Parents of Reddit: what is your best parental advice?

It's not always an easy thing being a parent, but truly rewarding.

Today, from a mathematical point of view, our second child will be born. However, my wife shows no signs of labour yet...

Last week, I talked to a colleague about how you to raise your children.

During the conversation, I told her that my wife and I always try to give an alternative when we say "No" to our daughter. So we say; "No, you can not throw your potatoes on the ground, but if you do not like them, you can put them here, on the side." In stead of "Don't throw your potatoes on the ground!". This strategy really works wonders.

I guess there are loads of other great parental "Tips & Tricks" around that will help making life easier for both parents and children.

What's your best advice as one parent to another?

Posted Jan 30, 2010, 1:20 PM UTC

35110
WhoreChurch•
  • Five Rules: Ask, Listen, Obey, Respect, Put-Away
  • Three Steps: Remind them of the rule, Remind them of the rule and the consequence, Consequence
  • Do not let your kids sleep in your room--if they need company, sleep in theirs
  • Have a date night every week with your spouse and teach your children they must respect your privacy
38
sandrc2002•

This excellent advice is amplified by your excellenter user name.

12
RagnarLodbrok•

also do not be a nazi all the time

2
WhoreChurch•

In my opinion your children need to know you love them and that you punish them not because you are angry or because you enjoy it, but because you want to teach them how to be a good person as an adult.

In our case my wife and I would typically tell our boys exactly that with any major discipline.

1
tomjen•

Could you expand on what you mean by the five rules?

1
WhoreChurch•

Studies of assertive discipline show that it is difficult for children to grasp more than 3-5 rules. The rules you give you children need to be general enough for wide application without being too numerous. My wife and I developed these 5 one-word rules and found they covered just about every situation we encountered with our two boys (now 21 and 24.)

Here are a few examples of how we used the rules in "real life":

  • "Stop making fun of your brother, we respect one another."
  • "Put that pop back in the refrigerator, you need to ask if you want a pop."
  • "We don't smash our toys, we respect our possessions by taking care of them."
  • "When you are told to wash your hands, you obey, you don't whine or complain."

We created a little hand-sign routine for the 5 rules and would go through the five rules with the boys at dinner each evening. Ask (point to lips), listen (point to ear), obey (palms open in a receiving gesture), respect (a salute) and put-away (hands thrust forward as if one is throwing a ball into a bin.)

This worked well for us. Your mileage may vary.

8
borick•

I find it interesting the OP asks for general help but you cover only discipline. Do you have advice in regards to any other aspects of the child's life?

Some terrible parents have great adult kids because the kids overcome their upbringing.

Projecting...?

3
WhoreChurch•

I find it interesting the OP asks for general help but you cover only discipline. Do you have advice in regards to any other aspects of the child's life?

I have lots of advice in lots of areas. These were the best, short, quips I had with general application.

Projecting...?

Possibly, that's why I wrote it. Looking at adult children from the "outside" doesn't tell you whether their parents were good or bad. Possibly interviewing them may tell you, but even then some adult children are fiercely loyal to bad parents and lie.

So, you got my point exactly: Asking someone how their children turned out doesn't tell you much about whether that person is a good parent or not.

1
pheus•

how did your two boys turn out?

2
WhoreChurch•

Well, the youngest has been off meth for 7 months and we're very proud of him and the oldest is up for parole next month.

Just kidding.

They both seem to be responsible, respectable men. Though I would caution using adult children as a measure of parenting. Some terrible parents have great adult kids because the kids overcome their upbringing.

My oldest is finishing his second BS in mathematics at University of Kentucky on a full academic scholarship and already has a job as a civil engineer following graduation. My youngest goes to Eastern Kentucky University part-time and works for the State Department full-time in some job he's not allowed to talk about.

11
fishboy1•

My one word of advice, they're smarter than you think. Almost always.

32
RandomQ•

Not only are they smarter than you think, they are smarter than you.

12
fishboy1•

And they are always thinking. Always.

17
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
dnlslm9•

for the inheritance.

