I know what the Censored item, "Something on a wall, in a black house" is. Decyphering Petscop? HERE WE GO AGAIN.

Finding

Alright boys, just gonna say some stuff before explaining:

​

  1. I'm not sure if the community even knows about this and it's common knowledge.
  2. Somebody on Youtube commented his find, but sadly, I wasn't able to find the source. So in no shape of form do I wanna say "oh this is all me", but I further have found evidence to support the thesis that I found on my own.
  3. Before telling you on what I believe to me 100% accurate on what the Censored item in Petscop 14 is, I'll try to theorize on the previous ones too.
  4. And lastly, I come to believe that if this is not common knowledge, this find mainly shows one thing: We just aren't connecting the given context pieces we get.

​

​

Let's do this:

​

THE FIRST CENSOR:

As the Petscop Doc explains, it maybe could be a Red Tool. Though I can't really believe that fact since then I wouldn't see why the proprietors would censor it only in "Paul's Room" but not the other's.

I think it's an object more according to what Nightmare Masterclass says here. It must be something that:

- Wouldn't concern any of us while normally seeing it (since Paul doesn't acknowledge the item as something out of the ordinary either)

- Probably helps the viewer to identify Paul

​

This is the only censored item I have no clue about what it could be, honestly. It seems very hard.

​

The "BROTHERS" Prologue:

​

First of all though, I kinda have to break this "stereotype" of "Rainer" being a good guy. I bet I could write a whole thread just about this, anyway;

​

If you re-watch all of the dialogues in which Rainer talks to the "For You" Person (a.k.a probably Marvin),

IN NO SHAPE OR FORM DOES HE EVER TALK TO HIM AS IF MARVIN DISGUSTS HIM.

​

Remember the first dialogue box you find from him talking to "You?":

"When you find her room, the passage to my right will lead to her." - MatPat definetely got it all wrong regarding Rainer. Does this sound like someone who tries to defend/support/save Care?

​

​

Want another example? Remember how Rainer's description of Care A said "When the emergency began, you were all looking for Care A. I told you all, we would never find Care A. When Care A goes missing, she goes missing forever."

This is what I believe: He only knew that looking for Care A was futile, since Rainer HIMSELF was an accomplice in abducting her.

​

I think his motives are to rebirth Mike. So he isn't trying to stop Marvin, but rather learn from him. He found evidence about Rebirthing, and he wants to make up for his brother. There are some things still sketchy here though. I have 0 clue what happened to Mike, so I'm currently guessing that Mike died through Marvin trying to rebirth Tiara. At this point Rainer did not know about Rebirthing, but only post Mike's death. After grieving over him (which we can see in many, many sections throughout the Petscop videos; that he's definetely depressed), Rebirthing is the only option Rainer sees.

​

Something else that's sketchy and I've seen NOBODY talk about is:

After one of the dialogue boxes the person that speaks from them reveals himself to be " - Rainer, Newmaker"

There is more evidence that concludes Newmaker to be a family name. Then why though is his "brother" called Michael Hammond? They are Half-Brothers. It's the only possible conclusion to get out of this.

​

Also regarding "She'll appear from the darkness, limping, and I'll shoot her in the head."

Remember this brightened up loading screen? (this is a marked one for convenience):

While it could be Jill (I'ma leave this as an open possibility since she's another female and I'm on to her sketchy ass),

I theorize this to be Care right before she'll get shot by Marvin. It would be rad if one of you guys could brighten the original and check whether there's a gunshot in that girl's head. Nonetheless, somebody also made a thread months ago about how if you brighten up the Pet Amber, she has something that looks like a gunshot wound hidden beneath her head.

​

​

THE SECOND CENSOR:

I think I know what this is, but y'all might not like this.

It's f-ing Mike.

Mike was a gift, remember? Also we can see Mike having multiple connections to Toneth in his description. "Stupid funny blob monster."

