What ship did you think you would love, but don't? What ship you thought you wouldn't, but do?

Discussion

I've been going over my collection recently and thinking why I enjoyed each particular ship (or why I didn't), and was wondering what was everyone else's personal thoughts. My own two are:

Surprisingly do not like:

Khabarovsk - This one was a no-braner for me. I liked the previous DDs, I liked going fast and burning the world around me. But this just didn't click. The short range, crap torps, crap maneuverability, massive pens from all BBs. People have gotten pretty good at shooting full speed Khaba, not at all like a few years ago. I'm of the mind that it could use a buff, but I haven't heard anybody complain, so maybe it's just me.

Surprisingly do like:

Huang He - It's an awful ship on paper. No armor, no HP, no firepower, and requires quite a few captain points to be usable; one of the least scary ships in the game. And yet... I can't help but feel comfortable just plinking away at enemies from smoke or ambushing DDs. Do I wish it was more powerful? Absolutely. But it's weakness is kind of what makes people ignore it in the first place, a kind of armor :)

Posted Mar 2, 2019, 12:10 AM UTC

3287
Zockerpflaume•

I love DM. Donskoi with a ~70% winrate, after the grind to Moskva I didnt like Moskva at all, even tho people told me i would love her and that she is so much better than Donskoi.

21
unclekisser•

Woah you posted this while I was typing up my entry on the Moskva. Guess I’m not the only one underwhelmed.

12
Doc__Bo•

me too, I was disappointed aswell:/

1
Ponald-Dump•

I was disappointed in Moskva when I first got it too, but after about 100 or so games in it it sort of clicked. I love it now.

2
Randnote•

The RU cruiser line is a strange one, it actually decreases in DPM after IFHE Chapayev, unlike the other cruiser lines that steadily increase in effective DPM (or at least stay the same).

4
PM_ME_A__THUMBS_UP•

I'm going through the exact same thing right now! My beloved Donskoi carried me to rank 2. I only have half a dozen games in the moskva so far but I don't really like it at all. The AP is more punchy and the ship is tougher but that's about it. You lose those great 8k torps and the ability to dodge.

2
chotchss•

I love the DM with the module, it makes the ship so much more fun to play (for me). I love being at a full stop, spamming rounds into an enemy, and then accelerating to top speed the moment I see them fire at me!

2
learnyouahaskell•

DM. Donskoi

Why do people consistently write it like that? "Dmitrii" or Demetrius, is what it means. It is abbreviated simply to show within the space allotted.

1
Zockerpflaume•

Because i am not russian and dont know how to write "Dmitrii". So if you complain i think you write "Friedrich der Große" in full name and with the "ß" aswell?

8
learnyouahaskell•

No one's picking on you in particular.

I don't write FD der Grosse, nor MK/MH Kutuzov. Everything that was needed to understand it was written in my post. You did not respond appropriately if you understood.

The point is the consistent re-capitalization of the two initial letters. It is repeatedly done that way, and even spoken that way, "D-M" just as others refer to "Des Moines".

Maybe it's a "lag stretch" with your use of the shift key (maybe not), which is why I simply made a topical observation, "Why do people...?"

0
unclekisser•

I don’t really enjoy the Moskva. It just feels too passive and too dependent on your teammates. I post up bow in and just click ships. I soak up a lot of damage and deal a bunch back, but unless my team pushes too, I can’t really force the issue. It’s hard to articulate but it feels too fragile to push into danger like a battleship, but not agile enough to flex around the map like other cruisers. It’s not a bad ship by any means. It’s just...boring. I’ll probably never spend steel on the Stalingrad because of my Moskva experience.

