r/ftm•
TimberVolk

Regarding Selfies & Voice Posts

ModPost

It has increasingly come to the mod team’s attention that photo posts are becoming of excessive frequency on r/ftm, to the point that they are wiping out all other content when sorted by “Hot,” which is Reddit’s default. We understand these are generally well-received and celebratory in nature, and we don’t want to get rid of them. Rather, we think it best for more substantive, pressing, and on-topic content that these posts find a new home that allows a better variety of content to populate the home page. This is similar to what r/mtf had to implement a while ago, in response to a similar issue. Effective for any posts moving forward, the following changes will go into effect:

  • Selfies will now only be allowed on a weekly selfie thread, or in other applicable recurring threads. Selfies with their own dedicated post will be removed and directed to re-post under an applicable thread of their choice, such as what is currently called the "Selfie Sunday" post that will likely be re-branded as the Weekly Selfie thread. Note: selfies also include photos taken of you by others, with others, etc. Not just those taken with phone in hand and of only yourself. This includes the ever-popular “What name would you give me?” and “Do I pass?” posts, along with random photos of part(s) of one's body, such as beard or workout progress photos, body hair, hands and feet, chests in binders, etc., even if they do not include your face. Any text posts found to be little more than subversive/glorified selfie posts will also be removed.
  • Voice Pitch Analyzer (and similar apps) photos will now only be allowed on Voice Post Thursday threads or other applicable recurring threads. As above, so below. They don’t really contribute to discussion and we’ve had several complaints about these, especially when they start a chain reaction. They certainly don’t need a whole post about them.

I say this all with the caveat that if the photo adds context to a question or more discussion-related post, this will be considered when deciding on approval/removal. The photo should add necessary context or information. This is not to be used as a loophole to the above changes.

  • I could probably come up with some more examples if this is unclear, but one acceptable example off the top of my head would be something titled “Here are some fashion tips for passing,” accompanied by a list of tips and an album of the poster demonstrating the styles discussed. Alternatively, if someone is asking about the genetics of balding and at the end includes a photo of their own hairline for context, that would be fine. This would be in contrast to a text post entitled “Am I Balding?” that enclosed little or nothing besides a link to a photo of the same hairline.

If you have any questions, clarifications, or complaints, feel free to post them here and we’ll help clear things up. We explored several options, and this appeared to be the most amicable to text and photo posts alike given the goal in mind and Reddit’s limitations. And don't worry, we understand it will take a while for this change to make it all the way down the pipeline, and we aren't going to be upset with/punish those who don't get the memo (though if you're here, hopefully you feel like you've gotten the memo). Changes take time, we understand that, but regardless this change does go into effect immediately. Eventually we will make a rule reflecting these changes, but those require some hurdles we're still working around in regards to the Reddit Redesign. EDIT: The rules have been updated! If you see any lost souls not aware of this update, feel free to flag selfie and VPA posts under Rule 10.

-The Mod Team

​

Edit 2: There is now a selfie subreddit called r/FTM_SELFIES. So you're aware, that sub is not cross-moderated by any of the mods here, so we're not responsible for the content/conduct there, but it seems to be hopping!

Posted Jan 10, 2019, 1:08 AM UTC · edited

16189
richardparker14•

Is there any kind of sub where we can post our selfies? Left Tumblr bc they put too many restrictions in the community, came here and was overwhelmed by how supportive people are but now we're only allowed to post them in specific threads? When I look at the daily threads no one seems to post in them much anyways. Also wasn't the flairing supposed to solve this so people can filter out the selfies if they didn't want to see them? I guess it's just upsetting bc seeing daily photos of people in the community is quite reaffirming and it's nice to get a moral boost or tips when needed instead of saving and remembering them for 1 day. but if there's another subreddit where we can go that's fine too

44
scout51748. trans. gay.•

I've done just that a little while ago: r/FTM_SELFIES 😁

45
AndySloth24•

Thanks!