Also we know that people are treated like Pets in this game + remember Marvin's very first appearance? When Toneth just plops out of nowhere? You know what imagery was depicted before Toneth with a broken leg showed up? A gift.

​

It would also make sense in terms of Paul literally freaking out to what he is seeing. "Wh-What the fuck?"

​

So while I can't fully pinpoint it, we are probably supposed to see something that demonstrates Mike's death.

​

​

THE THIRD CENSOR:

As I stated before, this wasn't my find, but I found evidence that proves this finding to be true.

The 3rd censored item is, and I quote "Toneth with a broken leg, who is hung on a wall."

​

At first I had my doubts, but when you put stuff together, it makes so much sense. The following will be my find:

​

If you try to watch Toneth's description again, you will realize, that it first states "(Enter a description here)".

Which Mike (probably as a request and/or help) tries to do with his "blob monster" comment.

​

​

But what do we see after that?

​

"Painter. Painting Puzzle. -- Catch Randice first?",etc.

Pretty convinced that these are devnotes. Remember that at multiple occassions the creator of Petscop talks about how we shouldn't be able to catch Toneth yet, since he's not implemented (if you wanna rewatch it, here).

​

But guys, "PAINTER. PAINTING PUZZLE."

This is a huge hint to make us understand that Rainer wanted to connect Roneth in some shape or form with the "PUZZLE" (it's even mentioned like this in the game the first time it's presented. "Here's a puzzle for you, Marvin:...")

of overdrawing the image in the black house.

​

I bet my left butt-cheek that the censored item somehow depicts a hung Toneth, hence why he was censored.

​

"But why isn't Paul bewildered on this one then?" you may ask. It's because he wasn't able to see it the first time it was shown. Remember that he always had to go and wait for the demo of his "attempt" to show up.

​

What do y'all think?

​

​

​

(O N L Y R E A D B E L O W I F I N T E R E S T E D)

​

​

Other theories:

While I strongly believe that I know what the 3rd censored item is, these are just other theories I'll skim over.

​

Theory A:

The pets represent the relationships all human characters have to each other.

​

Toneth - Michael Hammond

Randice - Jill/Belle

Roneth - Paul (I'm implying that maybe, even though it sounds crazy, Rainer & Mike are half-brothers, while Paul & Mike are always half-brothers? *facepalm* that would be so obscure, but maybe Paul & Mike are just related, since Paul definetely pocesses his eyebrows.)

Amber - Care

Pen - Belle/Jill

Wavey - Rainer

​

Why Rainer is Wavey? Let's talk about: Through a letter we know that a wife was scared of her husband and that somebody hsould've stayed until he comes. We assume it to be Rainer. We see Wavey supporting Randice while Toneth isn't there. Randice could be Jill OR Belle since Rainer had (as we at least assume) interactions with both.

​

There's a really "yucky" part about Toneth's description. The repeating of just his name "Toneth". I at first believed this to be some sort of Anagram, but rather (I literally came up with this while writing the thread and re-thinking about Petscop) "Toneth" seems to be some sort of combination of words.

​

It kinda-ish would work with Wavey I guess? This could be a complete reach, but I always thought of:

​

"cloud" --> something that rains --> a "rain-er"

​

Now I rather believe it to be more according to:

​

"rain cloud" + "X" (If it was the case that Jill is Randice, maybe the "-er" of Provider?) = Rainer

​

Just like "Petscop" probably is made up of two words, maybe the other pet's names are also structured this way. I mean, Toneth's half-brother being called Roneth isn't a coincidence at all.

I'm just not good enough though to come up with neologisms for the other pets.

​

Theory B:

While we give Paul a lot of shit (rightfully so sometimes), I wouldn't trust him AT ALL. Watch this petscop sync.