I got the Asashio in a Black Friday crate and was kind of bummed out because I wanted an Atago or a Massachusetts. The Asashio might be the most infamous ship still for sale and I wasn’t looking forward to its 1-note torps or annoyed teammates. I took my ten point captain and quickly slapped together a torpedo acceleration, reload, concealment build. And then had a 170k damage game including taking out a Grosser Kurfurst with a monster strike+flooding. It’s guns are also surprising and if you catch other DDs off guard and they aren’t paying attention, you can gun them down before they know what happened. All-in-all it’s an extremely strong and good ship. I think people just can’t handle that it’s neither overpowered nor a useless waste of DD spot in the age when everyone has a hot take. It’s just a fun ship with a cool gimmick.

It is funny how people were so afraid it would cause BBs to never push again, instead of being a funny, niche destroyer.

19
ShrekthePhilosopherAll I got was this lousy flair•

I enjoyed the Moskva when I was playing it as a long-range support ship with range mod. But I knew I had to be closer to cap to make use of my radar so I changed my play style and she immediately became unfun. One of the best feeling for me was the ability to reliably hit BBs at 22 km and set fire. Tanking is situationally fun but I don't like doing that at the beginning of a match. Too big and clumsy to be an Islands camper. Guns are unusable from behind Islands.

Zao on the other hand is perfect for me. Great concealment, manuverability, reliable guns. No radar so no one is going to flame me for not be on the front line.

2
watsik227Belfast EU dmg record•

what I thought I would like but dont ? 100% the Sims.

I wanted a US DD captain trainer and I was deciding between the Sims and a perma camo for Gearing and after watching some videos on the Sims and remembering all the times I got radared or melted by harugumos in the Gearing I went for the Sims. bad decision. where to start ? the horrible concelament ? dogshit useless torps that either dont have range or speed ? I literally burst out laughing when I hit my first torp after like 5 games and it did 5k dmg on a New Mexicos bow. Only good thing I can say about it is that the guns are ok, I mean they are after all Benson guns. I got the Maass at the same time as Sims and when playing them it feels like a tier difference. Maass has better torps, hydro, only slightly worse concelament, amazing german AP, more HP and I could go on, you get the point.

What I like: Richelieu

After finishing Lyon with its 16 guns I wasnt sure how the richy would work with half as many guns but damn it did. I fell in love after the first battle. the speed is amazing and with speedboost 0-10kt acceleration is instantenious, almost like a DD. I remember all 5 of my battles with it like it was a week ago (because it was lel) 1st - 133k, 2nd - 145k, 3rd - 155k, 4th - 178k with points denying me 200k, 5th broke the chain with "only" 125k. So after that I didnt want to ruin my 145k avg dmg in it so yesterday I fXPd the Alsace, you might be asking why ? 2 days ago I got a SC with 15k coal that put me over being able to afford the Jean Bart. so yes, I got it and holy moly what a ship. played 2 battles so far with one of them 200k on the new Shards map. I cant even decribe how much I love it.

9
ALEX-HAVOCUnited States Navy•

Sims recently got a torp buff that makes her significantly better

5
Henry575•

Totally agree about the Sims I have it as a captain trainer and I thought I would love it but I have found myself just grinding the US DD line now and I feel like I use my Farragut and like it more...

2
t_baseGlorious Hipper•

I've almost exclusively played Sims in the Dunkirk scenario which it is a beast in, but I found it only so so in randoms. However, I haven't really tried it out since the buff it got.

1
NotSoSubtle1247"Nope." -WG•

Sims thrives on her small size, speed, and rudder shift. She's the fastest USN DD in the game, has a tighter turning circle than even the Clemson, and can pull turns like something out of Initial D. She's actually just as good at kiting and dodging gunfire as the Khab at Tier 10 if you can learn to read incoming shell arcs. When probing a cap with a DD that might have lower concealment, approach at about a 40% angle so you can turn away in a hurry and use your speed and rudder to get clear. Get the other DD to shoot at you, and let your team punish it while you avoid damage.

Don't underestimate her long range torpedoes. They can't be used like normal, high speed torps against a specific target very well, but they are fun in the early parts of the match when you can spam them into groups of enemy on the other side of a cap. They are great for area denial and spamming into enemy smoke.

