r/3d6•
NotTroy

Multiple/Extra Attacks Vs. All-Or-Nothing

This is less asking for advice and more just something that I'm curious about. What are the pros and cons of offensive strategies that make use of multiple attacks (Extra Attack Fighters, EB Locks, Frenzy Barbs, etc.) vs strategies that use one large all-or-nothing attack/spell (e.g. SCAG cantrips like BB and GFB)? I'm sure someone somewhere has done the math on how dpr is affected by things like hit and crit chance when it comes to this aspect of combat, but I'm having a bit of trouble googling good analysis. If anyone has a link to something that would help me quantify the difference, I'd be grateful.

​

To be clear, I'm not looking for in depth analysis of Fighters vs. Clerics or something like that, but instead a more general idea of how results are affected by doing all the damage on one hit vs spreading it out over multiple attacks which all have their own separate attack rolls.

Posted Jan 12, 2019, 3:16 AM UTC

3333
vancurious•

One advantage multiple attacks have over all or nothing is less wastage of DPR via overkill: if one opponent is killed, then one can redirect attacks towards another.

54
Haboobalub•

I'll break down everyones post for ya.

Extra attack scales better with feats, crits, magic items and things that trigger on hit and has a better consistent damage.

Single powerful attacks feel good.

30
jozza05•

Fucking hell they feel good, “one” shotting cr17 monster at level 11 (two fully rested pally/warlock crits in a turn I used everything)

6
eduw•

I kind of want to do an AnyDice comparisson between a Multiattack scenario (prolly CBE fighter) and a Smiter (prolly a Vengeance Sorcadin?) but I have no idea what is paladin's optimized combo at level 11-12.

Anyone mind commenting on what would be the optimized combo?

1
Deathmon44•

One level of Hexblade, two levels Paladin, the rest Sorc.

1
jozza05•

On that toon I was pally 6 warlock 5

So I could triple smite on my first attack

I ended up with like 500 odd dmg in two swings using a gwm lucky build (I rolled 18’s so I didnt need asi’s at all)

1
Daelnoron•

Single, powerful attacks also scale better with help actions, guiding bolts or other "advantage on next attack" effects.

3
Haboobalub•

There's so many ways to get permanent advantage it really doesn't matter.

2
Daelnoron•

and there are feats that work better on single attacks and why crits are superior on extra attacks is something you'd need to explain to me.

You claimed to summarize (somewhat facetiously, I get that), otherwise I wouldn't have gotten involved.

I'm with you that more attacks are clearly superior, but there are a few (probably overshadowed) benefits single attacks still have.

0
Haboobalub•

Better chance to crit with extra attacks. Which feats are you speaking of?

2
rmch99Every character I make is a chaotic-good lesbian spellblade•

I mean, it's more consistent with damage spread over more attacks, assuming the damage is exactly equally spread, you're more likely to do some damage, less likely to do max damage, and do the same average damage, with multiple attacks over a single, because that's how averages work.

29
RegulusMagnus•

Anecdote from last night, playing a Paladin 5 / Warlock 1:

We were fighting something that resisted slashing damage. I dipped Warlock mostly for BB and GFB, and GFB was proving very useful while they were grouped up. Once a single target remained (that I had Vow of Enmity on), I had the choice of cantrip for guaranteed non-slashing damage, or two regular swings. With advantage on two attacks, I decided to go for the multiattack, hoping that one of the 4 dice would hit a critical roll. I had a feeling, and it paid off! Second attack was a crit, giving me 4d6+3 slashing plus 4d8 radiant from a smite.

TL;DR: more attacks = more chances to crit, which should be factored in.

20
Jimmicky•

Mostly the difference is consistency.

4 attacks of D8 damage each is almost always going to do some damage. At least one of those is going to hit.

But at least one of those is likely to miss too, whereas 1 attack doing 4d8 is all or nothing- if it hits you are rolling all the d8s.

