r/Cardinals•
97643

#STLCards pitcher Adam Wainwright on @TMASTL: “Unless something changes, there’s going to be a strike. 100%. I’m just worried people are going to walk-out mid-season.”

Posted Feb 15, 2019, 7:11 PM UTC

158115
Cochise22I want fitty cent dranks. •

Honesty I won’t blame the players at all if they strike. Sure it’s billionaires vs millionaires, but fuck the owners and MLB for how they treat their players, especially minor leaguers.

99
SaltyBarkerWears #5 to Games•

especially minor leaguers.

The guys that don't even get called up until theyre 27-28, hit FA at 30. And not make near what they should because they're "Pass their prime".... MLB Needs to change their shit now and start paying these players.

​

53
Cochise22I want fitty cent dranks. •

Not just that, but the fact that they’ve actively fought to pay minor leaguers less than minimum wage. Until they pay minor leaguers a decent salary, MLB owners can suck it.

31

Earlier arbitration. Fewer years team control. To start.

14
Cambridge_•

I think they need to take up how the NHL does it.

Players are usually around 25 or 27 when they become UFA.

7
Philbob99•

I think that’s because NHL players make it a little younger though. Because the MLB has so much development and so many minor leagues, I’d imagine the average age of a rookie is 23-24 whereas it’s probably like 21 for the NHL.

That’s why a guy like Harper is such an anomaly, hitting free agency at 26 because he broke in at like 19

4
NeutralPanda•

The rule is 25 unless they've played a certain amount of games in the NHL (number changes based on if you're a goalie or not) and then there's a different list of rules.

1
doogalleh21•

It's nuts that the average career length is 6 years and the team control is 6 years (according to what I last read) That means that you have to be an exception to even reach the market, and you have to be above average to get to the MLB in time to get a reasonable contract on the open market. Until this year, where we learn that if you are exceptionally above average and demand an appropriate contract they'll say you are asking for too much and you won't get signed.

I don't get how people are saying 10 year contracts don't work out when talking about Harper and Machado. The only examples they bring up are people like Pujols and Cano who were already into their 30's by the time they signed their contracts. Harper and Machado will be 36 when a 10 year contract would end for them, which is an age that is still commonly productive for sluggers. No AL team has a valid reason to pass, since they could always at least shift their role to DH.

If the players strike, I'll be on their side.

6
EdgesofsanityLies, damned lies, and statistics.•

Yep. Pujols still put up a OPS+ of 113 in his age 36 season. Cano last year was 135 in his age 35 season.

4

100% this

2
Kyle1130•

I'm fine if teams keep control. Just need to increase the pay.

3
treblat•

Look at Tommy Pham and Jose Martinez. They have no chance at a big contract because they came up so late.

7
SaltyBarkerWears #5 to Games•

That’s why Tommy went off to sports illustrated last year.

7
crackalac•

If you come up at 27, you aren't hitting free agency until at least 33

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5†
ahoh15Don't Boo Pujols•

There was a report that 62% of American Billionaires are self made

https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/269593

So most billionaires are the smarter millionaires who were able to grow their wealth through smart investments and acquisitions.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
TommyPhamsGlasses•

In contrast, how many MLB players are in the league because they have God given talent? I'm not saying that they don't work hard, but I could spend 12 hours a day playing baseball and never make it to the minors. I'm sure theres a lot of players that make it because of hard work, but still plenty because it's in their DNA.

6
Useful_Paperclip•

The owners pay the players, build/maintain the stadiums, and pay all the staff. Without the owners organizing all of this players wouldnt be playing and you wouldn't be enjoying the product. The owners bring "joy" more than the players.

-5†

Lol most sport arenas and stadiums are funded by tax payers in the city it's built in

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

-12†
SveinsonALL HAIL THE LIZARD KING•

Enlighten us please

7
Halfbked19•

Nah keep thinking capital is magically acquired, like most kids on here lol ...

-20
RockmanllChicks Dig DeJong Ball•

The problem is, as of now, no ones fighting for the minor league players in this strike. I'd love to see the Players Union use this to fight for them but their prime concern is players under arbitration/team control.

5
cloud9ineteen•

It's not like the MLB players or PA give two shits about the minor Leaguers. If they really cared about minor Leaguers pay and team control, they would actually be in a better position now.

5
Mr_PhiloumenosPhuck the Cubs•

MLBPA care about no one but their current members.

If they cared about labor, then guys like Waino would have stood up against the CBA that stripped international stars like Ohtani of millions of dollars.