​

I couldn't put it better than Youtube user "Dead Medic" said in the comments:

​

" 'You're in the other place too!' refers to the Even Care centre being connected to the Newmaker plane. As Paul changes the gates in front of Amber's cage, it unlocks the door to the quitter's room on the side he hasn't been able to get in before. It's basically saying that his actions in the surface world have an effect on the underworld, too. It's all connected - in the same way that the piano puzzle made reference to the petals of the daisy growing from CareNLM's head. As Above, So Below.

Paul saying 'Oh my god!' as he walks down the corridor, is his disbelief in finally figuring this out. He's saying "There you go" as if he's been given a hint, or at least had an idea that Amber's room has a similar symmetry to the Quitter's room."

​

​

I can imagine Paul to be a lying shyster quite well honestly. Or just not telling us everything he knows.

This also makes me wonder about the continuity of Petscop.

​

Theory C - Candice Newmaker:

People take the Candice Newmaker case waaaay too serious. I know that it's optimal to make a creepypasta about, but I'm wondering if whoever made the game really meant to reference that case. I feel as if people always think of the Quitter's Room as the "Candice Newmaker Reference". I believe it to be more than that. Also there's a whole other reason of why the person is called Tiara.

​

A symbolic meaning about Tiara: " The Tiara symbolizes that the person wearing it is considered to be a princess in God's eyes. "

​

Theory D - QUITTER'S ROOM:

Not sure if this is common sense and we're all on the same page with this.

I do not believe the other side of the Quitter's room to be mirrored. This may sound stupid if I say it straight like this but whatevs. Of course the room itself is mirrored and so are the words "Do you remember being born?", BUT I kind of have my doubts of believing that Belle and the other figure (= Pyramid head. Just gonna state it in here lmao: I think Pyramid Head is Mike, not Paul) in there are mirroring Paul's movements. I rather think that we are seeing previous movements of them, which they did in their playthrough.

​

Theory E - Marvin can't language:

This is overseen too much. While Marvin quite surely calls Paul "Pall" and Belle "Bell", because of a dictionary beingimplemented into Petscop's communication system, "Pall" could also be referring to "Pallbearer" or the "pall" itself. I always found it weird that people just assumed Marvin to know Paul's name.

​

Also see the meaning of just "Bell":

"a hollow metal object, typically in the shape of a deep inverted cup widening at the lip, that sounds a clear musical note when struck, especially by means of a clapper inside. "

​

"A hollow metal object" kinda fits the description.

​

​

Theory F - PRESS F FOR CARE = AMBER

​

It was before quite difficult to understand what's going on in the huge pixelated picture of that creature we find in the school. In the Petscop texture map Tiara shows Paul though, it's quite easy to identify. It's Care, wearing AMBER'S FREAKIN HEAD. People = Pets theory confirmed. Boom.

Posted Mar 5, 2019, 2:34 AM UTC

4421
franzythebadmemecatboy paul•

After one of the dialogue boxes the person that speaks from them reveals himself to be " - Rainer, Newmaker" There is more evidence that concludes Newmaker to be a family name.

newmaker is a title, not a family name. notice the comma, he wouldnt put it there if it was a family name.

itd also line up with tool calling the player the "newmaker", as yet again a title, one that theyve been granted

or care nlm's description with "you're the newmaker"

17
DrivenDustOP•

hm, true true. At the same time though I kinda think of "Newmaker" as a double entendre:

- Being a family name

- Being a title

​

Not sure if you knew this, but back in the day a lot of names were formed out of titles or job descriptions. I can definetely see Newmaker meaning both things. It's probably from my own experiences, but I even understand the families established in Petscop a bit different. In my hometown there are lots, like literally tons of families with the same last name that are connected to each other. I understand Paul's,Rainer's, etc. families to be the same.

5
franzythebadmemecatboy paul•

back in the day, as in centuries ago, yeah - its not that common nowadays

newmaker is clearly nothin more than a title to our knowledge, tho we do know that rainer and michael (and possibly paul, who may be care with mike's eyebrows) are related due to p12: if they're in the face system of the child library, they are "family". presuming rainer is the one who said that, itd mean hes family too.

