Decks that you thought were bad, but ended up being very good?

Has anyone else looked at a deck and thought it would be awful, but upon playing it later realizing that it's actually quite good?

I opened Nihilspace, Barnyard Slayer and declared it to be garbage because of its low creature count (with 3 cooperative huntings!), shadows with only 2 cards that could steal, inability to fight and lack of board wipes. A couple weeks later I played it and I discovered the deck was actually quite good. It turns out that almost all of the actions in the deck generate aember, and what few creatures it does have synergize well with a strategy that largely ignores board control. And while it can't destroy creatures very well, it has lots of cards that make opponents pick up creatures to slow them down (and a few targeted killing cards). It my experience it generates aember so fast that the only decks that give it trouble are decks with huge amounts of steal, or an oppressive # of creatures that come out too quickly to be bounced back.

I think it's a few cards short of being truly great (I'm looking at you 3x cooperative huntings). It could use another Natures Call or Nocturnal Maneuvers, and perhaps Glorious Few, Spirits Way or Virtuous Works. But it does have Mimicry, which occasionally allows it to snipe just that action it needs (and if a player knows I have it, it often forces them to keep dead card in their hands, like board wipes, that they'd rather discard).

So what decks have you re-evaluated after an initial bad impression?

Posted Jan 23, 2019, 9:07 PM UTC

37
TiggerClone•

My LGS owner gifted me The Lavish Hunter, with the caveat that it was a bad deck. It's now my favorite deck and performs really well.

https://decksofkeyforge.com/decks?owner=TiggerClone

2
Horrordice•

Actually i got a deck which i thought was decent with troop call 3 apes, a queen, and a bait and switch which ended up being prettty bad with zero board control

1
ssphoenix•

A deck I thought was horrible ended up being my best deck. King Storm. I had originally wanted to play a logos deck but this was Brobnar, Shadows, and Dis.

I was bummed it didn’t have some of my favorite cards like wardrummer, loot the bodies, pile of skulls, key hammer, drumble, broken dreams, succubus. It also has sacrificial altar with no humans. Even though the shadows side looked solid I figured too much to protect would be too easy to play around or would be too situational to be useful.

What I realized after play testing it is how strong creature control and aember control can be, especially when paired with Arise! And a bunch of strong creatures. My favorite turns are late game Gateway + Arise! combo to flip the board or using capture mechanics to give my enemy a burst of aember right before too much to protect.

I’m 31-4 on Crucible without looking at opponents deck lists on the “casual” play setting. My next best deck is 10-4 and 5-2 after that. The rest of the decks I have are losing or break even records about 5 games each.

https://www.keyforgegame.com/deck-details/3ae1dd46-146f-406b-b324-3bd4752d163d

1
GorilaManco:Untamed: :Dis: :Shadows:•

Emperor Kuerblot and Grigor, Scalerock Technician. I thought both were bad, but they became my two favorite decks.

https://www.keyforgegame.com/deck-details/492f82ad-fdfe-448d-bc45-81b30865d26f

https://www.keyforgegame.com/deck-details/4c52f07b-6b18-4981-9bf6-3f164dd9a8b2

1
agrandstudent•

https://www.keyforgegame.com/deck-details/6ddacdea-6863-48a5-b891-8104804950fc

Thought it was going to be bad because of the lack of synergy between a lot of the cards especially because most cards cared about creatures when this deck only has 11. SaS of 65 and ADHD consistency of 0.15 also agree that it should be a poor deck. This deck has surprised me with its speed and showed me how much I undervalued bonus aember and the value of just playing cards instead of waiting for full value.

1
coraythan:Untamed: decksofkeyforge.com•

A couple more glorious few and that thing would be golden! Good expected aember and some aember control is nice tho.

1
morscordis•

I have one that I thought was super meh. Then I played it a couple times and it's efficient as hell. The Thing That Performs for Calvary. Double Library of the Damned helps.

1