This is going to sound like heresy, but right now she might be the most viable torpedo boat at Tier 7. Her long torpedoes outrange all radar at tier, and her torpedo reload is disgusting. By the numbers, individual Sims torpedoes do less damage, but she reloads them around 50% faster than most of her competitors, which means many more chances to get hits. Without skills, when her torpedoes reload the last set will still be running in the water. Combine this with the fact that you can play her as a torpedo boat with best in tier AA, means you have the full liberty to be a torpedo boat even in double CV games. And if another DD gunboat comes looking for you? You're still in a Sims, and can knife fight with the best of them.

The problem is you have to unlearn some core DDs skills to make some of this work. Sims torpedoes are less about leading a target than they are getting in the targets head and predicting his movements in advance. You can gunboat other DDs, but you have to play around your spotting disadvantage, and then winning the gunfight is less about winning a gunfight than it is winning a dance-battle. And you better learn how to dance in the Sims, because you're going to be spotted much more than you'd like even when torpedo boating.

But I adore my Sims. I play it with no flags as my no stress boat. When I'm tired of being screwed by matchmaker and potato teams, Sims is a boat I can have fun in no matter what. Because even when my team is throwing the match, I'm laughing all the way to the bank at the 2-3 ships that have been shooting at me on and off all match and have less than 2k damage on me to show for it.

1
SlpeeUnited States Navy•

Iowa. Without a doubt Iowa. I wanted to like it, I really did, and I saw lots of great videos from CCs and such while I was grinding up to it and then I finally got to it and.......yeah.

I really don't see how its anything than a sidegrade at best relative to the North Carolina. Honestly, in most cases, I'd rather have the NoCal - even in a TX game. Comparatively, you lose rudder shift time, a lot of turning circle, and concealment in exchange for what? A little more hp and a little better AAA. Oh and of course the legendary Iowa speed, which I'll admit is nice, but its nearly impossible to use. The Iowa hemorrhages speed in any kind of turn, which means that the only way you're getting up to max speed is by sailing in a straight line for a while. And I'm sure you all know what happens to BBs that sail in straight lines. And that even assumes that there's a scenario where you want that speed - high tier campy meta means sitting still and angled is more often that not the name of the game.

Ultimately, I preferred the nimbleness and stealthiness of the NoCal so much more and the Iowa didn't bring enough to the table to justify its higher rank. I loved the Monty though, getting more guns and armor and way more hp is at least a worthy trade off for the maneuverability issues. I think if the Iowa got to keep its speed in a turn a little better than I'd have a much better time with it.

8
BFsKaraya1Battleship Main, Reasonably good. •

Iowa gets the T9 module for increased accuracy. Thats why its better, You can get some really tight dispersion with her.

9
Ralfundmalf•

Yet somehow it has much worse dispersion than the NC, at least for me. The NC almost always hits home when I need it to and the Iowa almost always craps on me when it gets a chance. Maybe I am cursed or something. Btw the same applies to the Missouri for me, terrible disperdion over and over.

2
chotchss•

Preach, brother! I feel like I can almost always get a better performance out of Alabama or Mass- and have a lot more fun doing so. Iowa just feels like a big, vulnerable target, and the guns don't make up for the loss of mobility- shots that give me citadels with the NoCal give me OPs and bounces in the Iowa... Just frustrating.

2
NaCl-5844•

Same here. I had almost no fun with her compared to the North Carolina and Montana.

2

The first line I opened was IJN BBs, and I'm almost done grinding through the amagi. I always heard it was a very strong BB at T8 but I just can't make it work, the grind took so god damn long compared to my other boats. It's honestly a but upsetting to me that the first line I wanted to go through might not ever get finished, since the izumo isn't exactly a solid improvement over the Amagi, and if I'm having this bad a grind on her, I don't know if I can handle grinding through Izumo. Also the Bismarck but I understand the meta hasn't been kind to German BBs.