The average result in both instances is the same, but the standard deviation is much smaller on the multi-attack.

Crits don’t significantly change this - the 4 attacks crit 4 times more often, but each crit adds only 1/4 as much.

Multi-attack for stability, single attack for swing.

BUT damage riders (like hunters mark, hex, divine strike, etc, etc, etc) change this significantly. Once rider effects are a factor multiple attacks pulls in front significantly as far as average/expected damage goes.

11
jwrose•

Comparing a theoretical mega-hit that does X damage, with a series of hits all done in one round that do a total of X damage, comes out to the same average damage.

As other comments have said, typically the series of hits is better, as it is more predictable, and less likely to waste damage as overkill on a single target.

In real play, though, this comparison can’t be done. Because of the -5/+10 feats, and hit/damage bonuses on magic weapons; more attacks ends up being way more damage on average, in most realistic cases.

Additionally, if you have effect riders on your attacks (maneuvers, grapples/shoves, and to an extent smites and blade flourishes), having multiple smaller attacks gives you significantly more influence over the battlefield.

8
Necropath•

The extreme example of why Extra Attack is king when it comes to damage is a Rogue vs. a Fighter. A Rogue needs advantage to deal an average of 44.5 damage on a hit with one attack. A Fighter will deal an average of 48 damage over four attacks regardless of advantage. When you start to add magic items, feats, and other class abilities, the gap becomes wider.

An Assassin Rogue with Green Flame Blade and a +3 Rapier does 114 average damage on an Assassinate, or 228 average damage if Death Attack triggers on top of it. This requires winning initiative and surprise. Rounds 2+ will deal 61 average damage.

A Battlemaster Fighter with Hex, Crossbow Expert, and a +3 Hand Crossbow deals 92.5 average damage each round. This doesn’t include up to an additional 32.5 average damage from Superiority Dice. This requires attacking.

What this means is that after round 6 of combat (5 if you use superiority dice, less than that if any attack crits), the Fighter’s total damage is more than the Rogue. On top of that, the Rogue has one chance at a +14 to hit and deal it’s damage, and needs advantage to deal 35 of it. The Fighter is attacking 5 times a round at +16 to hit, can spread its attacks over multiple enemies, and only loses 18.5 damage if an attack misses.

Note that I didn’t include Action Surge, Sharpshooter, or multi-classing.

7
hexachoron•

Rogue don't need advantage to use Sneak Attack, they can use it if an ally is next to the target. Arcane Tricksters can also have a familiar use the Help action each round to provide advantage if no allies are nearby. Another option is to caste Shadow Blade and have advantage on all attacks in dim light or darkness.

Let's take an Arcane Trickster Rogue at level 20 with a +3 rapier and 20 Dex. Using Booming Blade and Haste, they will do 1d8 + 10d6 + 3d8 + 8 = 61 avg with the first attack, 79 if the target moves. If that attack misses then they can alse use a bonus action to attack again with an off-hand dagger for another chance at SA.

The rogue can then use the extra action from Haste to Ready an attack and Sneak Attack again during the same round using their reaction. That's another 1d8 + 10d6 + 8 = 47.5 avg, for a total of 108.5 dmg/round (126.5 w/ extra BB dmg). This is all from basic single-class features only, no feats.

But fights in D&D are rarely ever 1v1. A better solution would be to have the Battlemaster use a Commander's Strike maneuver to sacrifice a single one of his attacks and allow the Rogue to Sneak Attack again with his reaction. The Rogue can then swap Haste for Shadow Blade upcast to level 3. Assuming hits with both attacks, the Rogue will do (1d8 + 10d6 + 3d8 + 3d8 + 8) + (1d8 + 10d6 + 3d8 + 1d8 + 8) = 140 avg per round (158 if target moves).

