AITA for being mad at my girlfriend for giving me a free pass?
The character limit is killing me :D
My girlfriend (19f) and I (21m) have been in a really good relationship for over 1 and a half years. Currently I am on an exchange semester, I will stay here from the beginning of february to the end of June. We will not see each other apart from video calls during this time.
One month in, we were texting. In the transcript I’ll label her as GF and myself as I:
GF: By the way, if you are feeling anything like me, you can make out with any girl, as long as you come back to me
I: What? Are you completely out of your mind?
GF: I am fully on withdrawal from you. No, I’m serious, it does not matter to me, as long as you come back to me in the end
I: Do you need to confess something to me?...
GF: No
I: Then stop with this bullshit
GF: Trust me, I’m being faithful, I even have my own Cockblocker (good friend)
I: I hope so
GF: I am happy with you, I do not need anyone else but I miss being close to you, the only person I’ve kissed since you are gone was (female friend of us)
I: What kind of logic is that then?
GF: My logic, I want you to feel good and that your missing nothing
And then you aren’t all alone anymore
I: If you think I’ll give you a free pass just because you offered me one, you are in the wrong, If I wanted to make out with anyone else, I’d be single and would not be mentioning you in any conversation I have
GF: just so you know, I talk about you all the time too and even if you gave me a free pass like that, I would not do it because I’m feeling really happy in our relationship but I don’t want to force you to do anything that makes you feel bad when I’m not around
I: Do you really think, just because we are separated for 4 or 5 months that I jump on everything that moves? Do you really think our relationship means that little to me?
GF: no, but everyone has their needs, atleast I have our friends here, I’m not that alone here, I know that our relationship means a lot to you, that’s why I tell you you can do whatever you want, because I know that you will come back to me
I: Yes I’m “alone” here, without my friends, family and you, but does that make you think I do that kinda shit?
GF: I just wanted to give you the chance, I know that you love me and I love you, I never wanted to say anything that hurts you, I know you wouldn’t do something like that, but if it would help you get through those months, I just wanted to say that its OK for me
I: So wrong in place
GF: OK, I take it back, I’m sorry I just had it in my head and just wanted to say it, I’m really sorry and I love you
I: Can’t take something like that back, said is said and now I’m in doubt
GF: I don’t doubt you
I: But I doubt you now
GF: Are you serious? I do not do stuff like that
I: Yes, I am fucking serious
That was yesterday and since then we haven’t talked to each other. I kind of lost some trust in her now and I’ve been thinking a lot about what the future will bring
So AITA for being mad at her?
Update:
We have been talking for an hour after she finished working, about the conversation and about us in general. She explained herself further and pretty much stated, that she only wants me to be happy even if it means that she isn’t. Yes it sounds pretty sad, but she justified it with me never seeing those people again in my life and if that is what it takes me for being happy, I’m free to do what I would like. Again, I declined that, saying that all I want is her and to go even further, her to be happy and feeling good. Furthermore, I can now understand why she wanted to give me a free pass, or as someone called it the golden ticket. She would rather stay in control of the situation, as she has never had a boyfriend that stayed faithful. I am more than sure that I want to stay together with her and hopefully improve our relationship so that she never thinks again she has to offer something like that for me to be truly happy.
I also asked her again if she cheated or thought about cheating, she denied that and I have no rational reason to think that she was lying. She also understands why I reacted the way I did, and we discussed that too.
Due to this post, I got some insights and now I definitely see a few aspects I need to work on and a few others we need to work on together. But apart from that, I am really relieved and I still love her and she loves me.
Oh, and she is not a Cuckqueen, we had a pretty good laugh at that :D
Tl;dr happy ending, but not the “happy ending” :D
Posted Mar 1, 2019, 1:53 PM UTC · edited
NAH - going against the hive mind with this one...
It’s also completely possible that she isn’t cheating and that she’s just insanely immature.
This is some trope played out all over television and movies and I can completely understand some massively immature and insecure 19yr old thinking that this is the way things are supposed to work. It could also be her stupid ass friends in her ear talking about how “he’s definitely cheating on you” and she wants to let you know she’d rather keep you than lose the relationship to an indiscretion (again, in a very immature way).
Maybe she is cheating on you but I feel like you deserve an alternate perspective on this since everyone always jumps straight to infidelity and nefarious intentions on this sub.
Edit: I’m glad you guys talked it out and that it went well OP! Keep up that communication!
Yeah also, some people just are this way. I've never cheated. And especially in my late teens / early 20s, I wouldn't have cared if a BF had a summer fling while we couldn't be together. Now I realize that that was naive (that the heart is tricky and that flings can turn into a love that one can't turn off), but at the time, I had a certain confidence, like "if he doesn't love me best then we might as well break up, and if he loves me best then what do I care if he has a night of fun while we're a continent apart?" I could almost see myself saying something like this if I'd been watching a movie in which the main character was some dude in your situation or some other reminder got me thinking to tell you.
