Bruce J. Flatt "Durable Principles for Real Asset Investing" | Talks at Google
Posted Feb 1, 2019, 1:04 PM UTC
Posted Feb 1, 2019, 1:04 PM UTC
Saw this talk a few months ago and highly recommend it. Bruce & Brookfield are great capital allocators.
Long BAM.A & BIP.UN
Google engineers loaded up with tech stocks are gonna wish they came to see this talk in the next recession.
I can't believe how empty the audience is in this talk. I've watched the whole thing for or five times.
This is a niche talk. Most folks would be better served by having (say) Andrew Hallam of Millionaire Teacher come in and talk about index funds and how one should avoid active management.
Same! It’s shocking how many empty chairs there are. I’d love to see Bruce speak in person.
Real estate is a bubble right now too is it not?
Residential real estate in certain cities, yes.
After almost 20 years of super low interest rates, and increasing foreign investment, and relative stagnant wages, how can it not be?
The thinking now is the bubble is in everything. I definitely don't see real estate as inversely correlated with stocks. Real estate will also drop in a recession. And stocks will come back, as will real estate, so I don't see what the big risk is. If the Google engineers are savvy, which is more likely than not, they won't sell at the bottom.
In Millionaire Teacher, there is a story of how in 2004 (when GOOG IPOed) the company brought in folks like Bogle to talk about the advantages of index investing over active management. Seems they've forgotten that over the past few years.
"Bruce Flatt is a Canadian businessman and the CEO of Brookfield Asset Management, appointed in 2002. He has been referred to as "Canada's Warren Buffett"."
I'd like to see the "X's Warren Buffett" stop. Other than the fact that he has created a great company and is an excellent capital allocator, he isn't a Warren Buffett.
I think comparisons to Warren Buffett should be reserved for insurance holdings companies (Fairfax, Markel) or investors who built conglomerates as their investment vehicle (Westaim, Biglari Holdings).
Same goes for the stupid titles I've seen on Seeking Alpha constantly claiming "Brookfield is the Berkshire Hathaway of real assets", "BPY is the Berkshire of real estate". The only similarity is they make great investments.
These are lazy narrative devices.
It’s not an insurance float, but the way BAM charges management fees on every public vehicle plus all the private funds (which are a huge source of capital and have attractive upside features from realized carry fees) is a great business model. It’s also ahead of its time. If you compare AUM growth at Brookfield vs any competitor globally (including the U.S. heavyweights like Blackstone, KKR, etc), the comparison is favourable to BAM.
I do take your point that comparisons to Buffett are always a reach. Just wanted to highlight that Flatt has created his own innovative engine that is working well so far.
Oh trust me, I know. I love Bruce Flatt, and Brookfield is like 50% of my portfolio (and the other half has a lot of BPY and other asset managers (Dream, Integrated, Morguard, and Guardian)). I love the business model, in my mind it's one of the best in the world and probably better than insurance now.
Part of the genius of Buffett was realizing the power of float, so if you want you could make a comparison to Flatt in that he recognized asset management was better than just being a huge conglomerate. But the comparison ought to end there. In my mind, just coming up with a great business model doesn't warrant a comparison to Buffett or Berkshire.
By the way, if by "the comparison is favourable to BAM" you meant Brookfield has higher AUM growth, I think you're mistaken. I didn't look closely but KKR at least seems to be growing at a higher rate (19% vs 15%). I don't think it's an important point (there's room for all players, the market is huge, and they sort of play in different sandboxes) but Brookfield isn't leading the pack in AUM growth.
Fair enough - I hit google and found those numbers as well. Kudos for fact checking. It definitely depends on which period you look at and how you collect the data. Regardless, it’d be a close race, and agreed that it’s a good outcome for both.
Anecdotally, BAM just raised the 2nd largest ever real estate fund (after Blackstone) and is in the midst of raising the largest ever infrastructure fund. But you are correct that everyone has their own sandbox, and some of the other names are ahead in private equity and credit strategies.
[deleted]
[deleted]
Can I just invest in BAM.A and be done?
I'll admit that's pretty close to what I've done
Why has it been fairly stagnant since 2018? 2017-2018 is a good 25%
The whole market has been, which could be why.
so if BAM.A moves with the market why buy it?
It didn't decrease as much as the market (S&P total return was -5%, TSX was -9%, BAM.A outperformed both) and has outperformed long term (returned 19% a year since 2000 I think). The stock's performance over one year (especially when it outperformed) is not much to base a decision on.
Exactly. I guess you'd be betting that there's enough potential reward in the ways it doesn't move with the market to make up for the risks that it might not.
In this case though, looking at the chart, it's not super correlated. But in the downturn in December most stocks went down with it.
Crazy enough it’s all my dad’s friend holds but he also got in at $3.50 or so back in 1987.