r/formula1•
UserRed5

Will the displacement for next gen F1 engines?? Will it go under 1000cc???

Since we are going to have a dramatic engine regulation changes in 2023, I was just thinking that how small could the cubic displacement for next gen F1 engines get.

F1 initially wanted to have a 1.5L inline4 Twin Turbo engines for 2014 engines regulations but scaled it back to 1.6L V6 Turbo engines after Ferrari and Renault opposed it.

So we went from 3.0➡️2.4➡️1.6, what will F1 prioritise for next gen regulations,

Obviously F1 can't go full electric, at least for the next 2 to 3 decades, after all it's "motor" racing ( we still have motor parts in electric engines)

So will F1 go with a small (under 1000cc IC ) engines with massive emphasis on electric power??

What do you guys think??

Edit: Terrible Headline sorry!!

Edit: Even if F1 opted for a 4 cylinder under 1 litre engine,what configuration do you think works better and better suited for F1???

V4 or inline4 or Flat4 (boxer)???

Posted Feb 10, 2019, 4:52 AM UTC · edited

163
speedbarfFerrari•

I don’t have anything to add except that electric motors are in fact motors. That’s all.

26
UserRed5OPF1•

I just thought that it would be sound funny if they actually went for an under 1000 cc engine config.

Mighty F1 with with 998cc I.C engines certainly sound funny ,after experiencing watching cars with 3.5 V12 and 3.0L V10s.

4
speedbarfFerrari•

I get your point, fam. I’m one of those lost souls still clinging on to the idea of V10s but the reality is that F1 is all about volumetric efficiency and maximizing the power unit. If in some far out future they do get to 1000cc, hopefully we gain some RPM in exchange for the displacement.

14
a_berdeenNiki Lauda•

1000cc turbo V4 with 16-18k redline please. I wonder what type of power they'd get from the ICE alone? Forced induction motorcycles with that type of displacement and redlines seem to max out in the 300-400 hp range.

6
StrigidEyeDaniel Ricciardo•

600-700hp electric motor supplement!

2
sholder27Best of 2018 Winner•

Sounds funny, yes, but now we have 1.6l engines that go close to 1000 horsepower. And last very long without blowing up (usually).

4
Clueless_bystanderFerrari•

If they sound like 1L bikes I'm down

1
PM_ME_UR_MATHPROBLEMCharles Leclerc•

Obviously gonna switch to a 700kW electric system, r/formulaE turns into F2, and F2 turns into Formula Gasoline.

17
ichlibejuiceKevin Magnussen•

they're not going to go electric. batteries are too heavy. people already complaining about the current cars being to heavy. We already are basically at the theoretical limit for battery energy density for lithium ion. Race cars will never go battery only electric only unless some new miracle battery chemistry that doesn't even exist in theory yet pops up. Unless you want f1 to into some sideshow joke like formula e. A base model Civic type R is faster around a real track.

6
sholder27Best of 2018 Winner•

Unless you want f1 to into some sideshow joke like formula e. A base model Civic type R is faster around a real track.

not true, it wasn't base type R, it was specifically made for time trials.

2
ichlibejuiceKevin Magnussen•

SMH. Don't put words in other people's mouths.

-7
UserRed5OPF1•

You forget the weight is because of the limitations in current battery technology, the current Li-ion was made by Sony in 1991 and nearly 3 decades later, the Li-ion is extremely limited by the amount of charge cycles,maximum energy capacity of cells and limited operating temperatures.

The next big thing is Graphene batteries, but in order to make them,they have to seperate the carbon atoms layer by layer, imagine a light weight carbon paper that can hold more energy than a heavy industrial battery (but the catch is the thickness of the carbon sheet is exactly 1 carbon atom size)

So currently Graphene batteries cannot be produced at a massive scale due to the thickness of the carbon layer, in 20 years it's certainly possible and will be feasible enough to be implemented in mainstream applications and eventually completely replace these ancient Li-ion batteries.

-1
ichlibejuiceKevin Magnussen•

Graphene isn't a voltaic cell it's a dielectric and you're talking about capacitors, not batteries.

