Vigilance (+25% acquisition range of torpedoes) should be more effective on BBs and CVs - Perhaps 50%

Discussion

Title --- For balance and game play reasons it makes sense because these ship types are far less manoeuvrable , not to mention it encourages BBs to push caps safer especially at high tier where DDs can carpet large areas of the map with torps (looking at you asashio and shima). Historically it also makes sense because BBs and CVs would have larger and higher observation deck/s with more crew dedicated to surveillance.

​

Thoughts?

Posted Feb 19, 2019, 10:29 AM UTC

015
Vectoranalysis•

Short answer: No

Long answer: BBs already had far worse maneuverability in the past when Vig provided the same benefits. Then BB maneuverability got buffed and a BB player that is aware of his surroundings will hardly eat a torpedo. So from this point of view no buff needed.

Then there's the 'carpet' torpedo thingy: Torpedo soup is a thing of the past. Newer DD lines traded a larged torpedo volley every two minutes for smaller volleys every minute (and a bit). So while you can get hit more often, you'll get less hit by that massive wall of skill. And if a DD manages to hit you with that low number of torps ... good job on his side I'd say.

On top comes that a flooding rework is inbound, that reduceds the damage all classes take by a flooding.

27
Lord-YggdrasillImperial Japanese Navy•

Torpedoes are already the least reliable weapon in WoWs. They need no nerfs. If BBs are not able to avoid torps, they deserve to be killed because they got outplayed by the DD. Giving them even more passive no skill tools is not the right way to go.

19
leehwongxing:sub: CYKA, where are my deepcharges?•

You should realize that shima or IJN torp have at least 700m more detection range than any other torpedoes and they have 2-3s more to let you dodge. If you get hit by such torpedoes, you deserve getting it.

And Vigi was designated to work with Sonar or TA upgrade, buff that skill would mean a direct nerf to the IJN DDs that already struggle to stay relevant to the game nowaday.

7
skylordwilliam•

I would say this might potentially be a bit controversial buff, as currently Vigilance also extend the torpedoes spotting ranges of hydroacoustic search, which high tier german BB comes equipped with.

Also, base on my personal experience as someone who rarely runs Vigilance, proper game sense and WASD hacks is often enough to avoid torpedo.

5
Vanzig•

I would say definitely no. Battleships absolutely don't need better-than-vigilance, if you have vigilance torps are largely dodgeable unless you deserve to be hit (bad position, not using teamwork by following toher players, slowing down in obvious spots with a big ship, etc.) and the occasional single hit is made up for by heals/DCP.

As it sounds like the original question doesn't understand what the scale of the numbers is, +50% range on a circle would mean a whole 44% more of the map where torpedoes are visible compared to current vigilance and +125% extra area where torpedoes are seen compared to running non-vigilance. 50% extra torp-vision is such a big number it would be a mandatory skill for every BB ever and WG would have to buff torpedoes massively to compensate otherwise 99% of torps would be dodged unless it's an afk bowtanking potato. If WG were to reduce torp vision ranges by 50% to make it fair again, suddenly crazy-person-vigilance is the same power as it was before, except BBs without it would be totally helpless to torpedoes. In short, the idea has no value whatsoever. The detection ranges are already balanced.

The only real issue with vigilance is that it costs 3 points, it really is more on-par with a 2-point skill. I would move it up a row and move some other skill to 3 with some minor buff (DCP cooldown or all-cooldowns-reduced are two that would fit better at 3rd row if given a bigger number, like 10% to all consumables or 15% to DCP)

That would make an optional choice between gun rotation and vigilance. On something like Tirpitz that has good rotation inherently, now it'd be easy to replace EM with Vigilance if desired. On a ship like yamato that doesnt knife-fight, the extra torp-spotting might be enough to dodge japanese torps fired at 16km away, while the guns don't need to rotate fast if shooting at long range.

4
givemeadamnname69•

No

2
NovuakeLolilanta best shipfu•

BBs have enough tools to counter torps thank you very much.

1
ConohaConcordia•

Probably no.

Vigilance needs some changes but giving even more torpedo resistance to BBs is a bad idea.

Maybe make it extend hydro range/duration?

1
OmegaResNovae•

I would rather WG buff the Target Acquisition System Module to make it more of a choice vs the Concealment System Module.

Increase guaranteed detection range of ships to 4km, guaranteed torpedo detection by +50% instead of +20%, and a new bonus to +2km maximum visibility while under Thunderstor-m and Cyclone conditions.

1
orkel2nagato memes•

The module should increase hit chance stat of AA

1
SmokingPuffinoften has unpopular opinions•

The absolute last thing this game needs right now is DD nerfs. DDs are already an endangered species on live man.

1
TenguBladeNoots internally•

Fuck no. If you have to buff torpedo acquisition, buff the bonus TASM1 gives, not Vigilance.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0†
[deleted]•

[removed]

0†
MicMan42MANLY METAL DEATH FISH OF JUSTICE•

> DDs can carpet large areas of the map with torps (looking at you asashio and shima)

So fucking LOL.

If you have trouble avoiding torps maybe do not camp in one spot all game or change course once every 30secs and you would be immune to all DD torps.

How easy is that?

And for this easy way out you enjoy unparallelled durability and firepower on your BBs while DDs get killed left, right and center for the tieniest mistake or even for no other mistake than wanting to actively play the game if there is a CV.

0
hansjcScharnhorst best bote•

Vigilance can be negated by just looking at your map and knowing roughly where enemies are.

Couple that with constant use of rudder and accelerator and you really don’t need vigilance.

-1