11
hwks911•

Trying to find the weak spot.

2
Scarker•

"Goo-goo ga-ga shits diaper"

"This guy's a genius."

3
dullac•

It is part of being smarter but they hear and comprehend way more then you think. I have been left speechless by what my two year old will say in respond to things my wife and I are talking about. I had no idea she even knew what we were saying.

3
kmad•

I don't have kids, but I have 2 cacti on my desk at work. The only advice I can offer you from my cactus experience is that you need to water your children every 6 months or they'll start to look like diseased alien penises.

15
letmewipthisout•

I do have kids, and can confirm the same is true for them as well.

5
eatspam88•
  1. Don't circumcise.

  2. Breastfeed.

  3. Cosleep until they are done breastfeeding. More sleep for mother and baby. You can have sex elsewhere in the house.

  4. Patience

  5. Learn a little about child development so you don't have unreasonable expectations for a child given their age.

  6. Be gentle. Encourage and reward gentleness among siblings.

  7. Don't spank, yell in anger, or threaten.

  8. Forgive stupid kid shit like drawing on the walls or spilling milk on the couch. Help them learn to use paper and to clean up the mess. Teaching the proper behavior is the best kind of discipline. If you spill your beer, do you get hit or do you get a towel or mop?

  9. Montessori pre-school.

  10. Recognize that your child's uncooperative behavior most likely due to fatigue, hunger, or boredom. Do you really need to drag them to the store at 7 at night? Do they really need to be shopping for 5 hours at a time?

  11. Children have their own personality. Like with anyone else new in your life, it will take time to get to know them. Figure them out.

  12. You're the adult in the situation. Act like it.

  13. Children imitate. That's why if you act like a douchebag, your kid will be the exact same way.

11
possessed_flea•

Rule 7 should be ammended to: Dont spank your kids. I spank my wife all the time yet the kids seem to be turning out ok.

3
eatspam88•

Fair enough.. lol.

1
[deleted]•

I've read that the risks of co-sleeping (rolling over and suffocating your baby in your sleep) outweigh the benefits. Do you have any information to the contrary?

2
eatspam88•

http://www.marchofdimes.com/pnhec/298_29656.asp

Don't use excess linen, don't cosleep on couches or waterbeds, don't go to bed drunk or high, take precautions to make sure the baby won't roll out of bed, etc. Just use common sense.

Besides, how often do you roll over and hit your partner? Or roll over and squish a cat or dog?

1
bcos4life•

Why not spank? My parents spanked me and my sister. We are both Law abiding, polite, contributing members of society. I attribute my social success to my parents spanking me. I knew that if I was rude or did something bad, I would be physically punished and I learned quick that it f'ing hurt. If you want to go down this parenting path. Don't just beat there ass and call it good. My parents told me it was wrong the first time, the second time I got a spanking and an explaination of what I did wrong and what the right thing to do was... There was never a 3rd time.

-1
eatspam88•

Because there are much more constructive methods of teaching proper behavior. Demonstrate respect, including to your children. Figure out why your kid is misbehaving and correct the underlying problem - fatigue, hunger, or boredom, usually. Empathize with them. Teach them. Give them rational consequences, like cleaning up after themselves. Don't have unreasonable expectations.

My kids are 5 and 3, and I have never spanked them. They're both in all day preschool and they're consistantly the best behaved, best mannered children. Why? They've learned to control themselves without the threat of being hit. Teachers can't hit, so the other students exhibit a lot less control. I want my kids to behave respectfully because it is the right thing to do, not because they’re under threat if they don’t.

My brothers and I were both spanked, with my youngest brother the most severely. My middle brother and I are successful, but my youngest brother drank himself to death due to anxiety. All of us are and were self-concious to a fault because of my mother's spanking and aggression. Every error was punished with spanking or other nastiness. We could never doing anything right. Yes, my mother probably spanked more than "necessary", but it is so easy to cross the line from minor spanking to abuse when confronted with a more spirited child like my late brother. None of my mother’s discipline was constructive and I am doing all right despite the spanking, not because of it.

