r/vegan•
skatedog_j

Honey. What's story depsite mixed messages?

Hello there, vegan since August but I want to be able to get explain to others why honey isn't vegan and I'm sure it's the exploitation and abuse of honeybees but some people say that they don't harvest more than the bees can handle. What's the real story on it?

Posted Jan 9, 2019, 9:38 AM UTC

07
michaelsaraisveganarchist•

they don't harvest more than the bees can handle

Some people say the same thing about milking cows.

3
skatedog_jOP•

Exactly my thought too. It's still exploitative by nature.

1
2fplus1vegan•

I'm personally not that bothered by honey, especially compared to the other things we do (I grew up on a farm and we kept beehives but didn't really bother harvesting honey; they're beneficial to have around for pollinating). But, I will argue that an important part of veganism is shifting our mindset away from viewing animals as products for our consumption use and acknowledging that they have rights that we should at least try to consider. Whether it's exploitation and abuse is arguable, but we definitely didn't ask the bees what they wanted.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
NoHoneyImVegan•

@Gary! honey

1
gary_botvegan•

Hi, NoHoneyImVegan here is the information you requested for u/skatedog_j:

  • The philosophy of veganism is to do no conscious harm to any living thing. Commercial honey production is a long way from the image of a few hives in someone's back garden. In fact, all honey collection by humans harms and often kills bees - even when this is done on a small scale with smoke! If the bees survive the honey collection process they are often weakened and traumatised. Bees have been proven to have a complex nervous system. See this link for more.
  • In addition, bees produce honey as their own food. In its lifetime, a honeybee may only produce about a teaspoon of honey, but in the US alone, more than 400 million pounds of honey is consumed each year. Sugar water is often used to replace the stolen honey, which is a poor nutritional substitute. Here is more information and here too.
  • As with eggs, there is no dietary need for a human to eat honey. Doing so harms and frequently kills the creatures that produce it.

Always read the links in the sidebar --------->

^^Bloop ^^Bleep! ^^I'm ^^Gary ^^the ^^/r/vegan ^^helper ^^bot. ^^Comments ^^and ^^suggestions ^^to ^^/u/pizza_phoenix. ^^General ^^information ^^and ^^latest ^^keywords ^^here. ^^Statistics ^^here. ^^Latest ^^keyword ^^update ^^15th ^^August ^^2017.

3
skatedog_jOP•

Thank you!!

2
Re_Re_Thinkveganarchist•

some people say that they don't harvest more than the bees can handle

Bees need honey stores to survive the winter; if they don't have enough, the hive dies. And beekeepers attempt to not harvest more honey than they estimate the "bees can handle" doing without. So, they replace honey (which gets sold to humans) with a lower cost food instead: high fructose corn syrup. However, despite their best intentions (even when they are convinced they are doing what's best) to minimize risk of the hive dying during the winter, there will always be an economic incentive to take the most honey possible without causing that to happen, and since it's not an exact science, sometimes they will estimate too much and take too much. Bee hives which have had their honey food source replaced by high fructose corn syrup are at a higher risk of not surviving the winter and are also at a higher risk of other features of colony collapse disorder (like Verroa mite or other infections). This is because bees may gain some unique benefits from honey, including immunological (1, 2) or nutritional factors not found in HFCS. So any amount of honey harvesting may weaken the hive.

(Also, this does not, by the way, automatically mean that honey is a "health food", or that it does the same things to the human immune system. Humans are not bees: we are genetically and biologically different in many important ways, and honey won't necessarily affect us the way it does them.)

It makes sense (in an evolutionary light) that honey might do these things for bees: bees make honey for themselves as an energy storage food source for surviving the winter, and bees which had the opportunity to evolve to have that food source better match their own nutritional needs would evolve in that direction (because the populations of bees who made the best, most ideally suited or matched food storage for their needs would be more likely to survive winter, and therefore more likely to reproduce).

1