Reliable SUV on a budget?

I am in the Pacific Northwest(Canada). Lots of rain and ocassional snow. My eyes go after the 2018 GMC Terrain. Could get one for as low as $25k CAD(i believe). Our car was a Venza that after 7 years started over consuming oil and recently a write off. It was a mix bag of nuts. Some things were good some were not. I am afraid of going after toyota again. From what i read they are notorious for oil overconsumption. Have read the same stories about subarus. With that in mind, aside from the terrain, what should i look into?

Posted Jan 12, 2019, 3:33 PM UTC

232
banjalien•

I just got done looking at this class of SUV's, test driving a lot of them. My Top 3 was Mazda CX-5, Chevy Equinox, and Rav4

Rav4 being my least favorite

Mazda CX-5-It looks great, drives great. Negatives for me were I didn't like the way the transmission shifted and didn't like visibility as much.

Chevy Equinox-This is what I ended up with. It has higher reliability ratings than the Terrain and cheaper. I belong to a Chevy SUV forum and you see more issues with Terrain than Equinox. I have no idea why.

Tucson-It's a nice vehicle with nice options available but it has the Theta II engine. You can google "Hyundai Theta II recall or fires" and see why you don't want to go there.

Anyone telling you not to buy an American SUV and only Honda or Toyota doesn't know what they are talking about. Feel free to look up the American SUV's versus say the Honda CR-V on this site. The higher the index the worse problems it has.

http://www.carproblemzoo.com/honda/cr-v/ (Has the worst reliability rating)

http://www.carproblemzoo.com/toyota/rav4/

http://www.carproblemzoo.com/subaru/outback/ (Is 3X worse than Rav4 and Chevy, btw the Terrain scored about the same for the latest year)

VS

http://www.carproblemzoo.com/chevrolet/equinox/

So if you are going to worry about reliability from GM, you will have to worry about it from Subaru and Honda as well.

or if you want you can look at the "Clunker" sticker received for the 2017 and 2018 CRV here:

https://www.carcomplaints.com/Honda/CR-V/2017/

https://www.carcomplaints.com/Honda/CR-V/2018/

People need to stop with the don't buy American nonsense, especially if you are going to recommend the Honda. You have to base cars on individual models, years, and not just blanket statements about companies. There are SOME chevy's you don't want to buy just like Ford, just like Honda.

I can't help you much with the Ford but that is also an option. I didn't consider the ford because it gets the worst gas mileage of the bunch and a little bit lower safety ratings. I would at least give the Mazda and Equinox a chance.

​

8
weemo33OP•

Thanks for this. Insightful. I have friends who confidently purchase American cars because they never have issues with them including jeep.

2
banjalien•

My Ford F-150 has 260k miles on it, the drive shaft fell out at 210k...only issue I had in 15 yrs. I’m as far away from a brand loyalist as it gets. Certain American car models are very reliable, some are junk. You just have to do your research.

1
banjalien•

Btw you might want to look around at equinoxforums.net Terrain owners on there can give you further insight.

1
banjalien•

The more I research this the more I am starting to believe half the problem is the American car dealerships. I don’t know how they train service people but Ford and Chevy techs can create problems that don’t exist. I had a Ford tech mess up the fuel line on my truck when he changed filter...another crack my windshield and they had to pay for that too. I’ve never got the sense from Toyota that they were going to create problems my car didn’t have. I think the reliabilty of US cars would go up if greater quality control was in place at dealerships.

1
blue_soup_nazi•

What about a Hyundai Kona or Tucson?

3
weemo33OP•

Thanks didnt think about those

3
Derek71•

With the new generation of Ford Explorers coming, maybe you could get a good deal on one. They are pretty reliable over all and have been around a while. I would look into the 3.5 V6 instead of the 2.3 I4 EcoBoost if I were you.

