Scooby Doo Oneshot?

I’m currently working on creating a Scooby doo Oneshot where people play as the mystery gang and I was thinking of making someone play as the villain, are there any good examples on how to have this kind of dynamic or would it be better if I was the villain? Any other ideas you guys have for things I can add would be appreciated as well!

Posted Feb 3, 2019, 6:49 PM UTC

02
CuriousDM76•

Wouldn’t all the players feel left out when the person playing shaggy starts much stronger?

8

I don’t have resources, but I do have advice. Heres my two cents:

If your villain is a PC, the mystique of it is kinda soiled for the other players when they have the one guy at the table who’s character is elsewhere doing whatever and obviously not working with them. So the best way to go is to have them be a “villain in plain sight” party member, a player who works with the party but has a big reveal in the end. This could be easier or harder depending on how faithful you are to the source material. For instance, as unexpected as it would be to have Daphne come out as the BBEG, it wouldn’t make any sense in the context of the game. Nobody would see it coming though, so if each party is playing as a member of the gang, I’d consider it.

On the other hand, if the plot, setting and dynamic of the game are straight Hannah-Barbara but each PC is their own, unique character, the payoff of the reveal might be less worth it, especially in a one-shot setting where your players have a very limited window of time to form bonds between one another. We all know the gang from the show pretty well, but who knows what your players will come to the table with and how we should feel about them. We don’t have the same attachment, so the reveal is rendered “meh”.

For this reason, I would take the villain into your own hands, but don’t make it any run-of-the-mill NPC. What if the haunted house is one big Mimic, or the spooky island in the lake is actually a Zaratan partially submerged underwater? They’re both effective and hidden in plain sight, but don’t go around hinting their true identities like stereotypical secret villains do. Rather than the answers being given to the party in spurts, have the players dig for them and solve the mystery themselves.

Hopefully what I wanted to get across makes sense. Good luck on your game, and if you include ultra-instinct Shaggy, keep his power under 1%.

3