Why is Reddit very against karma-whoring... except when Flossdaily does it?
[deleted]
Posted Jan 16, 2010, 5:50 PM UTC · edited
[deleted]
Posted Jan 16, 2010, 5:50 PM UTC · edited
I don't think Reddit is as against karma whoring as you think it is. If I see a clever or worthwhile comment, I upvote it, and that's my personal standard for upvoting. If karma whores can appeal to that, good for them.
But take a look at how many novelty accounts you see, and how many upvotes they get. These are accounts with no purpose other than generating karma, and based on the votes, I think people don't mind.
Look_of_Disapproval is pretty much an unlimited comment karma generator.
look_of_disapproval still entertains me. i'm happy for him to get karma
I agree, i think some novelty accounts are to make other people laugh not to karma whore.
'sides which, if friend l_o_d were truly karmawhoring, he'd be pasting his unicode glyphs into every second thread. so far he seems to be exercising a properly artistic taste and restraint.
Also, what's the point of accruing karma on a novelty account anyway?
Yes, I realize that one could also ask "what's the point of accruing karma, period," but it seems doubly irrelevant when it's a running gag.
[deleted]
[deleted]
i like how he's actually going in numerical order, not inventing some random number for each new law
flossdaily entertains me also. So, why the bitterness?
despite the intrinsic entertainment value of his posts, there are threads where he lowers the signal-to-noise ratio (this does not mean his posts are noise because of some inherent flaw in them; they are noise when considered against the prevailing definition of signal). also, he posts too much at times, leading to the clutter effect - any given post is great, but together they just look like a morass.
ಠ_ಠ
I think the problem comes up when he outright asks for upvotes.
I have NEVER asked for upvotes.
[deleted]
BIRD!!
[deleted]
Too late.
It's about making a better joke using a conditional identity. Duh.
they aren't their regular names
So "flossdaily" IS a regular name? How is it different? In the same way we have ascii_unicorn who always posts a unicorn saying witty things, we have a "storyteller" novelty account. Just replace "storyteller" with "flossdaily".
Personally, cook of disapproval is my favorite.
flossdaily contributes a ton of original material. He deserves what little publicity we can give him. OP's whine, in contrast, contributes nothing.
The best way to get karma on Reddit is to be funny. Since most people here are karma whores, the majority of threads are full of obnoxious, usually cliched jokes. I would like to see more serious discussion.
That's my problem with karma whores.
If what got the most karma was what was most thoughtful, insightful, intelligent, and useful, then I wouldn't have a problem with them at all. That's just not the case.
[deleted]
✇ ✇
(____,
)
✇ ✇
(____,
)
faaiillll
I'm not usually one to share PM content, but ever since flossdaily PM'd me soliciting me to submit a comment he made as its own submission, I made it my policy not to upvote him. Ever.
In his defense, a lot of hist posts are high-quality and took a while to make, so he probably didn't want it to fall into obscurity.
I know I've made some good, quality posts with a lot of effort and only a few people noticed :(
We've all been there. I don't really think it is justified though. You win some, you lose some.
I agree that some of his arguments like "People have been asking for more, and they can't find it unless you bestof" are pretty weak, he does seem to have a bit of an ego, and that a lot of threads are completely hijacked, but the guy puts in way more effort into reddit than I do so I don't think I'm in a position to complain :P
It does seem, though, he's hit his first Reddit downvote squad. It'll be fun to see if he survives
"People have been asking for more, and they can't find it unless you bestof"
Actually, by friending someone, you can keep up on their writing quickly and easy. That is kind of a weak argument.
some of his arguments like "People have been asking for more, and they can't find it unless you bestof" are pretty weak
I get at least a dozen emails a day from people asking where they can find more of my work. That number is easily 50 on the days when I have a story that hits it big.
he does seem to have a bit of an ego
Could you point to a comment that indicates that? Or is it just your assumption that I must have a big ego because people have given me a warm reception?
and that a lot of threads are completely hijacked
All of my stories are on the topic of the thread. The I have a few emails from posters thanking me for posting in their threads, either because they liked the stories, or they enjoyed getting higher traffic. I have never received a single complaint from those posters about my comments.
he's hit his first Reddit downvote squad. It'll be fun to see if he survives
I'm glad you're enjoying this little hatch job that earlyworm_ has done on me. Personally I find it kind of horrifying that I can spend a month building up good will with people and then be knocked down by someone who doesn't even have the decency to confront me about his issues before he starts organizing a mob.