2
martin509984•

Stay away from the Terrain. It's been an unreliable POS even so far and has a Tonka truck interior. My dad was considering one at the $40k range and ended up with a Buick Regal Sportback. While AWD models of that are out of reach for you, you could look into a very lightly used 2017 Buick Regal, the previous generation. It has AWD available and depreciates hard. I would also look to Hyundai or Kia in your price range. They make solid vehicles and I second the recommendation of a Tuscon. You can also look at the Mazda CX-5.

2
sleepystarynebula•

I actually disagree on the terrain, my mom's friend bought one and it hasn't broken or done anything bad, thing with gm is that really it depends from car to car, the Kia is ok, kinda dull in my opinion, the Buick I agree on, the cx-5, hahahaha, one thing about Mazda, Subaru and Nissan, all of there cvt transmissions will bite you in the ass, the only cvt I like is the Toyota one, but that's a stretch cause eh it barely moves the car, stay with a regular auto people

3
martin509984•

Mazda doesn't have a CVT.

3
sleepystarynebula•

My mistakes but I've herd they are a hassle to own

1
martin509984•

Maybe the older Ford-based Mazdas, but the newer CX-5 has proven decently reliable.

1
knifedinkidney•

They might call it a "Skyactiv" transmission, but it has continually variable gear ratios.

0
martin509984•

Nope, it's a regular 6 speed torque converter automatic.

1
Aterners•

Skyactiv is their engine, not transmission.

1
sleepystarynebula•

From what I've herd and seen, the Ford edge turbo v6 is amazing, eco friendly but also punchy. you really wanna go for gm, just know it's gonna be kinda risky, because some gm cars can come out amazing and reliable, others can bit you in the butt. Surprising Jeep's are getting more relable, through not the greatest milage

Cars to stay away from: Nissan's.... There cvt transmission is horrible and the engine is under powered, the company has fell off a cliff when it comes to relibility

2
weemo33OP•

Just driving a Nissan rental, not a fan whatsoever. Heard about cvt on subarus as well. They work well (from what i have been told) but if they break, is a throwaway not sure if thats true. Soon will be test driving will see thnx

1
weemo33OP•

Wow what a big hassle this has been. A lot of overpriced cars. I cant believe how car prices have just went up. Tried the Forester and I liked it but out of reach (including the basic model). It looks like a Crossover will be my choice but still undecided. The Crosstrek feels solid but meh. I felt better on the Qashqai we got as a rental, it just felt more like an SUV than the Crosstrek. Went to Hyundai and found them too pricey incuding the Kona. Will keep looking for I am a bit overwhelmed. Nothing really stands out and everything seems wrongly priced! The Terrain felt nice but also way overpriced.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
weemo33OP•

Subarus are overly priced here in Canada. The crosstek is around the looked price range but is on the smaller side. Hondas are also so pricey in Canada. Is almost as if anywhere i look, i cant get a deal like GMC. Reliability scares me away though

3
bourbonbeerboat•

I know you said SUV but what about an awd car? I just picked up a 2011 g37xS for $11500. Maybe you have other needs but I thought I'd throw this as an option.

3
sleepystarynebula•

Infinity, reliable and ok, untill recently, the cvt transmission is awful and the new varible compression engine I feel is gonna bit people in the ass

3

Hey, sleepystarynebula, just a quick heads-up:
untill is actually spelled until. You can remember it by one l at the end.
Have a nice day!

^^^^The ^^^^parent ^^^^commenter ^^^^can ^^^^reply ^^^^with ^^^^'delete' ^^^^to ^^^^delete ^^^^this ^^^^comment.

1
bourbonbeerboat•

My understanding is that it's supposed to be a very reliable car. It doesn't have the CVT transmission.

Sorry, I thought you were OP. My G37 doesn't have CVT. You are correct about those other items. I would be cautious about the CVT transmission as well.

1
weemo33OP•

How is it on gas?

2
bourbonbeerboat•

Around town it's under 20. On the freeway I think I think I'd get up to 24.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
sleepystarynebula•

Actually you would be surprised, while you engine might be fine, the cvt transmission is sluggish and breaks easily

3