Multiple/Extra Attacks Vs. All-Or-Nothing
This is less asking for advice and more just something that I'm curious about. What are the pros and cons of offensive strategies that make use of multiple attacks (Extra Attack Fighters, EB Locks, Frenzy Barbs, etc.) vs strategies that use one large all-or-nothing attack/spell (e.g. SCAG cantrips like BB and GFB)? I'm sure someone somewhere has done the math on how dpr is affected by things like hit and crit chance when it comes to this aspect of combat, but I'm having a bit of trouble googling good analysis. If anyone has a link to something that would help me quantify the difference, I'd be grateful.
To be clear, I'm not looking for in depth analysis of Fighters vs. Clerics or something like that, but instead a more general idea of how results are affected by doing all the damage on one hit vs spreading it out over multiple attacks which all have their own separate attack rolls.
Posted Jan 12, 2019, 3:16 AM UTC
One advantage multiple attacks have over all or nothing is less wastage of DPR via overkill: if one opponent is killed, then one can redirect attacks towards another.