I’m the food writer for the Virginian-Pilot in Norfolk, Virginia. AMA!

OFFICIAL BIO: “Matthew Korfhage is food writer for The Virginian-Pilot. For a decade, he wrote about restaurants, bars and beer in his hometown of Portland, Oregon. He accepts Dungeness crab and Upright Brewing beer by mail.”

UNOFFICIAL BIO: I’ve been eating and writing about food in Hampton Roads (and thereabouts) for 10 months now — covering new restaurants opening, old restaurants closing, beer and booze and oysters and ham and a whole lot of hot wings: https://pilotonline.com/life/flavor/restaurants/article_6a48b048-6055-11e8-a05f-53d38c9d0c2b.html

I'll be here Thursday, February 7, at 2 pm EST answering questions about food criticism, embezzlement lawsuits, and Hampton Roads eating and drinking.

Proof: https://pilotonline.com/image_66c95474-2a60-11e9-9c7f-27af23160850.html

Recent Pilot articles: https://pilotonline.com/users/profile/matthew%20korfhage/

Q&A with the Virginia Press Association: https://www.vpa.net/qa-matthew-korfhage-virginian-pilot/

Posted Feb 6, 2019, 11:21 PM UTC · edited · locked

2765
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
HtownHokie•

Pierce's sauce is bauce

3
mos68w10•

I think Pierce's has better pulled pork than B&N's, but the latter has a better atmosphere.

Still inferior to the guy off route 15 in Loudoun who does pulled pork on weekends.

2
camrymonster•

Buzz and Neds 4 lyfe

2
[deleted]•

In the announcement thread, u/TechnicolorDeathship asked:

The year is 2049. The world has been thrown in turmoil over the microbrewery foodie war of 2025. Now, Virginia is divided into warring factions of chefs and brew masters. The ones who rule over the peninsula are Casear Todd Jurich Of Bistro Commune, General Antonio Caruana of the Luce District and The Conquering Nomad Mikey Maksimowicz of the House of Pearl. Although they remain in a peace treaty, from the west an army arises. The conquering hordes of Overlord Gordon Ramsay and Mayor Guy Fieri move east to lay claim to the fruitful land of our peninsula. Fieri has a lone bastion in Waterside but it is cut off from reinforcements. Our noble chef heroes in the area realize they must unite to defeat this dire threat. The question is, who will reign supreme in the coming battle?

3
matthew_korfhageOP•

Fieri can't exist without at least seventeen ingredients from as many places, so he'd starve out without provisions. Ramsay is still in hiding after his Pad Thai was sternly rebuked by the Thai people themselves. Maksimowicz, meanwhile, would fish for his own, as would Dave Brue at the Atlantic, while Commune would supply the land provisions. I'd say Tidewater is safe.

5
[deleted]•

In the announcement thread, u/dcnerdlet asked:

What’s the best brewery in Hampton Roads?

Do you ever get randomly comped dishes/free food in an effort to influence your reviews? How do you handle that?

3
matthew_korfhageOP•

for me, te two breweries that most reward consistent visits are Benchtop in Norfolk and Commonwealth in Virginia Beach: both consistent enough you don't ever get bad beers, both experimental and inventive enough that there are wonderful surprises.

Others? Peecarious in WB makes great high-booze beers: double IPAs, barrel-aged stouts, a really good barleywine right now. Big Ugly and Smartmouth are both very solid. New Deal on General Booth has the best pilsner in town. Farmhouse has well-made, malt-balanced beers and an amazing space—but I think their real flagship beers will come out of the barrels many months from now. Reaver Beach has a very interesting barrel program. Caiseal at the Vanguard is off to a good start. There are others of course, but those are the ones that come first to mind.

2
matthew_korfhageOP•

As for randomly comped dishes that arrive without them being ordered? It depends. Sometimes I overtip to compensate, sometimes I keep a tab in my head for later, sometimes I simply disclose it. I've also given food away after trying a bite: Food samples are generally shared with everyone in the office, but I do try them. Still, I don't believe chefs are trying to butter anyone up; they just want to make sure the reviewer tastes a dish they're proud of. The rule of thumb is that if I'd feel embarrassed or compromised if the reader knew I ate something for free, I make sure I/the paper pays for it somehow.

2
matthew_korfhageOP•

All right, I'm aboard. I typed out a couple responses in advance to questions that required longer answers, but I'll be working on the fly after that.

​

3
matthew_korfhageOP•

Aaaaaaaaan back to the trenches. It's been a pleasure chatting with you all, and if I missed a pressing question, I'm always gettable at [email protected].

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
2tb-of-yiff•

If I live in and around Richmond, where can I get some ethinic food? I'm tired of all the Italian and Chinese take outs. I want something different. Maybe a kebab or falafel.