Really? Have you spent 4 hours writing a story for a dead submission? I would really and truly love to see a link to it.
[deleted]
Reddit isn't here as a story-appreciation service. If you're writing stories and looking for credit, get a fucking blog. This is a forum for discussion.
Wow, okay... so like ONE day after someone /bestof/'ed one of my stories and got over 1000 karma out of the deal, karmaknotte stops in to see a new story I've written. He says he likes it, so I PM him saying that he looked like someone that was interested in karma, and that if /bestof/'ed my story he might get lucky and get some splash karma.
Do I have that right?
Is that any different than what I've done in other threads where I encourage people to upvote OTHER redditors?
Wow, talk about a character assassination. That's bullshit man.
I never asked for anything but more eyes on my stories.
You would too if you spent 4 hours writing one in response to a question only to find that the thread is dead.
Is that any different than what I've done in other threads where I encourage people to upvote OTHER redditors?
Why do you assume that this is correct behavior?
uh... because it's altruistic, and altruistic behaviors are encouraged in society?
Karma is worth nothing. It's like giving someone air. (Assume he's not underwater/in space/in Beijing)
It just draws attention away from posts that might have some actual content in them. Upvote if threads are considered to be against the reddiquette, comments could easily be seen as an extension of that.
tl;dr
[deleted]
I hate karma whores.
Starkinter.
Citizen Premier.
Aussie Golfer.
State the Obvious.
♪♪♪
[deleted]
LOL
oh baby please dont go
:(
its a pets.com sock puppet reset...
His stories are truly enjoyable. However, when I read comments I want to read other people's stories, opinions about the original post, not a dinosaur thread with his page-long novels, opinions about them, and people begging him to continue.
If he posted them as posts (or put them on a separate blog and posted them here as links), he could get all the karma he deserves for his writing skills. His point might be that if he splits it up in multiple comments, he gets more upvotes.
There's always the [-] button if you don't want the wall of text and subsequent responses to clutter the page.
C'mon, that involves active participation to remove a personal annoyance. Why can't reddit just be how I want it without me clicking a hide or collapse button?
Yeah! Why can't I always have everything exactly how I like it?
I break them up because reddit comments have a word limit.
Use posts then or post them on some dedicated site. They would also be easier to find, reread, refer to. The stories are worth it.
The posts are all replies to askreddit threads. reddit inspires the content, reddit should get it.
i fail to understand how it isn't easier to have a dedicated blog with the stories on there with a link to the pieces inspiration. you'd submit the stories and i imagine be handsomely rewarded in karma.
I think a story subreddit might be fun for a lot of redditors, writers and readers alike.
Plus front page, a bit of bestof exposure may help make it a more popular subreddit, but either way, looks awesome and I think I'm going to be spending a lot of time there. flossdaily as a contributor is a good thing.
Looks like it'll be fun!
[deleted]
I may get downvoted for this but the one bar story was a lot like the first saw even down to the illuminating paint in the bathroom, guy trapping victims.
There's something really strange about that guy. Like the time he made a huge deal 'cause someone stole his Star Wars story... DUDE, so FUCKING WHAT. After that, he didn't even realize he was being trolled, and just kept feeding and feeding him. He's not just a karma whore, he's a self-centered attention whore.
[deleted]
I don't see how clarifying my identity in the headline did anything but clarify my identity.
whatever you read into that came from YOUR head, not mine.
Hey, I'd like to read this, where is it?
If you go back in the OP you'll see that I admitted on the stop that I over-reacted.
The point wasn't just that he stole it. The point was that someone accused me of plagiarizing my own story.
I think most people could see that he and other members on that forum were clearly trolling you and you fell for it.
what? how can you not understand that? it's his story! i'd be pretty fucking upset if someone stole a song of mine and passed it off as their own, especially if it subsequently spread across the internet with their name attached to it.
Flossdaily is really good at it, so I'm willing to forgive him. Anyway, he gets reddit to upvote other peoples comments not his own, so I don't see it as karmawhoring really.
[deleted]
I dunno man, I think they generally deserve to get into bestof, so I don't see any huge injustice here. Even if that is what he is doing, wouldn't you try and get as many people to see your post if you put as much time and effort in as he does with his stories?
[deleted]
I twice saw him ask other commenters to invite their friends over to Reddit to upvote his stories. Now he complains his karma income is slowing down and that people are downvoting him only because they're jealous of his karma.
