Disolving Peanut Butter In Milk

So I have a very basic hot chocolate recipe that I personally enjoy very much. It's just 1 cup of very hot milk, stir 1 teaspoon of Hershey Cocoa powder into ⅛-¼ hot tap water until completely dissolved, then stir said hot Cocoa water into the hot milk with a packet or two of Splenda. Very simple. No more calories then straight milk, and to my Chocoholic self way better tasting.

This morning I thought, "I should put a little peanut butter in there." I use Crazy Richard's Just Peanuts which is literally just peanuts. No other ingredients.

I stirred it in directly to the fairly hot mixture and when I got to the bottom, there were all of these partially dissolved globs at the bottom.

Anyone have a way to get the peanut butter fully liquified?

Edit: I didn't even know Peanut Butter Powder was a thing. Definitely going to check that out! Thank you very much! Anyone have a way to work with what I have?

Posted Jan 12, 2019, 4:28 PM UTC · edited

1416
hyacyinth•

Have you tried PB2? It's peanut butter powder and I use it in drinks often (also less fat and calories if you're watching that!) I use a blender to blend it into drinks but I imagine if you whisked it into the hot drink there wouldn't be any lumps.

13
ThirdProcessOP•

Didn't even know that was a thing! And I am trying to eat marginally less-lethal, where can I find it?

5
TheLadyEve•

It's common in health food stores but you can also buy it online. Crazy Richard's and PBfit are two brands--but also look in your local grocery store because my Kroger's "simple truth organic" house brand makes some and it's cheaper than the name brands.

3
ThirdProcessOP•

Thank you, I appreciate it👍

1

My walmart has it next to normal peanut butter.

3
THE_DUCK_HORSE•

Put the peanut butter in a small bowl, with a splash of milk, and microwave at 15 second intervals. Stir between intervals. Add more milk as necessary. Keep microwaving/stirring until it is very liquidy like chocolate syrup. Then add it to the rest of your drink. Alternatively, you could do this in the mug, instead of a bowl, and after it’s liquified, add the rest of your liquid ingredients slowly while stirring to make sure it all gets incorporated.

By the way, if you do peanut butter powder, it will also stay as clumps if you just put it in a bunch of liquid. It does best if you mix it with a small amount of liquid until it’s dissolved (like you would for a cornstarch slurry). Then you can add it to your drink and it’ll blend much better.

13
ampersandator•

Edit: I didn't even know Peanut Butter Powder was a thing. Definitely going to check that out! Thank you very much! Anyone have a way to work with what I have?

You need to dissolve the peanut butter in hot water just like you do with the cocoa powder. I'd use boiling water, not just hot from the tap. It'll still settle over time, so you need to either drink quickly or stir occasionally.

9
TheLadyEve•

I would use peanut butter powder. All the flavor of PB and it will incorporate well.

3
jratmain•

What might work is to put the hot milk in a blender with the peanut butter (a Magic Bullet would work better but if you don't already have one, this isn't a great reason to get one). That will sort of force everything to emulsify. I'd do this when the milk is very hot and then reheat it after as it'll probably lose a lot of heat in the blending. Just stirring something so oily into milk probably won't work, oils and liquids don't like to emulsify.

2
ThirdProcessOP•

I was just thinking along those lines. That maybe there was a third ingredient that would be lipophilic and hydrophilic to pull it all together.

1
jratmain•

Soy lecithin, heh. But most people don't have that on-hand.

2
ThirdProcessOP•

Uh no lol. Besides I am anti-soy. It's a controversial opinion. It's just how I feel🤷🏻‍♂️

1
jratmain•

Eat what you like :)

2