2
twelvesteprevenge•

Not to step in on this guy’s AMA but you can’t be looking very hard if you can’t find more than Italian or Chinese in Richmond. One of the things I love about the area is the availability of food from around the world. For kebab and falafel, try Mediterranean Deli on Quioccosin or Mesopotamian on Lauderdale. If you haven’t been to the area around Horsepen (just over the city line near the intersection with Broad), go! Tons of southeast Asian food to try. Temple (Laotian) on Broad is amazing, too. Elsa Ethiopian on Boulevard, Hyderabad Biryani out in Innsbrook, Lemon Cuisine of India... so many choices.

4
matthew_korfhageOP•

Feel free to step on my AMA here! I've spent the year concentrating mostly on Hampton Roads, though I expect my radius to expand as time goes on—so I'm not yet a great guide to Richmond, beyond the breweries and some prominent new spots like Brenner Pass.

6
2tb-of-yiff•

I don't live in Richmond just nearby. I rarely go into the city because I hate driving and parking in it, but thanks for the suggestions. I'll try to catch an uber or something so I won't have to worry about it.

1
zellis3•

What are some good lesser known cheap eats spots around Richmond and the 757 that you know about?

Also how does one get into the business of being a food writer? Were you into food and wrote about it or a writer who covered food?

2
matthew_korfhageOP•

I've published reviews of most, but in order of when they occur to me, here are some newer or lesser-known low-cost spots in Hampton Roads I like a lot:

Guangdong Taste for Cantonese, Noodle Man in Haygood for hand-pulled Chinese noodles, Chulo in Janaf for excellent Nepali food and momo soup dumplings, Tamarind near Janaf for chaat-house style Indian, Five Brothers for some seriously bomb lamb shawarma in both Ghent and old-town Portsmouth. Few have found Mea Culpa Cafe on Colonial in Norfolk, but their liege-style waffles, savory oatmeal and orzo salads comprise some of my favorite light breakfast/lunch around.

3
[deleted]•

In the announcement thread, u/ThatGuy2070 asked:

Where is the best shop to find authentic Italian cheeses in Hampton Roads.

2
matthew_korfhageOP•

Been to Marchese Market in VB?

4
Thatguy2070•

No I haven’t. Honestly haven’t heard of it. I will check it out though. Thank you

1
Thatguy2070•

Thank you for posting this here.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
joshombroso•
  1. You've sweet a precedent for being more critical of restaurants than preceding food writers for the Pilot - how do you balance constructive criticism against personal preference?

  2. What are some places that, for whatever reasons, you think are notable, but not going to appear in the paper soon?

Eff the haters, a perspective from outside VA, and the lack of sacred cows is welcome. Cheers.

1
matthew_korfhageOP•

To question 1:

In general, I think my main responsibility as a reviewer is to represent the place accurately: both to be fair to the restaurant, and to be fair to the reader. That means including critical reports alongside the positive, so they can be better informed where and how to spend their money. A $100 meal is a rare experience for most readers, and it’s a crying shame if you end up at the wrong place or order the wrong thing.

At the same time—especially at small, chef-run spots—I generally find a way to fact-check with the chef before a featured review, and relay my criticisms before they come out in the paper so the chef has a chance to respond. Sometimes they might change a dish after a criticism, or look harder at execution in the kitchen. Sometimes they think I’m dumb and wrong.

As far as how to balance out my subjective opinion so it’s useful to people with different taste buds? In part, there are certain objective things you can call out in food—meat temp, burnt or undercooked food, salt levels. I know I’ve got a high salt tolerance, so if I find something too salty, it’s probably very salty.

There’s also cultural context. If somebody uses a flour tortilla on a taco, the food will sincerely need to prove why that’s a good decision.

But often it’s just a matter of trying to write descriptively enough, or provide enough context for the reader to see around my opinion—to say not just that I don’t like something, but precisely why. That way readers are able to see their way around my opinion and know that they’ll like something I don’t: Some people like pulled pork so smoky it might as well be Paradise, California. They know who they are.

6
matthew_korfhageOP•

To question 2:

I don’t have too many unpublished opinions on food, at least not for long. If I think it’s notable, I tend to note it eventually.

That said, reviews and news coverage tends to focus on the new or the unique—food you might travel for, or food readers haven’t tasted yet. So take No Frill Grill: It’s a restaurant with very good execution on classic comfort food. The meatloaf has some obvious love in it, and the place is usually packed because it’s a solid, reliable experience. But that steadfast reliability and familiarity and consistency can also make it less likely to appear in an article—simply because there’s no news to report. Not that I might not find a reason anyway!

2
TrumpologistFuck Maryland•

I'm a very strict vegetarian, not vegan tho, any ideas for good places near Leesburg?

1
matthew_korfhageOP•

I can’t speak to Leesburg, but--you’re about a half hour from Ethiopian food heaven in Falls Church, Virginia. For vegetable dishes, I heartily recommend the deluxe vegetable platter at Meaza.

3
frellingaround•

I have the same question (good vegetarian cuisine), but for Hampton Roads.

1
TotesMessenger•

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

 ^(If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads.) ^(Info ^/ ^Contact)

1
[deleted]•

In the announcement thread, u/Specter_RMMC asked:

Where can I find the best slice of pizza in VA, per your experience?