Also note that a crit on Sneak Attack will double all the dice and with advantage will happen ~10% of the time. A crit on the attack using BB and SB will do 2d8 + 20d6 + 6d8 + 6d8 + 8 (+4d8) = 141 (159) avg and you still have a second Sneak Attack to go. With advantage on both SA attempts you have an ~18.5% chance of at least one crit each round.

3
Maelwy5•

Unfortunately the Booming Blade + Haste + Reserved SA thing doesn't work RAW. The extra action granted by Haste can only be used for specific actions, none of which is the Ready action.

You can use the Hasted action to perform a standard Attack on your turn (triggering SA) and use your regular action to Ready a standard Attack for someone else's turn (also triggering SA) ...but unless you aren't the one concentrating on Haste, you can't ready a Spellcast of Booming Blade (since holding a Spellcast action also uses concentration). An alternative is using Shadow Blade instead of Haste then grabbing the Warcaster feat and exploiting Opportunity Attacks to cast Booming Blade on someone else's turn...

2x regular SAs from a single Arcane Trickster is still great DPR though. Particularly if you can use some combination of Bonus Action Hide, Mage Hand's "Versatile Trickster" and Find Familiar to gain advantage on both attacks. Especially with Elven Accuracy and a 3 level dip into Champion Fighter for Crits on both a 19 + a 20: you can get up to 27.1% chance of a critical hit on each attack!

3
hexachoron•

Ah you're correct, I forgot that I was using the regular action to Ready and the Haste action for the first SA, preventing use of BB. With that taken into account the average dpr would be 95, still a significant increase over the 61 dpr above. This will be even higher in a realistic game where the Rogue is bringing friends (e.g. the 45-63 dpr bump in the Maneuvering Strike scenario).

3
sdrow_sdrawkcab•

One upside of all or nothing is breaking concentration and damage threshold easier

3
madzag•

I'd argue that an enemy has a lower chance of succeeding on three consecutive DC 10 saves than on one DC 20 one. Though there could be special cases, like an ally imposing disadvantage on a single save, or only getting one chance to attack the enemy.

2
sdrow_sdrawkcab•

+9 con saving throw

1
adalast•

Truly it depends on what you are talking about for rule sets. In 5th all extra attacks are done at the same attack bonus, so everything people are saying is correct.

If you are in Pathfinder/3.5 it is a little more complex. Generally the expected damage you can do is the average damage for the attack, calculated as minimum roll + (maximum roll - minimum roll)/2 + bonus damage, times the expectation of hitting, which is just (10+hit-AC)/20 clamped between 0 and 1.

As an example we have a level 5 barbarian with 22 strength swinging a normal greatsword on a mob 13 AC. So his to hit will be +11, his damage will be 2d6+9. So the average damage will be 16 and his odds of hitting will be 0.4, giving is an average damage of 6.4. Moving up one level to 6 gives us an attack mod of +12/+7. Now here is where it tricks out some. The average damage on the first swing becomes 7.2 thanks to the increase in hit, and the second adds on 3.2 damage bringing the total to 10.4 damage.

Now if we were to take a look at the same barbarian dual wielding light maces, still 2d6 damage, but with full strength bonus on each, it is 1d6+6 + 1d6+6. Assuming that you are taking the TWF feats, you get an attack bonus at level 5 of +9/+9 giving an odds of hitting on each hit if 0.3. Average damage per swing will be 9.5, so the total average will 5.7. Getting level 6 brings along improved TWF and an extra two attacks at +10/+10/+5/+5, or 0.35 and 0.1 respectively. The same 9.5 average swing damage gives us 8.55 damage. In this case, the damage takes a real hit from the accuracy loss due to TWF, but if we make that a little more negligible, say if you were against someone with a 10 AC, the level 6 2 hander would see an average of 15.2 damage and the TWF sees 14.25 damage.