3
[deleted]•

Graphene can do lots of things, sadly making it out of a lab isn't one of them.

3
UserRed5OPF1•

They are eventually gonna come to our homes one day, but it certainly isn't tomorrow or next year or even next decade, hopefully soon...

0
Burntbigtoe•
-1
UserRed5OPF1•

They are Graphene Lipo batteries and not pure Graphene carbon sheets.

Yes you could buy them in limited quantities but are they mass produced??

1
UserRed5OPF1•

In the distant future certainly a complete electrification is possible, but I am just asking about the 2023 engine regulation change

What about IC?? Under 1000 cc??

1
PM_ME_UR_MATHPROBLEMCharles Leclerc•

I was making a joke. Last time I added a "/s" after a joke, I got people telling me that I didn't need it. Welp, you can't win.

6
UserRed5OPF1•

Ha, I forgot to turn on your sarcasm switch...😌😅

1
ichlibejuiceKevin Magnussen•

it's not possible. even at the theoretical limit batteries are too heavy, and fuel cells are like barely a working technology for road cars let alone world class race cars.

f1 switching to all electric will be suicide for the series.

3
UserRed5OPF1•

They won't completely replace the ICE with Electric power, but rather make Electrical energy the centre of focus but making it generate lot of power and keeping the ICE as the side kick,(the irony...!!!)

0
ichlibejuiceKevin Magnussen•

That's totally and utterly useless. If the ICE is generating less power than the electric motor, the electric motor is never going to have anything driving it anyway.

1
CookieMan0Force India•

I don't see a problem with sub-liter engines. If they still make a noise, it's still F1.

14
UserRed5OPF1•

My dad watches F1 races with me rarely sometimes, he just casually watches F1 without going into details about teams and driver's

He still thinks F1 still uses V10s and V12 engines lol...

I am sure he will have a heart attack if I tell him F1 will use 998cc engines in 2023 😁😂🤣

8
CookieMan0Force India•

He still thinks F1 still uses V10s and V12 engines lol...

Oh boy. Don't ruin the illusion for him.

11
UserRed5OPF1•

I remember during 2014 preseason testing,I was watching some preseason clips on my tv,he sat besides me and asked me why do they sound so different and so muted, I just said "they added a turbo"

After nearly two decades of casually watching F1 , he never bothered to ask me what type of engines they currently run, so I won't spoil that one for me until F1 goes under 1 litre.

After all whenever I talk about F1 , the first question he asks is about Ferrari, to him Ferrari=F1 😀😃😄

7
swissflamdrag•

Last I heard the current engine manufacturers led by Merc are lobbying to keep the 1.6 v6s with maybe slight changes to fuel flow and/or max RPMs, due to the millions of dollars spent on R&D for the current PUs.

10
UserRed5OPF1•

Won't reducing the cubic capacity to a litre make the F1 manufactures design,develope and possibly create the best 1 litre IC engine in the world??

After all it's road relevance, isn't it??

We could see better small displacement cars with less weight and better reliability than cars with higher displacements and higher fuel efficiency

-1
swissflamdrag•

In theory yes, but you have to keep in mind that race engines are very different than road engines.

For starters race engines idle at higher rpms, and are designed to operate in high temperatures.

Road cars are designed to operate from a cold start, in a wide variety of climates while still being as reliable as possible.

The reason current f1 engines can achieve such high horsepower with such little displacement is how tight the cylinders and pistons are. Road cars can't be built the same way because you want to be able to start it in any weather with a push button.

All of that being said somebody like Mercedes doesn't want to spend millions on a smaller displacement engine after having spent probably in the hundreds of millions on the current format just in the name of smaller displacement.

The goal should be to achieve 100% thermal efficiency rather than throwing a wrench into every bodies current designs and make them start from scratch with a new concept.

3
UserRed5OPF1•

I.C engines can never achieve 100% thermal effeciency, the maximum they can do is 35%, as for mercedes' 50% thermal effeciency record is under controlled lab conditions and not real life

1
MrAlagos•

The engine should remain the same in my opinion, at most tweaking the arbitrary limits on the energy harvesting and storage capacities. Let's stop wasting everyone's money all the time, the current formula is pretty good.

