Actual Debate Memes: Debater cites Harris, Peterson, Shapiro to attack the conception of white privilege; is disqualified
Posted Jan 31, 2019, 10:00 AM UTC
Posted Jan 31, 2019, 10:00 AM UTC
Okay this guy legitimately dated my sister, and oh dear god was it dreadful, every night at dinner he would break into another Peterson lecture and once we posed different ideas or was able to breakdown how his argument was wrong he would just crumble. Watching him “debate” with destiny would be the most interesting downfall of all time.
[removed]
Unfortunately your comment has been removed because your Reddit account is less than 20 days old OR your comment karma is below 20. This filter is in effect to minimize spam and trolling from new accounts. Moderators will not put your comment back up.
If you're a new user, you'll have to wait to post in this subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Slam poetry followed up with hyperventilating speed reading, can someone explain how this style of debate is a thing?
I did policy debate for 4 years in high school and it's really weird I admit. "Spreading" or speed-reading started as a way to introduce more arguments and "cards" (evidence) into the round. It became a really easy way to overwhelm an opponent if they weren't able to talk as fast since if the opponent failed to respond to an argument or an important card, you could automatically argue that you won the round. The more evidence you introduce, the stronger your case as well.
Policy debate in itself was a lot more like playing a game of chess honestly and less like any form of actual debate that you might have encountered in real life. It's dumb, I know but it was fun for me at least once you got over the fact that "this isn't debate, it's a strategy game."
The slam poetry part I always hated. Performance kritiks started as a way to essentially say, "FUCK this resolution and debate, there are way more important issues that affect me and we need to talk about them." Sometimes they'll do even more than slam poetry and sing/dance too.
[removed]
Unfortunately your comment has been removed because your Reddit account is less than 20 days old OR your comment karma is below 20. This filter is in effect to minimize spam and trolling from new accounts. Moderators will not put your comment back up.
If you're a new user, you'll have to wait to post in this subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
I'm sorry but I cannot take this format seriously at all. It's so frantic I feel stressed just listening to it. How is this enjoyable to listen to or participate in.
Idk maybe if they can't find common ground on the jbp /Harris front destiny and this guy can bond over debate rap.
I knew the Angel Mom's would lead us into musical debates
Those girls and the judge are retarded beyond belief... holy shit.
they're high schoolers
I wouldn't rush to the defense of someone who cites peterson and shapiro even if the girls actually said "lol ur white and dumb"
because lets be honest, that's not what happened here- besides the fact that the judge is likely a college student into debate and philosophy and entirely within his depth by my assumption
In my opinion it has nothing to do with who he cites but what he cites. However the girls completely dismiss that and as it seems they did before make everything about race. They are throughout the debate blatantly racist it seems and have no issue with it. That judge seems to actually push his own agenda on them.. what was his reasoning in the end? Something like "psychological violence" - Are you fucking kidding me??? That guy needs to seriously seek some help as should the girls because if they think that is psychological violence then they are really far gone from reality.
depends entirely on what the basis for this response was, frankly attacking the source is completely valid outside here as shapiro is roughly a journalist and peterson is out of his field
and it's the judges decision to decide that their lines there probably weren't a rebuke of the argument those girls were making; in addition to citing a man who thinks torture of muslims is okay
I don't know the rules of competitive debate, or what could be the topic at hand, but getting into this abstraction and (even if their prescription of those cited wasn't accurate) drudging up pretty far right ideologues to combat identity politics with you know, white identitarianism is pretty yikes
Well from what I took, the girls were saying something like "you can't comment on that because you are white" - which is as we both surely agree a very racist statement disregarding that both guys are actually their own entity and may have made experience or research to qualify them enough to speak on a topic. And I think this is what this is basically about, they say you can't say anything since you are white - the guys say that this is bullshit and that only because they belong to a race/group they don't necessary share all the same beliefs and experience.
Actually they argued pretty good for my opinion - take the whole skit and turn it around. Make the girls white, the guys black and then have the girls say "you can't comment on that because you are black". then let the whole argumentation of the guy play on that premise word by word (except exchanging white with black) - the message, the support and the outcome would be a 180° degree of what it was now.
Is his view of torturing muslims any different from torturing other people? He seems very unopposed to extremes, like castrating and killing people who commit incest.
As someone who wan an officer of a college debate team I can tell you right now that the debate circuit is highly left wing, and judges are sometimes completely random in their decision-making, defaulting to dumb as fuck decisions. I had a debate where a girl argued that its ok that soririties arent allowed to throw parties because "lol thats mans work, lol tradition" while talking extremely fast. Despite my argument that this is very standard fare sexist atttitude, they still won. Even as a leftist, im pretty sure that they won because they knew the judge / were poc women. Ergo, the college debate circuit is notoriously badly judged and cliquey.
the debate circuit is highly left wing
Good
your anecdote
Regardless of accusations of nepotism you're going to have to convince an audience (which is what I assume the goal of competitive debate is) from multiple head spaces left or right wing, and if you failed to do so, its because something you did wasn't quite persuasive enough. Judging seems like its largely arbitrary regardless of if the circuits are left or right wing (as even, say presidential debates are)
tbh i would have countered with college rape statistics or something like the amount of rape that occurs at fraternity houses but that would require more context
Debating is a joke now dude lol, it isn't a way to assert evidence it's meant to be a way to assert charisma. Why would you be proud of lefties yelling at each other?
