Vigilance (+25% acquisition range of torpedoes) should be more effective on BBs and CVs - Perhaps 50%
Title --- For balance and game play reasons it makes sense because these ship types are far less manoeuvrable , not to mention it encourages BBs to push caps safer especially at high tier where DDs can carpet large areas of the map with torps (looking at you asashio and shima). Historically it also makes sense because BBs and CVs would have larger and higher observation deck/s with more crew dedicated to surveillance.
Thoughts?
Posted Feb 19, 2019, 10:29 AM UTC
Short answer: No
Long answer: BBs already had far worse maneuverability in the past when Vig provided the same benefits. Then BB maneuverability got buffed and a BB player that is aware of his surroundings will hardly eat a torpedo. So from this point of view no buff needed.
Then there's the 'carpet' torpedo thingy: Torpedo soup is a thing of the past. Newer DD lines traded a larged torpedo volley every two minutes for smaller volleys every minute (and a bit). So while you can get hit more often, you'll get less hit by that massive wall of skill. And if a DD manages to hit you with that low number of torps ... good job on his side I'd say.
On top comes that a flooding rework is inbound, that reduceds the damage all classes take by a flooding.