[New player] why is spellsword bad?

I recently started playing TESL and outside of my short experience with mtg in my childhood days, I am not really a ccg expert. Tried TESL during open beta, then got caught up in path of exile (again, for hundreds of hours) and recently got (after dismissing hearthstone) interested again in TESL (design and lane mechanics are just so much more appealing).

So I played couple if games,collected login rewards and bought the alduins apocalypse deck. It seemed like a solid choice to me, as yellow has piercing javeling and the deck got me a second copy of edict of azura, which seemed fine to me as removal is said to be rarer in legends than other ccg in order to focus on board interaction. Together with other guard cards from yellow and windkeep spellsword, (young?) Mammoth and barrow stalker (I'll try getting that one at some point) I thought I had decent tools available at my disposal when playing spellsword.

Now checking reddit and competitive deck lists (don't want to go the competitive route but having some additional knowledge on what's currently going on in the game won't hurt) it is obvious that spellsword doesn't seem to be in a good spot.

Can anyone explain, why that is? Have I fallen into a "noob trap"? And should I try to switch the deck or is it really not that important in low rank ladder when first learning the game?

Thank you for your patience if you have made it to the end of this lengthy text.

Posted Jan 16, 2019, 11:23 AM UTC

924
blamjamjamcosmicfunkjuice•

It just is okay?

...But really, the argument is that whatever you want to do with spellsword, there is a class that does it better. In that deck you want to summon Alduin as a win condition and you could argue that scout does it better. Spellsword doesn’t have a good combo deck like pilfer monk or nix ox telvanni. Hlaalu, warrior, and crusader are better aggro decks, if you want to play control it’s arguable that tribunal is a better pick. These differences in power level are arguable though so don’t let that keep you from playing spellsword.

It could also be that no one has yet created a proper spellsword deck. Even if ppl consider spellsword weak, this game is complex and hasn’t been completely explored.

*also we’re about to get a new expansion so spellsword might get stronger

13
borburOP•

Thank you for the explanation. Perhaps I should have mentioned, that I use CHVs budgetify alduin deck. However, to be honest I never found myself in a situation where I could even play alduin, even if I drew it. The deck has no card draw and most matches end before I could get enough dragons decimated in order to reduce Alduins cost sufficiently. Matches end before that by either me being stomped or me winning by pumping out mid-sized creatures consistently once I reacht 7-8 magicka (hoping I’ve baited out enough of my opponents removal before that).

Actually…I might as well remove Alduin for something else. But that would also reduce the usefulness of other dragons and cards that synergize with them...which means I might as well just switch decks entirely.

I guess I'll just keep playing and learning the game, holding back on potential gold investments until it is clear how IoM is going to shake up the meta. Thanks again :)

5
onehitparry•

Removing Alduin is a good choice. As cool and splashy as that card is, you really have to work to make it castable. In other words, it tends to be more of a liability than an asset.

2
blamjamjamcosmicfunkjuice•

That’s just the way Alduin works out in game honestly. I called it a win condition, but rarely does he win games(although when he does it’s awesome). It’s a card for fun more than anything else. I’ve actually been trying to make looping copies of Alduin on the ladder this week and like you said, he either sits in your hand or by the time you can play him you could have won another way(or in my case your opponent concedes the turn before you want to play him).

Ppl have tried to combat the same problems you are seeing with spellsword. They played merchants camels or shrine of namira for card draw in addition to ordirniran necromancer. Pretty much a similar gameplan to uprising scout, but control scout and control spellsword, it could be argued, are in the same predicament in that they are lacking a reliable AoE removal(which is relevant in this hyper aggressive meta). However, I think these power level differences aren’t noticeable unless you are comparing them to the best decks in the game, so just play what you want and have fun.

2
WalrusMaximus🦎•

Thanks for this! I've been playing a lot of control spellsword this month and am having pretty decent success and lots of fun. I did get the impression that Tribunal was probably a better choice for control, but I have yet to move on to Tribunal due to my lack of good Blue spells.

1
kebabfritekebab•

No one mentioned that spellsword's early drops, though pretty good( lots of potent 2/3s in purple), become near useless in late game as they offer no versatility nor effect that can help your own creatures.

take windkeep spellsword: it's very strong early and dumb late game.

other colors bring things such as harpies, daggerfall mages, wardcrafter, red things that boost creatures and so on. These numerous creatures are good early on and just as useful late game.

In spellsword, the best you can hope if you topdeck a 2 drop is barrow stalker, because it does at least have guard.

But guard is rather bad so...and it's a 2/3 guard...

Combine that with everything that has been said and you understand why the poor archetype is the worst, and hopeless too, it would take a considerable amount of new 1-3 drops to just be on par.

A last thing is due to it's stiff and slow nature, it relies on removals, but unlike what you initially can think as a noob, yellow removals are at best OK. They cost a ton, target on creature for most and the ones that do mass removal are either random or just too expensive(since when you dawn's warth, you clear everything, you often have no magicka to refill your board, so the opponent is actually the one who benfits from the spell: he gets on his turn all his magicka to use on refilling while you don't, and basically, dawn's wrath just delays things for one turn).

Spellswords can gain a lot of life, but life gain is actually sometimes more of a penalty to you than a a benefit in this game where runes give you opportunities to turn things around.

Spellsword sucks, it's playable, especially in low ranks, but sooner or later, you realise you're better off with any other class for whatever you were doing.

