AITA for confessing to my best friend/crush

Not the A-hole

To preface this, I have known this girl for about 4 years up till my confession, and liked her for about 2 of those years. So my best friend and I had been getting really close over the past 2 months or so, and getting far more touchy as a result of this. I had chosen to keep my feelings at bay in the past, but as things escalated my feelings became too strong to hold back. I began to feel like I was betraying her trust by being as touchy as I was with her, although most of the time I was not the one who initiated this. Eventually, I decided enough was enough and decided to confess to her how I feel.

Sadly, she did not feel the same way for me, which I was fine with and began the process of moving on. The next time I saw her though, she began immediately talking about other guys she was either talking with or trying to have sex with, and this felt very cruel to me. I had just poured my heart out to this girl and it felt like she was intentionally trying to hurt me. After this, I asked if she could refrain from talking about guys for the time being, as I needed a lil bit of time to recover before I could only see her as a friend again.

This is where the potential assholery comes in. My statement resulted in a small argument where she essentially stated she didn’t want to talk about the fact that I had confessed to her. She said it made her extremely uncomfortable and honestly angry. For some reason, this really upset me and confused me, considering in the moment she was relatively understanding. I tried to get her to talk about it more, so I could understand where she was coming from and potentially work this out, but she continued wanting to avoid that topic in its entirety.

Later, I texted her essentially saying that until we can talk about what happened as adults, I would like to take a break from speaking. She never responded to this text and I’m kinda feeling like I may be the bad guy here.

So, Reddit, AITA?

Posted Feb 12, 2019, 10:52 PM UTC

212
1nciteAsshole Enthusiast [7]•

NTA. in fact she is the ass. if she cant handle you being a person with feelings and telling how you feel. then she is being insensitive. its ok for her to say no. and ok to keep being friends but requiring the other person to pretend it didnt happen is wrong.

5
greenbastardetteCommander in Cheeks [123]•

NTA - she is being WILDLY insensitive, and if she's a good friend, she should agree to talk this through with you OR to not mention other dudes to you while you're obviously getting over her.

​

She does not respect you.

5
PrimemimeOP•

She did agree to stop mentioning dudes, but basically said “ok I will stop talking about other dudes but don’t talk about that”

3
DragonBornLuke•

NTA. It's time to move on. Your friendship seems to have run its course. I've been there. I found THE girl 10 years later and married her. You sound like a decent enough guy to find yourself in a similar situation.

4
PrimemimeOP•

Thanks dude. Perhaps you are right. This has been a very eye opening situation for me

2
DragonBornLuke•

You know I'm right.

2
giny33Asshole Enthusiast [5]•

NTA. Find a new friend.

2
AutoModeratorMODAutomation Enthusiast•

^^^^AUTOMOD This is a copy of the above post. It is a record of the post as originally written, in case the post is deleted or edited.

To preface this, I have known this girl for about 4 years up till my confession, and liked her for about 2 of those years. So my best friend and I had been getting really close over the past 2 months or so, and getting far more touchy as a result of this. I had chosen to keep my feelings at bay in the past, but as things escalated my feelings became too strong to hold back. I began to feel like I was betraying her trust by being as touchy as I was with her, although most of the time I was not the one who initiated this. Eventually, I decided enough was enough and decided to confess to her how I feel.

Sadly, she did not feel the same way for me, which I was fine with and began the process of moving on. The next time I saw her though, she began immediately talking about other guys she was either talking with or trying to have sex with, and this felt very cruel to me. I had just poured my heart out to this girl and it felt like she was intentionally trying to hurt me. After this, I asked if she could refrain from talking about guys for the time being, as I needed a lil bit of time to recover before I could only see her as a friend again.

This is where the potential assholery comes in. My statement resulted in a small argument where she essentially stated she didn’t want to talk about the fact that I had confessed to her. She said it made her extremely uncomfortable and honestly angry. For some reason, this really upset me and confused me, considering in the moment she was relatively understanding. I tried to get her to talk about it more, so I could understand where she was coming from and potentially work this out, but she continued wanting to avoid that topic in its entirety.

Later, I texted her essentially saying that until we can talk about what happened as adults, I would like to take a break from speaking. She never responded to this text and I’m kinda feeling like I may be the bad guy here.

So, Reddit, AITA?

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
AutoModeratorMODAutomation Enthusiast•

#State of the Subreddit

If you want your comment to count toward judgment, put one of the following abbreviations at the beginning of your comment. Include ONLY ONE of the following abbreviations in your comment. If you don't include a judgement abbreviation, the bot will ignore you when it looks for the top comment.

JudgmentAbbreviation
You're the Asshole (& the other party is not)YTA
You're Not the A-hole (& the other party is)NTA
Everyone Sucks HereESH
No A-holes hereNAH
Not Enough InfoINFO

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
neonsaberAsshole Enthusiast [3]•

NTA, take the loss and move on my dude, zero contact and you'll get passed her

1
TheMiniManCanPartassipant [2]•

YTA

Next time, when someone says they don't want to talk about something, you listen to them.

Now, people are going to shit on you here for being "that guy." Just take your lumps, learn and move on. Apologize for being pushy and give her space. It's her decision now whether she wants to talk to you and continue being friends.

-2
PrimemimeOP•

I get that and normally I wouldn’t be pushy, but in this case she was trying to pretend like my confession didn’t happen which I felt was unfair to my own feelings as well.

With that said, I appreciate the opinion, that is why I am here.

2