5
DrivenDustOP•

Really? Maybe this is cultural difference, but as somebody that lived in Germany for his whole life, names like "Schumacher" (abbreviation of shoe maker) are still quite common.

​

After thinking about it though, you should be completely right about Newmaker just being a title. Up to this point though I might have suggestions, but it's never really clear what kind of relations Mike has to Paul and Paul has to Rainer. It's quite bugging me, because I am so sure that the actual Pets try to resemble the real life relationships.

5
franzythebadmemecatboy paul•

ig its still kinda common around there, but in terms of "newmaker" it doesnt seem to correlate with anything else like that.

its already been stated what their relation is, that theyre probably "family". now what "family" means could be up for some interpretation, but past that, who knows tbh

2
BaronVonCakeman•

Except that if you sign your name with a comma, typically you are putting your last name first. So by writing "Rainer, Newmaker", his name would actually be "Newmaker Rainer".

3
Wisielec•

Don't forget to fully quote this part of Toneth's description.

Has broken leg for some reason.
I already hung him on a wall, too
late to take it back. It makes me
think about the dog actually.
Because when the car hit him I
thought "at least it will be over
soon." He survived it, and I was
the only one who still wanted to put
him down.A dog is an innocent

​

There were several comments connecting this "painting puzzle" to Toneth.

​

I'm 90% sure that when the series ends, we will be shown (either directly or trough ARG) the uncensored and uncut footage of Petscop. Perhaps it will be the "family channel" that Paul once spoke about.

​

Probably once Petscop ends and we see the whole picture, everything will make sense... Hopefully.

​

The reason I believe so, is because there's too much cut footage, especially everytime when Paul touches a white block. I think once the series ends, we'll still have many unanswered questions, and this raw footage will be an answer.

​

Maybe the series will end abruptly and controversially, perhaps Paul actually showing himself in a neglected state or some shit (just throwing random ideas), then they let us see the whole picture. That's my prediction at least.

8
DrivenDustOP•

While I wish this would be the case, I wonder. That wouldn't feel natural to Petscop at all. Currently the series pretty much let's us interpret everything ourselves. The only "explanation" or hints to stuff we get is currently coming from Paul, and I'm also unsure to how much that holds up.

​

I might talk some time later over this weird af meta storyline of Petscop (because this is the thing that by far freaks me out the most), but in a way, regarding theories & findings it REALLY is kinda like Paul said. It's not that just the game, but this whole video series called "Petscop" doesn't really care if we try to make sense out of it or not. It doesn't care if we find synchs or try to put objects, colors & sceneries into context.

4
Truthwhatistruth•

I hate to be that guy but you said hung tineth heh heh heh

Seriously though..great insights. Im thinking you could be correct about the censors for sure

8
DrivenDustOP•

What really baffles me though is what the first censor could be. I though about it soooo much and it having a few red pixels beneath do not help even a tiny bit.

​

At some point I thought about that so much that I considered if Paul was maybe transgender, in a wheel chair or had an uncommon disease. The IRL "CRE Care" (just google it) also came up.

3
el-Dudo•

Loved your insights! Didn't notice that that image could be Care using Amber's hat. If true, it'd probably confirm inverted color theory, since it'd strongly link Care (yellow) to Amber (blue).

4
DrivenDustOP•

Thanks! Also while researching about the inverted color theory I found this image again by the awesome user u/jimjomshabadoo ! I think he's completely right about the gun wound.

​

https://imgur.com/a/LwPWwre

3
ReDaUlTrA567•

Dude i literally freaked out when I realized that the second censor could be mike !!! And it sooo make sense !!! what the f--- !!

4
theJohann•

This is a theory, not a finding, but nice read nonetheless. Some really interesting ideas!