Yeah obviously colleges or going to have left-wing biases, but as a left-winger myself I can tell you from personal experience its not necessarily "highly rational and well researched opinion that leads to left-wing beliefs" but can sometimes be "like many right-wingers I stumbled into my views" type of leftism.
Not sure why you would say that I wasn't being persuasive enough when you just watched a clip of a judge saying someone lost for no reason. If I was these conservative dummies I would report the shit out of this judge and or scratch them.
Like I said previously, people in the debate circuit can be quite cliquey and conformist when it comes to their ideological beliefs. Additionally, I did include the rape statistics. You're going to have to take my word for it, but the women I mention literally had no good argument other than gaslighting the judge saying that they had womens' true empowerment.
yeah I have no fucking idea why they let this shit happen. I understand the Lincoln-douglas debate format is limited but what the fuck is the point is trying to do a full page at full speed?
Not to mention that it becomes a Gish gallop because the other side has to cross examine and counter some of those points in a limited time.
It seems like a gish gallop because the people are talking so fast but you have to realize that everyone is trained to speak very quickly so you kind of account for it. Not to say that gish galloping or 'shotgun debate' as i've heard it called doesn't happen, just that it's not the norm relative to debate standards cus while everyone is pushing out a lot of arguments initially you want to focus on the arguments your opponent had the weakest response to which boils 11 arguments down to 3 or 4 over the course of a debate.
It's kind of wild though cus every debate i would try to read the judge and sometimes you can pull off some bullshit wins by shear persuasiveness. so while it's structured to be very technical "which arguments were dropped" kind of thing the human element of just arguing with someone for and hour and a half straight makes it SO worth it if that's your kind of thing. I remember pulling an over sentimental speech out my ass because i had to address an argument i had no prepared evidence for which was actually able to move the judge to tears and won me the debate. I would definitely recommend a highschooler try it because if it's your thing it will be so worthwhile and such a great experience plus it's a great extracurricular to have on your transcript.
[removed]
Unfortunately your comment has been removed because your Reddit account is less than 20 days old OR your comment karma is below 20. This filter is in effect to minimize spam and trolling from new accounts. Moderators will not put your comment back up.
If you're a new user, you'll have to wait to post in this subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
[removed]
Unfortunately your comment has been removed because your Reddit account is less than 20 days old OR your comment karma is below 20. This filter is in effect to minimize spam and trolling from new accounts. Moderators will not put your comment back up.
If you're a new user, you'll have to wait to post in this subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
This guy; he quotes probably the only MLK quote white dudes know in his follow up vid, to support his position lol It's a high school debate, just take the L and 🅱️egone.
Anyone mind breaking down the video. Anything of note happen?
[removed]
Unfortunately your comment has been removed because your Reddit account is less than 20 days old OR your comment karma is below 20. This filter is in effect to minimize spam and trolling from new accounts. Moderators will not put your comment back up.
If you're a new user, you'll have to wait to post in this subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
[deleted]
imagine being loldamar
instant cure for suicidal depression
[deleted]
Shapiro and Harris are right in part, people specifically like you do live in absolute sewage and deserve torture
[deleted]
I can't imagine a better definition of "white privilege" than being this asspained over something as inconsequential as a high school debate.
[deleted]
for the sake of argument if she threw cardboard at me i would be forced to defend myself in a self defense situation
also why is he talking so fast that he gets asthma, why would anyone agree to debate like that? and it's bizarre that he's being called racist but nobody is explaining why at all, this is why people like peterson exist in the first place
is this the kid that went crying on debate and then on conservatives.
High Schools debates, i fucking hate them. I once was asigned to debate in favor of marihuana usage, and the fucking arbiters encourage us to use anectodal evidence and appeal to authority. My team wich i was the leader ( not because they assign me or anything i was the leader because i was the one that created due to the fact that nobody wants to participate, and end up carrying with me a girl that had a crush on me and her friend)
We loose, we try to use the basics arguments in favor of Marihuana, but we refuse to use anecdotal evidence to support our claims, and anecdotal evidence was valued by the judges way more than anything else.
[deleted]
Is this Destinys 3rd son, that inherited his talking fast gene?
speaking fast while reading is a common meme in debate circuits from what i know
holy shit poc are fragile
It would be nice if this dude had a talk with Destiny instead of being sucked into the anti-sjw black hole because of awful arguments made by the opposition, it seems that he can be reasoned with
That actually sounds like a good idea. We need to make that happen
What do you reckon u/michaelmoreno2k, interested?
u/michaelmoreno2k
I doubt there's any redeeming someone like this; especially if they're ready to go down that hole and then receive positive reinforcement for doing so
That's just not true, probably a good chunk of people here were into anti-sjw stuff before
Me, for instance. If you don't think about it a lot of what those people say makes sense. As soon as you do think about it tho....
this is the problem with a lot of white men. they dont think
i can vouch :)
‘Were’
I wouldn't go that far;
again this video has been posted around far right subs of all types who particularly see these citations as valid and reliable sources.
Besides that its never been destiny's goal to convince anyone of anything
Maybe I'm naive, but I'm under the impression that everyone has the capacity to be better. It's just for a lot of people, the time necessary to make someone better just isn't worth it.