When asked "what is your desired salary" on an application, what's the best way to answer? Or if being offered a position, how do you know you're being paid enough?

I think I've scared a lot of potential employers away by asking for relatively "healthy" salaries, but I have to be paid a certain amount or I'm simply not going to be able to pay back my student loans. If I were to answer too low, I would worry about locking myself into a self-inflicted underpaid position. But if I answer too high, I'm worried that it's an automatic disqualification in the application process.

Any suggestions? How should I answer the question "what is your desired salary" on applications? I know it varies from state to state and position to position, but that's exactly why I'm asking: where can I find these values for a given job in a given state? How can I know what to expect? Glassdoor has some estimates, but I know from experience that some, maybe even a lot, of these estimates are screwed up because the job title isn't exactly what Glassdoor thinks it is.

On a more specific note, when looking at jobs in locations with extremely high costs of living (I'm thinking of California specifically), how can you make sure you're being offered enough to survive on? I hear that in California, a six-figure salary is like a mid-level five-figure salary elsewhere, yet I don't see jobs offering salaries that are that much higher, proportionally speaking. So what's the deal? I see a lot of jobs in California that I'd like, but I'm afraid to apply because I might trap myself and my family in a location we can't afford in a job that doesn't pay enough to keep us above water.

Any and all advice is welcome and appreciated.

Posted Jan 28, 2019, 7:03 PM UTC

3548
eta_carinae_311Environmental PM/ The AMA Lady•

I've been dealing with this recently. A friend of mine is a corporate recruiter and has given me some tips; mainly, don't answer. If it's online and the program won't let you move on without entering something, put a 0 in. If it forces a dropdown menu on you, choose the lowest option.

When they see your application they'll either know you don't want to give anything away up front, or they'll think it was a simple mistake. Either way, you haven't shot yourself in the foot.

Also, some good ways to avoid giving a number first during interviews are to just defer "you know, I'm really not prepared to discuss base salary right now, without knowing the rest of the benefits, PTO, bonus structure, overtime, etc., it would be like submitting a bid for a project without a scope of work" (that was geared toward me because I've been working in project management so it makes sense to toss that out, but I think it's a great example). You can also say things like "my approach is to see if we're a good match first and discuss compensation later if we decide to move forward" or, if you're really in a tight spot and they just won't give up "let me give this some thought and get back to you, would that be ok?". Nine times out of ten most people will back off after one or two deferrals. If they keep pushing you on it it's a warning flag they are more interested in your price tag than your worth as an employee. "Why is this such a concern at this point, have people been declining offers" is an option if they just won't let it go and it kind of flips the rudness back onto them. YMMV though, if you're desperate for work you might not want to take it that far :)

31
GeolosopherOP•

This is (or at least sounds like) great advice. I like it, and I'll try it from now on. Thanks!

4
tpm319•

Not answer or put 0.

20
hawt_pawket•

I think this is the best answer. If pushed perhaps one could write something like “a salary appropriate for the position and commensurate with my value to the organization”. Never give the first number.

18
GeolosopherOP•

Well then I done goofed.

A lot.

13
tpm319•

Not a big deal IMO

7
hawt_pawket•

It happens. Take it as a lesson.

3
GeolosopherOP•

You don't think that would be automatically disqualifying?

7
tpm319•

If it does, I do not want to work for them

21
purens•

A key observation is that they already know what market rates are for that position. So what do they want to learn by asking?

Simple--they don't want to spend time interviewing anyone that is way out of range.

Putting down way too high a number is an automatic disqualification. So don't do that. Putting down no number also may disqualify you, especially if your resume is marginal--so that might also not be the right answer.

Putting down a fair answer like you've done is actually fine, especially if you have a firm salary requirement and you'll be happy if you get it. In that situation--you have a firm minimum, and will be happy with it, you've given a good answer.

And the best thing to put down is something they can say "yes" to but also which keeps open your negotiating power.

Example: Do some research and find a published "median" salary for the position you want, in the same market, and same amount of experience. If they try to pin you to that salary, you simply respond with, "Thanks, that's the median salary from X source, we will have to negotiate final pay once we get that point." If you end up asking for more than that, simply state that based on your credentials and the job description, that's a fair salary. Once they've decided to send you an offer, you have the highest leverage.

​

Negotiating salary is tough because you are talking to someone that has done it dozens or hundreds of times, while you haven't. Negotiating salary is easy because by the time it gets to that point, the HR rep just wants to hire you and not have to look for another candidate.

Good luck!

​

​

​

8
GeolosopherOP•

Excellent advice, thank you. Do you think Glassdoor is a reliable salary estimator, or are there more accurate sites you would recommend?