5
JonTheObtuse31 yrs old, on T, came out at 30•

Great! I hope this sub takes off because I like seeing transition selfies. :)

2
AlexaviortheBravierMOD31 |T: 3/15|Top: 4/16|Hyst/O: 09/17•

To be honest, I'm hoping someone will make one. There is none that I know of and it seems somehow inappropriate for any of us to make it. Not to mention, I'm not sure any of us want to moderate another subreddit.

The flairs were supposed to solve it but it didn't really. And Reddit is changing in a way that makes the flairs less useful to be honest. Maybe that will change but I wouldn't bet on it.

ETA: If someone wants help setting up a FTM selfie subreddit or moderating, I'm willing to join one created to help start it up/acclimate someone but I am someone who filtered out all the selfies so I have no interest in actively moderate a subreddit full of selfies.

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
richardparker14•

There's a new sub !! r/FTM_SELFIES

2
manowar8820 | T Feb '17 | Top May '18•

Could we consider getting a stickied weekly selfies/pictures thread like in r/mtf? I know a lot of trans guys aren't really comfortable posting in the female-dominated selfie subs like r/transpassing and r/transpositive, so as it is there's no easily accessible alternative place for guys to put selfies. Plus having something that's always available would help the guys who do like browsing selfies rather than restricting selfies to Sundays. I know there's the 2-sticky limit, but I wouldn't mind it replacing the other weekly recurring threads (fitness Monday posts can just be normal discussion posts, and I don't know if anyone would actually miss not having a specific place for way back Wednesday or voice pitch analyzer Thursday).

39
AlexaviortheBravierMOD31 |T: 3/15|Top: 4/16|Hyst/O: 09/17•

We have been talking about making changes to weekly threads in relation to what to do about selfies and the decision to disallow them going forward. We've already made some minor ones already before this decision was made. For a rundown of our currently weekly threads:

  • Motivation Monday: Motivation/progress/goal-specific thread. (Pictures are fine.)

  • Fashion Tuesday--Image Thread: For sharing images that are fashion-specific.

  • Way Back Wednesday--Image Thread: "A thread in which you can share older images including anything from childhood pictures to comparison/progress/timeline pictures."

  • Voice Post Thursday: "This is a thread where you can feel free to share your voice progress pictures, videos, tips, and more." (Pictures are fine.)

  • Fitness Friday: "A place to get advice/brag/give advice on all things exercise and sports." (Pictures are fine.)

  • Social Media Saturday: "This is a thread where you can feel free to share links to your social media accounts including links to your blog, YouTube, Instagram, etc." (Pictures are fine, obviously.)

  • Selfie Sunday--Image Thread: General Selfie Thread

We made a few changes to them already including the days and to adjust Way Back Wednesday because it was HIGHLY specific. All of them can have pictures in them but they are themed which can be frustrating for general-selfie purposes.

We may make adjustments to add more general selfie threads and remove theme-specific ones especially rarely-used threads but we've not fully discussed that yet. I have also suggested making some of those less-used, recurring threads into monthly ones instead and putting them in our monthly sticky thread.

I'm not into removing the Voice Post Thread because Voice-related posts WERE surprisingly popular and I'd rather them stay in one dedicated thread.

We absolutely will be discussing other ways we can accommodate selfies with this rule in place.

9
TimberVolkOPAndrew 22 OR | T 4yrs, Top 3.5yrs, Hysto 2.5yrs, Phallo 1yr•

We go back and forth on what to sticky a lot, it's really frustrating. I feel like if there was just one more slot, you could have one sticky for announcements/mod posts, one for a monthly post/index of monthly posts, and one for either weekly or daily recurring posts. I do intend to add it to the monthly stickied thread list, but alas I'm sick and tired tonight so I'll add it to the list of things to do tomorrow. We're always trying new ways to keep recurring threads both relevant (we recently got rid of a few less popular ones in favor of stuff like VPA Thursday, for example), though, so we'll keep this in mind.