Instead, the MLBPA agreed to a rule change that made it so Ohtani could only get $2 million, instead of 20 to 30 times that amount.

To hell with all of them.

3
ilandstlfan•

The MLBPA has historically shown zero interest in minor leaguers, and they have been more than willing to sell the early years of a player’s career to serve expected big contracts for veterans.

4
dtrain1234•

Free dotem

39
meatball_the_wise•

You've been suspended, suspended a period of two days time..

11
Kyle1130•

I think the suspension joke has run it's course.....

1†
SaulGibson•

As long as that Lwellen’s Pub money keeps coming in.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
HRC509•

Is it likely the players manage to get the 6 (or is it 7) year team control down to 4 years?

28
unidentifiedfish55•

Yes, I think that's the direction this is headed. Not until the next CBA in 2022 though

14
SveinsonALL HAIL THE LIZARD KING•

I'm betting they also do away with keeping ready players down in the minors for extra years of team control (such as what happened with Vlad Guerrero Jr., Kris Bryant, etc).

8
HRC509•

Bryant might have taken the Cubs' offer last year if they brought him up earlier. Now he's basically, "nope F.U. I'm going to free agency." Of course, being a free agent is backfiring on players nowadays.

8
Kyle1130•

I doubt he would have taken their offer. Boras likes to go to market. It could be a big mistake on Bryant's part if they offered over 200 million. That is such a big risk to pass up.

8
crackalac•

It's 6 but it's often manipulated into 7.

3
NominallyReal•
26
CaptainJingles•

Don’t forget not paying MiLB players anything like a liveable wage.

38
dafunkmonster•

How many people pay to watch minor league baseball games?

2†
800oz_gorilla•

Quite honestly, while I agree with you, I think the major league teams should be better subsidizing this cost. (To be fair, I don't know if they do this already.) But the minors are your training grounds, your rehab facilities, your backup staff. To pay them so little based on ticket sales of that stadium seems unfair.

27
dafunkmonster•

But the minors are your training grounds, your rehab facilities, your backup staff.

But CaptainJingles was talking about minor league players not making a "liveable wage".

Fact is, nobody is forcing athletes at gunpoint to join the minor leagues. Players are taking those deals because they make sense to them - they feel the compensation (which is more than just salary) is worth it. If they didn't, then minor league teams wouldn't be able to recruit anybody.

If MiLB is pressured into raising their "minimum salary" for players, they'll have to do something to raise revenue or decrease costs. They'll have to increase ticket prices or reduce the number of games played. Increased ticket prices will reduce attendance. Reducing the number of games played will negatively impact player development. Reduced attendance won't be a problem for teams that already have strong fanbases, but it will murder the clubs that are already hurting for attendance.

2
Covane•

guaranteed that farms who feed their guys good food and free them from income stress will churn out better players and it'll cost nothing to the bottom line

1 million per year specifically to improve QOL for each minor league team above a certain level (like high A to AAA) only needs to generate 1 additional strong player every 5 years to profit. If it's generating them every 2 years it's a no-brainer not to mention jesus what a waste of talent

5
OtterInAustinStay rainbow, pony boy•

i dunno overall, but theres usually a decent crowd at round rock express games

2
TheStuffleJose McLargehuge•

I'm there just about every Friday home game, it's usually crowded.

Springfield Cardinals used to be busy every game I went as well.

3
dafunkmonster•

And what would attendance look like if they doubled ticket prices?

0
Fastball360•

MiLB games have like the highest collective attendance in sports.

2
dafunkmonster•

highest collective attendance in sports

That sounds like an impressive stat until you consider just how many minor league teams there are and just how little they charge for admission to games.

There are 240 minor league baseball teams in the minor league system, and only 160 of them are revenue-generating. The average adult ticket price for a minor league game is around $9. The average attendance per game is around 4,000. That means the average minor league baseball game draws on the order of $36,000 in ticket revenue per game. That's not a lot. The lease has to be paid; the power bill has to be paid; the grounds have to be maintained; staff and security have to be paid.

There just isn't a lot of money in minor league baseball, which was my point. Minor league players don't make much money because people aren't willing to pay high ticket prices to attend minor league games. If you raised ticket prices to cover higher player salaries, attendance would drop off.

At $10/ticket or less, I'm interested in seeing a minor league game. At $20/ticket, I'm much less interested. At $30/ticket, I'm never going to a minor league game - I can get decent seats at a major league game for that price.

1
Fuzzyphilosopher•

If they packaged it right I'd be a big follower.

I've really enjoyed the Nashville Sounds games I've been to and the players are eager and having fun.