5
StruukduukerSweetroll•

I think spellsword ain't that bad, only thing I dislike about it is the lack of reach.

4
lawrevrbPure, un-cut skill•

before 3-color decks, spellsword struggled beecause Purple and Yellow really lack in reliable card draw. It was easiest to run Spellsword out of cards compared to most other classes, and that hasn't changed very much in today's meta.

Lack of card draw is the big reason - Spellsword Control was the first deck I ever piloted to legend, though - it'll always have a spot in my heart. RIP Mantikora.

3
borburOP•

from what I understand Mantikora has been nerfed previously. Is it still good, or has it's utility been reduced to "meh"-kind of level?

1
lawrevrbPure, un-cut skill•

it's no longer a 3-of, it used to be auto-include in any yellow control deck.

it was originally 10 magicka - 6/6 Guard, Summon: destroy a creature.

It was the clock that aggro had to kill you by, before the big walls started dropping from the sky and blowing their threats off the board. You could Night to Remember it to the other lane for a 2nd kill - all for 12 magicka.

Then it was nerfed to only kill creatures in the lane it's played in. Fair.

Then it was nerfed most recently to remove guard. That just kills it. it's a 10-cost targeted removal spell with a vanilla 6/6 body. Some control lists will still run it but it's power level was completely neutered, IMO.

​

4
borburOP•

rebalancing the removal sounds fine, but removing guard feels like the final nail in the coffin. But this is highly subjective, I don't know enough about the game for a solid estimation. Most likely for people like me using it felt bad and people losing to it where rejoicing

1
lawrevrbPure, un-cut skill•

It was an extremely reliable, powerful control tool that was auto-include in anything yellow controlish. banish effects didn't exist then either so you had to kill them early before they could get them down, or let them play out all 3. Spellsword could cycle them again too if needed with soul tear - and if you couldn't, then you had to hold back an earthbone spinner or other silence to be able to get damage through. But it still removes a threat of yours... it was just obnoxiously strong - but removing guard just makes it ughhhh. Control mirrors are already really long games, but it always included mantikora killing mantikora killing a mantikora killing a mantikora lol now control lists are more varied for sure.

3
fredduckyMudcrab Incarnate•

I know you’ve already gotten some great answers, but I just want so say that spellsword aspects can still be fun and playable. Both Redoran and Tribunal decks include the spellsword colors and are considered much more competitively viable. There’s a lot of fun to still be had in spellsword, despite the issues it can have.

3
Bozara25•

Alduin premade deck is pretty good for new players. You can reach rank 9 with that deck so easily. The real problem with spellsword is that other classes are better in their respective archetypes. For example, control spellsword is much worst than control mage or tribunal. Token spellsword is worst than token crusader and mage.

One of the problems of spellsword is its lack of car draw. Probably this problem can be solved adding the new legendary card that transforms a lane into Mania lane, because yellow + purple has a lot of high health creatures, but its a unique card.

Spellsword has been the worst class since beta, and I think it will continue like this for a long time

2
borburOP•

Yes, the lack of card draw has been noticeable. I unlocked most of the core and many skyrim commons and rares,and there's nothing enabling card draw.

I don't know if it is easy, but I'll do my best :)

Another question: Is there a way to watch replays of previous matches from the match history/log? I got crushed by a redoran deck yesterday and I would love to revisit it in order to memorize my misplays and see what went wrong (other than just me letting redoran rally it's creatures at will).

2
Bozara25•

Nowadays there isn't an option for that, but many players were asking for it.

2
borburOP•

I've checked up on the games histroy throughout the last couple of months. New dev seems to have stepped up his game when it comes to client improvements, maybe one day it's a feature they might consider implementing. I will certainly look forward to it.

1
someBrad•

Basically mediocre card draw (although Wilds Incarnate seems like it would fit really well into a spellsword deck) and almost no reach (Dawnbreaker is about it). Between the two issues, you tend to run out of gas and not quite get over the line against control.

​

But Dwemer spellsword is a good deck. Easy to turn on Siege Catapult with Mechanical Ally and Steam Constructor. Then Divine Fervor and/or Halls of the Dwemer buff those little guys into actual threats.

2
ChrisMorrayDo you mind? I'm doing a fishstick!•

It's still fine, it's not a noob trap but it requires some consideration. You'll lack draw, but in exchange you'll have access to Yellow's tremendous control power, and Purple's strong standalone cards. I still play Spellsword, and once you've built a decent collection you can make it work.

Tribunal and Redoran share those colors but add Blue and Red respectively. This allows for those colors' amazing draw to compensate, but at the cost of having a bigger deck (Morrowind's 3-color deck have a 75-card minimum). Spellsword alone is viable, but these two colors are more popular than Spellsword in the current meta. Don't let that deter you from playing Spellsword though!

My general advice is: Play around. Get the Skyrim decks (the 500 gold ones) and try to make some fun decks. Get yourself some expansions and see what cards you like to play.

1
TurquoiseLink•

Everyone always says no card draw, they are wrong. Odirnirian Necromancer exists people. The reality is Spellsword isn't bad anymore. The main reason spellsword control isn't popular is because sorcerers negation + ice storm is such an easy and potent splash that you turn it into tribunal. The main reason to stay spellsword is you get better card draw than tribunal (heresy I know, but true), I still think its really powerful but is less popular. Spellsword aggro is good, Siege Catapult is one of the better incentives to pair with either yellow or dwemer tokens.

1