Also, part of the hope with referring selfies to alternative, recurring threads is that those will pick up some foot traffic. For example, WBW would be a great place to post before-and-after pics/"X months on T vs Y Years on T" selfies/comparisons!

6
manowar8820 | T Feb '17 | Top May '18•

I don't envy y'all the decision of what to/what not to sticky-- the restriction really makes for a sticky situation there.

I was thinking a weekly thread might replicate the experience of browsing the current/past front page more (though probably it'd be better if someone just makes a new separate selfie sub like what happened with r/MTFSelfieTrain). Even if the daily threads pick up a lot of traffic, they'll still be relatively empty towards the beginning of each day. But at the same time I can see things working out a lot better with the updated recurring thread themes as u/AlexaviortheBravior outlined (I was definitely thinking more of the old themes with the highly specific WBW in my original comment), so hopefully those end up being able to satisfy the demand.

5
simon_here36 · T/Top: 2005•

Thank you. I like that people feel confident enough to post selfies, but it seems like they've taken over in the last couple of months.

35
maiLManLiam18 / T: 10/25/16 / Top: 7/10/17•

This is a good change, and I appreciate that you guys are implementing it. I had always wondered why r/mtf had banned selfie posts but not r/ftm.

Hopefully there is no controversial reaction to this, because as it is now selfies are the cornerstone of this sub. It will definitely take some adjusting.

20
TimberVolkOPAndrew 22 OR | T 4yrs, Top 3.5yrs, Hysto 2.5yrs, Phallo 1yr•

I had always wondered why r/mtf had banned selfie posts but not r/ftm

Selfies didn't used to be quite so bad here (hell, even just a year ago), and mtf looked much more selfie-heavy than r/ftm before their reform, but that's changed since and now r/ftm is the selfie-wall that r/mtf used to be. So hopefully this remedies that and allows for more diverse content hitting the front page!

12
mx_marvelous27 | circa 2010 | queer•

Thanks for this you guys, I think this will make reading through the sub a lot easier.

19
giovanni-di-paolo•

Oh no!! Selfies are my favorite part of r/FTM — I’m barely four months on T and they give me a lot of hope

I will miss seeing them in my feed and though I understand why you need to make the change, I hope you make the selfie thread easy to access...

17
Ebomb1Top 13y|T 9y|Hyst 8y | IDEK anymore•

Well now instead of a full page of photo selfies I guess we get a full page of drawn selfies.

17
LeonDeCoolSimon|21|T:5/30/18•

Can we bundle these in with selfies please? I feel like it's a loophole and it's being abused so badly rn. It's not a photo but Christ the point is we don't want to see everyone's faces all day every day and nothing else.

16
failtrocity24 | T: 3/1/2019•

And now it’s all memes like it’s cool but maybe we could have them over at r/traaa and if we did, it’d probably be a bit more balanced

2
TimberVolkOPMODAndrew 22 OR | T 4yrs, Top 3.5yrs, Hysto 2.5yrs, Phallo 1yr•

If this becomes more than a 1-day trend I'll bring this up as an issue since it is garnering some complaints. You know how it is though, sometimes these things just flash through a little 1–2 day phase and fizzle again into oblivion.

I will say, at the very least, it is showing infinitely more expression than a selfie, and even without saying anything, they do say more than the former. But as with anything we'll keep an eye on it, don't worry, we are aware of all the creatively drawn faces. I don't think this spurred out of malice for the selfie rule.

5
flyingmountain•

I think this current situation is actually worse than before. A day or so ago when I looked, all but two posts were drawn self-portraits. At least with photo selfies you see a real human and sometimes progress pics, but that interaction/information doesn't exist with the art. It's so pointless and I do think that for many it's a snarky attempt to get around the "no selfies" rule.

