Linus experiments with getting a $67 GTX 1060 mining only equivalent to run games with equal performance.

Info

Posted Jan 15, 2019, 12:20 AM UTC

6667
flyingjamOP•

Obviously pretty jank, but the value proposition is almost high enough to sometimes be at least something to think about. This can get a $300-400 build to perform like a $800-$1000 one in gaming specifically.

37
John_And3rson•

You could run dual 1060 cards for a little more than 100 and have decent performance. Thats not without many struggles though...

10
Zouba64•

I mean, besides them being mining cards with no display outputs they don’t support sli

33
John_And3rson•

Yeah I forgot to add “not” without problems. My bad lol.

6
Lardzor•

You could run dual 1060 cards for a little more than 100

I checked, these cards don't have SLI connectors.

EDIT: It turns out that there are some 1060 & 1070 mining cards that have SLI connectors. Just not all of them.

15
tetchip•

No 1060 apart from the GP104-based variant has them.

5
Lardzor•

Well I'll be damned, you're right.

https://static.gigabyte.com/Product/3/6501/2017122214315242_big.png

EDIT: This is actually a GTX 1070 variant mining card as u/tetchip pointed out. Still good to know it has SLI though.

2
Paracelcus•

1060s don't have sli

3
xxTheGoDxx•

You could run dual 1060 cards for a little more than 100 and have decent performance. Thats not without many struggles though...

SLI is basically dead for new games. For example Dice has never even bothered to implement it into their Frostbite engine, even though they do a lot of cool new PC tech in their games.

There is no struggle.

2
gvargh•

Or use them in a renderfarm.

8
capn_hector•

The real winner is 570/580 mining cards, they can be used as a crossfire card for a cheap boost in performance.

22
ferretzombie•

What is crossfire support like nowadays? It was mediocre at best in the past, and games seem to support multi-gpu setups even less nowadays

8
1leggeddog•

Its still 100% based on what game you play.

There is an unofficial wiki of how good or bad games scale with it here:

http://amdcrossfire.wikia.com/wiki/Crossfire_Game_Compatibility_List

5
BurningCactusRage•

In my experience it's not often supported and it tends to crash a ton of games / applications that don't support it. I used to have a double card setup, and after every update, crossfire would be switched back on and would nothing but trouble.

I never found a game it worked better with.

1
kowalabearhugs•

Do you know where these can be purchased?

6
capn_hector•

Newegg had some mining 470s for $99 a while back

10
loggedn2say•

freesync is iffy since they have nothing but dvi and maybe vga in standalone.

otherwise great deal and shouldnt matter for xfire.

1
capn_hector•

If the monitor is plugged into the other card, FreeSync should work fine.

3
QuietSpaces•
2
kowalabearhugs•

Thanks. I wasn't familiar with the former.

1
SirCrest_YT•

That's genius.

3
sucmyleftnut•

Correct me if I'm wrong but wouldn't games using battleye not work because it would detect Windows in test signing mode? It's a great idea otherwise. I bet one of the 1070 equivalents would be alright for video editing and other productivity.

19
ptrkhh•

After you installed the driver, you can turn Test Signing back off. I managed to install unsupported Windows 10-only Kaby Lake GPU driver on Windows 8.1

Another alternative is to force install the official GTX 1060 driver using the Device Manager "Have Disk" method. You may need to add the P106's vendor and device ID to the GTX's driver INF file by copying the line for the GTX 1060

8
ronniedude•

I think editing the INF breaks the digital signature for that driver.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

17
Saltright•

For $100 equivalent there should be a few deals available locally and are probably in better condition. Most miners got them for slightly more.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
JakeRadden•

Not bad, but given where RX580 8GB used prices are, not a great buy either. Just bought both a 1060 6GB and a RX580 8GB for $135 each.

1
ryno9o•

Perfect candidate for LookinGlass

11
skullt•

Not sure I'd even want to login to my Steam account, let alone do my day to day work, on a system with modified drivers I blindly installed from an unknown taobao seller...

9
abctoz•

why would u even buy this if you're doing serious work, this is obviously for gamers

16
skullt•

Cool, let me just buy a second computer real quick and keep it air gapped so I can save big with this $67 GPU

17
flyingjamOP•

Obviously if you already have a rig there's no reason to buy a scuffed mining 1060. It's more for people on a tight budget.

If you're on a budget, and your alternative is a GTX 1050 for $120, that's a card that performs like 50% worse, cost $60 MORE, only has 2 GB of VRAM vs 6 GB.