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Chwiss•

My father spanked me, my grandfather spanked me. I learned from it and knew when I went out of line. I think that if an education is based on a rewading system, the opposite (punishment, like a little pedagogycal spank, not abuse) can also be of value in certain situations. It's one thing to ignore and not to reward, but sometimes you have to make clear in the same way as you reward, that something was very wrong, by a spank... My 2 cents.

1
obscure123456789•

You sure you weren't simply abused?

Were you innocently playing with your toys in your room as a child when you were ambushed, beaten, and left in a sobbing mess with no explanation?

List an example?

Spanking worked for me. It didn't work much for my sisters very much though, they could never understand or accept why they couldn't have things go their way all the time. So they bitched and screamed a lot. They were also woefully average in the intelligence department.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
obscure123456789•

I have to disagree, spanking works when the kids know they're being little stinkers because they're not afraid of a stern glares + wagging fingers.

On a related note: As a 5 year old, I learned to stop flashing people real quick.

-1
eskimorose•

i agree completely. when i was little, and i would get in trouble, i knew my mom would tell my dad once he got home from work, and i would dread it the entire day. needless to say, i definitely learned my lesson with spankings. and i'm not suicidal or depressed because of it!

-2
kcoombs•

consistency is key. when you have a rule and a consequence for that rule, you need to stick to it. It sounds strange but children view enforcement of rules as an indicator of trust. if you awaringly let them get away with something, they will immediately write you off and probably not listen to you nearly as much.

-also, praise children twice as much as you correct them. and redirect them to good behaviors with choices. like the potato example. if you just say "don't do that" they don't know what desirable behavior you would rather they replace it with.

10
stromm•

Don't dot on and coddle your kids. Too much love and undermine being a good parent. Your job is to make sure your kid learns everything they need to have a long, happy and functional life. It's not to be their best friend or to treat them like they're a puppy who needs your attention every waking moment of yours and their life.

GIVE THEM SPACE!!! Heck, MAKE them independent. Don't take them to bed with you. Don't fret when they whine that they don't want to X. Don't worry about playing music/TV to loud when you put them to bed (They'll get over it very quickly).

Don't shelter them in a bubble. They need to explore and experiment to learn who THEY are. They're not YOU, don't force them to be. That'll just make them hate you.

Don't let them control you and your life. You're the parent and adult. ACT LIKE IT!

Learn them that you will not always be there to protect them and DO NOT MAKE EXCUSES FOR THEM!! God that pisses me off.

Let them fail!! Then help them understand what they need to do to not fail. I'm not saying completely ignore them or don't give them any training, but once you've walked them through how to do something, STEP AWAY and let them try it without interference. If they mess up (and they likely will), ask them what they think went wrong. Don't get pissy, work with them to understand. Let them try again.

Understand, it can take 7-10 times for a child under 18 to permanently learn a simple process.

Monitor their TV, Internet and phone use. They don't NEED a cell phone. We all made it through being a kid without one (my first was when I was 19 and I'm 40). Besides, there's reputable studies (even accepted by cell phone manufacturers) that show cell phone use by children under 17 can negatively impact the development of the brain.

And for crying out loud, learn them that it's OK for someone to disagree with them and not like them, but it's not OK for your kid to be an ass about either.

Learn them that they don't deserve everything their fellow man doesn't. They aren't better than anyone else, though they may be smarter or faster or stronger, etc. Everyone has a "nack" and someone is always better at something you aren't.

Talk with your kids. Explain things they don't understand. Especially, don't freak out when they start looking at porn, cause they will and there's nothing you can do about it. Make sure they know that sex is OK, when 1. it's legal and 2. protection is used. Also help them learn about the lifelong repercussions of having sex, not just physical but also mental (say when they get used and dumped).