On a related note, I wish that progress/comparison photos (or before/after, etc.) were exempt, because I think they are informative and helpful in a way that the one-pic "name me/do i pass?" selfies are not. When someone shows their progress over 6 months in the gym, or 6 years on T, or whatever, that is providing useful information to others and often sparks discussion. Although I don't know much about the reddit moderating system, it seems to me that it wouldn't be too hard to allow selfie posts only if they are comparisons, because the only ones allowed would have a minimum of two pictures in them.

3
TimberVolkOPAndrew 22 OR | T 4yrs, Top 3.5yrs, Hysto 2.5yrs, Phallo 1yr•

That was a short-lived fad, and we're currently discussing how we might remedy these trends in the future; fast and short-lived though they are, we understand they can get on people's nerves. If you look right now, however, that' mostly died down again and been replaced with thoughtful discussion.

I will keep this suggestion in mind, although I will say that these photos are not exempt if they accompany a thoughtful/informative text post. I think it's more helpful if people start the discussion themselves and share their experiences from the get-go, so that people can ask more specific questions as they come up. If you just assume someone has had the Generic Trans Experience, no one thinks there's anything more to ask, but if you happen to mention, say, idk, having a heart condition and someone with that same condition asks if there were any extra hoops to jump through when acquiring T, I think that's infinitely more useful than "here's my face two times, now with a beard." If you'd like just a collection of those, there are the Way Back Wednesay threads, or you might find some in Motivation Monday as well, if it helps.

For gym photos, there are also recurring fitness threads where people can exchange fitness tips, comparison photos, and ask questions about working out, healthy eating, etc.

2
flyingmountain•

Thanks for your response, I understand and I agree.

For what it's worth, I'm not actually looking for more selfies of any sort, just thinking about the types of posts that have some utility for others. I'm old enough and far enough into transition that most of this sub doesn't feel particularly relevant to me, but I still hang around sometimes to respond to people's questions. Recently I have noticed a large increase in posts that to me seem mindless and/or useless (memes, voice pitch app, name-me selfies, etc.) and I've found it frustrating so perhaps I just need to remove myself from here and unsubscribe lest I really get into "get off my lawn/kids these days" territory... ha.

Thanks again.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
NeonPupper•

Thanks, this will help me. This sub used to make me feel myself, but now it just makes me envious

15
AnnoyedintheVoid26 UK Questioning 🥣 "NB Soup with Masc Croutons" 🥣•

Yeah been there, I've had a few moments where I've felt a bit bombarded as I live in the UK so I can't quickly start the transition process and sometimes seeing a lot of 'Omg just started T yesterday been out for a month' posts get me a bit down.

15
superkam41•

Wayyy too frequent. I regretted posting my own. I think discussion topics need to be the main focus, and the selfies should go back to Instagram. Or a weekly topic where everyone can link their instas with some info about themselves

14
TimberVolkOPAndrew 22 OR | T 4yrs, Top 3.5yrs, Hysto 2.5yrs, Phallo 1yr•

Or a weekly topic where everyone can link their instas with some info about themselves

We actually have this! Social Media Saturday is now a place where you can share your social media accounts with others.

6
izalexEli - 20 - T 4/11/17 - Top 10/23/18•

Thank you guys. It was getting pretty ridiculous, lmao.

14
FoundAtFour-Oh39|HRT 2018-08-28•

Out of curiosity, would "look at my bottle of T/new birth certificate"-type posts (basically a celebratory pic of a milestone item with no context, story or question) be subjected to similar rules? I picked those examples because I've done both and they're essentially the same as the voice analysis-type posts. Thanks for this new initiative and for creating more space for stories, questions and discussions :)

13
TimberVolkOPMODAndrew 22 OR | T 4yrs, Top 3.5yrs, Hysto 2.5yrs, Phallo 1yr•

Currently this only affects selfies/selfie-esque photos and voice posts specifically, since those are like 99% of what gunks up the sub's "Hot" sorting. If we do see a similar issue popping up with those once selfies are out of the way, however, we may enforce stricter rules for those sorts of things too.