1
iarobertson•

Seriously, where is the great pizza?

1
[deleted]•

In the announcement thread, u/zapatoada asked:

What are your top 5 meals in the state? Like meals worth planning a vacation around.

1
[deleted]•

In the announcement thread, u/dragonjujo asked:

What style of cuisine do you want more people to enjoy?

1
matthew_korfhageOP•

I'd say I'm less likely to be an evangelist for a particular country's cuisine than that people be open to the country's cooking in all its variety. China has eight major cuisines, and there's a good chance an American trained only on American-Chinese takeout has tried precisely zero of them.

That said, Virginia Beach will soon have a Malaysian restaurant and I couldn't be more excited about that.

8
[deleted]•

In the announcement thread, u/ElegantLandscape asked:

What is your favorite Hampton Roads restaurant that no longer exists? What dish of theirs will you never forget?

1
matthew_korfhageOP•

I haven't been here long enough — just 10 months — for this list to be very long. But I'll say I just lost two of my favorite Reubens around at Shipwreck Sally's and Hoyt's Luncheonette.

It also was a shame that Sydney Meers closed Stove a week after I arrived. But I suspect we'll see more of him soon.

5
EatMoreFiber•

Sydney Meers

Believe he was recently involved with a special dinner at Cedar Point Country Club in Suffolk, so "soon" maybe even sooner than anyone thinks.

2
[deleted]•

In the announcement thread, u/armyprivateoctopus99 asked:

Do you ever cover Williamsburg and if so is Barrett's seafood overrated or is it overrated?

1
matthew_korfhageOP•

Since the Daily Press and Pilot have come under the same ownership, my range has expanded out to Williamsburg, but it's still somewhat recent: I haven't made it yet, but it's now solidly on my list.

3

You should try the blue talon!

2
matthew_korfhageOP•

Will do!

6
[deleted]•

In the announcement thread, u/Zlegacy asked:

How do you critique food? Does it merely boil down to personal tastes and likes or have you given a place a good rsting even if you personally didn't care for the food?

1
matthew_korfhageOP•

I've never called a place good that I think isn't good, no — but that doesn't mean I haven't given positive reviews to places that I wouldn't personally go to. For example, I don't go out for fried whitefish a lot, but clearly there are good and bad versions: overbreaded, soggy, moist, dry, fried into oblivion, flaky and just to the edge of crisp, etc.

It's generally a matter of trying to understand what the restaurant is trying to accomplish, and assessing accordingly — and often I'll take dining companions along who really know and love a particular food, to offer their perspective. If I'm eating at a Venezuelan spot, for example, I might be dining with a Venezuelan friend.

3
[deleted]•

In the announcement thread, u/TechnicolorDeathship asked:

Who has the best tacos in Hampton Roads? Best seafood joint in Hampton Roads?

1
matthew_korfhageOP•

The best Mexican-style street tacos overall that I've had in Hampton Roads are at Los Cuates in Virginia Beach—in particular, they make exceptional barbacoa and carnitas. The carne asada I like better at El Rey on Little Creek, however. Fish tacos I haven't explored enough to say—my pool of spots is about five deep so far—but The Truth at Bro's Fish tacos is genuinely excellent, and I hope they get corn tortillas soon or have them already. My favorite Americanized bougie tacos so far overall are at El Diablo Loco in Hampton —great beef — and my favorite oyster tacos are at Casa Pearl in Williamsburg and at Harper's Table in Suffolk.

As far as seafood: If you're talking the old school crabcake, fried platter, broiled platter? Best I've had so far overall is Blue Seafood and Spirits. Great spot. Fin in Newport News makes wonderful elevated seafood plates, Coastal Grill and Terrapin in VB each do insanely good softshell, I like the Dockside on the Inlet for blue-crab pickin', the fried shrimp are great at District in Portsmouth, and the she-crab at Mannino's isn't exactly a secret. There's probably whole categories of seafood I'm forgetting.

4
matthew_korfhageOP•

Realized I forgot to add raw bar in here as a category yesterday: The Atlantic in Virginia Beach is out on its own, there, as far as direct-sourcing and simple knife skills.

But in a pinch, you'll find me at AW Shucks. And at happy hour at the Big Easy in downtown Norfolk, you can get some of the only dollar oysters in town I'll eat with relish: Prince Edward Islands are often a buck. Looking forward to seeing what Fuller's Raw Bar is up to in Hampton, as well. They're opening... very soon.

2
[deleted]•

In the announcement thread, u/ElegantLandscape asked:

What food trends are you already tired of?

1
matthew_korfhageOP•

Kale, bacon, spelt.

4
matthew_korfhageOP•

Also: rolled liquid nitrogen ice cream. It's worse. We should all stop.

4
[deleted]•

In the announcement thread, u/roguesoci asked:

I just moved to Hampton Roads. What are your top three ethnic food places that should be “regular” type weeknight places? Excluding expensive Saturday night treat type places.

1