3
tonisstorkus•

I'm generally happy when people see Rainer as a potential bad character. When I first observed the series, I thought it was more of a Stockholm syndrome-type relationship, where maybe Rainer was a somewhat good guy to the family that did something super messed up but was allowed communication over and over. I've said this before, but I think the 'real world' Petscop interactions are important on piecing together certain key elements, but we will never know all of the information.

​

A good thing to remember, too, is that written language does not express emotion unless it's clear of what it wants to express. We can't express sarcasm without implying it or if the idea is obvious enough. We can't express fluctuations and subtleties in a written format in a similar fashion as to how we speak (well, we can, but it gets convoluted), so a lot of what we have read can be interpreted a number of different ways. If we read it cold, we have one perspective on it, but we can't assume everything to be factual, we can't assume one tone of voice. Reading into it too much makes it difficult to interpret.

​

First Censor: Agreed. It could be something as mundane as a mouthguard, and there's not enough reaction from Paul besides a bit of hesitation. It's too difficult to state definitively what it is. A specific colour of tool, maybe Paul's favourite colour or something, could be the case. The other idea is this could be a red herring.

​

Second Censor: Makes sense, it's not a stretch of the imagination, really.

​

Third Censor: I feel like this is a bit too obvious, though. I want it to be more than that. I agree in the simplicity of the solution, but it feels too simple.

​

Theory A: I feel there's a relationship of the pets to the human elements, but to what end is another matter. I've had an idea where the actions of the pets corresponds, but we don't know enough about some of them (human elements) to make a full and proper guess.

​

Theory B: 100%. Paul is holding out on information, I don't think this is doubted. About what, though, is the real question. Those managing the channel are probably doing some amount of additional censorship which likely removes a lot of what Paul is trying to get out.

​

Theory C: I feel the Newmaker reference is a cross between a red herring and a way to make the material more grounded, feel more real. The connection is definitely eerie, and adds a lot of mystery to the whole thing, but I'll agree people have taken it a touch too seriously. Mind you, the recurring information from both definitely pushes the notion that there may be something more to it. A continued red herring? Maybe.

​

Theory D: In disagreement, although, I like the direction you're taking it.

​

Theory E: I think the idea that a limited word library existing that can be accessed and made use of makes the most sense here. A lot of theories about how the communication system works generally revolves around the phonetics helps this out, as well. Pall and Paul can be phonetically similar or the same. Tiara is generally thought of to be a word, not a name. Bell is a word, and Belle is a proper name. I think NAMES are not in this dictionary in the game, but the closest available word is. This is likely why Marvin is not said at any point, but rather the error that pops up ('Not in table.' with a different sound playing).

​

Theory F: I don't understand where you're going with this.

3
DrivenDustOP•

First of all thanks for the great comment dude!

Let me give some thoughts on it:

​

If you ask me, this is what I currently think about Rainer:

​

  1. He had a normal relationship to Care's family
  2. Something happened to Mike (*insert "That's a dead kid" joke*)
  3. Rainer's world view became either depressing and/or pessimistic at least
  4. He found evidence on Marvin knowing about rebirthing
  5. He desperately tries to Rebirth Mike

​

After I re-watched the creator's notes personally adressed to 'Belle' that makes a whole lot of sense. Something that all of us might be missing is that maybe(?) the "creators" or "developers" of Petscop kept changing during different periods.

​

​

Your observations regarding sarcasm definetely is remembering me about something that often goes over my head at least:

It's not only important regarding the 2nd censored item, but Petscop as a whole. Petscop itself is just a Youtube video series. Without us people, who try to make these connections, it'd just be the medium as is. That always blows my mind. I strongly have a feeling that Petscop literally plays on this idea and tries to play with our perception and connection of the us given context therefore. This exactly lead me to Theory D in a way. Before that though...