12
Ebomb1Top 13y|T 9y|Hyst 8y | IDEK anymore•

I think "look at my first T vial" posts should fall under the rule. They don't have additional useful content and don't even have the redeeming feature of a getting to see a human face.

17
flyingmountain•

100% agreed here. A photo of an inanimate object does not constitute good/useful content for this sub. Unless it's part of a large product review or something, no one is getting anything out of it. At least when people post comparison pictures there's some kind of utility in seeing progress over time.

14
AlexaviortheBravier31 |T: 3/15|Top: 4/16|Hyst/O: 09/17•

We'll probably discuss it. When we made this decision, it was not something that came up much. Pictures of T vials were far less likely than voice images to cause a cascade of similar images and they never filled the top of the subreddit like selfies did.

Personally, I agree with your opinion, but we all try our best not to moderate based on personal opinion and to moderate for the community as a whole. (Aka, it really was never mentioned to us not to mention mentioned multiple times like selfies and the voice posts were.)

5
FoundAtFour-Oh39|HRT 2018-08-28•

I'm someone guilty of it, and I agree. Chalk it up to being a newb.

1
Ebomb1Top 13y|T 9y|Hyst 8y | IDEK anymore•

Everyone is at some point!

5
Wild-King•

Thank goodness. I can't filter out the selfie posts with my method of redditting and it's gotten out of control. I hate 97% of faces and can't stand looking at them. Even that 3% I'd rather not look at. No offense to people's faces; it's not you, it's me.

Question though. For posts that are celebratory but are accompanied by a photo or photos, are those allowed or should they be reported too? A majority are a celebratory title and then a photo with nothing else. Sometimes flaired "selfie", sometimes flaired "celebratory".

Also I can edit my comment if people are taking it the wrong way

11
AlexaviortheBravierMOD31 |T: 3/15|Top: 4/16|Hyst/O: 09/17•

It is about the content of the post, not the flair.

So, yes, celebratory that are just selfies fall under this rule.

Now, if someone made a post about their wedding and talked about the wedding details and at the end, included a picture; that would be okay. But the point of the post would have to be the text description of the experience, feelings, thoughts, etc. not to share a pictures.

1
Redjay12•

what about a before after transitioning photo

3
Ebomb1Top 13y|T 9y|Hyst 8y | IDEK anymore•

Not a mod, but as I understand the new rule, it's meant to keep validation-only photo posts to a minimum and encourage more written content creation. In terms of benefit to the community, I would hope that allowed before/afters would show a significant time lapse/transition progress and be accompaned by text with more details--dose, reasons for dose, access route, challenges, successes, or similar sharing about surgery--enough about the person so the comments can be a conversation instead of just a string of "looking good!"s.

7
AlexaviortheBravier31 |T: 3/15|Top: 4/16|Hyst/O: 09/17•

Essentailly what u/Ebomb1 said. Transition photos would be included.

When the text is the main focus and the pictures merely supplement the text, pictures are okay. Think about the difference between a news article and a picture book. Sometimes pictures are relevant, add depth to the text, or provided needed content, in that case they are fine.

As the OP says, if a post is clearly just an attempt to avoid the selfie rule, it will be removed.

4
flyingmountain•

Thank you! So happy about this, particularly with regard to the voice pitch analyzer screenshots.

If we notice any misplaced posts that slipped through the cracks, what's the best way to flag them for the mods? Report? Under what "rule" for the time being?

8
TimberVolkOPAndrew 22 OR | T 4yrs, Top 3.5yrs, Hysto 2.5yrs, Phallo 1yr•

Actually it appears we now have a rule for such things! Thanks u/AlexaviortheBravier! You can go ahead and flag them under Rule 10 now :)

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Ebomb1Top 13y|T 9y|Hyst 8y | IDEK anymore•

This is going to be a hell of a lot of work for you but I think it's a good move.

