Is position based ranking in soloQ really what we need?
Warning: long text.
After a week of playing ranked I can't find many positive words about this system, at least on in its current form. SoloQ was atrocious before, but now, in more than 60 played games I couldn't find more than 10 games where someone wouldn't go full int mode, first time a champion or a role in ranked, go afk, throw a game after some bad words from a teammate or give up after first/second death, all because "I'm on off role, I don't care". Maybe in 5 games have I felt like I, or somebody else from my team, did carry a game, and not an enemy who decided to troll the match.
So, these experiences made me question the sense of this system. I get why it's there, I really do. I thought it wouldn't be as bad in reality as well, that's why I never protested. I don't blame Riot for putting it in. But, after seeing what's happening I gotta say, I can't support it at all and will just probably stick to normals for the rest of the season if it's not removed.
But, I don't want my post to sound like a whiny rant, here are the arguments as to why I don't think the system is a way to go in its current form:
-
Ranked games are treated less serious. Because, why would you try your best on a meaningless role if it doesn't affect your main LP at all? I know there are many competitive people there, but, they're sadly a minority, not only in lower ranks, but also in Platinum and Diamond, where many people don't have any dignity. Source: I spent there last 3 years (and probably lost a lot of my own dignity as well thanks to these people). Enemy laner got fed and you can't trade with him anymore? Let's spam that "ff15" message and run around jungle, or just fight him constantly and die. You are leading but lost one fight and a Baron in consequence? Yep, the game is totally over, go next. My jungler doesn't come while the enemy one camps my lane, leading to me dying thrice? Fuck it and fuck you all, it's running it down time. Or afking. Or trolling your teammates if you're Tahm Kench. We all know these attitudes from the past, I discoverd nothing new here. We all hate it when it happens. And, sadly, now it happens even more often.
-
Games become stomps more often than not. This kinda comes from the first point, if a top lane main meets someone who's off role, and kills him like 3 times, the off role player will most likely give up and either not try his best, or just straight up troll the game so it ends faster or for whatever reasons. But, not only that. The system encourages more people to play other roles than their main ones in ranked. We all know how much of a difference is playing with an autofilled support vs playing with a support main, and the same thing happens with other roles now. People who are new to the role and aren't exceptionally better than others in their elo often get stomped by their counterparts who happen to main these roles. In theory this should lead to some people being fed on both sides as top main from blue team will smash, but the same thing will do the mid main from red team. In practice, the matchmaking is way too random for that to happen frequently. Also, leads to many games feeling like a 4v4 or even less because some players are totally irrelevant.
-
Fun factor. Do we like being stomped? Of course not. Do we like stomping enemies instead? Yes, kinda, but if every game feels like that, it quickly becomes boring. Also, I don't know about you but entering every game knowing that it's gonna be a stomp for either side in 90% makes me feel a bit uncomfortable. I like it when games are close for at least first 15 minutes, because I feel like I don't play against monkeys (or feel like a monkey myself when it's my team being smashed) and that my mechanical superiority (or the lack of it) could be deciding in winning a match. Feel free to disagree though, that's more of my personal opinion.
-
The punishment system is not good enough to detect people who ruin games. 99,9% of League's permanent or 14 day bans are for toxicity. Inting isn't punished in any way, neither by reports nor by support tickets. Maybe one out of 1000 inting players got any sort of punishment. Afking? Just attack a creep every 3 minutes and you're good to go. Reports for being afk are ignored if the leaver buster system never notices you being inactive for too long. Trolling by leaving your ADC after 5 minutes of laning to go top and dance around just so your top laner gets less xp? Also ignored. The punishment system is bad, Riot doesn't know how to improve it and it only encourages people to behave in a bad way. Removing the very last sort of punishment - a loss of LP, encourages them even further.
But, hey, suprise suprise, I don't think the system should be gone. I don't even hate Riot for implementing it, because as I said above, I can totally see the reasoning why it's here. I just think soloQ isn't the place for it. Remember dynamic queue? We hated it to the point the change got reverted, but dynamic q still remained, renamed to flex queue. I think the best way to go is to put the position based ranking here. Flex isn't the main ranked queue and is already treated more like a practice mode than a competitive one, while still remaining some sort of rivalry by having LP. Add/keep it here (is this system in fleq too? I'm genuinely asking, I don't play flex myself) and I'm certain it wouldn't hurt anyone.
