r/Fantasy•
JHunz

The cliche fantasy phrase challenge

This evening, I was reading Rogue Arcanist from the sale that got posted here the other day. Around 2/3rds of the way through, the phrase "I'm going to finish this" jumped out at me as possibly one of the most repeated phrases in the urban fantasy genre. Out of curiosity, I searched my Kindle for it and got back 23 books in which it was contained. About 10 were urban fantasy, 10 others were assorted other fantasy and sci-fi, and 3 were other fiction and nonfiction.

My challenge to you is to find a phrase of five or more unique (see below) words that will return more than 23 results in my library. Post one and I'll let you know how you did.

Posted Feb 16, 2019, 1:36 AM UTC · edited

7065
Esmerelda-WeatherwaxStabby Winner, Reading Champion 2016•

"Wet my blade with your blood"

"burned the village to the ground"

"the mud sucked at his boots"

"Lies and treachery!"

"I will cut out your lying tongue"

"the ringing of swords"

"That was a bad idea"

"We need another plan"

"locked away in the tower"

54
JHunzOP•

Wet my blade with your blood

Only 1. I'm surprised, I would have expected more as well

burned the village to the ground

24! You beat me without breaking the search feature like the other two.

the mud sucked at his boots

10

Lies and treachery!

This is only three words, but all 9 results were either exact matches or the phrase reversed, so I'll give it to you

I will cut out your lying tongue

2

The ringing of swords

The search apparently cut out both "the" and "of" and just returned every sentence that had both swords and either ring or ringing in it. , for a total of 178.

That was a bad idea

Another search with a bunch of non-exact results for 394

We need another plan

48, and a good percentage of them looked like exact matches. This might be the winner so far.

locked away in the tower

16

25
Esmerelda-WeatherwaxStabby Winner, Reading Champion 2016•

looks like characters should just go with plan B from the start. Plan A doesn't seem to work out

29
JHunzOP•

If Plan A always worked, we'd lose an awful lot of plot points in every genre of literature

10
Reverent•

Rule of thumb is that if the plan is explained, it will fail without fail.

If the plan is obscured, it will be either a success or a partial success.

7
covah901•

Plan B is to make sure that plan A works.

2
notpetelambert•

"Every time they make a Robin Hood movie, they burn our village down!"

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

41
Dodrio•

This phrase is in almost every fantasy book in existence.

7
Mochuela•

If you take a away "his" then it must be in every one

2
owlberine•

Makes whatshisname in Abercrombie's First Law series such a lovable individual. Severard! "Severard smiled with his eyes." I think it is.

3
JHunzOP•

7 for that exact phrase, but I think you're right that I'd find an awful lot if I could look for every single variation.

6
RAYMONDSTELMOWriter Raymond St. Elmo•

"Relax. I have a plan."
"Kill them. Kill them all."
"I will bathe in your blood."
"The Dark Lord has returned."
"You must look within yourself."
"The wallaby! It's almost to the bagpipes!"

Wish I had a million bucks for every time I've heard that last one.

32
leftoverbrineReading Champion 2017, Worldbuilders•

The darned wallaby is such a treacle in the ol' clockworks.

10
RAYMONDSTELMOWriter Raymond St. Elmo•

Treacle?
It was the best butter.

3
leftoverbrineReading Champion 2017, Worldbuilders•

Butter? I hardly knew her!

7
JHunzOP•

Relax. I have a plan.

13

Kill them. Kill them all.

This search returned so many results initially that it crashed my search, at which point I realized it's actually impossible to do an exact-match search on it, only a search which returns all of the words specified in close succession. So I guess I have to add on that they need to be 5 unique words. 655 results without that specification.

I will bathe in your blood.

1

The dark lord has returned.

2

You must look within yourself

1

The wallaby! It's almost to the bagpipes!

It's very odd how I couldn't find any of these. Perhaps I'm not reading the right fantasy books on my Kindle. Is it in Malazan? I only have those in dead tree form.

10
Kudysseus1•

Don’t forget “Love is the greatest power of all” or similar drivel

7
RAYMONDSTELMOWriter Raymond St. Elmo•

"The old argument," he said softly. "But nothing I have seen in the world has supported your pronouncements that love is more powerful than my kind of magic, Dumbledore."
"Perhaps you have been looking in the wrong places," suggested Dumbledore."

-- Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince

8
JHunzOP•

"Love is the greatest power" is showing 22 :)

3
Kudysseus1•

Damn! So close to 23!

1
NeoBahamutX•

smoothed her skirts

20
hyperman500•

*braid tugging intensifies*

17
cjdudley•

Nynaeve's skull falls off

3
Nicholas_EamesStabby Winner, AMA Author Nicholas Eames•

So well played.

2
JHunzOP•

95, and that's without any Wheel of Time books

6
NeoBahamutX•

That would add that many more per book

4
SagiroWriter Dorian Hart•

Off the top of my head:

​

"I can't believe this is happening."

"You won't get away with this."

"If only that were true"

"You haven't seen the last of me."

​

14
JHunzOP•

I can't believe this is happening.

3

You won't get away with this

13, not bad

If only that were true

This is another one that broke the search and returned 500 results instead of good matches.