In Japan the national High School Baseball Championship is fucking fantastic!

Baseball was my true love as a kid but I'm not willing to fork over the now ridiculous amount of money to go see the Cards when I'm in St Louis & I put games on the tv when I'm doing other stuff but won't sit through them unless it's a really interesting playoff game to me.

Give me an easy way to follow the minor league teams with good player profiles, shorter games & goofy stuff for the kids in the stands & I'll throw some hotdogs on the grill, follow my local team & buy shit.

MLB is stuck in the past & trying to milk an old cow.

If they'd just open their eyes and stop being foggy old dicks selling corporate boxes & going for one big revenue source through cable tv they could actually make more money & grow through the minors and just letting baseball be fun again!

Hell I'm now getting into soccer to find that spirit of fun that I had as a kid. - That's a sad state of affairs for a boy who got autographs & pics with people like Lou Brock, Johnny Bench, Yogi Berra, Reggie Jackson & got to hang out on the field with players during Spring training. yeah I was lucky & it was only for a brief while but how the hell has MLB been able to turn that boy into someone who is ambivalent about modern baseball? I remember Hank Aaron on that magical night & the Reds Sox World series etc

But get with the new age MLB

1
TheWizard01Go crazy, folks!•

It's kind of a tradeoff, isn't it? Team control of younger players in exchange for 100% guaranteed contracts when you hit FA? It's not like the NFL where it's the worst of both worlds.

5
Pashto96•

That was the tradeoff. Except now they aren't paying for the later years either. You used to get paid for what you did and what you can do. Now it's just what you can do. It makes sense but now you gotta change the team control aspect of it too

11
NominallyReal•

That was the idea, but now with sabermetrics and ageing curves the owners have hard evidence that is far more economical and efficient to exploit the younger players than to overpay ageing veterans. Nobody is getting the pay they think they deserve now.

6
TheWizard01Go crazy, folks!•

Fair enough.

1
blowmefuckface•

It's kind of a monopoly where they own you for 6 years after being drafted by an organization you had no part in choosing. Free enterprise please.

1
dafunkmonster•

Why would a team spend time and money on player development if they can't make a return with a few years of control?

1
fungoid_sorceror•

That six years of team control has been in place since the 70s.

3
NominallyReal•

Doesn't mean the players should be happy with it. If anything, that's more reason to ask for better terms. I wouldn't be happy with getting the same compensation and benefits as someone who was in my industry in the 70's. MLB has grown exponentially since then, it's not like the money isn't there.

2
fungoid_sorceror•

It wasn't really a problem until every single team decided all at once at the exact same time that they simply weren't going to sign free agents anymore. The deal was always that they played for less money in exchange for the FA payday. This is just the owners' latest attempt to reinstate the reserve clause and hoover up all the money.

Because let's face it, no matter how low player salaries fall, ticket and concession prices are never going down.

6
treblat•

They also got burned by guys like Pujols. Really they have been getting burned for years. Who’s that knuckle head from the Mets that has a lifetime contract? Anyway it’s all about the analytics now. They know exactly how much they are going to give for each point of war and it’s apparently not negotiable.

2
flagamuffin•

they gotta rearrange it so players can get paid for their good seasons rather than their (likely to be) bad ones, otherwise the system will never be stable.

19
Covane•

Arb early and often

Automatic arb on league percentile performance over consecutive seasons

Significant increase to league minimum

Nuke all rules that let teams keep players in the minors to extend control

Minor league players aren't protected by the agreement nor honestly should they be, but eventually teams will realize a spare 5 million in their farms to improve QOL will pay heavy dividends. It's nuts that's even a question, I'm sure there are major league dietitians making more than it would cost to feed a team quality meals for a year.

oh and ban scott boras from baseball

11
Cards2WS•

I’m all for increased payouts for younger players, but I’m not at all for less team control. Sometimes it takes players 2-3 years to get acclimated to the big leagues before they start to hit their stride and really produce. If all of a sudden teams only have 4 years of control over their young players, then competitive windows for smaller market teams are gonna close completely within 1-2 years rather than a solid 4 or so (if things go right). I feel like the value of building from within is gonna plummet

17
JetSpyda•

Then how would you suggest increased payouts. Because as of now, the only way for them to get money is to hit free agency.

If owners wanted to change how arbitration worked, then maybe that’s a different story. But in all likelihood, team control is going to need to be reduced.

3
Kyle1130•

That's not gonna happen. The big market teams would feast in that situation. Other clubs won't approve it.

2
JetSpyda•

Are you talking about giving up control of the players or changing arbitration?