5
IHaveADullUsername•

FoM, Ross Brawn and others have come out saying the engine architecture isn’t changing. The base unit will still be a 1.6L turbo hybrid. Other than that it’s all up in the air. It’s extremely unlikely that it will ever go to an flat/unlike anything as the engine than can’t act as a stressed member and the cars get heavier and engine changes become a nightmare.

5
LazyProspectorJenson Button•

They'll probably stick with the 1.6L V6 Turbo-Hybrid for a while. And up the electric capacity significantly and possibly add in front wheel motors.

If the engine did change a 2.0L I4 Turbo would be the most obvious but that's seems unlikely

5
UserRed5OPF1•

They are down sizing the engine all the time, so if they were to downsize once again, how will they increase the displacement of the engine??

1
LazyProspectorJenson Button•

My guess would be based on road relevancy. As turbo i4's are going to be increasingly popular.

Then increase displacement and reduce revs and fuel flow to give a engine output of like 500-600HP with another 500-600 as electric motors.

And then limit to 1 or 2 engines per season. Which is easier to achieve with larger displacement engine at lower load.

1
x1echoCharles Leclerc•

TT V8s would be sick.

3
UserRed5OPF1•

998 cc Quad Turbo flat 4 🤤🤤🤤

Edit: yeah obviously I forgot the /s

-1
Burntbigtoe•

I'd rather they revert back to NA V10/V12 engines, 3.0, 1200hp, and maybe a 300hp electric motor on the front axel, and another 300hp one on the rear. So 1800hp and 650kg. Go the opposite direction but keep some KERS components. If they don't move to bump up the power soon. EV road cars like the 2020 Tesla Roadster will be considerably faster than F1 cars in a straight line.

2
UserRed5OPF1•

They are never going back to NA engines be it V10 or V12, NA has lesser thermal effecieny than Turbo petrol engines and also F1 was never about straight line speed anyway.

1
Burntbigtoe•

Who cares about thermal efficiency? We want the sound, the speed and the spectacle. Fuck 1800hp, let’s go to 4L V12, 300kers on both axel for 2500hp and only underbody aero, no wings. That’ll make some exciting racing.

1
dat_boring_guyCharles Leclerc•

The manufacturers care.

5
Burntbigtoe•

Fuck the manufacturers

-1
PorscheGuy7McLaren•

It is certainly a very interesting time in motorsport in general. I think the question can be asked differently. How much energy can F1 cars use that is not produced by fossil fuels? Or how much energy does the good old ICE have to produce the keep the cars at the desired speed?

I think the sport and the manufacturers are looking at it from this perspective. I don’t think fully electric F1 will be something we’ll see in quite a while but love it or hate it there will be a time when ICE will be dropped from F1.

I think for 2023 the engine will stay the same. Maybe with reduced power output but certainly with increased efficiency.

2
UserRed5OPF1•

During the 2.4 V8 era, we simply had a small 80hp KERS system to assist the main ICE, now we have a 1.6 V6 with a MGU K and MGU H witha combined 160hp output, and step by step they will try to make the output from electrical system higher while limiting the ICE as a side kick., reversal of roles....since they can't completely electrify F1 they will reduce the ICE role to assist the main electrical system at the same time producing a lot of power, feel free to correct me.

2
PorscheGuy7McLaren•

I don’t think there is any need to correct you. We are saying basically the same thing here. To answer your exact question I do really think that it’ll stay 1.6 v6 but I also think that the electrical component will produce a lot more power and the engine will produce less than it does now. And I do think that step by step the ICE will be replaced completely by electrical or other resource driven power unit.

2
CapelaBrancaJolyon Palmer•

All of it can be non fossil

Look at IndyCar

1
dax-joel•

They will go back to naturally aspirated engines. If not I am fucking done with this sport. Motorsport without motors?

1†
UserRed5OPF1•

Electrical energy systems certainly have a motor, so it's still a Motorsport.

