Ar edit on ranked maps

Discussion

Hello everyone,

This has been on my mind for a long time and I have asked a lot of pro players, but people have been kind of split on this matter. But what I was curious about was what would be wrong with allowing players to edit the ARs in maps?

I love to play maps they have pretty decent AR, such as 9.5 and higher. I just over all enjoy the more and there is some maps, there more playable with higher AR, to me especially the older Maps. I know that everyone has their preferences, but I don't see how this can be damaging to this game at his core.

I think it would be cool to see many different types of scores with various ARs. That would mean that you would see maps with very low AR, and maps with very high AR instead of being forced to play a specific AR that the mapper wanted to put for specific mods.

For example n e v o,sotarks, Armin, and various other map of specifically put Maps in a certain they are so that they can be played with certain mods such as DT, HR, and even some maps this specific for ar-11 I think that it should be up to the player what AR they are allowed to play for ranked Maps.

Yes some maps will be changed at his core intention of what the the mapper intended, for very Niche Maps, that plays on low AR or high AR but this should ultimately be decided by the player which AR he should be allowed to play with. And before anyone says that oh you can always just added the map but sometimes people would like to play maps that are ranked and playing whatever a r that they feel comfortable in or an AR that they feel like they are trying to improve in but do not want to specifically pay the AR that the map was intended for.

At the end of the day I just think that it will bring some more creativity to Maps and leaderboards as opposed to just playing Maps as they are mandated and it would force certain mappers to not map Things specifically for mods like DT or mods like hard rock.

So tell me what most you guys think and to the people who are mostly responsible for the updates to the core mechanics of the game what is your personal opinion and what is your game design opinion and how it would affect a negative or positive way the outcome of the game or the future. Thanks for reading.

Posted Feb 16, 2019, 3:31 AM UTC

030
Mesitahater•

Strongly disagree. For first, many people will just play same AR on all maps. And secondary a lot of scores and map will not be that hard/unreadable/special/etc anymore. Imagine "Made of fire" ar10 version, much easier, isn't?

14
deathbyspdOP•

How can you predict what everyone will do ?not everyone likes the same ar, you have many people who play maps for dt,hd,hr, or whatever they think they could achieve. Also, if that's your argument then people already do that, with maps like guess who is back, everyone mostly plays dt on that map, because the ar is set up for dt ?

Also, what's wrong with people fcing maps? Some maps are only hard because the vast majority of people dont train to play that ar like on made of fire, but the ar alone is not what makes that map, hard but still AR is reading skill that is subjective to the individual and should be treated that way.

I shouldnt be forced to play ar9 on a map that I like just because the mapper intended it to be played with dt, when I can't play ar10.33. Before someone even says it," well you shouldn't be playing that map anyway" that's not the point. The point is, mappers build maps to be played and enjoyed, and having an ar edit, on rank maps doesn't change the game at its core at all. It just allows for more versatility amongst players.

For example, if a player wants to only play ar9.3 maps, and he enjoys it, what's wrong with that. Eventually, he will want to move up, and by allowing him to play with what ever ar he wants, he can fc maps with whatever ar he desired. Rather that's ar3 or ar10, it should be up to the player.

-6
Mesitahater•

For first, any mapper created map with HIS vision of HIS map. If you or someone do not enjoy HIS map - you free to create your own custom version or even new map. Some maps was created to be a challenge. Let's allow to edit maps as well, why no? I do not enjoy dumb ending on that map, allow me to delete it or remap.

And here we coming to my previous point. You are already want just edit AR instead of learn something new. So why do you think that majority will not do the same?

6
deathbyspdOP•

True about the vision part but editing the ar doesnt change anything about the map itself. It literally only changes how its read, and depending on the individual and what ar they could read determines who fc it. There's plenty of maps for example in ar7 that most players cant read besides a small select few but the same exact map in ar9.8 players can read it and FC of modern times

I'm not asking to change maps to your own benefit, I'm simply asking to open the door so many different skillsets can be shown on the same map, just by allowing ar edits. It's not like people can't edit the map to ar3,or ar9.8. It only changes how the player reads the map, and if they can read the ar, then what's the problem? Ar edit isnt detrimental to the core game, not have I seen someone present how it can be taken in a negative way.

