How do we solve the student loan problem in the U.S.?

The debt is getting out of control.

How do we solve this problem? Only thoughts I can think of is by giving out loans to students who have parents with good/decent credit only.

Another requirement should be that students should be forced to take only selective programs and degrees. No worthless degrees (art studies, liberal arts, where you cant get a job after)

Final requirement, decrease the interest rate on the loans.

Thoughts? how do we solve this? Or are we all screwed by 2050 when the debt increases by 150%.

Posted Jan 17, 2019, 7:06 PM UTC

011
ANGR1STExperienced Borrower•

Only thoughts I can think of is by giving out loans to students who have parents with good/decent credit only.

So you hate poor people?

Another requirement should be that students should be forced to take only selective programs and degrees.

And you're going to pick winners and losers? Government sucks at that.

Final requirement, decrease the interest rate on the loans.

This is arguably possible, but then we need to deal with paying for all the forgiveness programs somehow.

Thoughts? how do we solve this? Or are we all screwed by 2050 when the debt increases by 150%.

Drop the bankruptcy protection for new Private loans. Relax regulations and reporting requirements on universities to help cut administration.

Realize that not everyone that wants to go to college gets to go to college. Tough.

15
horsebycommitteeModerator•

How do we solve this problem? Only thoughts I can think of is by giving out loans to students who have parents with good/decent credit only.

This would defeat the purpose of loans, especially federal loans, since it would essentially prevent poorer students from ever getting a college education (and for students at the margin, it would be a lot more burdensome). It also violates a fundamental tenet of due process, that each person should be viewed as an individual, neither rewarded nor punished for the behaviors of their parents or others.

Another requirement should be that students should be forced to take only selective programs and degrees. No worthless degrees (art studies, liberal arts, where you cant get a job after)

There's already a push in this direction for areas who need more teachers, STEM-trained graduates, and other in-demand professions, but it's really hard to say what degrees are "worthless", especially before-the-fact. You tend not to hear about the liberal arts students who are employed, only because it's not something that's really worth commenting on; it's not rare at all for art, history, English, or Poli Sci majors to use their degrees to find sustainable careers (or go on to graduate school). A large part of employability is the person, not the major. And even if it were just the major, asking the government to figure out in advance which degrees will be marketable is begging for trouble--it's going to be wrong a lot and we'll have a bunch of unemployed business majors tending bar.

Final requirement, decrease the interest rate on the loans.

That's been proposed for federal loans, tell your members of Congress that you support this. But would you try to force this on private loans too?

6

Most students have no credit so that’s a flawed plan. You can also get plenty of jobs with a liberal arts degree- it’s not worthless.

There needs to be a systematic change in education where the tuition costs are lowered and job training is provided for those that choose not to go to college. I think investing in free or low cost community college is a great step but it’s going to take money and time

5
ANGR1STExperienced Borrower•

I think investing in free or low cost community college is a great step but it’s going to take money and time

We need to cut back on the standardized testing bullshit that we do earlier in the process. Students coming out of highschool aren't as well prepared now as they used to be. I blame ED for that.

2

Agreed! I think we also need to teach kids useful skills (like taxes and other things) in high school too.

2
ANGR1STExperienced Borrower•

We used to. We put men on the moon before ED was even a thing.

2
HordesOfKailas•

Get the federal government out of higher education. No more federal loans.

Allow private loans to be discharged in bankruptcy but also allow banks to choose their own standards for approval (degree program, high school GPA/SAT score, school being attended, credit score, etc).

Problem solved. You either qualify for a loan that's likely to be a good investment, get scholarships, or are lucky enough to have a benefactor. Fewer people will go to college, but the ones that do will be more qualified, have a greater chance of success, and not be saddled with tons of debt. Without the saturation of applicants with college degrees, job requirements will stabilize. Lack of a college degree won't kill careers and alternative educational paths will develop.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
kattlover89•

a lot of intelligent people are trying to come up with solutions. Purdue University in Indiana is trying Income-share agreement as a way to charge "tuition" for graduates of some of its degree programs by having graduates pay a fixed % of their wages for a fixed number years to the University. So students pay nothing but have to pay back once they get a job. Graduates pay nothing if they don't have a job.

You need to think about ways to control the insane increases in tuition rather than looking for ways to give universities the money they want.

3
innuendobot-5000•

The problem, IMO, is because government-issued loans. You guarantee income to a school, they are going to bring in as many students as possible. Schools get paid no matter what.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
bt12483•
  1. tell kids it's ok to not go to college and choose a trade job (I believe there was a concerted effort to stigmatize careers that didn't require college and to drive college attendance (aka tuition $$$))

  2. if the kid still really wants to go to college, show the true cost and expected return on investment - this needs to be done in high school. Show them how that $60,000 job isn't really too hot in the face of that $60,000/year tuition. It just doesn't make economic sense.

  3. tell the kids that even if you do land the holy Grail of the "six figures" job, that shit gets eaten up quickly when you have, gee I don't know, $150,000 in loans to pay back.

  4. stop requiring jobs that don't really need a degree to require a degree. This is on employers. You don't need a degree for half the shit they say you do.

  5. colleges need to find ways to reduce costs (bloated salaries, unnecessary expenses, etc). They have been gorging themselves. Time to stop feeding the tick.

All of this needs to be done, in addition to any plans to blow the whole fucking thing up somehow.

1
formalde_heidi•

Instead of "forcing" students into certain fields, I would suggest the tuition for in-demand fields be subsidized so that it's more affordable. However, I imagine that would be a short-lived plan as those fields would quickly become saturated.

I think a huge part of the issue lies with asking 18 year olds to make huge decisions about the rest of their lives. At my high school we weren't asked "if" we were going to college, but "where." It wasnt treated like it was optional. Too many people graduate HS and jump right into college because their parents or teachers or peers tell them they should, even if they dont know what they want to do for a living. A blind investment is never a good idea. Kids need to be better educated about loans and majors so they can make more informed decisions. (What job can you get with this degree? Is that job in demand? What is the estimated salary? Would this be enough to pay back your loans?) I dont think it would be the worst idea to make the minimum age for college enrollment 20 years old, so young adults can get a little experience working and managing money, and have more time to contemplate what they might like to do with their future.

Edit: I'd like to add that a lot of the responsibility lies with parents. Too few parents tell their kids not to borrow $30,000 freshman year to take the basic core classes (college algebra, English 101, etc) that they could take at the local community college for only a couple hundred dollars a pop. Too few parents counsel their kids on how interest works. Too few parents sit down with their kid and say, "look, if the job you want is only going to earn you $35,000 a year, dont spend six figures on the degree."

A lot of changes need to be made to the cost of tuition and the interest rates on loans. But a lot of the problem also comes from reckless borrowing by young people who don't understand what they're getting into.

0