8
jotxgalacticx•

Sounds like a great move. I have to admit that the frequent selfies is a big reason I haven’t frequented this sub in a while.

8
Inkspotty•

Same! I liked it better when the sub had little or no selfies at all. Selfies get very repetitive and don't really add anything new to a conversation.

2
charlieinlove•

Seems like a good move! Just wondering, are the days of posting according to U.S days? I live in New Zealand (a day ahead) and want to make sure I post on the correct days. Thanks!

7
TimberVolkOPAndrew 22 OR | T 4yrs, Top 3.5yrs, Hysto 2.5yrs, Phallo 1yr•

The days/times don't really matter since the days only correspond to automated posts that you can comment on all week, they're not just days that determine what you can/can't post. Sorry if that wasn't clear!

7
failtrocity24 | T: 3/1/2019•

Hey fellow Nzer! Thanks for asking this was wondering the same!

2
calcaneus•

Thank you. All my upvote.

7
mshcat•

I thought that the Flair's were supposed to help with that. Do we have a flair for selfies, because we could add that and let people filter what they don't want to see. I personally like the selfie pictures. It's easier to look at, you don't have to go to a different site to look at it, and it's easier to reply to

4
TimberVolkOPAndrew 22 OR | T 4yrs, Top 3.5yrs, Hysto 2.5yrs, Phallo 1yr•

We do have a flair for selfies, but the problem is, that filtering isn't available to everyone or super easy to access depending on which device they're on. Also it's just become too many selfies no matter which way you look at it; the top 20 posts when sorted by "Hot" had like 1 text post, and the rest were primarily selfies. This is supposed to be a support-based forum, and while I understand people find these selfies supportive/uplifting, it's burying more pressing content such as questions, advice, requests for help/support, and other actual discussion. As it were, the sub essentially turned into FTM Instagram.

12
mshcat•

I'm curious as to what devices don't allow flair filtering

-1†
TimberVolkOPAndrew 22 OR | T 4yrs, Top 3.5yrs, Hysto 2.5yrs, Phallo 1yr•

I'm not sure off the top of my head what all devices do/don't allow flair filtering, but I do know that there are dozens of third-party reddit apps that people may use based on individual Reddit uses/needs they need to fulfill, and I can't guarantee all of them allow for it.

Also some, like appears to be the case with the official Reddit app (on Android), require you to know how to use Reddit search booleans, which is one of those things you really don't know are a possibility unless someone tells you; they're sort of difficult to just stumble upon if you don't know they exist/might exist. So again, even if it's possible, it may not be readily apparent.

Edit: Also if you're using the Reddit redesign, the modulated format of the sidebar isn't as space-efficient and the filter buttons were pushed way to the bottom of the sidebar as a result. You really have to scroll to find them—again, if you're even aware they can be found/exist at all.

8
javatimes12 years on T | Top Surgery 8/18•

I still use alien blue sometimes and that’s an app that doesn’t do post flairs

5
zacholotl•

i’m stupid and i’m on mobile... i can’t figure out how to find the threads to post in??

3
TimberVolkOPMODAndrew 22 OR | T 4yrs, Top 3.5yrs, Hysto 2.5yrs, Phallo 1yr•

If you're just on the mobile browser site you can go to the search function and type "flair:recurring". It should come up with a list! If you're using the official app and this doesn't work/apply, let me know and I may have to download it to check into available workarounds.

6
Mad-Mandrake•

Personally I don't like this change but I guess it could be a good move for you guys. I like to see reaffieming images, and reading so much discussions can worsen dysphoria for some ppl, so I guess ill be using the selfie thread or wherever images are posted now.

3
Mad-Mandrake•

Yah reading through all the vents is making me extreamly dysphoric, I'll just use this subreddit on sundays image threads then or if they make a thread for selfies

1