I have a sneaking suspicion he's trying to get an online audience to woo a publisher with. It could work if he spends as much effort on improving his writing as he spends on marketing.
[deleted]
No no, you misread my post. The reason he deserves to be on bestof is because he's genuinely 'one of the best of'. The reason I can understand that he would choose to use karmawhore tactics is because of the amount of time and effort he puts in.
[deleted]
BAWWW FLOSSDAILY ISN'T REDDITING LIKE HE'S SUPPOSED TO
You do know that self posts don't get karma, right? So the only real benefit of being in r/bestof is a few more people seeing his comment.
[deleted]
Circle of whoring... isn't that what bestof is?
Ok, fine, I forgot that they weren't technically self posts. But still. Does this really bother you that much? How does this actually effect you? Downvoting and ignoring his posts is clearly too simple a solution for you.
You go earlyworm_! SPREAD THE WORD!!! AND JUSTICE FOR ALL!!!
jesus earlyworm_ why the fuck do YOU care so much about this??? does Flossdaily have more karma then you pumpkin???
[deleted]
You know what would make reddit less enjoyable for me? Flossdaily's absence.
write a sex scene... it's write a sex scene.
I'd prefer if you sent your friends here to see it. I'm trying to get some exposure so that when I sell a book I have some people lined up to sell to.
-flossdaily
I don't understand why you're finding that so offensive. Redditors are the ones who encouraged me to write a book.
I'm putting in a lot of time and effort to do that- and possibly damaging my chances of lining up steady employment in the processes.
If I spend a ton of time working on a book then find that I have no audience to sell it to, I am really and truly financially fucked.
If I didn't try to build an audience here, I would be a goddamn moron.
What's the problem? Do you feel like I'm using you? Has anyone who has actually taken the time to have a conversation here feel that way? I'd love to know.
I've tried really hard to be part of this community. I haven't asked you for anything but your eyes.
I don't have a problem with it. Like I said later,
That being said, I do want to read a flossdaily book, and don't mind having flossdaily having some references for publishers. However, please include the quote to expose the hypocrisy for the double-standards that some hold on karma-whoring.
See, many Redditors would easily downvote anybody else who tried doing what you did in the name of "karma-whoring". It's a double-standard that should be questioned.
I have no problem with you getting your references on Reddit, especially if you'll give a shout-out to Reddit in your book(s).
[deleted]
That being said, I do want to read a flossdaily book, and don't mind having flossdaily having some references for publishers. However, please include the quote to expose the hypocrisy for the double-standards that some hold on karma-whoring.
I'm sorry, what hypocrisy would you be talking about?
Someone wanted to put my story on his blog, I asked that he redirect traffic here instead.
How is this a bad thing for reddit?
And what does it have to do with karma at all?
I'm sorry, what hypocrisy would you be talking about?
If some other people tried to do what you did, they would be obliterated in the name of "karma-whoring". This isn't meant as an attack on you. The standards by which people are held to "karma-whoring" are often selectively applied, and I want to expose the people which selectively apply it.
[deleted]
Well, I, uh... I, um. Well, I didn't say you would say such things.
Bananas are full of potassium!
-Cheesasaurus
Who the fuck is he anyway?
Apparently he's a world class asshole.
I see, interesting.
Flossdaily writes nice stories. He may be an ass but that just means I'll downvote his stupid posts but I'll still upvote his stories; most of the time.
Why are you so against it? Do you think you're the only one intelligent enough to see Flossdaily is karmawhoring? Are you concerned for the community?
Flossdaily, that's a pretty good new junk account you have there. You're so funny.
[deleted]
I think you missed me implying that you are flossdaily. sigh
[deleted]
So, in seven minutes I've turned you into the "monster" you hate. I've been pretty productive for a Saturday.
be careful. you might get scolded for this type of behavior.
context - when i posted this, the linked-to post above was at -5 . good to see i'm not the only one that feels this way. thanks y'all. =)
[deleted]
see thats better likeaturbine! your playing much better with others today. now get your mom to sign your daytimer and you can have this nice gold star! your a big boy!
your a big boy!
does this validate that you're an idiot?
LOL this is fun! Not really i dont care what your gender is... I just liked how you linked our flame out from the other day and needed to comment on it again. Also I upvoted your comment, only because i really liked the exchange. I comment to be sarcastic. Its lost on some people but thats okay by me!