You haven't seen the last of me

1 result

7
green_meklar•
  • 'a man in a dark hood'
  • 'a new age is upon us'
  • 'as the gates closed behind'
  • 'at the crack of dawn'
  • 'cannot be defeated by a'
  • 'from the corner of his eye'
  • 'he looked into the fire'
  • 'he moved like a cat'
  • 'he will one day be'
  • 'it is better to die'
  • 'let that be a warning'
  • 'must not learn the truth'
  • 'since the beginning of time'
  • 'tell me where it is'
  • 'the folds of his robe'
  • 'there is only one way'
  • 'to the great city of'
  • 'was given to me by'
  • 'you are the chosen one'
  • 'you look like your father'

I didn't copy+paste these from anywhere, they're all off the top of my head.

13
UltimateInferno•

Guess how many times someone rolls their eyes in a Sanderson book

10
NeuralRust•

'Kelsier snorted.'

If I had to read that phrase one more time...well, I'd probably roll my eyes.

11
JimmyTMalice•

Eyebrow-raising is the real bugbear in Mistborn. Everyone does it, quizzically or otherwise.

5
EddieTheCubeHead•

Ribbon of light...

3
NeoBahamutX•

Or skirt smoothing in Wheel of Time

1
GALACTIC-SAUSAGE•

Is it more often than people grunt in Malazan?

1
zenitor•

Shallan blushed

1

tugs braid

9
nerdgravity•

Not all phrases, but similarly, from The Toast (http://the-toast.net/2015/01/23/tell-high-fantasy-novel/):

The Elders would like a word with you.

The Ritual is about to begin.

Something that has not happened in a thousand years is happening.

You are going to the City. There is only one City. It is only said with a capital C. No one needs to bother saying the name of the City. It is the City.

Certain members of the Council are displeased with your family’s recent actions.

A bard is providing occasional comic relief; no one hired or invited him and his method of earning a living is unclear.

The High Priest is not to be trusted.

Someone is eating an apple mockingly.

There is one body of water. It is called the Sea. The Great Sea, if you are feeling fancy.

You live in a region with no major exports, no centralized government, no banking system, a mysteriously maintained network of roads, and little to no job training for anyone who is not a farmer.

You have red hair. You wear it in a braid. Your father was a simple man, and you don’t remember much about him – he died when you were so young – but you remember his strong hands, as he fished or carpentered or whatever it was that he used to do with them.

You’re going to have to hurry, or you’re going to miss the Fair – and you never miss the Fair.

There is trouble at the Citadel.

Your full name has at least one apostrophe in it.

It is the first page, and you are already late for something. Your mother affectionately chides you as you gulp down a few spoonfuls of porridge; she will be dead by page forty-two.

There are two religions in your entire universe. One is a thinly veiled version of Islam. It is only practiced by villains. The other is “being a Viking.” You are a Viking.

There are new ways in the land that threaten the Old Way. Your grandmother secretly practices the Old Way, as do all of the people of the hills.

The real trouble began the day you arrived at court. Every last nobleman hides a viper in his smile. How you long for the purity of life in your village, which is currently on fire or something.

5
MasaIII•

« The High Priest is not to be trusted »

Recently read a book playing with that. Main tension during the whole book comes from the probable and speculated schemes of the high priest.

Climax : turns out the high priest was to be trusted

5
songwind•

Until the climax I was going to ask if you were reading The Three Musketeers. :)

1
MasaIII•

Nope :) And since it’s quite the spoiler, I can’t say the book’s name for safety.

2
emailanimalReading Champion 2017•

Ok, let's try something.

"Her eyes shone like the sun"

"I swear on the blood of my kin"

"Speak now or forever hold your peace"

"He sat on his haunches"

"We were betrayed by our enemies"

"gagged on the putrid smell"

"Uhm, boss? Shut up, Loiosh!"

"The Elder Gods have returned"

"Sausages! Buy some sausages!"

4
notpetelambert•

And that's cutting me own throat.

4
emailanimalReading Champion 2017•

Yes. How could have forgotten?

2
colblitz•

This is not in the spirit of this post, but "This is a work of fiction. All of the characters, organizations, and events portrayed in this novel are either products of the author's imagination or are used fictitiously" :P

This is more in the spirit, but I imagine searching for phrases about mundane things like "He opened the door and stepped in the room" or something would actually have more hits.

Anyways, maybe

  • "he/she/I rose to his/her/their/my feet"
  • "chills crept up his/her/their/my back"
  • "____ jumped from the saddle"
  • "threw his hand in front of him"
  • "sword held with both hands"
  • "__ motioned for __ to stay behind ___"
  • "___ following in ____'s tracks"
  • "You're hiding something from me"
  • "He regained control of himself"
  • "We'll have to risk it"
  • "he said, keeping his voice low"
3

I could just put my book down and read this thread and I'd get all the main points

3
EdMcDonald_BlackwingAMA Author Ed McDonald•

Heard the clashing of steel

3
Dark_Squall001•

Honestly, thank you so much for this whole post, and to everyone that listed clichés from very popular novels. I'm trying to write, and I'm very bad for self-editing when I feel a phrase or word is being used too often. To see that even the big names do it so often makes me feel a lot better.

3
Ender_Guardian•

<clears voice> You meet in a tavern...

2

From the top of my head:

There's not much time left

​

A plan? I don't make plans

​

You fools, it's already too late

​

You are nothing compared to me

2
emergingeminence•

death came swirling down

2
zebba_oz•

Was it spilling seed at the time?

2
twistedmic•

Here's another one- "stepped into the crowded tavern"

2
AmissArcher•

“Like a puppet whose strings have been cut”

It’s a pretty big Overlord LN meme, and I’m also convinced that it’s a hidden requirement for all Wuxiaworld novels.

Outside of anime/that branch of things, it also popped up in Arcane Ascension once

2
Haldum96•

Raises eyebrows...

2