Is anyone else underwhelmed by J. Crew boots, even at sale prices?

Sale

[removed]

Posted Feb 14, 2019, 1:47 AM UTC

2122
MDRNCULT•

They are not a boot company....that’s the secret

40
strbeanjoe•

Yah man, I got a pair of Levi's sneakers and was totally disappointed!

8
Koen-K•

I have Kenton Cap toes in the brown color. I personally love mine but I only paid like $115 for them. I would say definitely better than Thursdays Boots but not as good as Red Wing and others for obvious reasons.

I really don't think they are comparable to other boots like at DSW. The Kentons are definitely way better than anything you can get at a $50-120 range.

11
ChambersMonroeOP•

I haven't tried Thursday boots. They look nice in pictures, but the heel is very tall, which was a dealbreaker for me. Do you find the Kentons comfortable? I was surprised by how hard the soles felt. To me, they felt similar to Clark's Bushacre chukka, which basically has a piece of paper as the insole. Leather was a bit stiff too, although that didn't bother me much. It seemed sturdy/durable at least.

2
imperialka•

I agree with the commenter above and I think they are great boots around the $100-$150 range. I have them and I would not pay full retail for them.

I wouldn’t go as far to say they are not worth it past $100 but the quality is decent. The only thing I dislike is how easy the leather scratches but aside from that I like the leather and overall construction of the boot. As someone else said, jcrew is not a boots company so I wouldn’t expect them to make a top notch boot, but I’ll say they are worth it at a discounted price!

5
Koen-K•

I would have to agree on the Thursday's they look nice but I don't mind the big heel. The insole on them are horrible though and for $200 I would rather try to find a wolverine or Chippewa second.

I do find the Kentons comfortable. I have three pairs of Red Wings so I have a decent frame of reference. The Kentons have a nice insole and sole IMHO. The upper does look a bit cheap but my comments stand I think they are great around the $100 range. Kentons are definitely a lower mid range option. Maybe if you rank it then like this Trickers/Viberg/Oaks/Etc (400-500)>Red Wing/Taft/Meerim/AE/etc(250-300)>Kentons/Tim's?/Seconds (100-200)>Anything under $100 are really not worth it.

1
sarch•

Why spend $115 on a pair of boots that last half as long as a $230 pair of boots?

1
mcfabber•

My experience was the opposite actually. Considering how cheap you can get their gyw shoes for I thought they were great. I have a pair of the ludlow bluchers and they honestly feel on par with my Allen Edmonds and I got them for $50 on eBay. I haven’t tried the boots though, but these shoes are great. Leather is thinner, but leather sole has held up extremely well.

5
MMiUSACXL is the best. Don't @ me.•

My experience isn’t huge with them, but I have owned a pair briefly and have handled many and personally at the price point (especially on sale) they are hard to beat IMO.

Construction wise they are sound, their designs are fairly stylish, and comfort was fine. They certainly aren’t Alden, but they also cost 1/4. About 1/2 of RW. Same for Wolverine.

Combined with arguably the best CS in the business, I have zero issues recommending them as a quality entry level option.

BTW, for someone saying “they aren’t a boot company”, I feel the need to point out that as unimportant. Neither is Maison Margiela, RRL, etc. All of which make high end goods (or at least outsource to the proper channels). Even Alden started off as kids shoes IIRC, Nintendo was a trading card company. It’s not a direct relationship being a “mall brand” and having “bad footwear”. J.Crew footwear is definitely a notch above most in their category.

5

BTW, for someone saying “they aren’t a boot company”, I feel the need to point out that as unimportant

Came to say this.

In fact, most things we buy are just names on another factory's product. Go buy a bike from a bike shop and they're all mostly made in the same factories as their competitors.

1
arpus•

I got my Kenton pacer boots for $85. Pretty good deal!

4
M635_Guyaddicted to NST•

My Kenton Pacer boots were nicely built/made, but seemed a bit lackluster for leather/etc. They improved a lot as they got worn/brushed/etc. Bang-for-the-buck, I think they're pretty darn good, but the out-of-the-box state needs to be seen as a starting point.

2
calvinball_expert•

I bought a pair of Kenton Pacers on sale and really wanted to love them. Unfortunately they were the most uncomfortable boots I’ve ever worn. I also didn’t love the leather; it was really stiff and dull, even after wearing them for over a month and conditioning them. Style was good though since it’s just an Indy knockoff and the construction did seem decent.

2
ChambersMonroeOP•

This is exactly the same impression I got from examining/trying on the cap toes.

1
arpus•

Hmm. I found the leather stiff, too, but the sole was comfortable. I put Saphir neutral polish and it softened quite a bit, but more like from plastic to cardboard.

1
DesolationR0wI was once a lost sole.•

Hello!

I've removed this post. It contains a question or discussion that is best suited for our Daily Questions posts. It is posted every day, and is frequently visited throughout the day.

Please feel free to repost your question or discussion in the most recent or upcoming thread.

The most recent one can be found here.

2
1RaizenBoots & Loafers•

I have them both but I prefer the looks of the Pacers. You know, come to think of it, they are pretty average. I think $150 is still too high for those, specially when you can get really good ones on sale.

1
northcoast1•

Returned 2 pairs I got super cheap from there. So yes.

1
clutchthepearls•

I don't feel this way. They aren't worth the $250, but at closer to $150 there's not much in that price range that's really any better.

I have the Kenton Pacer model and paid $140 on eBay. They aren't as nice as my 1k Miles, but they're better than my Golden Fox boondockers.

1
not_old_redditor•

J Crew and BR's merchandise is always at least 40% off because that's how much it's actually worth. You're not getting good boots at a killer deal, you're getting boots that are marginally worth the price tag at 40% off, and even that's debatable as OP has shown.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
PsychoWorld•

I heard their ludlow shoes are made by the grant stone factory.

-2
ronearc•

Are the boots made by Alden? No? Then I don't care.

(Sorry if that seems snarky, blame the rum please).

-5†