[deleted]
um ... i think he was talking about ... oh never mind ...
For a writer like flossdaily I think it means more than it does for us. Karma shows how much appreciation people are showing for his stories. More up votes the better the story was. Most of us make nonsense comments we care little about so it doesn't matter to us. To him its more because he puts thoughts into his stories.
Or anyone else who tries too hard to be liked by everyone on Reddit. I have to admit that these people know what they're doing. They know how to say what's going to get up-voted most, even if it's a really fucking obvious joke, or stating the obvious, or presenting some stupid cliche that doesn't even need repeating.
Does it matter? Until you can trade karma for cash, who gives a shit?
You've obviously never been to /r/circlejerk.
Yea I'm pretty sure there is a writing subreddit. Some of his writing is pretty good but then again if people didn't want to see it they would just click the down arrow.
[deleted]
Exactly. And I understand that there is a bigger audience outside of the writing subreddit but people might complain if everyone was doing this. Posting links and comments that aren't relevant to the thread. I really don't care either way because karma doesn't do anything for me and you can always downvote and minimize the comment thread.
[deleted]
I don't think it counts as karma whoring if you are contributing something significant, which his stories usually do.
No they don't really. If someone is asking something and someone writes a story of fiction how is that contributing to the thread? And honestly, if more people set out to write stories in threads like that a lot of people would be complaining regardless of the quality of the stories. I see it as a writer spamming threads to get Karma.
It's contributing because it is enjoyable to read. To me it goes in the same category as joke responses or pun threads. If something is really funny then I will upvote it even if it doesn't actually answer the question because it still is providing entertainment and there is still plenty of space on the page for legitimate responses. Also, if story writing became a problem then simple downvoting would take care of it.
Yea that's what I said in another comment here. I don't mind minimizing it and moving on. I can also see how it is karma whoring though. He is just writing. That's it. There is a subreddit for writing. Some of his writing has nothing to do with the topic. But again, if people have a problem just downvote and minimize the comment.
WHO THE FUCK CARES
?
You trollin'.
The better question is...why does anyone give a flying-F about karma?
same reason you care about your score in a video game - the human mind seems geared towards numbers-as-a-reward.
I've only read one thing I was aware was by FlossDaily. Honestly, it had me for about the first two paragraphs, then it was tl;dr. I was surprised by how many people seemed to cream their jeans over his writing. I think these people should spend less time on Reddit and more at their library.
actually, i read a lot (10 books this year, e.g.) and i find his style quite enjoyable. his story about the kid sister and the music box was very well done, for instance. however, they are beginning to seem cluttery here on reddit; they break the flow of the normal (or, rather, my normal) reddit-reading experience, so i skip them more often than not.
10 books a year = a lot? I have sex a lot =]
:rolleyes:
Holy shiat, man. That is a lot of books.
Any particular genre?
Some of his stories are fantastic, some are not. This story is fantastic
You know what, I did read that it was was great, I just didn't know his username when I did. Okay, maybe I've read some of his lesser works and got my impression from them. I'll take a second look.
Good comment, here's an 846 - There ya go!
[deleted]
you think us easterners don't play videogames?
[deleted]
i thought the Japanese were famous for making some of the best videogames *pausing to bow to Shigeru Miyamoto and team for creating a masterpiece*
For a writer like flossdaily I think it means more than it does for us. Karma shows how much appreciation people are showing for his stories. More up votes the better the story was. Most of us make nonsense comments we care little about so it doesn't matter to us. To him its more because he puts thoughts into his stories. - Copied my response from before
edit: I think the links help him get through his his writers block and give him ideas. Guess he wants to be best of if he finds something he wrote really good and wants more people to see it
Here are two posts:
A lot of upvotes, but virtually meaningless.
Still a good number of upvotes, but not as many Here, the upvotes meant a lot more to me.
I put more effort into that second one, and snotboogie's comment and a PM from bozarking made it all worthwhile.
I don't know why people are hating on flossdaily for posting stories in exchange for karma. He isn't looking for money or traffic, he's just looking for some validation and to entertain some people.
Edit: As it turns out... he is looking for money.
Huh. He wants to write a book to sell to reddit. Huh. I mean I support the community and if a redditor said "Hey guys, I wrote a book" I'd definately check it out and be more inclined to purchase it than another unkown book. But still, it appears he's trying to aggressivley market himself on reddit, (via karma) in order to be able to market a book. This makes me feel awkward.
