r/smashbros•
Setchi

Can people stop being toxic about the guy modding ultimate?

Ultimate

https://twitter.com/NyxTheShield

For people that don't know, this guy has been modding ultimate to make the wavedashing and movement more like Melee.

Now, if you don't prefer or like melee that's absolutely fine, but can people stop harassing this guy? He's just trying to have more fun with the game, he's not saying ultimate is a bad game he's just making it more fun FOR HIM.

There are many people on twitter and reddit harassing him over it, and even reporting it to nintendo and @ing them on twitter about it.

How can you say that the Melee community is toxic if this sort of harassment isn't called out properly in your community? Live and let live.

Posted Jan 11, 2019, 8:32 PM UTC

612
db1416Falco (Ultimate)•

The people harassing him have way too much time on their hands and they are childish. He’s doing something he finds fun and it’s something people seem to want. It’s not like he’s trying to sell it and make money off of it, he’s doing it for fun. People are such buzzkills sometimes.

24
ItsKipzSSB64 Fox is better than Melee Fox.•

I don't think harassing him is right at all, but I really don't agree with someone attempting to "fix" ultimate this early. The worst case scenario is that he manages to fracture the community into Ultimate players and Project Ultimate players and ultimately (heh) kills the competitive scene for both. Best case scenario, he just wastes a bunch of time for nothing.

EDIT: Gotta say tho, going through this guy's tweets I'm pretty impressed with the effort he's put in and the mod looks pretty clean.

17
VegetezMarth•

The modder did all of it for his own fun and shared his progress online. He isn't "fixing" the game, he is messing around with it and having fun.

21
Dumplexer•

He is fixing parts that he finds unfun

17
VegetezMarth•

Fixing isn't the right term at all to use. It implies ultimate is bad and you fix it by turning it into melee, which isn't the intention of the modder.

6
ItsKipzSSB64 Fox is better than Melee Fox.•

https://twitter.com/NyxTheShield/status/1083625334447185920

https://twitter.com/NyxTheShield/status/1083574756341940224

https://twitter.com/NyxTheShield/status/1082892071910948864

https://twitter.com/NyxTheShield/status/1082831622406369285

Again, I don't support harassing him, but he's made his intention pretty clear. He wants to "fix" ultimate, a game which I thought was pretty accepted to be good competitively, to be more like Melee.

17
Richter_Is_Bad•

How is that best case scenario? Best case is that both games thrive. Not that I expect it to. If Project M died to the hands of Nintendrones, Project Ultimate does not stand a chance. Realistically, even Melee might start struggling. Ultimate is really the only good Smash to have come out since, so we will have to see how it impacts Melee as this is a first.

-7
ItsKipzSSB64 Fox is better than Melee Fox.•

This early in the game's lifespan, both games thriving isn't realistic. Melee players will 9 times out of 10 pick the mod if it has closer mechanics.

10
FenrirW0lfall awoos, all the time•

Eh, I don't think that's the case. There were a ton of individual factors that all combined to allow PM to grow as big as it once did, but the vast majority of them no longer exist. The biggest confounding factor nowadays is that Nintendo is absolutely not going to tolerate a mod of their biggest, most recent game getting exposure at major tournaments, so most Melee players are going to stick with a game that won't be under constant threat of getting squashed out of existence.

Plus there are a number of little corner cases where PM doesn't quite line up with Melee, and at higher levels of play it's almost worse having to deal with minuscule differences in similar games vs major differences between games like Melee and Ultimate. There were quite a lot of Melee players who either stopped playing PM at all or moved to it exclusively because of that, and I don't think that lesson is going to be forgotten when considering whether future mods are worth dedicating extensive time to.

3
FreezieKO•

If he didn't want criticism, he could've just tinkered with the code in his basement. Instead, he posted the project and made it public, and people are commenting.

The mod is based entirely on the creative work of others. If he can't take criticism of that, then just wait until he tries doing something actually creative.

And there's nothing wrong with alerting Nintendo. If this guy isn't breaking any laws, then he should be in the clear.

1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
B3_Prof•

Nay

-7