Analysis - Comparing Team Statistics Between Hoiberg and Boylen

Analytics

LINK TO THE STATISTICS: https://imgur.com/gallery/XbRCUtP

It has been slow at work, so I created a spreadsheet that compares all the team statistics between games played under Hoiberg and Boylen so far this season. All the statistics come from stats.nba.com. I figured the easiest way to share the stats would be to pdf the Excel and then take a screenshot of it.

Hopefully you guys find this interesting, I know I did while working on this. Everyone can take a look at the stats themselves but below is a brief summary on the main points. Of course, we need to remember that Hoiberg’s firing happened right around the time when Lauri and Kris came back so the differences in stats cannot be solely attributed to coaching differences (i.e. not a pure apples to apples comparison) because of the differences in the available roster. Still, I think the comparison is pretty revealing.

- Interestingly, the offensive and defensive ratings (and team rankings) are very similar between Hoiberg and Boylen. There was a larger difference earlier in the Boylen era, but the defense has got worse as time has passed while the offense has remained atrocious. Both ratings are actually slightly worse under Boylen (even though we got Dunn and Lauri back), but overall, we are ranked similarly under both coaches compared to the rest of the NBA.

- As we all know since this has been discussed widely, but the difference in pace is very significant. Hoiberg’s Bulls were at the middle of the pack in pace while Boylen’s Bulls are 26th (we are a fraction ahead of the Magic, the Cavs, and the Heat with Memphis further back). Because the pace is down and offensive rating is roughly the same, it follows that points made per game is down. To offer some perspective, we are down 17 points compared to the Kings, 15 points compared to the Hawks, and 11 points compared to the Suns.

- Another dramatic difference is in the decline in three point attempts. We are now dead last in three point attempts in the NBA and second to last in three pointers made. The three point percentage actually increased, probably because we are taking less contested/bad three pointers (because we are taking them less overall). Three point attempts make only 27.3 percent of all field goal attempts under Boylen which also puts us dead last in the NBA.

- Another significant change is in the relative share of how we are scoring our points under Boylen. The relative share of three pointers, free throws, and mid-range two pointers are all down while the share of points made in the paint has increased dramatically. Under Boylen we have made exactly 50 percent of our points in the paint which puts us second in the NBA.

- In terms or rebounding, we have improved our offensive rebounding under Boylen (not hard because we were dead last in the NBA under Hoiberg) but we are still only 28th. However, we have got worse in defensive rebounding so the overall effect on total rebounding is pretty much a wash. We are still one of the worst rebounding teams in the NBA so no change there.

- Under Boylen, blocks are slightly down while steals are slightly up. True shooting percentage is slightly down.

- Another significant difference between Bulls under Hoiberg and Bulls under Boylen is that assists are way down under Boylen. We dropped in assist percentage (percentage of field goals that have an assist) from 17th in the NBA to 28th. At the same time, turnovers are up (even though the pace is way down) and we are 28th in turnover percentage under Boylen (i.e. third worst). This means that assist to turnover ratio has obviously declined as well and we have been the second worst in the NBA in that statistic under Boylen.

- Personal fouls drawn are down although we were already second to last under Hoiberg already. This also translates to less free throw attempts per game under Boylen, we are last in the NBA during his tenure.

- Another well discussed issue has been the decline in fast breaks and that is also evident in the statistics. Fast break points made per game has clearly declined under Boylen (26th in the NBA). If pace is taken into account by looking at the percentage of fast break points out of total points made, that has declined as well and we have been 22nd in the NBA under Boylen’s tenure (that is actually higher than I expected).

- In terms of allowing second chance points, fast break points, or points off turnovers, they have remained nearly identical under Boylen compared to Hoiberg, so the “road dog mentality” is not really visible there. However, there has been a fairly clear change in points allowed in the paint – we have allowed the 8th least in the NBA under Boylen whereas we were 14th under Hoiberg. That would suggest to me that we are clogging up the paint more but just based on the eye test, this has led to teams being more open at the three point line. But I have no statistics on that.

Overall, there are no huge surprises given what the Bulls fans and media have already discussed a lot since Boylen took over. Still, what surprised me personally was just how much we have emphasized scoring points in the paint compared to all the other ways to score.

Also, overall, there is way more “red” than “green” numbers which means that most of these statistics have declined/got worse under Boylen. Some of those changes have been relatively minor while some have been more dramatic. But it’s hard to point to any statistic that shows clear improvement under Boylen even though he has had better players available than Hoiberg. I am going to stay diplomatic in this post so that's all I'm going to say about that.

Posted Jan 17, 2019, 3:11 AM UTC · edited

3914
mewesleyToni Kukoc•

So statistically speaking, GarPax have chosen to pay Hoiberg and Boylen for declining results? For some reason, I'm pretty sure this is what GarPax wanted, because Hoiberg with a fully healthy team might have been winning games. At least with Boylen, we are guaranteed to be in tank mode.

24
tremble01•

considering that Hoiberg basically had no Dunn, Markkanen and Bobby, this is tough stuff for Boylen.

5
JCivXOPChandler Hutchison•

The timing of Fred's firing would suggest that, but hard to know for sure. Someone could argue it was so that Boylen would be able to instill his new system on the team when the team got fully healthy.

Either way, the results have not been great, maybe it's on purpose or maybe it's not. But there's a way to tank while developing players properly, now we are just shit and it shows in Lauri's etc game and surely that is not what the front office wants?

3
CohoDolls•

Agreed. What's the point of drafting a slightly higher pick (lottery odds for the teams with the worst records are also worse than before this year), if it comes at the expense of stunting the growth of and making the players on the roster unhappy, as well as driving away potential free agent signings?

1
HBananaKingBulls•

So basically boylens somehow managing to do worse with a full team while hoiberg essentially only had Zach.

20
Gibson2212•

This is excellent OC. Good work man.

7
JCivXOPChandler Hutchison•

Thanks!

5
TravellingMonkeyManGimme the Hot Sauce!•

Good comparison of an average and below average coach.

4
imnotbergBenny The Bull•

Of a below average coach and a belower average coach.

9
friendzonedefMichael Jordan•

below average coach.

garbage coach.

9
thehungarianjordanChicago Bulls•

Fantastic work!

2
erwistoToni Kukoc•

Quality post.

2
jeffreyweeeThe Windy City Assassin•

This is good, but you need to at least post the strength of schedule under both.

1
JCivXOPChandler Hutchison•

Links to where I can get that? I haven't been able to find a source where I can get schedule strengths for past periods (like Hoiberg's tenure), I see only sites that have the strength of schedule posted for the remaining games.

4