Suddenly the danger might be worth it. And it's not a sketchy driver from a taobao seller, it's a sketchy driver from the LTT forums, since the Taobao seller actually doesn't give instructions on how to use it at all.

8
DrewSaga•

GTX 1050 Ti is more than 50% behind an RX 570 so I am pretty sure a GTX 1050 is far behind a GTX 1060, more than 50% so.

4
Abortion-is_Murder•

I bet you're fun at parties.

2†
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
abctoz•

wtf is wrong with you lmao literally no logic

1
skullt•

Dude, you're installing totally unknown modified drivers. If they have a keylogger or something you're risking every email / paypal / bank / game store account you log into from that system. Or from other OSes you're dual booting on that system. Or possibly from any other computer on the same network. Why would you do that? wtf is wrong with you lmao

10
SuspiciousSugar•

Knowing Nvidia they'll disable this to "protect their customers"

8
Spudlinator•

Well yes actually, as Linus mentioned he does not recommend this as you will have no way of knowing if the drivers for this card contain malware or not. Until they can be independently verified to be clean (if that's even possible) - NVIDIA has the complete right (both legally and ethically) to block this until future research can be done

5
SuspiciousSugar•

You have to explicitly accept a bunch of warnings not to install this, even use powershell to enable test mode. Linus is just covering his ass because he's a commercial channel that could get in trouble if the drivers turn out to be malicious.

That said a block from Nvidia is not ethical at all. It's just business. Doesn't mean I have to like it.

8
yuri_hime•

If you've actually unpacked the hacked driver and done a binary diff between the official and the hacked driver, you'll find that the only difference is the .inf file used by Windows and the driver installer to determine which files are installed; no binary files are touched. This is probably also why you can turn off testsigning after installation, as the drivers are still signed.

From this it's clear nvidia doesn't care about the use of these cards 'out-of-spec', as the way nvidia usually blocks features they don't like consumers having (like PCIe passthrough) is the dreaded "Code 43".

7
bakgwailo•

To be honest though - why would Nvidia care about them?

0
agentpanda•

To be honest though - why would Nvidia care about them?

Well the counter-question is "why does Nvidia care that I want to use my GTX card in VM PCIe passthrough?" and the answer is "Because they want me to buy a Quadro."

So logically the same answer applies here- they'd care because Nvidia wants you to buy a regular gaming card most likely.

2
flyingjamOP•

You're only installing sketchy modified drivers to AVOID the nvidia driver block. That's all the modified driver does. If Nvidia didn't purposefully block these cards you wouldn't need the unsigned driver.

How does nvidia protect their users from installing sketchy drivers by forcing them to install sketchy drivers in the first place.

6
radioactivemagic•

Wouldn’t this work with LucidLogix Virtu MVP trash that came out in 2012?

5

Ugh that thing never fucking worked right.

1
radioactivemagic•

Maybe it just needed janky Chinese mining card hax?

1
bubblesort33•

I'm sure that price will now go up to like $100 that so many know about this.

4
Co0lboii•

even so, like he mentions in the video; at least these cards live to see another day instead of heading to the trash

10
jigsaw1024•

I didn't see him try, but I wonder if you can OC these as well to squeeze out a bit more performance?

I wonder how saturated the PCIe x16 connection is in a situation like this?

3
el_smuff•

While they use a x16 slot, even high end GPUs only require x8 PCIe lanes.

7
flyingjamOP•

Saturation should be fine. Most laptops do something similar, after all, and there are laptops with GTX 1080s and now RTX 2080s, an OCed 1060 should be fine.

6
bctoy•

There was a post here from a user which can do this with AMD and nvidia dedicated cards. It was likely PCIE bottlenecked and the fps decreased with the resolution since the frame size increased. With x8/x8 I got around 70fps max at 6400x1080, probably the RAM speed also coming into play.

This situation is a bit different with the igpu not having dedicated VRAM so one less data copying over.

2
netok•

I cant watch video. Can someone explain how they got video output?

3
jenya_•

They got output via internal GPU (iGPU) using feature from notebooks where both internal and additional GPU work through single output.

7
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

mining as in crypto mining? confused by the mentions of mining in this thread

1
TheVog•

The GPUs being sold were manufactured as crypto-mining GPUs. They don't have a video output connector, for example. That's why crypto-mining is being mentioned.

5
blakdart•

they didn't make mining performance that was higher than 1060?

1
ptrkhh•

I dont think its higher, its the same GP106 die.

2
Virtike•

Where would someone buy one of these cards? Any source other than Taubou?

1