I've written stuff in exchange for karma, but I did it all for the karma.
Now it has gotten more complicated.
you make it sound like I'm using people. I haven't asked anybody for anything. not money, not book sales, not karma (for myself). I've asked people to read my stories, that's it.
These quotes are troubling.
Do NOT get me wrong. I like your writing, I like that you are part of the reddit community. I know you were a part of the reddit community before you decided to try to write a book to sell to us.
And we of reddit support our own. As much of a bitch as the hivemind can be, we still like other redditors, even if they are assholes.
And we aren't entirely against marketing either, but it has to be done with a lot of humility and love in the face of the community, ie soapier.
Still, the idea that you weren't going after the karma for exclusively the karma's sake but because you wanted to stay popular in order to sell a book is an issue. Let the community do its thing and you do your thing, it's like sex with a polar bear, you have to make sure it is 100% consensual or things won't end well for you.
Sometimes good posts don't get what they 'deserve' in attention or upvotes but that's the way it goes with reddit.
hello, people? please do not downvote the man for coming here to the thread and explaining himself, whether or not you agree!
Yes that does complicate things. Well he said he wasn't intending to do so at first. Redditors were actually asking to buy his work, so he started to promote it on the site that people were asking at. Its still terrible just not as bad as I was expecting reading your edit.
I see this comment all the time when people bring up karma, it's amazing how uninformed people are about how the system works. As if karma was just a number that did absolutely nothing...
Comment karma affects how often you can post comments. Some people don't like being forced to one comment every 5-10 minutes after the hive mind decides to downvote them. That's one reason why people give a fuck about it... Submission karma affects how often you can post submissions in a similar way from what I understand.
Ah, how nice... Once the hive votes you down really bad you can't even have a discussion on other topics, it's great! Such an awesome way to promote opposing viewpoints that don't follow the general mindset here...
You'll understand if I don't reply to any responses, I don't feel like sitting around 5 minutes just to comment again...
you can't blame everything on the hivemind like mentality, maybe your comments are just bad. I say some things that get downvoted, I shrug it off. Most well presented opposing views are not down voted.
Do you talk into an empty room? No? Why not? Because it's pointless. People write comments in the hopes that they'll be read and taken seriously. Redditors don't typically even bother to read comments that are downvoted. On the other hand, people tend to just assume that comments that are heavily upvoted are meritorious and lend them and their authors more credence than they would if they read the content of those comments out of context without knowing their karma scores.
Additionally, the frequency with which you can post is a function of how much comment karma you have.
I don't understand why people don't get this. I have pointed this out dozens of times and, yet, every time the topic comes up, someone says "I don't even know why anyone would care about karma". There are legitimate reasons to care (legitimate if only because people are illogical and consequently can't dispassionately and objectively appraise a comment without letting its score affect their perception of its worth. Cf. Argumentum ad Populum fallacy)
Whatever method reddit uses for sorting posts based on karma seems to work pretty reasonably. But yeah, outside of a particular thread, I agree there isn't much reason to care. Now everybody please upvote me!
Karma has no impact whatsoever on any sorting method.
Tends to disagree with you
The best sorting algorithm works based on the ratio of upvotes to downvotes that comments receive, weighted by a threshold of the average total votes in a thread. The karma of each user has nothing to do with it, and keep in mind that karma is distinct from, while based on, a comment's score. There is a greasemonkey extension that lets you view the exact upvotes/downvotes of every comment.
That's because having a shitload of karma makes you feel awesome. 'Tis the truth.
The better question is "when you do a self post and you don't get karma from it... why do people still think you're karma whoring?"
Karma is made of rainbows and muffins.
puppy seed muffins!
FOUR IS TWO UNLESS YOU'RE DEAD.
Do I smell a meme?
puns, karma parties, and general karma whoring have caused a karma point inflation. karma is basically meaningless and worthless.
On reddit, karma is and always has been worthless. I don't think the founders every meant for it to have actual worth.
The point is having a way to show others that you contribute a lot to the site.
Because some people view karma as a way of displaying to the rest of the community that you are an established member. Somebody pulling some shenanigans that has <100 karma is less likely to get away with it than somebody who has >10,000.
Sometimes you get n00bed with commenting too soon.
Why to people care about points in a sports game? Both have equal value.
Sports are generally team-based. Winner and Loser. With karma, nobody wins.