Oh, and I meant to write "learn" vs. "teach". There's a difference. You can teach all you want, but someone doesn't necessarily LEARN from it. Just as you can take a horse to water, but you can't make him drink :)

MOST Importantly: BE CONSISTENT! What you do for one child, do for the other. Older, younger, male, female, step-child. A four year old doesn't get rights/privileges of a 6 year old and definitely not those of a 10+ year old. If you have multiple kids, the younger ones should be treated as the older at that age.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
stromm•

I guess I'm from the days where caps was mostly used to stress importance and wasn't seen as yelling. I always thought it funny when that "impression" first started spreading across. Started on AOL though, not event the early net, CompuServe or BBS's.

1
kiyo213•

Learn them that they

Learn them that you

Teach them you dipshit, teach them! Obvioulsy your parents didn't take the time to teach you how to speak. You don't "learn them to" you TEACH them to. I downvoted you for that.

-1
bkbeezy•

Wow, way to be an asshole.

2
kiyo213•

Seriously? How many people honestly can speak perfectly good english and not know when to say teach and when to say learn? I don't care if I am being an asshole, the guy needs to learn how to talk.

-2
bkbeezy•

It was a typo/error. I can speak perfectly good English and it still happens to me. You can correct him without insulting him or his parents.

Also, he's not speaking, he's writing.

1
vodkat•

Oh, and I meant to write "learn" vs. "teach". There's a difference. You can teach all you want, but someone doesn't necessarily LEARN from it

2
kiyo213•

Then say make sure they learn, not "learn them to"

3
vodkat•

If you want to get all grammarnazi "learn them to" isn't good english either the best way of phrasing it would be "make sure they learn that".

1
stromm•

Guess you missed why I intentionally used "Learn".

2
redditg0nad•

Best parental advice? Enjoy ever last day because it flippin flies. Seriously.

5
stromm•

So true. My oldest is now 20 and youngest almost 16. I'm 40. In 4-5 years, both kids will be on their own. The wife is starting to freak out and I'm looking forward to it, but it's bitter sweet.

But I know my kids will be self-sufficient when they leave the nest.

3
bcos4life•

Jesus H man. I'm the baby and it's been 30 years since my Mom and Dad have had an empty house. I moved out in July and she still blubbers like a baby when I leave after a visit. She calls me 3 times a day to make sure I'm okay and comes to my house all the time. I live an hour away too. I know she does it because she loves me and misses me so I just smile and deal with it. Sometimes I go down just to take her to lunch and my Dad says that makes her week.

2
bucknuggets•

First off, rather than ask for advise from people you don't know - find some families with older kids that really amaze you. Ask them. But in the meanwhile, a few ideas:

#1. Parenting is way harder than conceiving. #2. When you're frustrated or angry remember that the little things you do or don't do in their lives will often be remembered for many decades. #3. Understand that your children learn from what they watch. So, if you don't want them to grow up thinking that they must have toy X to be happy, or learn how girls & boys relate - you should avoid television. I've found that it's far easier to completely eliminate tv/cable than reduce its time. #4. Praise publicly, criticize in private - typical respect stuff #5. Don't say no - give them choices. But choices that carry consequences. #6. Give them small and incrementally growing responsibilities - including dangerous stuff. When your kids mildly burn a hand on the stove cooking with you at 7, or nick their finger on a small pocket knife at the same age they learn a lot. #7. Teach delayed gratification. Show a little discipline and reward them for putting off instant gratification. It'll help them tremendously when its time to focus on homework, learning difficult skills, etc. #8. They take a ton of time - build relationships so that you can enjoy each other's company. Otherwise you'll be avoiding them when you shouldn't be.

5
vafnord•

Children are mirrors. They will treat others as they are treated. They learn manners when treated with courtesy. They learn to respect the bodies and property of others when the integrity of their own bodies and belongings are respected.

Many have said "You're the adult. Act like it." I'd like to unpack this statement. Adults, allegedly, have had years of practice at patience and self-control that children do not have. This may even be the main difference between children and adults. Why, then, in a situation where the needs of an adult and a child come into conflict, is it so often the child who is forced to give up his will? The adult is the one who is supposed to have those finely-honed skills of delaying gratification. A child learns how to exercise self-control by witnessing adults exercise it.

Think really hard about anything like a "strategy" or a "technique" or a "trick" to "use on" your children. Manipulation is not respectful, most people can sense it.

