Soc 1005 - Ted Henken - Weird research project? Legal?

Is a professor allowed to force students to go to Mosques, Synagogues, Churches, or any holyplace regardless of the religion, and demand students write a 5-6 page report ?

" Ethnographic Research Project & Paper (20%):Can Islam be American?Muslims in the New York City Metro AreaAll students will complete an ethnographic research paper of 5-6 pagesdue on Tuesday, December 5(Thursday, November 30). In the project, each student must choose a single mosque, Muslim or Islamic community or cultural center, or other Islamic association in the NYC metro area. The student must visit the place twice (at least once prior to Tuesday, November 7, when your prospectus is due) and interview three (3) Muslim individuals associated with it. They can be attendees/members, clerics or imams, or other persons related to the institution. The subject matter/focus of the visits and interviews is the same covered in the book CanIslam Be French?(except applied to the United States and/or New York City):*How are Muslims responding to conditions of life in America today and how are they dealing with the demands of being simultaneously “good Americans” and “good Muslims”? "

I am considering taking this class- however how is this legal? What if your religious beliefs don't allow you to enter such places. Anyone can explain this?

Posted Jan 21, 2019, 10:00 PM UTC

010
Plasmasph3reEconomics•

Yes. It’s a sociology class. What are you expecting? Trips to the zoo?

3
whtsabagginses•

If your religious beliefs truly prevent you from doing a project, you can have a civil discussion with the professor who will gladly let you do a different assignment.

​

But if you plan on succeeding in life, you will at some point have to interact with people of different cultures and religions.

​

Also, I take great pleasure in always calling you out as the troll/immature redditor you are, who plagues this subreddit with inane questions.

3
Plasmasph3reEconomics•

Lol, half the threads on here are posts by OP

1
RandomStudentHereOP•

ok

-1
redforeman55•

I had a similar project for a religious study/sociology course in undergrad. A little bit confused by which part of the assignment seems illegal.

1
DerivativeOf0•

You aren’t being forced to pray or follow anything related to Islam. All you are doing is visiting these places with the prospect of interviewing Muslim individuals. I see it as perfectly legal.

If you really do find it that offensive or illegal for any reason I suggest you take a different course entirely.

1
RandomStudentHereOP•

I dont know.

​

Asking total strangers and random people of a different background/religion on the touchiest issues and subjects in America today seems off putting and uncomfortable to me. Why can't it be interviewing students of that background instead? There is a common ground there at least.

1
redforeman55•

That doesn't seem illegal at all. The purpose of the assignment is for you to have a dialogue with an informed/practicing member of a different faith from your own (if you have one) and gathering information on the challenges of being a Muslim in America. Actively gathering information from members of a community, society, or culture is at the heart of sociology.

It would be a different story if the course is a required course to graduate and forced you to participate in religious traditions/practices or fail the course.

1
sekif•

Surely if you brought up your discomfort with the professor they’d be willing to listen and assign a different project?

1
Icamed•

The answer is. Who cares. Insofar as they integrate. Don't cause trouble. And Don't break American Laws. Who gives a fuck. Why would you take such a dumb fucking class anyhow? This won't help you in life at all. You would have gotten the same experience simply by befriending a conservative Muslim.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0