reasonablemannOP•

I thought the last paragraph was fascinating. Unfortunately I don't have the means to verify that total returns from the 1929 peak were recouped by 1936.

5
Piraal•

You will often see people mock that dividends don't protect the downside, something like "Yeah, that 3% dividends really saved you from the 40% pullback in 'insert recession year'". Often these people don't understand the math behind compounding over the downside year(s).

This isn't to say a growth stock couldn't recover just as fast today, as many of today's top companies are growth oriented. A corporation that retains all of it's cash flow(or is just sitting on a pile of cash(wave*BRK)) could for instance do buybacks, or even M&A at depressed asset prices, and make a killing. It is essentially the same thing, it would just be compounding in a more tax efficient manner(from a retail investors POV).

7
mark0fo•

The problem with a lot of these big cash hoarding corporations is that they may very well actually need the cash internally just to keep themselves alive. BRK in particular is highly dependent on consumer consumption. Guess what happens to those sorts of businesses in such a scenario?

In a "Great Depression Part 2.0" scenario, I'd also be very concerned that large conglomerates which seemingly have no reason to exist as conglomerates, ie: no vertical integration, could be vulnerable to being broken up per legislation. As was the case with the big "trusts" in previous episodes of economic downturns. Not that BRK is regarded by many as an abusive organization (its pretty hard to argue that they abuse any monopoly power), but the sheer size of the organization may lend itself to managerial inefficiency.

2
Piraal•

Just name dropped for an example.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mark0fo•

Gold miner stocks were "the place to be" in the Great Depression.

Stocks like Homestake went up 20-30X relative to the Dow. Homestake being a large-cap behemoth of its time, sort of like a contemporary Newmont or Barrick. Smaller mining companies may very well have gone up 100X.

1
reasonablemannOP•

I've often wondered how Gold would have reacted in the depression if it was floating. Using miners as a proxy is a great idea.

2
mark0fo•

Careful, there's a very large distinction between the miners (which are a spread play between the price of gold, and the cost of producing gold), and the price of gold itself.

For example, the price of gold didn't rise much in the Great Depression -- only 50% or so due to the FDR revaluation.

But the miners produced absolutely massive gains, comparatively. As they could hire men and machinery for extremely cheap due to the depression, but had a product they could sell for good cash.

2
mr_j936•

It is odd though that in a deflationary crisis where the worth of money goes up that gold prices should rise as well... Unless the actual fear is that following the great deflation there will be a great inflation.

2
mark0fo•

I believe the mechanism of such is that deflation causes defaults in a lot of personal and corporate debt, and gold, which is an asset in and of itself (and not merely a liability of someone else), is completely immune from defaults.

​

1
mr_j936•

Why would defaults cause inflation? And won't panicked people helplessly looking for money to pay rent and debts sell all their gold and jewelry?

2
mark0fo•

Defaults do not cause inflation. Gold becomes desirable because of deflation and its destruction (default) of financial assets.

And most people don't own anything but negligible amounts of gold. So once they've sold their wedding ring, which may contain, at best, 1/10th of an ounce of gold, the primary selling will be in everything else. Spare cars, quads, RVs, jetskis, etc., going first. Stocks and bonds. And then eventually investment real estate, and even primary real estate.

People wealthy enough to buy meaningful quantities of gold usually aren't in a position where they're forced to helplessly look for rent money.

Strong inflation and strong deflation, basically represent exactly the same thing -- destruction of financial assets. Inflation, the value of financial assets is inflated away, and debts are repaid in less real value. Deflation, financial assets theoretically become more valuable, but large amounts of the debt doesn't even get repaid at all. Both result in a loss of value to the owner of said assets. Gold is an excellent hedge against such.

Gold miners perform very well in deflation (probably better than in inflation) because of the rising "real" price of gold, and the willingness of otherwise idled men and suppliers to go work in the mines.

For instance, there's a new gold mine planned for Northern BC at the KSM site near Terrace by Seabridge Gold. One of the biggest planned new open pit mines in the world. If the company needed job applicants a few years ago, they would've been competing heavily against the oilsands projects, real estate construction, etc. Today they could put out a job ad in Alberta, and probably get thousands of applications from unemployed heavy equipment operators.

2