Has anyone changed the lenses?

Question

I'm in the process of modding my HP headset: http://imgur.com/gallery/18xJ3kl And in the process I brought a damaged psvr off eBay to see if I use any components to improve the HP one. I got some gorilla glue on one of my lenses which I removed (cleaned it successfully with a nail varnish remover pad). I tried the psvr lens in its place, holy cow! Aside from some edge distortion the image quality was increased dramatically. The god rays were gone, the sweet spot improved, the image looked sharper and the screen door effect was reduced. Unfortunately I have lost one of the lenses, I think one of my kids has posted it in the bin or something. I understand that messing about with the lenses could cause lots of issues trying to fit them and if they are misaligned it can upset your eyes, but has anyone experimented? I know the gear vr lens mod seemed to work for some people on the Vive but not everyone is convinced.

Posted Jan 25, 2019, 10:21 AM UTC

45
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
bobzdar•

Has anybody tried the Zeiss One + lenses? I'd imagine those are good lenses.

1
Bakamoichigei•

The biggest problem with changing lenses, is that we can't define the image distortion properties anywhere in the software or drivers. So a lens that introduces a bit more spherical distortion than the stock ones can't be corrected for.

Otherwise, lemme tell ya, I'd be swapping in the bi-convex glass optics from my DIY headset build! Sure, it's got more distortion than a fresnel lens, but it doesn't have a 'sweet spot', and the image is crystal clear and razor sharp pretty much edge-to-edge.

0
buffcode01OP•

I'm not sure why the developers use Fresnel lenses I'm sure they have their reasons (cheaper). I would love to see your custom headset build, might give me some ideas!

1
Bakamoichigei•

A lot of the thinking behind using fresnel lenses is that instead of having a massive amount of distortion and chromatic aberration toward the periphery of the lens, you have much much less distortion and CA applied uniformly over the image. Given the fact that we have more than ample CPU and GPU horsepower to correct for any lens distortion in real time now, it really seems pointless to me to use fresnel optics.

As for my headset, it was nothing special. I was working on a fully 3D printed one, but eventually the design process reached a point where I realized I'd be better off just modifying something cheap. (Since the stuff I was getting hung up on was the more basic ergonomics and dimensions.)

So the headset I was using before I got my Lenovo Explorer was a Samsung Galaxy S8, in one of these but with the entire optics assembly gutted, and these lenses in some 3D printed lens carriers I designed as a drop-in replacement for the original assembly. (I should probably put those up on Thingiverse!)

0
buffcode01OP•

Ah, I see. Maybe with the next generation of headsets they will move away from Fresnel. Although it's still kind of early for the vr technology, it's exciting times

1