2
EdgesofsanityLies, damned lies, and statistics.•

I took it to mean giving up control. Functionally the controlled years give smaller market teams a way to keep their players away from the large media friendly markets. Without that in place over the long term you’ll see a drive of players to larger cities for the marketing dollars they can command. Eventually the smaller city teams will then be forced to move to larger markets themselves.

Say hello to your Brooklyn Reds and Los Angeles Brewers of Riverside!

3
Luke5119•

If a strike does happen, it does not bode well for public interest in MLB. After the strike in '94, the boom in the steroid era and the homerun chase of '98 got public viewership and attendance totals to the highest levels in history. Even if an agreement is reached, I see public interest in baseball outside die hards tanking.

11
Kyle1130•

What minor leaguers are paid is a much bigger issue than what is going on in the MLB. The MLB players will fight for more millions but they won't give 2 shits about the minor Leaguers making below minimum wage.

9
FrankapaloozaFuck the Cubs•

Look at the positives, cubs can't win a world series if there's a strike.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

16
rtmcb89•

The replies to that tweet make me want to stick my head in an oven. It's 2019, and we are STILL taking the side of the billionaires? Do those people seriously think the owners will use that extra revenue on the fans?

6
Onephily•

People have a problem feeling sorry about people who are living better than most the population.

5
VinnieMatch69•

It's hard for most people to sympathize with a guy like Bryce Harper turning down $300 million guaranteed for 10 years.

NFL players have more reason to strike IMO. Their $$ isn't guaranteed outside of signing bonuses.

4
Kyle1130•

I'm so tired of people thinking being a billionaire automatically makes you a bad person. That's the new dogma on social media. "You're taking the side of a billionaire" ..... Like that makes you dumb or something. Their goal is to make money and also win. You also want to run as efficiently as you possibly can. You can't just pay everybody what they want. Every single person in their job always thinks they deserve more money. What teams are doing right now is smart. it is stupid to overpay a veteran who is getting worse for 5-7 guaranteed years. Why would you ever do that? It has never worked out.

3†
Altimaz•

I agree. The Billionaire vs Millionaires thing is played out. To the common person, both of these groups make an obscene amount of money. The truth is that both sides are right in some aspects, and are wrong on other aspects. Both sides are trying to make as much as they can make, so I do not blame either.

My issue is that if there is an agreement, both sides better uphold it. If the players strike before the end of the CBA, you guarantee that I will take the owner’s side. If the owners lockout the players before the agreement is up, I will be on the player’s side. If the season is put on hold while both sides negotiate, so be it.

9
Robby_Fabbri•

Great way to think about it.

2
Detective_Dietrich•

That probably does make you dumb. The goals and interests of a billionaire will almost always be contrary to yours.

-4
Kyle1130•

Wow, what low level thinking. So Google's inventors haven't helped the lives of everyone on the planet? Amazon hasn't saved people money and made shopping more convenient? Microsoft? How about all the people billionaires employ? The owners of respectable sports team do everything they can (within reason) to win. Obviously there are some cheap asses like the Rays and A's. Just because they don't give a free agent 300 million dollars doesn't make them bad.

2
Detective_Dietrich•

Someone's gotta be loyal to the corporate masters, of course.

-2
Detective_Dietrich•

There's a real resentment towards pro athletes. People don't like it when people get rich playing games. So instead they take the side of the billionaire robber baron plutocrats.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Useful_Paperclip•

Imagine being such an insufferable cunt you would walk away from playing a game you're making millions playing. Fuck these guys thinking they are owed money. In the grand scheme of things, they provide no more value to society than our firemen or police officers who get pennies compared to them to put their lives on the line.

MLB will not recover from a strike in this day and age. Its behind the NFL and NBA with soccer coming after it. Thssenplayers will strike demanding more money and the one who havent been lucky enough to get paid big yet will find themselves flipping burgers the rest of their lives

6
BetterThanAFoonBird is the word•

It certainly seems that way on the surface doesn't it? When you do a little more than Twitter depth research what you will find is that the baseball compensation system is totally upside down in favor of owners.

The way the system is headed makes it extremely hard for a player to get compensated near what market value for them should be.

Their best years of baseball are locked up under team control and artificial salary caps. That worked for a while because players could go to a free agent market eventually and get a good pay day.... Aka market value. Now once hitting free agency players sit unsigned. They sit there till the last minute and then take lower and lower contracts not at market value......or shorter contracts because they're older. That's actually probably ok in most cases because an Albert Pujols signing at phenomenal rates is stupid. Teams want younger cheaper talent so more stock is put into scouting and drafting.