Unlike dynamic queue, it actually has its advantages. It encourages players to play more champions and try out new roles, helps them to get more familiar with the game. It is great for newer and more casual players who are in that middle ground of being too afraid to experiment in ranked, while not being interested in non-competitive modes like normal draft and quick match. But, i need to emphasize on that phrase, ranked is the most serious mode in League of Legends. If you don't treat it this way, you should accept the possible loss of LP and demotion if you don't improve or go back to your best role and champions. Actions of a unit affect nine other people, in a good or bad way. Let's not help help these who don't care about the competitive drive by allowing them to keep their main LP.
Posted Jan 31, 2019, 7:34 PM UTC
Positional ranks only work if you don't have autofill. The entire issue comes from being autofilled. They don't want to disable autofill because it will increase queue times. I personally would rather wait an extra minute to guarantee my role than get into queue faster to end up filled into a role I don't even want to play.
I could imagine if they created a system that gave you accurate feedback on ETA for each position. For example, if queueing support was 2min ETA but mid was 6 min ETA then it could incentivize players to fill roles based on that.
Autofill is just a bad solution to the problem of long queue times. They need to implement other ways to reduce queue times rather than autofilling players.
FTFY.
3rd grade math test visualisation. Jung, ADC, Top, Mid all have 100 people queueing. While Support has 10. 10 more support players queue per minute. How long till everyone finds a game?
HotS was forced to revert the same change that just about ruined the game. Draft NEEDS autofill with its queue system, else it creates a bottleneck.
You're assuming no one would queue up for other roles. If people could see the queue times and what needs to be filled along with incentivization to fill that role, then many players would choose to fill.
Off roles could give bonus LP based off of need for them. If I'm gold 5 and see my estimated lp gain is +15lp/-15lp if I play my main role with an ETA of 6 minutes but see support is 1min ETA with lp gain of +25/-10lp then a lot of people would think to themselves "eh, I can play support okay" and queue up
On top of that, they should gain more lp if they win in their off role since they are playing tougher opponents anyways.
Additionally, combining that with a higher mmr range would make queues faster. Currently, in high elo you end up waiting 6mins+ to get a queue while the system broadens your mmr range. It should just be higher in the first place to reduce queue time.
I'm not saying the concept of filling a position is incorrect, but rather the current system of blindly autofilling people is inherently flawed. This new positional rank system is an attempt to fix the flaws of autofill. I would rather just not be automatically filled and instead have a different system that gives you more information to incentivize players to fill themselves.
Currently, one tricking is incentivized with little to no punishment. You don't gain anything by playing a different role. This is why being autofilled sucks so much - the system punishes it. Now with the new system you have 5 different positional ranks, which just feels even more punishing since you don't even climb on your main elo.
If they need to fill players in order to make things work smoothly then the system should reward that behavior instead of discouraging and blindly forcing you to do the behavior that they need.
Yes. It was a trick question. Because more people queue more frequently for more popular roles. So no matter what, the queue times will always be atrocious.
You can never force a perfect 20% split between all roles. And as a HotS player, I've seen first hand that incentives don't work.
EDIT: Also, extra LP and widened MMR ranges is a fucking stupid idea. If Timmy is a silver who belongs in Silver. Absolutely no one in the game wants Timmy to have accelerated MMR, while being matched with far better and far worse players.
In higher elos the queue timers were getting really long before autofill happened. I remember waiting for 10 minutes or more in mid Diamond back in season 5 on average. Autofill is needed. What could be done is to give you a low priority queue for that moment (excluding challenger and both masters) so you wouldn't drag your team down that much, while also lowering gains and losses of LP for an autofilled victory by a small marigin (like 3-6). Also, silver, bronze and iron shouldn't have autofills at all, queue times are low enough here. At least that's my idea.