2
purens•

Glassdoor is fine for common positions. You'll have to look into specialized sources for uncommon ones.

2
SnoopingLurker•

This is kind of hard to do since a lot of applications require 5 figures greater than zero and don't accept worded text in the boxes.

3
tpm319•

10,000?

-1
ferdterguson•

theres no straight answer for this. ultimately there has to be a convergence of (1) what theyre willing to offer and (2) what youre willing to accept.

1 is you doing research - online, talk to people, talk to people at peer companies, talk to recruiters, talk to seniors whose long past pay does not need to be a secret, etc

2 you and only you can answer for yourself

you can put something in based on above... or you can leave it blank and negotiate it in person...either way the convergence has to happen eventually and that requires due diligence on your part

9
GeolosopherOP•

Do you happen to know of geology-specific sites for estimating salaries, or, alternatively, forums where geoscience salaries are regularly discussed (aside from this one)? Or is Glassdoor as good as it gets?

2
ferdterguson•

glassdoor. hays and other industry surveys. aapg/seg/industry association surveys. public company filings and disclosures (do the math from the financial statements) (e.g. they may also reveal things like CEO-median employee ratio). bureau of labor statistics. etc etc

4
TheR0ckhammer•

I agree with everyone about putting 0 or not answering. Don’t give them a reason to throw your resume out immediately. Do whatever you can to get an interview, and once they decide they like you, you can talk salary later. As a geologist in Northern California, the cost of living varies greatly. Basically, as you head west toward the coast, property prices and rent dramatically increase. Making 120k is under the poverty level in the Bay Area now. I am in the Sacramento area, making around 50k, and doing fine. But if I moved an hour west, rent would be double. It’s fairly easy to look up rent prices for any area, and that is the biggest thing that will influence salary change for any region. So, like everyone said, just put 0, but if you want to know if you can survive in an area on a given salary, look up the rent in the area and calculate your rough budget based on that.

7
GeolosopherOP•

Thanks for the info. How would you qualify the state of the job market where you are? I would love to live in California - especially northern-central CA - but it would require moving almost literally from one coast to the other for me and my family, and that would be a huge (and scary) life change for us. I'd like to know that there's some stability and opportunity there if I were to lose the job I moved there for in the first place.

2
tpm319•

I would get the CA PG before you moved if your serious. They have a state specific test, so your current credentials won’t transfer.

Are you only looking at Sacramento? What’s the draw to CA? I am generally bullish on CA geo jobs.

2
GeolosopherOP•

I really like a pseudo-Mediterranean climate, and California has several regions with a similar climate. I'm also drawn to its culture, at least as it's portrayed by my limited exposure to people who have lived there. I haven't chosen a specific area to search yet, but I've noticed a large number of CA geology jobs pop up when I search nationally.

2
tpm319•

Saw you have no experience, I would try to get hired at a large company, and after 2-3 years put in for a transfer.

1
TheR0ckhammer•

There are plenty of environmental and Geotech jobs in the Sacramento area. I believe this is one of the easiest places to get a job as a geologist right now, as long as you are OK working in one of those two industries.

1
StrafeBink•

Your student loans shouldn't even be a factor if you are a fresh graduate with zero experience.

Depending on region you might be looking at a relatively low wage.

They won't care that you need X amount to pay back your self inflicted loans.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
kuavi•

Yep.

Always base your salary expectations on the value you provide to the company, not what your needs are.

1
bullmoosespecial•

I used to write the standard “whatever is you think is fair bullshit in hopes it wouldn’t be a disqualifying” answer. Now I just straight up say what I’m looking for (75k a year minimum plus potential performance bonus, or whatever I can expect in that particular market). I would recommend taking this approach if this isn’t your first job and you have some experience.

3
GeolosopherOP•

Unfortunately, this would indeed be my first job, and I have zero real experience (fresh M.S. grad). That's more or less what I've been doing, but I don't think I have the kind of resume "mass" necessary to make any demands just yet.

5
[deleted]•

Just don't ask for ten bucks an hour because apparently that's asking too much, in my experience

2
tpm319•

mudlogging?

5
[deleted]•

Log mudding Edit seriously tho can you mudlog wuthout the degree first?

1
tpm319•

Yep, if there desperate enough

2
kuavi•

Absolutely.

You probably will have a hard time landing a job though if you don't have prior oilfield experience, a geology degree or someone inside the company to vouch for you.

However they are desperate for bodies so who knows?

1
GeolosopherOP•

Oh jeez...

2
tpm319•

Pay no attention .... thats a low rate for mudlogging where you work for 84 hours a week.

2
deputyshitbat•

What field are you trying to work in, and how much do you NEED to make?

