r/hockey•
capcomist

Why are Corsi/Fenwich good stats if wins don't correlate to shots?

Looking at nhl teams ranked by shots for and against neither seems to correlate strongly with success.

Carolina dominates in shots for, while Tampa, Winnipeg and Pittsburgh all are amongst the "worst" teams in shots against.

So if team shooting stats don't correlate to success, why would this be important for individual players?

EDIT: Almost all the responses I've gotten have been: "Corsi is good because . . ." That's NOT why I am asking about. I'm asking about the apparent dichotomy between corsi's apparent ability to predict team success vs individual success.

Posted Feb 7, 2019, 1:18 AM UTC · edited

028
InternationalCowTOR - NHL•

Corsi For % at 5v5 predicts out of sample and future GF% better than current GF%. TB has a +186 corsi differential at 5v5 this season.

13
capcomistOP•

It correlates better but still correlates weakly - the very dominant Tampa are only eighth in 5v5 Corsi%, well behind the mediocre Hurricanes.

8
InternationalCowTOR - NHL•

Tampa is dominant in other areas as well. They have a very strong special teams goal differential which is unrelated to their top 8 score adjusted 5v5 corsi differential. The research on corsi's usefulness as a stat is well documented and repeatable. http://metahockey.com/publications/articles/

filter by "corsi"

Corsi significantly outperforms goal differential in predicting future goal differential https://hockeygraphsdotcom.files.wordpress.com/2015/09/newplot.png.

10
capcomistOP•
  1. I'm not a "Tampa hater" :)

In fact I'm using the (IMO, valid) assumption that "Tampa is the best team in the league" to show the lack of correlation between corsi% and team-strength

  1. I'm not even necessarily saying Corsi is bad. I'm wondering how can Corsi be

(a) good at predicting/measuring individual players' strength, but

(b) bad at predicting/measuring the strength of teams

5
InternationalCowTOR - NHL•

You're lacking the understanding of some key facets of statistical analysis in hockey.

Current total goal differential correlates extremely highly R^2 with current standings points. Total goal differential is made up of 5v5 goal differential, 5v4 goal differential, 4v5 goal differential, OT goal differential, and other (5v3, 6v4, 6v4, 5v6) situational goal differential. Score adjusted corsi differential is far more predictive than goal differential in predicting future 5 on 5 goal differential. This has been proven repeatably as you can see in the numerous publications compiled at metahockey. Therefore score adjusted 5 on 5 corsi differential is a valid way of measuring team strength at 5 on 5.

To measure the impact of a player's ability to drive their team's shot differential, analysts first looked at their personal on-ice differential. Then they started looking at relative on-ice differential, measuring their differential when the player is on the ice relative to when they are on the bench. Finally, regression-based mathematical models are now in play to isolate a player's impact in isolation from their teammate's impact, their competition's impact, their shift start impact, and other factors.

2†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
oortcloudxdTOR - NHL•

I'm curious, how is that graph generated? Does it take a rolling sample of the past few games or something?

1
InternationalCowTOR - NHL•

It's not rolling, it's first 10 games predicting remaining 72, then first 20 games predicting remaining 62 etc. Detailed here: https://hockey-graphs.com/2015/10/01/expected-goals-are-a-better-predictor-of-future-scoring-than-corsi-goals/

1
64bubblesCHI - NHL•

All (publicly available) hockey analytics have very poor correlations to anything useful.

Corsi and its derivative stats just happen to be some of the most tenable among the poor quality stats that can generated from the nhl's public data.

1†
vince_nhANA - NHL•

One possible explanation is that the stats you're looking at seem to be Corsi/Fenwick for all situations. This doesn't account for score effects: a team winning by a lot won't shoot as much as they play more defense. Conversely, a team down by a lot will tend to throw whatever they can on net, unless it's Anaheim.

There's a stat called Corsi/Fenwick Close, which only tracks if the teams are within two (IIRC) goals of each other, which accounts for score effects.

10
OtherThingsILikePIT - NHL•

A lot of that has to do with score effects; the team that's losing tends to take more shots in order to try to catch up.

4
epwnymOTT - NHL•

FYI, you linked to last season's stats. This is the current season.

4
epwnymOTT - NHL•

Tampa - by far the best team in the league - has a negative shot differential.

So this is wrong, for clarity. Their shot differential and corsi is positive.

11
capcomistOP•

Yes, this was a mistake - although the general trend of "shots for and league standing correlating poorly" remains true.

0
capcomistOP•

Thanks, fixed!

1
FlackfacionMTL - NHL•

No stats are good if taken by themselfs. It's good to look at corsi, but you also have to look at sites that track high danger shots. A lot of people try and push one stat as the end all. I'm telling you the end all stat doesn't exist

2
wholalaaMetropolitan Riveters - NWHL•

And shot metrics only mean so much if your players don't shoot well or your goalie can't stop pucks. Some stats folks just chalk all of that up to luck, but the reality is that some teams are consistently better or worse at it than others. (Which is why winning the Corsi Cup hasn't translated to real success for Carolina.)

3
FlackfacionMTL - NHL•

Which brings me back to another stat I fuckin' hate the most. pdo is the stat I hate the most. So many of the most popular stats people use it, and it always makes me question how much they actual understand

0
wholalaaMetropolitan Riveters - NWHL•

I find it most useful early in the season when you can look at outliers and say, "Yeah, that's not sustainable." But by this point in the season, if your PDO is good, you probably just have good goalies and some good shooters.

2
logan_81TOR - NHL•

It’s a well known thing that some teams are able to sustain higher sv%s and Sh%s.

Washington for example will be high in both, Toronto will also have a sh% above average.

Don’t get mad when someone points out that your favourite team with a PDO in the 99th highest percentile in history won’t sustain their wins.

1
FlackfacionMTL - NHL•

Yeah, I think my comment came out wrong. I'm not saying it's a bad stat. The problem I have is that I've seen people throw out PDO as to why a team will regress after a small sample size. If you look at something like a 5 game sample size and the goaltender happens to get a shutout in that sample, It's going to effect the PDO significantly. Like you said, some teams are able to sustain higher sv% and sh% because they have better players. to say a team is going to regress because they have a 102 PDO after 5 games is silly. There are much better stats that can be used to find a predictable pattern

1
Pen2PaperLAK - NHL•

Decent source of individual player performance and can tangent into performance with linemates. It’s overused, overstated and the application is misunderstood by most number warriors who think it’s proof of “eliteness” and shittiness and can predict Cup winners. That’s not what it’s for.

1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
lancemeszarosCGY - NHL•

"Good" is relative. The idea is to continually progress to find a model that's more predictive than the previous one, not to give up until you find a magic bullet that's 100% accurate (which is impossible).

0
blueline7677•

Realistically only 2 stats matter for a teams performance. Goals for and goals against.

-12