On SNC-Lavalin

So I've been reading and watching all of the coverage of the SNC-Lavalin debacle, and am left with a couple of questions I hope Reddit can help me understand the answers to.

Basically, the arguments I've heard in favour of giving the company a non-prosecution alternative to justice in this case boil down to:

(1) Without such an agreement, there is little chance of a conviction in a reasonable time because the company will fight tooth and nail and the thing will drag on for years.

and

(2) If the company IS convicted, and barred from competing in government contracts for the next 10 years, it will effectually destroy the company. Thousands of jobs will be lost, other companies in the supply chain will go bankrupt, employees will immolate themselves on the steps of Parliment, the province of Quebec will fall into the sea. You get the idea.

​

As far as I can tell, (1) is just capitulation. It is a veiled assertion that justice is impossible, when the accused are wealthy and powerful. It is essentially agreeing to allow criminals to crime, if it will be too hard to punish them, and simply ask for a cut later, if we catch them. It's realpolitik, but it's also cowardly and dishonest. If you want to say 'the law shouldn't apply to the wealthy', then just say so.

​

Now, (2) is more interesting. It's trivial to say that SNC-Lavalin will be incredibly harmed by a conviction and subsequent ban, but will the knock-on effects really be as dire as the company predicts? Certainly, it'll be bad for the company and it's stockholders. They will need to lay-off employees and drastically reduce size and operating costs. Sure, that's going to be hard. But it's not like the contracts that SNC-Lavalin was going to bid on are going away - other large civil engineering firms will need to step in and take those roles, they're going to need to hire new employees to fill the new positions that are created to fill the demand. Suppliers who used to work with SNC-Lavalin will either be supplying these other companies, or other suppliers with existing relationships to the other firms will have to grow. Either way, the total amount of economic activity seems like it would be largely unchanged - it will just be different organizations participating.

The other thing that's bothering me in all of this is individual responsibility. If a Montreal Mafia family is bribing the mayor, we don't prosecute the organization. We prosecute the people who committed the crimes. Where are the individual prosecutions against SNC-Lavalin executives, middle-managers and other employees involved in these schemes. It's not as if the company is some sort of physical entity that could carry out these offenses, every step involved decisions made by individual actors, decisions they knew or should have known were criminal. I would probably not have a serious problem with the company (essentially an entity made of money and contracts) being let off with a fine, if all of the people who actually directed and carried out it's crimes were sitting in the prisoner's dock. Why does the coverage of these crimes consistently omit the names of the people who actually committed them?

​

edit: That's odd, something deleted my first paragraph. Re-added it the best I can.

Posted Feb 13, 2019, 4:02 AM UTC

96
coffeenorth•

It's trivial to say that SNC-Lavalin will be incredibly harmed by a conviction and subsequent ban, but will the knock-on effects really be as dire as the company predicts? Certainly, it'll be bad for the company and it's stockholders.

Not at all. A company that is willing to make bribes is also willing to lie, and these claims of ruining Québec's economy are exaggerations at best and lies at worst.

Stockholders have full access to company financial disclosures, and get to speak with executives at meetings and conferences. This means that stockholders should know which shady countries SNC is doing business in, and where money is flowing, and they should've known their investments were risky (unless of course SNC cooked the books, in which case, the Stockholders should push for fraud charges). This also isn't SNC's first brush with the law, so again, stockholders should be well aware of how risky these investments were.

They will need to lay-off employees and drastically reduce size and operating costs. Sure, that's going to be hard. But it's not like the contracts that SNC-Lavalin was going to bid on are going away - other large civil engineering firms will need to step in and take those roles, they're going to need to hire new employees to fill the new positions that are created to fill the demand.

Exactly. Good employees will not be left unemployed.

Some people are worried that the engineering companies who move into Québec to take SNC's place will be American companies, and profits will start flowing out of the country, but the simply solution to preventing this is to give bid preference to other Canadian companies.

Another more complicated option would be to sell off the ownership of SNC in pieces to different engineering companies across Canada, and pass on the contracts and employees at the same time to these other companies.

​

​

Where are the individual prosecutions against SNC-Lavalin executives, middle-managers and other employees involved in these schemes. It's not as if the company is some sort of physical entity that could carry out these offenses, every step involved decisions made by individual actors, decisions they knew or should have known were criminal. I would probably not have a serious problem with the company (essentially an entity made of money and contracts) being let off with a fine, if all of the people who actually directed and carried out it's crimes were sitting in the prisoner's dock. Why does the coverage of these crimes consistently omit the names of the people who actually committed them?

The executives are still in court facing criminal charges in relation to their last scandal: https://business.financialpost.com/news/snc-lavalin-faces-criminal-probe-over-montreal-bridge-contract-documents-reveal

​

Edit: here's an article from 2013 noting that "Canada now dominates World Bank corruption list, thanks to SNC-Lavalin": https://business.financialpost.com/executive/canada-now-dominates-world-bank-corruption-list-thanks-to-snc-lavalin

Out of the more than 250 companies year to date on the World Bank’s running list of firms blacklisted from bidding on its global projects under its fraud and corruption policy, 117 are from Canada — with SNC-Lavalin and its affiliates representing 115 of those entries, the World Bank said.

​

5
SnarkHuntrOP•

See, there it is again. The FP article you linked to says:

Former federal official Michel Fournier pleaded guilty in 2017 to accepting more than $2.3 million in payments from SNC-Lavalin in connection with the project.

Where are the names of the SNC employees who committed this crime? Have they been charged/convicted of anything? I know that incorporation is supposed to give a pass on financial liability. I didn't know it offered protection against criminal liability as well.

4
coffeenorth•

This article has a few names in regards to crimes back in 2010: https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/a-brief-history-of-snc-lavalin-1.1154986

It looks like Mexico and Switzerland have arrested some SNC employees, but unfortunately I can't find anyone jailed by the Canadian government yet.

Edit 1: a previous CEO was arrested on fraud charges: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/former-snc-lavalin-ceo-arrested-on-fraud-charges-1.1211641

Edit 2: a couple other people facing Canadian charges are mentioned in this article, but as of the time it was published, one guy was on the run and the police couldn't find him: http://www.montrealgazette.com/news/Lavalin+exec+claims+firm+fostered+close+ties+with+Gadhafi+clan/9560797/story.html

3
SnarkHuntrOP•

I see that the previous CEO got 20 months of house arrest for a whole slew of offenses, for which he pleaded guilty to one. (source: https://www.thestar.com/business/2019/02/01/newsalert-former-snc-lavalin-ceo-pierre-duhaime-pleads-guilty.html) He paid a 200,000 fine, which probably doesn't even offset the money he made during that time.

The statement said Duhaime did not receive any money from the crime. It added that he was not connected to and had no knowledge of the $22.5-million in bribes paid to then-CEO of the MUHC, Arthur Porter, and his right-hand man Yanai Elbaz.

Good grief - the CEO of the company is unaware that one of his subordinates is paying out 22 million in unaccountable bribes? How were they entered on the balance sheets?

Yanai Elbaz got a 3 year sentence, which means out in 2 at most. Not too bad, I guess. That's about what you'd get for a minor armed robbery in most places.

4
coffeenorth•

The government really needs to launch a national investigation into SNC, across all 13 provinces and territories, going back all the way to 1991. Perhaps the investigation should be funded by Canada, but done by a foreign entity like the UK to make it truly impartial.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1