Great Article for all DACA
thinkprogress.org/trump-administration-wants-...Posted Jan 17, 2019, 8:40 PM UTC
Posted Jan 17, 2019, 8:40 PM UTC
Can you do a summary for the ones at work please!
I skimmed it, so I'm probably missing a lot of details, and I'm not very familiar with the legal system, but basically they're potentially investigating if the Trump administration ended it based on their opinion, rather than legal basis.
Trump didnt do his homework. We are good for now.
I don't think we can really say "We're good for now" because of the following:
Let’s start with a premise with which no one — or, at least, no court that has previously considered Trump’s effort to rescind DACA — appears to disagree: The Trump administration has the power to end DACA.
If this is true then they could, and probably will, try to end it another way.
They have that power. Noone is disagreeing. Its just that they didnt follow the procedure.
The article wrongly predicted the SCOTUS would announce that they would review the lower court cases on DACA. The SCOTUS did the opposite and will wait until the lower courts have finished their cases, likely pushing any ruling into, at least, mid 2020. This site is too biased to be of much use in providing reasonably factual information about DACA status. Most (not all) of the legal discussion is correct. However, the bias causes a perceived opinion of the facts and skews the players motives and rational. Stick to non emotional sources for information. Examples; court sites, USCIS information releases, statistical analysis sites, this site (with caution), etc.
The article is basically saying that Trump is making the Supreme Court do his dirty work (ending daca) for him when in reality, he can do this himself. But if the Supreme Court ends it, it sets bad precidence and makes the judiciary his bitch for the rest of his presidency.
Trump would like the SCOTUS to rule in favor of the Texas DACA suit. That would put DACA back in crisis mode and give him a lot of leverage with the Democrats. On the other hand it would undermine his authority in other areas of Presidential powers.
Remember there are four cases involved. Three are about the President canceling DACA and one is the Texas and other States suit alleging that DACA is an unconstitutional creation of Obama. That is the one Trump really wants a ruling on.