What I suprisingly like: a bunch of dds. I tried dds when there were only USN and IJN dds and I didn't like either line. Now with the Russian and RN dds I'm having way more fun than I thought I could with a squishy sneaky floating peashooter.

7
nickierv•

As long as you have a 14p captain and are top tier, Bismarck is a blast. You have to have at least some support and a team not 100% potato. It takes some getting used to.

I don't have Yamato but I have Musashi. Even knowing the Izumo is a total dumpsterfire, I am working on getting Yamato.

3

Agreed, Bismark is a fun ship.

3
BFsKaraya1Battleship Main, Reasonably good. •

Izumo was buffed a LOT recently. Shes actually pretty good. She also rewards good angling like Yamato does, so that you can get used to the "angle or get deleted" part of her.

I also could not get to click with Amagi. I always felt like i was an XP pinata for everyone to farm and the guns were kinda inaccurate. The only IJN BB i just didnt enjoy at all. Now when im in my Yamato i REALLY enjoy being mean to Amagis. They can angle against it. But it doesnt do anything.

2
t_baseGlorious Hipper•

Same here in regards to IJN BBs. I do alright when I play them to meta but I really don't enjoy their meta.

1
Purity_the_KittyNext Gen Sky Cancer•

Didn't like:

​

Hindenburg - I thought I'd love it after I enjoyed the hell out of Yorck and Hipper and finally clicked with Roon. Just can't seem to get this ship to work. It feels sluggish and extremely vulnerable in open water. "How are you better than Zao?"

​

Surprisingly do like:

​

Midway! I thought I'd get bored of the new CVs, but I'm really enjoying the gameplay. It needs some serious ironing out and some major banhammers thrown around at the "community balance team", but we're getting there. I just wish it had torps.

4
Brn4meplz•

I absolutely loved my time in Gneisenau. I still live the Bismarck, but I miss the torpedoes(no Tripitz here)

It’s a pretty quick ship, and the torpedoes are a nice surprise. The guns are underwhelming but that adds to it for me.

Dislike: Kitakami. Because they removed it from the game. I’ll never forgive them

Special mention: Any of the German DD’s with forward arc torpedo launchers. Honestly, that crazy death charge into a low tier battleship fleet has got to be some of the most fun you can have. Nail biting, shell dodging craziness.

They could create a fictional High tier destroyer with forward arc Torpedoes and I’d play it. Without question.

4
Henry575•

Yes! Did they take them away at tier Iv?

2
Brn4meplz•

The T IV is the last one that mounts forward launchers.

1
TheSoberCannibal•

Tirpitz. Bought it after I loved the Massachusetts and it just feels worse.

4
IronWolfV•

Ship I did not like?

Nurnberg. Granted before the buffs it got, but I hated it with a burning passion. Just like Konisburg, but now facing tier 8s with a floating citadel.

Loved: Scharnhorst. Love at first sail.

3
xHelios•

I really wanted to like the IJN gunboats, but the Akizuki and Kitakaze were really disappointing after I went up the Russian dd line. They just handle like fucking trucks and it's awful.

I surprisingly have found that I really enjoy the French bbs. I hated playing bbs for a long time because they don't go 40kts (tashkent is love, tashkent is life), but the Lyon seriously changed that. 16 gun broadside, and I'm enjoying the Richilieu as well. Can't wait to get the Jean Bart.

3
stuff_rulzBattleship Life•

I thought I'd love the Musashi, hearing how OP it is and everything. But I find it really boring and the guns are so inconsistent with me. I probably just suck with aiming with it as everyone else seems to love playing it, but I feel pretty confident that it's often the dispersion on it completely messing with me. I do really well in other ships like Massachusetts and Montana, even with Mass' inaccurate guns, I am still confident enough to cit cruisers and such from a distance. Musashi from a distance though... I just pray I get even 1 pen.

