Is anyone else getting nervous about the large amount of progressives running?

Discuss

Right now we already have Warren, Ojeda, Gabbard, Yang, and hopefully, Bernie Sanders. Then on top of that, we have establishment Democrat politicians like Harris, Booker, and Gillibrand, who are likely going to be trying to frame themselves as progressives.

I'm definitely not condemning progressives for throwing their hat in the race. I'm actually happy to see it. My only concern is that unless we end up with a similar number of centrist establishment candidates, that we might split the progressive vote and ending up with another establishment nominee.

Maybe it's too early to be thinking about this, but does this concern anyone else?

Posted Jan 12, 2019, 7:59 PM UTC

621
HIGH_ENERGY-VOTERHindsight2020•

i don't see Habbard, ojeda, or yang getting very far into the race. Warren is the only one that seems like a threat but not really. and its pretty obvious that Harris, booker, etc are not really progressives (although they try to act like it, or morph the meaning of the word to just standard liberals) especially if they go up to wall street and try to soak up their support.

10
HenryEVOPCalifornia•

its pretty obvious that Harris, booker, etc are not really progressives

While this is obvious to you, me, and most people in this sub, I am not so sure if the distinction between a progressive and a corporatist pandering to progressives will be clear to most of the country. I hope you are right, though.

4
beachyboy50•

I still like Harris quite a bit. She's no Sanders but she isn't like Booker.

3
ardelavanda•

Do Harris or Booker take corporate PAC $? I heard that they stopped a while ago but not sure if it's true

2
BebopFlow•

I think it's a good thing. It will completely change the tone and focus of the dialogue, and even the establishment candidates will have to adopt progressive policies in order to stay in the running. It's far too early to worry about splitting the vote.

8
axiomsofdominion2016 Veteran•

You mean they will lie about adopting progressive policies.

3

Tulsi and Ojeda are s running for VP, WARren will drop out, and Yang won’t even be in the debates

3
axiomsofdominion2016 Veteran•

I doubt Warren will drop out. She has a good chance at staying at 10-20% of the vote, which gives her power at the convention.

6
Zepherx22Massachusetts•

I think Ojeda is actually running for Shelly Moore-Capito’s Senate seat, but yeah, same diff

1
silvertui•

the possibility of vote splitting does indeed worry me. But we have to stand 100 percent behind Sanders.

3
seamslegitCalifornia - 2016 Veteran•

In 2019 and January 2020 I am happy to have as many candidates as want to travel the country, get lots of press and stand on the debate stages talking about Medicare-for-all, paid college tuition, marijuana legalization, ending foreign military intervention, campaign finance reform, net neutrality and all the other progressive issues. They are going to all push the progressive agenda to the party mainstream. Unless you live in Iowa and maybe New Hampshire you are never going to have to choose between progressives. They are smart enough to consolidate the progressive vote to the front runner hopefully before Iowa but definitely before Super Tuesday.

3
HenryEVOPCalifornia•

That’s a good point. It is way too early for it to be an issue. I just hope that after New Hampshire they’ve narrowed it down to at most 2 progressives.

2
BopTheDrassCanada•

A huge number of candidates are going to drop out early. There will be way more establishment candidates than progressive ones, leading to a greater vote split.

2
LetsSeeTheFacts•

Ok how about this information.

The HAF founder defended the destruction of a mosque by violent Hindu fundamentalists where hundreds more were killed before. Organized by Modi's poltiical party. He explicitly said he supported Hindutva and Hindu Nationalism.

That essay was featured in Modi's party website!!

Again this is one thing. You say "Indian Nationalism" not "Hindu Nationalism" which is the problem.

It's like saying "American Nationalism" not "White Nationalism".

The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) credited Meghani as the author of an essay on their website titled Hindutva: The Great Nationalist Ideology, which claims that Hindus and Hinduism were denigrated by the Indian National Congress and that Hindus rose up to demand a "true secularism."[58] He defended the demolition of the Babri Masjid, which he called the release of "thousands of years of anger and shame."[53] 

-1
BopTheDrassCanada•

Did you respond to the right comment?

2
LetsSeeTheFacts•

No. just want a response to it. Are you going to go pro BJP in defense of Tulsi?

Can Tulsi condemn Hindu Nationalism and extremism like she condemns Islamic Extremism?

Even then. Your exoneration of Modi in his role in the killings are ridiculous. Just to defend Tulsi

Many people who have committed genoicide or killings are not convicted by the courts.

Modi incited mobs against a group and the mobs then murdered people.

Read Gujarat Files:Anatomy of a Cover Up a book to know the details.

I do not like how you want to white wash his extremist ideology and actions just to promote a candidate.

I will support Tulsi even over Sanders if she makes one statement that condemns the Hindu Nationalism.

Lawmakers have condemned Erdogan and many of his policies too.

-3
BopTheDrassCanada•

HAF also endorsed Ro Khanna and Pramila Jayapal. Nobody calls them hindu nationalists. Next....

9
attosama•

Only if it makes Bernie think he should run, and none of these people are truly progressive who claim to be. If Bernie does run, of course he'll be the obvious pick and any cannidate claiming to back his ideology would step down to help the best choice to stop Trump's dangerous wave of nationalism.

2
zdss•

The Democratic primary is decided at the convention and delegates are awarded proportionately. Since a true majority is required to win, if no one captures an outright majority, progressive delegates can rally behind a single figure to pool their votes. A Biden-40/Bernie-35/Warren-25 split probably means Bernie becomes the nominee.

The downside is in the optics, not the actual vote totals.

1
sciencebro•

No. Only of them is as credible as Bernie, and that's Bernie. The real glut is of centrist candidates.

1