Just tell us, so we can actually help you.

Also, I have dozens of friends that live in LA on less than 50k and they do perfectly fine. Assuming you’re getting into environmental, you’ll be lucky to start at 50k in CA.

2
GeolosopherOP•

My wife and I together have over $200k in student debt, so we have to make enough to pay those monthly and then live at least a lower-middle class lifestyle on top of that. I don't know what kind of income we'd need for that, but I'm guessing it's a hefty five-figure at least.

As for what field I would work in, the only meaningful answer is: whatever field would give me that. I'm a structural geologist, really just a traditional field geologist (I've done a ton of mapping and my thesis was primarily focused on the tectonic history of my study area), so there aren't a hell of a lot of jobs like what I've done for my degree. Oil and gas or mining would probably put my degree to use the most, but I'll honestly do anything (as long as I get to see my family regularly).

1
kuavi•

Well the mining/O&G sectors aren't known for their great work/life balances.

Was it physical or digital mapping you did? Depending on your answer, I would look into surveying or GIS related jobs as well if that's what you already have some experience in.

1
GeolosopherOP•

Physical. Just the old style, wandering through the woods, marking stations on a paper map kind of mapping. My "futuristic" evolution of the process included using the FieldMove software on an iPad with GPS in tandem with the paper mapping. That's as high-tech as it got. I used a bit of ArcMap once I had my data, but not nearly enough to be comfortable with it, unfortunately.

1
Kdm28_7•

Really liked this post, thanks, OP!

I'm from Brazil and soon to be graduated (hopefully 2019 will be my final year) and i wanted to share a point of view from here on how to estimate the living cost on the area you Will be moving.

At first, here in my country we think more on monthly gains, not yearly. So we don't go saying we make 48k reais in a year, we say we make 4k monthly.

So here is my thought, i think you should look for rent price, of apartments/houses you can see yourself living at, around the area and calculate the salary you should get based on that. From finances studies i learnt that a good percentage you should spend with your essentials for living is 55% of what you make. So, monthly, 55% you should spend with rent, food, public transportation, gym, basicly, all the things you just can't leave without. Let's say you are a NBA fan and you would like to go see a game or two, monthly, cause it's good for your mental health to relax and enjoy some basketball- that should be on your 55%. Based on that you can simply math these numbers to see how much you must make to have a decent, healthy life anywhere.

I think you can work with that when you start negociating your salary, just to be more secure on how much money you are accepting.

Just to clarify, i think what the other redditors said to not give any numbers first feells like the way to go, this idea of mine is just so you don't get tricked to accept a job and then is forced to live a life not healthy for you.

Hope it's not too confusing! This month/year thing really bugs me sometimes, it's two very different point of views on the very same thing. Best of luck on your job hunt!

Edit: some missing words in portuguese were in the text... Internationaly autocorrected is the worst...

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

-2
BooCMB•

Hey u/CommonMisspellingBot, just a quick heads up:
Your spelling hints are really shitty because they're all essentially "remember the fucking spelling of the fucking word".

You're useless.

Have a nice day!

^Save ^your ^breath, ^I'm ^a ^bot.

0†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
jwalters48•

Everyone these days thinks they’re worth way too much. You negotiate a fair salary, get your foot in the door, work your ass off, and then renegotiate later on. Everyone thinks they are worth a high 5 figure salary. Newsflash, fresh out of college, first job with no experience....you’re not.

1
deputyshitbat•

5 figure? I think that was a typo bud.

0
ThoughtsonrocksMineral Exploration/Artificial Intelligence•

A high five figure salary would be probably 60,000+. That is unreasonable for a first job expectation unless you are lucky or O&G.

2
GeolosopherOP•

Even with a master's degree? I was told a master's would do so much more for me than a bachelor's, but now it doesn't seem like it was worth it...

0
tpm319•

A Masters does not buy you much (for geotech/enviro), even in CA you would start at 45-53kish or so.

A few grand at most.

2
kuavi•

Depends.

For O&G for working your way to an office geologist position, its probably really important.

For environmental, ehhhh. You'd be better off careerwise working instead of spending more time in education. It does help but its questionable at best if its worth sacrificing years of work experience for.

1
canadianstone•

I just wanted to add that for California specifically, Paysa can be a tool to help balance salaries you're seeing on Glassdoor. It's generally better at including full compensation (base, stocks and bonus) where I found Glassdoor was commonly just reporting base salary. Having moved to the Bay Area about a year ago from Canada, Paysa was really helpful to get a foot hold on what pay I might expect. If you want anectodal evidence on expenses feel free to send me a pm, but note I'm a fairly fresh grad saving money by living with roommates, so I'll have a different perspective than someone with a family.

1