds of it and was like "i don't get it but cool" (i think the accompanying tweet was something along the lines of "bts is about to blow up" or a similar sentiment). then bts began becoming more and more popular, and i actually watched a few of their james corden clips when they aired to try to understand what the appeal was. didn't get hooked until idol and here i am.

because my main fandoms that i come from are 1d and taylor swift, i'm used to everyone in the world hating the artists i like and their fans fiercely defending them, but jesus christ do kpop fans (especially armys) take it to a whole new level. i affectionately called yoongi a raccoon and my weird friend affectionately called him her goblin and army twitter rioted against us. there's whole accounts dedicated to blocking and reporting people the hive mind doesn't agree with or like. i understand that in korea being a fan is an occupation not a hobby and that bts gets shit on a ridiculous amount by literally everyone, but non-korean fans really take that concept to heart. it sucks all the fun out of being a fan and i honestly hate saying i'm an army because i just don't like the hivemind. (i also have a lot of issues with the "othering" of mainstream pop fans through fandom names as opposed to fans of literally any other band/genre of music, but that's a different dissertation for a different time.) i just stay to my small bts friend group on twitter because we get that being a fan is supposed to be FUN, and here because i love fan discussion and analysis.

as for other korean artists, yeah, i'm open to listening to them. i just started a playlist the other day titled "girl group songs that go off" and currently have blackpink, twice, and gugudan on there. i hate how my spotify discover weekly has become all kpop, though, and the chance of me becoming a fan of another group is like .001%. i didn't even think i would become a fan of bts, but here i am.

2
kdf_333•

I think around Oct 2018 i really started. I mean, I saw bts on the award shows and was just entertained. When i saw them on my fave talk shows - ellen, jimmy fallon, jimmy kimmel, james corden- then i had to see what the hype was about. First impression incredible dancers, pretty boys, and funny. Now how i just wanted to be able to tell them apart an figure out how young they were. Not as young as i thought. It actually was ARMY crack videos i think that got me. I watched a bunch of introduction to Bts videos. Youtube started recommending thongs and the next thing i know i am up all night lol. Then certain jokes and memes i did not get so more videos and then twitter and then vlive and ..BTS and ARMY have sooooooooooooooooo much content. It is easy to stay online for hours, days.

I don’t consider myself ARMY. I have read and watched stuff created by ARMY and yeah, that is not me. I have never been a major fan of any group, even when i was a teen. I liked groups. I liked their music. I would read articles about them and watch their interviews. I rarely bought anything though. One cuz mo money and two i could hear the songs for free on the radio. I think fandoms are way too obsessed in general. I always thought it was due to age, teen girls+fave celeb=obsession.

I thought at first the only difference between ARMY and Swifties was the language and sheer numbers. Y’all are a lil scarier than Beiber’s fans though. Kpop fandoms remind me of Micheal Jackson fans. They are very loyal, know every single detail about their idols, constantly stay up to date, crazy fantasies, buy everything, and are everywhere, international. but unlike MJ’s fans this new generation that “stans” celebs fight other fandoms. In my day MJ lovers also loved Prince, Madonna, and a gazillion other artists. Maybe it’s the online fan awards and combativeness that causes the fandom wars. I don’t know but it is quite off putting.

I was happily amusing myself looking up bts tweets. Then all the silly tweets about bts and coachella and black pink came up in my search. At first i dismissed it as young folk getting offended when there was no reason to be offended. Then i saw more and realized this happens ALL the time between fandoms. It was very off putting. I left twitter and went on youtube.

Oh then shipping... i am just this week really looking into it. Shipping was something i thought only happened in fan fiction and was never about real people. So i looked it up cuz i mean jk and jm cannot be dating every member in the group. But after watching 30 or so shipping videos and reading the comments,i was pretty sure lots of ARMY truly think they are. Imagine my shock and horror when i look up kpop shipping, discover fanservice,and then the fact koreans still shun homosexuals...i was just ugh. So disappointed the ARMY that gets so much praise from BTS and the media would be like all the other kpop fans in this area. Cuz i at first thought the videos to be true, then found them, amusing and obvi fantasy, then learned about skinship when i looked up Korean culture. then I was concerned about BTS since they say look at fan content on social media. I do not understand it and i no longer find it amusing. Cuz what if one really is gay. Teenage years are rough for those not in the spotlight. It is rough realizing you are gay in a country that is against it...which was the usa just few years ago. But then being told your best friend, your brother is going to pretend to be gay for you in order to please the fans... I just can’t with shipping & fanservice.

I do like the fact i can find out everything i want to know about BTS cuz of the obsessive nature of kpop fans. It reminds me of scifi & fantasy fans. I enjoy the online databases fans make. I enjoy the memes and videos. I enjoy all the social media groups. I enjoy BTS. But i will never be ARMY. Just like with MJ, NKOTB, Prince, Madonna, Bieber, Tom Hiddleston, Micheal B. Jordan, Benecio del Toro and others - for a few months, maybe even a year, i will devour everything BTS. Then i will just go back to listening to their songs whenever. The searches will stop. I will once again just look at my talk shows and award shows and enjoy everybody almost equally. Until the next artist grabs me. It happens once every other year. I will see BTS on a show and enjoy them but not rewatch clip after clip.

I have enjoyed other kpop videos. I looked them up after hearing/seeing them due to bts. Or they popped up on youtube recommendations or trending lists. Sometimes other kpop groups are mentioned in a comment online or a meme or an entertainment article. I look them up. I have not listened to any of them on spotify or youtube music cuz bts has a lot of music i still am not familiar with. And the love yourself albums get lots of play. I just started listening to the album that has young forever on it. Daddy by Psy is awesome. Bang BangBsng, Love Shot, Tempo, DduDdu, and a few other videos had awesome songs and or dancing. Oh the group 15& with Jimin those girls could sing.i watched more than just the hot song mentioned in the comments of the after school club video. So thanks to BTS kpop is in my youtube rotation but not my car drive, work, doing chores at home, or going to sleep music rotation.

1
SmoothLaneChangeHappy Hobiuary!•

Do you think you would be willing to explore other artists or korean music, or just stay as an ARMY exclusively?

I don't think you need to be part of a fandom to enjoy an artist's music, unless I misunderstood (in which case my bad). Being a fan of one group while listening to other artists doesn't have to be exclusive or an either-or scenario.

Not super new to them (started around Tear era), but before them I only casually listened to Big Bang and nothing else of kpop. It wasn't until I started listening to BTS when I opened up to other artists. BTS is probably the only artist I actively follow, including Western. I listen to other artists but don't keep up like this.

I wasn't really into any music fandoms before, and tbh I don't want to be. I listen to a lot of genres and what's interesting to me about kpop is how there's this weird shame thing going on with how many groups someone listens to. Like if someone only listens to one group they get guilt-tripped for not listening to others (most likely an i-fan thing though), but some people get guilt tripped for listening to others. It's weird. This isn't just about k pop culture but fan culture in general I find can be very overwhelming, toxic, and tribalistic as mostly expressed on different social media platforms. For those reasons I try not to get too involved with fandom culture, especially kpop fandom culture which has some of the most intense fans I've seen (and that's coming from a Dodger/Red Sox supporter). I will say I do enjoy the community aspects, fan content production, and philanthropic efforts of fan culture.

I agree with your first paragraph; I think BTS is probably one of the biggest ambassadors of Korean culture (including pop culture), and I'm insanely proud of them for that considering their fairly unorthodox journey/circumstances.

1