This is of course excluding critical, though including them is somewhat tricky, but it would be an application of Bayes Theorem for the probability of getting a critical or not. I can do this if you like, but I think this was deep enough to show that extra attacks are great, if you are good enough to hit them. 10% accuracy penalty is pretty steep for quite a while, or unless you have some other way to offset it. Also, it is worth noting that the + modifier on damage is hugely more important than adding more d's, unless it is A LOT more d's. Sneak attack is an example of this. Dual wielding as a rogue is obscene amounts of damage as getting sneak attack on each hit offsets any damage loss you may see from accuracy. Also, flanking negates the dual wield penalty.

3
S-J-S•

Extra Attack lets you add modifier damage more, have a better chance of at least hitting, get multiple kills / spread damage after a kill, and take advantage of damage adders like Hex. There’s no question that it’s better than a single powerful attack.

3

If an enemy spellcaster has super high constitution saves, you'll want to have a few very strong attacks to try to break it. If not, having more attacks will be better for breaking concentration.

2
falloutboy14•

A few things that would be different. I'll use the terms EA(extra attack) vs Cantrip

  1. more rolls from EA will produce more 1s. Depending on how your table handles these would be how big a deal this is.

  2. Breaking concentration. EA will hit more, so more con saves for the opposing caster. Cantrips will hit harder, but you need to break 22+ damage to increase the save. That would be pretty rare until cantrips get their 4th tier damage increase.

2
Haboobalub•

Most of my characters average damage is 22+ each hit. I usually take sharpshooter and great weapon master. Using cantrips is always a suboptimal way to deal damage in normal circumstances.

I know that you'll bring up the likelyhood of actually hitting and I can assure you that it's not an issue.

1
rickandmonty•

So, time for a bit of maths, but I will give a few points to note beforehand. Firstly forgive me, this is on mobile, and also long af. This question, has way too many variables to give an exact general answer, so I've just gone for the extreme case of a level 20 fighter with 4 attacks and a level 20 EK with GFB both against something with an AC of 16. So DPR is based on the expectation values of damage per attack, so with 4 attacks we're gonna get some wild results. Firstly let's find out some probabilities, and to do this we need to define a few things: "Skill"= proficiency+Ability modifier+weapon bonus = 6+5+0 for both cases We are using a longsword so damage is 1d8 Crit: 1/20 Hit: 19/20*(1-[AC-skills]/19) =7/10 Miss: 19/20*([AC-skills]/19) = 1/4 These are the same for both EK and fighter.

So to find the DPR, we need to find the expectation values, and this is based on the combination of damage of each roll times the probability of getting that combination of rolls, for example rolling 4 crits is the most damaging but also the least likely. So what combinations are there? Well: Hit+miss+crit is what we get for a single attack, so: (Hit+miss+crit)⁴ gives probability combinations for all four attacks. Now I'm not going to write this expansion out because it's very long, however it is necessary to calculate it, as each term will have a unique probability and also a unique damage coefficient. But in general for four attacks this will be: Sum over i,j,k to n=4 of {C(4,i)C(4-k,j)(i+2j)d8 + (i+j)[damage modifier])*[P(hit)^{i}*P(crit)^{j}*P(miss)^{k}]} Note the binomial coefficients in that may be wrong, just expand the (hit+miss+crit)⁴ Through a long expansion and some computation we get the expected value at: 29.4

Now we do the same process for GFB, with an Int bonus of +5 and a strength bonus of +5, we get at level 20 that GFB gives us 1d8+5+3d8+3d8+5 for a normal attack. Since this is a normal attack, and the only one you can take (excluding haste and bonus action attacks) , you.either hit or miss and this means that there is a 25% chance to deal no damage, that said, the expectation value of the GFB, with another target in range is: 32.7 DPR. However, if there isn't another target within range, this goes down to: 18.15 DPR

Conclusions: More attacks, gives consistently more damage but a single big single attack is good against low AC, high HP enemies, and more than one of them. Whereas multi-attack is good for wrecking the face of one tough guy, or more, so as most other replies have said, it's situational.

P.S. got kinda drunk halfway through this so hope the maths checks out

1