Honda CR-V or Subaru Forester?

I'm looking to buy a small SUV in the next year or so. I've narrowed it down to these two (2015 or newer CR-V, 2019 only Forester). My major requirements are safety, reliability, and quiet. These two were the easiest to drive, most comfortable, etc. But how are they once you own them? Are they actually safe, reliable, and quiet? Especially on the highway - 70mph for an entire day of driving gets very draining because of sound for me - so which one is quieter for that? Thanks!

Posted Feb 27, 2019, 2:32 PM UTC

22
DoubleDinner•

I was in a very similar situation last year when I had it narrowed down to a 2018 CRV and a 2018 (last gen) Forester. I ended up choosing the CRV for several reasons, but could definitely see the benefits of the Forester.

First off, the CRV felt much more "premium" and drove that way: seats were more comfortable, quieter cabin, smoother ride. Next, the CRV was considerably less expensive when comparing similar trims.

Now, I live in a very cold, snowy climate and there are definitely days where I could use the functionality of the Forester. But I wasn't ready to sacrifice 9 months of comfort for 3 months of winter capability every year.

To address your specific questions: my CRV is great to drive on the highway. The driver- assist safety features work well and I've had no complaints. As for reliability, I can't speak much to that just because it's new.

I've heard that the 2019 Forester addresses lots of these issues, so in the end either of these cars will likely be a great choice.

3
NDRob•

Yeah. The two cars are much closer after the Forester update this year. The CR-V still has an edge on paper with power and fuel economy (and maybe reliability), but they're both very comparable. The two are priced within a few hundred dollars of each other. The Foresters sell further below MSRP than the Honda, so even though the Foresters look like they cost more they are pretty damn close.

1