3
ciaocibai•

I’m a DD main (and occasional CA), hardly play BB’s but love the Musashi. Averaging about 130k in it, which as a non-BB player I’m pretty happy with it. The Massachusetts on the other hand just does my head in. I’ve had shots 10km that wouldn’t hit at all, whereas I’ve landed triple cits at 26km in my musashi. We must have traded dispersion or something.

2
TGangstiHSF Graf Spee / AL Hood•

there isn't really a ship which i thought would be great but isn't, although i'm a bit disappointed by the shimakaze.

on the flipside, while still being awful, seattle isn't as terrible as i expected her to be.
but the real winner here is the emile bertin - that thing is hillarious.

3
cain071546shooty boats•

I love my Huanghe, It's my number one boat for t6 operations, I love everything about it.

I hate Perth, one of my worst boats, I can't seem to do consistent damage and I can't hit anything with the stupid spotter plane.

Leander is meh, I have no idea why but it just feels bland and meh.

2
SharpspoonfulClosed Beta Player•

That's so funny to me as they are damn near the same botes with different guns and torps. But the core of their gameplay loop is almost identical.

2
cain071546shooty boats•

I don't get it either.

1
ciaocibai•

I love Perth. It feels so OP to me. I put the smoke screen module on it and just sail around dakka-ing. Just want to get my captain to 14 points for the IFHE...

1
cain071546shooty boats•

Sounds like me in my Huanghe.

Maybe ill get the hang of Perth one of these days.

I really want to like it because i am gonna grab a Haida so i can swap my captain back and forth.

EDIT: a word.

2
unclekisser•

If it feels OP without IFHE just wait until after you unlock it. You’ll do so much more damage.

When I first bought the Belfast and only had a 10 point CE captain I thought, “it’s really good but I don’t really get the hype.” Then I got IFHE and just melted everything. It’s nuts.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
mrbibs350Just here for the show•

I thought I would love the King George V. I loved the Iron Duke and Orion, my first purple ships. The QE I just muddled through. And the KGV I just couldn't make work. I sold it with something like a 25% win rate.

I didn't think I would like the Nurnberg. It didn't seem much better than the Konig (which I enjoyed) but in worse mm. But it was at least as enjoyable as its predecessor, and the two of them were my favorite cruisers until I ground out the Helena.

2
LewdTaihou•

I hate the USS black. With the bare minimum amount of DD around lately it just doesnt have a place.

You can radar and kill the one DD they have. Congrats. There are 5 radar cruiser and 5 bb left. They will never eat your slow ass torps. it just has no impact outside of killing dd. I have a 70+% win rate in stuff like z52 and lightning and I cant make the fucking USS black work.

What ship did surprise me was Gallant. That thing is just straight up OP. I missed it the first time around and regret it.

2
EchoblammoGlorious 792 m/s•

The Black is a monster, take it back.

2
RemyTheDogPizza Navy•

Truth.

1
RemyTheDogPizza Navy•

My experience. If you take the torp reload skill and AR you use the torps by just spamming them constantly in any shipping path. The range let's them surprise and they hit like a MFer. You don't torpedo things that you are aiming at, you spam and get lucky by constantly having torps where boats need to travel.

2
ciaocibai•

You’d better have got your money’s worth last ranked season, but as a kita player I was surprised how many potato Blacks were in game.

1
unclekisser•

I was too! I used Jutland to great success but I think most Black players had no idea what they were doing. It’s like they heard the ship was OP in ranked and never thought to ask why.

You smoke up. And use radar. That’s it. That’s what you do in the Black that makes it so good. Instead they would radar you 7 km out, start shooting and take a bunch of return fire while smoking up, and when they finally went invisible their radar had ended. Maddening.

2

Kind of dumb but:

Surprisingly did not like: Perth, when I first bought her roughly 1.5 years ago. Played one match in her and instantly regretted my purchase.

