r/WRX•
phrontier1

2015+ Catch Can Recomendations

Who here is running a catch can? Was originally looking at the IAG AOS for my 2017 but seems not really worth the cost and difficult install now that I've done my research. Looking at cheaper options like the ADD W1 WRX catch can kit.

Anyone ever buy a universal catch and do the rest themselves? And is it worth getting both CCV and PCV cans or just PCV? Seems like the PCV one catches some stuff while the CCV catches minimal on the two can setups.

Posted Mar 1, 2019, 3:20 PM UTC

28
VVOD_52016 WRX Cobb 1+ WR Blue•

I have a Crawford V3. Very happy with it.

2
pankomushrooms•

I’d suggest the Perrin AOS over a catch can, but definitely understand the cost effectiveness of the catch can. The install is also easier. Got a few guys I know who run the Crawford, no issues.

1
refuse_2•

Its not that bad, and trust me, the AOS is worth it. As I’m sure you’ll hear several times on this post. If the question is Subaru, the answer is AOS. Stock pcv systems are straight garbage.

Also, you’ll have to empty the catch can every once and a while

0
phrontier1OP•

I'd rather do a catch can personally. From what I've read, you'll only get a few tablespoons of fluid every few thousand miles with the FA20DIT. I'd rather just empty that every oil change than have to worry about the return line sludging up and have extra coolant lines running around.

Plus with the AOS, all that moisture is dumped right back into your clean oil, I'd rather just isolate it and dispose of it.

2
refuse_2•

Not sure why you’re worried about the coolant line failing? One feed one return. And no the AOS, by design, separates and cleans the oil before putting it back in, including condensation. Subaru’s are notorious for oil consumption, so the peace of mind that I can mitigate that is worth it for me. You do your build though, good luck man, just my two cents.

Granted, I only really know anything about EJ’s

1
phrontier1OP•

Appreciate your input, just like the catch can idea better due to its simplicity and its way cheaper. Seems like the FA doesn't have anywhere near the oil consumption of the EJ. I'm looking into doing it just to keep the intake valves clean due to the direct injection.

2
DemandCommonSense2002 WRX GT3076 (sold) + 2015 WRX + 2014 E63S AMG•

That moisture is condensation due to temperature differences between the oil and the ambient engine bat temps. Any AOS that runs a coolant line shouldn't have as much sludge build up.

Honestly the IAG and Radium (which is more than the IAG) AOS do stand out in the crowd as far as how well they reduce blow-by in the intake tract.

As far as catch cans: Is there a filtering media in that "ADD W1" catch can kit? If not it's not going to do much.

1
phrontier1OP•

It states it has an internal baffle 3 stage chamber system. I haven't heard much about this brand though so I'm a little iffy on it.

I was originally planning on the IAG but it seemed overkill to me. I just like the simplicity of a catch can style system with not needing to run more hoses than necessary. From what I've read, the FA should not have much blow by at all compared to EJ cars, so what's the point of sending that tiny bit of oil back to the pan?

I basically want the filtration abilities of the IAG or similar but not have to run a return line or coolant lines. Are there other systems out there that operate like this?

1