Restrictions in Cube, or, please stop misusing 'restrictions breed creativity'

The heated argument yesterday around the value of a singleton restriction in cube made me realise just how incredibly abused Mark Rosewater's 'restrictions breed creativity' quote is, and it seems that the main reason for this is that people seem to think that creativity in and of itself is a virtue rather than simply a useful trait, and that somehow, imposing arbitrary restrictions upon yourself improves your cube.

This, to me, represents a fundamental misunderstanding of cube design. While it can absolutely serve as a creative outlet, noone is trying to design a cube in which creativity is the end goal. A cube which only includes cards with art of birds flying to the right is very 'creative', but I would politely decline if someone invited me to play it.

There are absolutely valid restrictions in cube, restrictions which do 'breed creativity'. A not-uncommon thread to see here is something like 'How do I build the best cube with a budget of $150?' - a budget restriction. The key concept in this request is 'the best cube' - which I always interpret as 'the most fun cube for my playgroup', i.e. we are aiming for fun-maximisation as the end goal, and in this case, we need to maximise fun with a restriction of only spending $150 on cards. Suddenly we are forced to be creative, but we are not being creative for its own sake, we are trying to find a solution which creates the most fun for a playgroup at a given budget.

Of course, the unaddressed question is 'how do we define fun for a playgroup?', and here is where thinking diverges. Maybe the playgroup are all spikes, and you are trying to create the most competitive environment you can for $150? Maybe they all played when they were younger, and you are trying to create a highly nostalgic environment with your $150? Maybe they enjoy silly swingy games, and playing huge haymakers, and you are trying to build the most degenerate environment you can for $150?

All of these are perfectly valid, and as part of building toward these, the pursuit of fun (or enjoyment)-maximisation is naturally going to result in other self-imposed restrictions. You will probably choose to include a roughly equal representation of colours, since that allows for greater draft variety. Similarly, a number of people in yesterday's thread commented that they liked running singleton lists because they enjoyed seeing a wider variety of cards - so perhaps for the nostalgic group above staying singleton is fun-maximisation. On the flip side, maybe it is impossible to get the redundancy of effects you need for your competitive environment without breaking singleton - so imposing a singleton restriction upon yourself doesn't actually maximise the fun of the environment. All of these outcomes are fine, but these are hardly the sorts of restriction that 'breeds creativity', rather it is an almost inevitable consequence of your larger goal.

Another good example of a restriction which does spur creativity is an aesthetic restriction (though please don't build my 'birds flying right' cube from earlier). Building a cube using only old-border cards is probably a pretty interesting adventure, but it is obviously going to play worse than a cube with very similar ideas that includes a modern border card here and there to shore up archetypes. Chances are that the aesthetic pleasure of the cube for the designer and players outweighs the impact on the fun of the actual gameplay, so it doesn't really matter.

The other reason to arbitrarily restrict yourself is to prevent analysis paralysis. Designing a cube is hard - there are thousands and thousands of Magic cards, and 10^700+ possible combinations of them in a 360 card cube! If putting restrictions upon yourself means you finish a cube and start playing it as opposed to leaving it as 40 incomplete cubetutor sketches, that probably results in more fun overall (unless you subscribe to the Balduvian Trading Post-school of cube-design). It is important to recognise when your restrictions are of this form, as they certainly mean your environment doesn't play as well as it could - but that is what play-testing is for.

Edit: Some of the responses to this post have led me to refine my argument slightly. I missed a class of cube designers in my post - those building a cube for a group which already has a primary cube, as well as those who are designing a cube as an intellectual or creative pursuit, rather than for a playgroup. In these scenarios, emphasising creativity can be a mechanism by which you are also maximising everyone's fun.

There is a lot of enjoyment to be found in novelty - and playing a list which causes me to have to put aside my assumptions about cards and see them in a whole new light offers a lot of 'joy of discovery', even if the actual gameplay might not offer the same level of replayability as a list built without the same restrictions. Seeing cards interact together in interesting and new ways is very exciting when it happens in a cube you are familiar with, and designing a list with arbitrary restrictions or guidelines which are likely to prompt that response more often does sound like a worthwhile pursuit seeking fun, even though you might not want to play such a list all the time. It is also likely going to require a lot of creativity to put together.

This class of restriction is probably quite similar to the aesthetic restriction outlined above, only instead of being rewarded with aesthetic pleasure for choosing to build using only lands, instants and sorceries (thanks u/Ixoran), you and your players are rewarded with a uniqueness of experience, and the joy of having to rediscover and reevaluate whole classes of Magic cards.

So, what attributes cause your cube to be the 'best' cube for your playgroup, and what restrictions shape your list?

tldr; If you have to build a bridge, and only have wood, then you will need to be creative in your engineering. If you have to build a bridge, and declare 'I refuse to use steel', then your bridge will never be as elegantly designed as it could be. If you have to build a bridge, and say 'I want to use wood because it is beautiful', that is fine, provided the specification wasn't for the optimally engineered bridge.

Posted Jan 10, 2019, 9:43 AM UTC · edited

6819
Loading comments…