1
dax-joel•

Keep dreaming mate, it wouldn't be motorsport it would be a joke, I don't understand this subs obsession with dead silent cars without gears. Where the hell is the fun in that? Think back to the days when Senna pulled 4G in a corner at 15 000 RPM with one hand on the steering wheel and one on the stick, with no power steering! That was motorsport. There is no bloody reason to put electric power units anywhere near a Formula 1 car.

-1†
UserRed5OPF1•

I don't know how it's going to pan in the future but, rest assured the automotive industry will be to an extent completely or partially electrified

With other forms of locomotive power being provided by Fuel cells and hydrogen power.

2
cafkOther teams•

Obviously F1 can't go full electric, at least for the next 2 to 3 decades, after all it's "motor" racing ( we still have motor parts in electric engines)

The main reason for this not happening before 2034 is the fact that FiA and Formula E have an exclusive deal for all electric Formula series :)

Though Formula 1 is already hybrid and having a 600hp 4 cylinder engine would still be an amazing engineering feat, a kin to WRX

1
stillusesAOLHello! You've got mail!•

I’d be down for a 1.3-liter turbo inline-5.

Cylinder size remains the same as now but we get that sweet 5-/10-cylinder tonality.

And increase the electric power.

Win/win?

1
UserRed5OPF1•

Can inline engines be used as a stressed member like current V engines?? Also odd cylinder engines tend to suffer from vibration and balancing engines though balancing won't be a problem with inline configuration, if a change is made, it's definitely an inline4

1
stillusesAOLHello! You've got mail!•

All I know is that:

  • the cylinders in an I5 make a wave formation going down the line, and

  • it creates a major-tenth music interval just like a V10.

2
UserRed5OPF1•

I don't know anything about major-tenth interval or music, please suggest me a video or anything that can help me explain that.

1
stillusesAOLHello! You've got mail!•

You could probably google or YouTube that term to hear an example, but...

Every engine makes two tones simultaneously. These tones are always the same pitch interval apart (octave, major tenth, etc.), and they slide up and down together with RPM, always maintaining the same interval apart.

The bottom note is constant through every type of engine for a given RPM. It’s the top note that changes (and therefore the interval to that constant bottom note) depending only on one thing: the number of cylinders in the engine.

On 2, 4, 8, 16 cylinder engines, the top pitch is one octave up from the bottom pitch (from, say, a C to the next C up on a piano. 12 semi-tones apart).

5 and 10 cylinder engines produce two pitches a major 10th apart (from a C, past the next C to an E. 16 semi-tones apart). These are the best and most interesting sounding to me because it’s the richest sounding interval in the engine types.

3, 6, and 12 cylinder engines have their top tone a perfect 12th up from the bottom tone (from a C, past the next C to a G. 19 semi-tones.).

(A 7 or 14 cylinder engine produces a slightly-flat minor 14th interval (from a C, past the next C to a B-flat. About 22 semi-tones apart.))

What this means is that at a given RPM, the loud top tone of a V12 is a higher pitch than a V10 at that same RPM, which itself makes a higher pitch than a V8. In all three cases here the bottom tone is the same. It’s one of the reasons those Ferrari and Lamborghini V12s just scream. It’s also why the F1 V10s screamed higher than the V8s.

—

If anyone is interested in hearing some examples, the road cars all have about the same redline (8.5k RPM) and the F1 cars have the same redline (19k RPM) but you can hear how the upper pitch is higher at the moment before they shift at redline going from the 8- to 10- to 12-cylinder engines. The bottom pitch at redline is the same through all the engine types.

The top note of the F1 V8 is E-flat at redline but the F1 V10 is the G above that for the same RPM. (The bottom notes are of course both the E-flat, an octave below, at redline.)

F1:

F1 V8 - https://youtu.be/-DlpMjeB36g?t=12s

F1 V10 - https://youtu.be/aRkDXqeIMQM?t=1m13s

Road cars:

V8 - https://youtu.be/qujYKDVw654?t=1m57s

V10 - https://youtu.be/DWWhzfNQYRI?t=1m7s

V12 - https://youtu.be/xkeeMPJHNok?t=1m18s

Bonus:

A 7 cylinder engine - https://youtu.be/x0rxRcaEEcg?t=41s

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1