That said, your GF's comments about feeling the same way would make me worry, and the fact that she kissed a girl already IS cheating, soooo.
The kissing a girl thing is only cheating if he didn’t know and wasn’t okay with it. The way he glossed over it makes me feel as if it’s something mutually agreed upon previously.
Not mutually agreed, but that's just the way the other girl acts ^^ I don't mind actually, because i like the girl as a friend alot and I know it's nothing serious
As I've written in the comment above, kissing in that case meant more like a quick kiss, not a full on makeout ^^
I was wondering about that kiss because it sounded like she was one who kissed her thanks for clarifying that. It might be distrustful but I would be tempted to talk to some other friends you know around her because a cheater is generally unlikely to admit it when just asked.
Yeah if they discussed it, fair enough. And if he just doesn't care, more power to him.
Well, I actually had more information in the text for passage, but the character limit made me delete it ^^
The part about the "feeling the same way" is actually bugging me really, that will be one of my main points when i talk to her the next time...
The kissing with the girl, got to put in some more context, the girl is a good friend of both us, she always had it with drunkenly kissing other people, especially friends of her
She did it with other friends of us when I was around, that's just the way she acts
Although its the first time, as far as i know, that she did it with my girlfriend ^^
And kissing in that case meant more like a quick kiss, not a full on makeout with tongue etc
It’s definitely a sentiment that needs clarification, I agree.
It could simply be that she was just trying to show empathy and that she understands the longing and loneliness of separation.
With you both being so young and new to all this I would suggest caution when approaching this situation. If you care for her then tread lightly and avoid accusing language when you talk.
It may turn out she’s been unfaithful and if that’s the case I’m truly sorry because that’s a uniquely painful life lesson. But I wouldn’t approach the conversation from that premise. I’d ease into it and just be honest and direct with how you’re feeling and what you’re thinking.
Good luck, OP. I hope it all turns out well for you.
Yea, that's something I must avoid, especially when I'm angered, i tend to say the wrong things
I think I'll just try and gather more information on why she suggested such a thing and then dig deeper into the subject
Thank you for your advice :)
I feel as though.. When reading her 'vibe' she wants the free pass. And is only trying to give you one to get consent from you to have a fling? 5 months is a long time away from your partner at 19 and thoughts are all over the place.
So you're okay with her kissing someone else but not okay with her being okay with you kissing someone else?
Well, it wouldn't be quite the same situation if I kiss a girl she doesn't know, for my own pleasure and stuff
Yea, I've been thinking about her being immature making her insecure and thus, suggesting such a thing
Although I have never tried pushing her over that line as I've always only wanted her
Either immature or insecure. I could see either causing her to think that OP needs to satisfy his needs elsewhere while they are apart.
Yeah, I get the feeling she's trying to be the "cool girlfriend." Girl, you don't have to do that!
This
Agreed. I am going with insecure as well. Sounds like she is scared of the distance and that she will lose OP/OP will cheat on her and wants to get ahead of. Or be the "cool" gf that allows her bf a pass. Definetly immature. But as she is 19 i'll give her a pass on this
I agree with your NAH judgement, but it's not immature to not feel threatened by your partner sleeping with other people. Look around and you'll find plenty of people in happy long-term non-monogamous relationships. I felt much the way OP's girlfriend claims to feel as a teenager - that if I felt secure in a relationship, it didn't bother me if my partner was with other people. 10 years and several open and polyamorous relationships later, I still feel the same way and am blissfully happy with my partner of ~5 years. I write this here in the hope that some people reading come to understand that this is a genuine way some people feel that can lead to healthy and long-lived relationships. Many non-monogamous relationships start, as my first did, with conversations much like this one (with a more receptive partner of course).
To be clear, I don't think there's anything wrong with monogamy; it's just not the sole valid way to do relationships.
Alternatively, she's depressed and thinks that's what she's worth. Especially at 19, I think this is more common than people think, with sad or depressed people thinking that they need to do anything they can to keep the shred of happiness they have (their SO) and that if their SO wants to do shitty things to them it's okay because they're a shitty person and they deserve it.
It's not a fun take, but I see it a lot and it's not uncommon at all.
I don't think it's abnormal to think "she's cheating on me", and that's definitely what I'd be doing initially, but it's also important to recognize your own insecurity. Nothing about what she's said suggests she's cheating any more than it suggests anything else. It's just easy to look at a weird situation and say "well, she -might- be cheating", and then convince yourself of that.
[deleted]
Going against the hive mind? Wait that’s illegal
Just asking, why is that immature if they are appart she wants her SO to have fun? Is it the same for everyone doing that?
She sounds like a freaaak. Red flags brother red flags.