Your children DO NOT OWE YOU ANYTHING. They did not ask to be here. You're the one who caused them to brought into the world in a state of profound helplessness. Helping them to survive and gain the skills for self-sufficiency is the LEAST you could do. Expecting gratitude for raising your own children is pompous at best. The good news is, you will often receive gratitude anyway if you can manage to comport yourself with even a modicum of graciousness, since every child has Stockholm Syndrome.

No matter how gentle you try to be, little kids are still constantly reminded by the universe how weak and powerless they are compared to adults. This makes them very sensitive to intimidation. Whenever you raise the volume or lower the pitch of your voice, you are intimidating. When you loom over a child with your great height and strength, you are intimidating. Be aware of it. Exploit it at your peril.

If you yell at your kid about every goddamned thing, they will start to ignore you, including when you're yelling about some real imminent danger.

4
moonflower•

on the subject of discipline, i would say set clear boundaries and think carefully about any threats of punishment, because you must be willing to keep your word, to teach your children that no means no, it does not mean ''scream for long enough and I will say yes'' ... children really benefit from a well structured set of rules, and parents who have the confidence to enforce the rules, it helps them to feel more secure, knowing that the parent is in charge and taking responsibility ... sometimes the most loving thing you can do is allow your child to hate you for a moment while you stick to your ''no'', instead of giving in to their demands in the false belief that it will make them happy and make them love you

and remember to praise them when they are doing good :)

3
barracuda105•

No empty threats.

3
Minim4c•

My dad used to say: "If you don't clean up your toys I will clean them up for you!"

I never knew what he meant until I had to sift through the garbage can to grab all my Legos and action figures.

3
[deleted]•

My mom did this too, she said that she was going to clean the living room (or any room) and that anything I wanted to keep I had to clean up first, everything else went in the trash.

1
Rubin0•

Don't take my word for it. Ask Lipschitz

3
Coffin•

My wife doesn't know what Reddit is, I emailed her this thread since I thought she would interested in the responses.

Here is her reply.

"It would probably be something that I would like to read, but there are so many spelling and grammar mistakes that I cannot finish it.

love you

seafood lasagna for sup! "

*edit: Corrected my spelling mistake ...

3
rockymtnweigh•

When there were disputes in the house, my grandmother would ask what happened. She would say "tell me what happened and start with I". That eliminates the blame game and forces the child to think about what they did. Works wonders.

3
[deleted]•

My open-source child-raising advice :

Beat early, beat often.

2
[deleted]•

That is exactly right.

Also, keep them out of public places. They don't belong there. Especially get them the hell out of the cinema.

3
deeperest•

If your child doesn't flinch every time you enter the room, you're doing something wrong. Thanks Maddox. :)

2
BitRex•

Always err on the side of strictness and structure.

Stay a mile away from being their friend; that's their friends' role; yours is to be the grownup.

Give plenty of affection and make it clear you love them no matter what.

2
stromm•

Unless they torture, rape or murder someone.

There should always be a line kids know they can't cross. Not everything should be forgiven.

1
BitRex•

I'd still love my child if she did one of those things, although I would of course expect her to face the legal consequences. I love her no matter what (and believe me she's tested that premise this year).

1
mexipimpin•

Love them, just love them... If you love them, most of the other things will fall into place.

2
TheySeeMeTrolling99•

When you notice that your son or daughter has red eyes from blazing the green delight, then offer to blaze with them at home so they don't get involved with the wrong kind of people. Teach them responsible toking in moderation.

Wow son, you got 5 A's and 3 B's, this calls for a round of bong tokes!

2
deeperest•

There is no such thing as "quality time".

Spend as much time as humanly possible with them at all stages of development. Your 2 year old isn't going to hold in all the amazing things they are learning to do until the weekend, and your teenage son won't wait until "game night" to think a thought that will stun and amaze you.

2
Nougat•

Dirt is not scary.

Everything will get broken.

Kids will invariably play with toys in ways they're not "supposed" to; let them.

2