Surprisingly did like: Perth, when I took her out the other day. I only have a 5 point captain for her and I've only won like 2 in 9 or 10 matches but somehow something in me flipped over time and I really like her now.

​

2

What ship did you think you would love, but don't?

I had the choice to grind Mino or DM. I went for the Mino, and regretted it. When I get it right, I love the ship, but a lot of the time I have to lead too far to hit distant ships, that they are off the screen in binocular view, so I miss any direction/speed changes. A lot of the time I feel like I am firing 100s of shells just to land 10s of shells, especially if the red ship won't stay still. When I am distant from a red Mino that is shelling me, I just jiggle, knowing they will miss most of their shells, no matter what ship I am in.

I later went for the DM and love the ship all of the time.

​

What ship you thought you wouldn't, but do?

I can't really answer the question atm, because I kind of knew I would like the ships that I went for. The only ship I don't think I will like is the Moskva, based on what I have heard of it, so I have not bothered stepping up from the Donskoi which is a great ship. One day I will, so maybe at that time will be able to answer the question.

2
Lord_Viddax•

That is a shame to hear as the Mino was my first tier 10 and is still my favourite ship. Thing is the Mino has to hug cover in order to make sure it engages enemies at close range. Its engagement range is pretty much 10km as that’s the torpedo range, radar range (if using), and range at which the guns operate consistently without going into ‘death by a thousand plinks’ mode. It also needs to have concealment expert perk and concealment module to give you the best chance.
I’m saying this because I would like you to love it as I do, but can understand if you do not. Different ships for different peeps!

2

Oh close range is where I love the ship. And stealth AA is so much fun melting a whole squadron in seconds. Like I said, when I get it right, I love the ship. It just seems lately I am pushed out further than is ideal for the guns. The DM is far more forgiving from a positional perspective.

2
Lord_Viddax•

Guessing you are using the smoke version of the Mino. The ship relies on being pretty much a big destroyer so likes to have other cruiser support of bb support. Though with the current radar meta I thought the Mino would be pushed into closer ranges rather than away. Still, with the withering hail of fire though it may not get you any witherer awards it can plink the enemy into death or maknig a mistake out of annoyance.

1

I play both. But when most teams jump the Lemming train to the local A or C camp, radar becomes less effective because it's suicidal to go hunting solo in a Mino, and radar in the camp yields very little rewards. It is fun playing radar when you get support though.

The ship will remain hit or miss for me. I just had two really good matches in it, one with radar, and one with smoke. And that was on a week-end 😲 but I'm not taking that as a sign things have changed. Just luck of the draw lol

Tomorrow I will sail away from the spawn, a sea gull will shit on me a couple of times, and take two citadels of me 🤷‍♂️

1
Mauzeraut•

Thought I would love the Donny, but I couldn't quite find my place with it. It's a very awkward ship, though powerful, and a bit uncomfortable to play.

I bought the Stalingrad for clanwars thinking it was going to be a lot like Moskva, a ship I didn't do very well in (but played an essential role in CW), thinking it would play in a similar way.

Nope. Doing stupidly well in SG, but I can't brag about it because the ship is an absolute monster.

2
EchoblammoGlorious 792 m/s•

Surprisingly do not like: Langley

I got into carriers right before the rework hoping to hop in on that sweet sweet RTS gameplay and sky-cancer seal clubbing before the rework came around. It was fun for awhile while I grinded my way out to the Gearing.

Now I average out at about 16k damage a game and the baby seals club me. Feels bad man.

Surprisingly do like: Anshan

The Pan-Asian Destroyers never really caught my eye, even as a DD main, and the Anshan especially didn't being a Russian DD, which I hate almost everything about besides the maneuverability.

Yesterday I Kraken'd with her (almost got a 6th end game when we were all lobbing shells at a fleeing carrier but was robbed by a Baltimore) and dropped 4 the next. I'm not sure what it is about that ship, but I definitely click with it.

2