From a players perspective they never get what free agency should bring them. As a young player you are salary limited and as a free agent there aren't many teams that spendy when it comes to developed MLB talent.

This absolutely put focus on righting the unfair contract structures when players are younger.

I personally think something like the NFL hs could be helpful. Get rid of 100% contract guarantees and ease up the caps on young players by providing things like performance bonuses etc

Kris Bryant, Mike Trout, Stanton, Harper, and Machado are poster children for an unbalanced system. They were worth soooooo much more when they were making league minimum.

0†
Robby_Fabbri•

But the players agreed to all of that. They should fulfill their end of that agreement and renegotiate terms when it ends. Going on strike mid agreement robs the product from the fans.

5
BetterThanAFoonBird is the word•

It erodes the brand and hurts media outlets and a other more.

They damage themselves more than the fans. That's why everyone is better off trying to head off a strike.

5
Robby_Fabbri•

The players are the group causing a potential strike, so all of those parties should be on the owner side. Bottom line is that the players agreed to this and should wait until the end of this CBA to renegotiate.

3
Useful_Paperclip•

Oh no! The people who buy and maintain the stadiums, pay the electric bill, pay the support staff, run day today ops, and shoulder all the downside of a failed business are favored in compensation? Why the fuck would you want it any other way? Speaking of Twitter, stop getting your economic advice from Alexandria Cortez's twitter feed. How economically illiterate do you hVe to be to think a society can function when the person shouldering all risk and financial responsibilities doesnt have compensation tilted in his/her favor?

4
BetterThanAFoonBird is the word•

My posts have nothing to do with politicians or politics. Of course the owners should make money and they should certainly be taking home the lionshare of the take.

However the compensation system for the players has been eroding. In fact it has been systematically been broken down. Players have a lot of reason to be angry with the league and their union.

The league and owners would love for everyone to believe it's a bunch of Millionaire whiners being paid to play a game unjustly asking for more money.....when in reality it's players pushing for owners to stop preventing players from getting a Payday they would command in a more open manner.

Owners aren't above colluding at the players expense. They've already had to settle in the past because of it.

1
Useful_Paperclip•

Your, and the players who would strike, life priorities are jacked up. They are playing a game. I dont give a fuck if they get paid zero. It's a game. Play for the fun of it and be happy you get paid at all. Trying to make a game about getting a payday demonstrated how far peoples values and character have strayed. Play the game for whatever anyone wants to pay you or start contributing to society in a meaningful manner

-2
Halfbked19•

That will be the final nail in baseballs coffin

5
OtterInAustinStay rainbow, pony boy•

"dying metro area" 2: electric boogaloo

4
Kyle1130•

All these players are crazy. I think it's legitimate to negotiate so they can get paid earlier in their careers. 30 year old players crying that they can't get a 7 year deal is not. Teams have been burned by them too many times. It's smart for them not to over pay for veterans whose best years are behind them. The players should try getting paid earlier. You can't use Bryce and Manny for an example because we do not know what they have really been offered. I am sure each of them has been offered over 200 million. For them to act like the system isn't working for them is just fucking nuts.

4
Ytriox•

I love the Cards, but I'm drifting away from the game more and more with each passing year.

I went through this bullshit once and won't do it again.

4
Gospel_of_Fredbird•

Sort of what happened to me and the NHL. I never missed Blues games and even watched out of market games. I knew every player and what team they were on, who they were traded for, etc. Then the strike happened in the 2000's and I haven't watched a complete game outside of the playoffs sense. I've tried but just can't get the feel back.

2
Ytriox•

There are rumblings that they too might have another work stoppage.

2
IndianBird1983•

Just what baseball needs, another work stoppage.

3
wet_beefy_fartz•

Yup. This has been building for years.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
homefry91834More Cards choose Spanish...•

Just read the title and I completely thought that Adam was pitching so well that he was going to strike everyone out. I was hyped for that level of confidence

3
joshhoppe•

You guys are forgetting that minor leaguers aren't part of the MLBPA. The player's union doesn't fight for the minor leaguers and have for years actively agreed to terms that limited minor leaguers to benefit "the union members". The MLBPA made their bed and now they are getting to lie in it.

The fact that Harper and Machado aren't signed is hardly the owner's fault....I'm going to wager both players have fine deals on the table and the agents/players/MLBPA is using this to stoke the fires of discontentment to galvanize the union for 2022.

If they go into the next CBA negotiations with terms that are reasonable there's no reason to strike.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1