-1
Mesitahater•

AR is a part of map. Just get it. Mappers not just randomly choose it. They use it for density, overflow, visualization and etc. Some maps was created for DT/HR farm but in same time some maps do not want to see DT/HR scores in leaderboards so they are using AR for it. And reading it's a skill. Same as speed and aim. So if someone can't FC something just because of high or low AR then he simple not deserved FC there and need practice or search for other map.

5
fuckingfatidiot•

I wouldn't mind a 0x multiplier mod like Relax that lets you change the AR as you please, but not for setting ranked scores.

7
Jam1906w•
2
Williamgo125retard•

imagine AR change was a Nerf mod like NF and SO. You can change the AR to anything but it gives .6x score and like .7x pp multiplier. Would be pretty dope imo

6
UnHappySticktimberwolf•

so basically like different key mods in mania when you're playing beatmaps converted from std? iirc that gives 0.9x

1
hfamCagliostro400IQ Player•

Admittedly I only read the first paragraph because the idea behind this is always the same and has been brought up a lot. (Should I change my mind after reading further on I'll change this).

Edit: Read it now, this has been brought up too many times.

(Everything here is subjective):

While at first glance it could definitely make sense, being able to edit the AR of ranked maps would promote an even less diverse skillset than most people already have. I am a prime example of a bad player. I mostly farm and recently switched to playing mostly HR, because I started having troubles after getting accostumed to / or playing DT in general. If I could change any ranked map's AR to 10, I wouldn't have to worry about playing HR and stop developing stable reading skills.

TL;DR: Not a good idea, promotes bad reading habits.

3
deathbyspdOP•

Thats anecdotal though, just because you do it that doesn't mean the vast majority of people will also. Just as much as you say people like high ar, theres plenty of people who like low ar also, so it goes both ways. Just because you approached it that way, you could always go back and play those maps with lower ar anyway.

There's plenty of players that has different skillsets, and reading low ar and high ar is completely different.

1
hfamCagliostro400IQ Player•

It doesn't nullify what I said. People have different skillsets but you shouldn't be able to adjust the map to your likings. There is always a reason the mapper provided the difficulty settings. In the end it would boil down to people abusing it mostly for farming.

I've had a discussion about this already, I can see where you are coming from with this idea but it really doesn't make a lot of sense when you consider the bigger picture.

2
deathbyspdOP•

But people already farm regardless lol. People already farm with hr,hd,dt, no mod, dthdhr. Farm maps are just that, and people mention farming like its a negative thing. Theres no one whom has ever reach top 100, or top 10 in any game without some form of farming.

Mappers abuse jump patterns for pp, stream spacing for pp, which is why we are going through updates and changes. There will always be farming, there will always be people find a way to abuse any system but allowing ar edit does way more good than bad.

0
Magnus-Cosmos•

I can't wait for 800pp EZHDDT scores

1
bubblyrainbowshttps://osu.ppy.sh/users/8815179•

reading high or low ar is a skill and by allowing players to edit ar on ranked maps, you'd essentially devalue any skill that players who focus on that aspect would have.

3
deathbyspdOP•

I think, that would be a cool idea, because on mania, you can change the scroll in the maps, and it makes a world of a difference on some maps but it's two completely different games but I want to see what some of the dev's people think about this, and what would be the most logical way to go about implementing something like this or similar.

Hell, I would take a hit on my pp points just to edit the ar, but then again, the higher the ar, with dt it would buff it also, well that's for anything that's 10.33 and higher

2
TehDragonGuyhttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/6177661•

Nah, there shouldn't be a buff for pp for high AR, because it could so easily be abused as a lot of people can read 10.5 or even higher without any issue at all.

0
Magnus-Cosmos•

?? I'm pretty sure he'd talking about the high AR bonus in the current pp system

0
TehDragonGuyhttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/6177661•

with dt it would buff it also, well that's for anything that's 10.33 and higher

I take that as meaning anything 10.3 and above should get a buff to pp amounts which I don't agree with.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Magnus-Cosmos•

High AR already gets a buff so I don't know what you're trying to say

0
deathbyspdOP•

It's already in the system itself, lol. Anything that's above ar10.33 gets buffed, this has been in the game for a least 3yrs

0
TehDragonGuyhttps://osu.ppy.sh/u/6177661•

It's like you didn't read what I said to the other guy who said that.

1