ELI5: How does a Vickrey auction work?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vickrey_auction
It says that the highest bidder wins, but they pays the amount bid by the second-highest bidder. Am I interpreting this wrong? Why can't you just bid a billion dollars, because you never pay your bidded amount?
Posted Jan 10, 2019, 8:40 PM UTC
46
I think what you’re missing is the purpose of auch auctions. The purpose of this auction as a buyer is to buy a product of unknown price for about as much as it is worth to you.
You don’t bid in an auction to win (usually) but to buy a product of limited availability for the price you are willing to pay. The problem is, that you as a bidder don’t know, what everyone else is bidding. You might be willing to pay 1000$ for it, but when the second highest bidder just wants to pay 10$ you effectively wasted 990$.
So you guess, that other people are just willing to pay around 10$ for it, so you bid 20$. But let’s now say your guess was wrong, and someone else bid actually 21$. You lost, despite the fact, that you were willing to pay 50 times as much, if it were necessary.
This kind of auction fixes this. Now you can actually bid your 1000$ you are willing to pay, full knowing, that you won’t waste any unnecessary dollars.
To answer your question: you don’t simply bid 1 billion $, because it’s not about winning, but it’s about buying a product for a reasonable price.
And if you’re not willing to pay more than 500$ you shouldn’t be sad if anyone else wins paying 750$, because you wouldn’t want it for that much anyways.
Okay, now it makes sense. So if you value the item at $500 and bid $1 billion, and second-place values it at $600 and bids that amount, you win the auction but overpay $100. Is that right?
Yep, exactly.