​

The 1st censored item:

This. What you just said is beyond crazy to me, because it sounds accurate as hell. How did you come up with it being a red herring? The Petscop Doc states that it might just be another red tool (shifting previous ones on the table would shift it to that exact same position). Because if you haven't seen Nitrorad talk about Red Herrings here, it's super crazy how both of you come to the same conclusion (though you are talking about different aspects of the game) and to the same stylistic device

​

2nd censored item:

While evaluating the context given to us prior to this, I'm kinda sure that except for the "I did this for Mike" speech, everything we get in connection to him could be seen in a sarcastic way. Then him being the censored item would make even more sense. And "I did this for Mike" could also be seen as something untrue then, since Rainer would've done the rebirthing for his own desires, not Mike's.

​

While I wrote the theories, I just wanted to tackle some stuff people already believe to be "the truth".

I wanted to show that even what we deem as "Basics" currently are still sometimes to interpretation.

​

Theory F summarized should just explain that the Pet = People theory is correct in terms of that the relationships & dialogs represent metaphors or give hints to the different human characters outside of the game itself. So it should support Theory A and give evidence to it being true. It's super difficult to say though which pet correlates to which character. But maybe you are right on just the actions of pets representing real life events.

​

While keeping what you said about "context" in mind, Theory D is really waking my interest. It's not really fleshed out at all, since I came up quite recently with it though. I mainly came to the assumption bc I had the same ideas you had regarding sarcasm mentioned above. We are in no shape or form told that the "Quitter's Room" is mirrored, 'nor that everything inside of it has to be.

As I tried to elaborate on before, I mean we can see that every object inside (except for characters, the white box being in the room + the paper with "do you remember being born" written on it) is mirrored in both rooms, but what we assume to be the "mirror" (the walls that split these two rooms; the right-most in the left room and the left-most in the right room) is just our assumption. Both rooms being connected may rather be a hint of two situations being the same, while the outcome is different (does that remember you about something? like maybe the bathroom scene with the white box disappearing? What a puzzle, heh).

​

Not much evidence on supporting this theory, but I did find something, though it's really tiny. So we kinda know from Paul's statement itself that Even Care=Newmaker Plane/Odd Care. I watched Petscop 1 again and checked Amber's room with the opposite one. Guess what? While both rooms look environmentally identical (by this I wanna say that in the Quitter's room chair & bed are identical with clock etc), the so called "Pieces" aren't.

Prior to Paul solving the puzzle he had 19 pieces. In Amber's room he finds 5 pieces = 24; after that in the opposite room he finds 6 pieces = 30; and then AFTER solving the puzzle he walks over the 6th piece of Amber's room = 31;

​

It is not clear whether Paul was able to obtain the 31st piece prior to solving the Puzzle and he was just sloppy prior. Also I would defend this and say that he wasn't able to pick up the last piece prior since we can be pretty sure that he has seen the Even Care part of Petscop multiple times before the first recording, otherwise he wouldn't know how to solve the puzzle.

​

Theory E always represents to me how different experiences and how subjective theories can be. I completely see how I am very probably completely false about this, but the first time I watched Petscop 16 rather than imagining the dictionary, what I thought out of this scene was how Paul's character didn't want to sit in that table. I know it sounds ridiculous in a way, but remember how Paul told the viewer's that sometimes there are "Demo recordings that explain mechanic's to the game in their reel"?

​

Yeah... I don't believe any of that. In no shape or form have we seen that to be evident in Petscop at all:

What we currently can be 100% assured of, is, that the game records prior game sessions (see Petscop 13 as proof), so I definetely believe that somebody also played the whole school & class segment. Though I don't believe that to be Paul at all.

​

So to me it seemed as if the person was forced to sit in the table/desk (people also speculate the green tool was Marvin leading Paul's character on in previous scenes), tried to refuse, gave in and "sat there for present".

On another occassion when we talked about gifts or presents it followed with a censored object. Now we see Marvin talking about a "present" again. Remember that another censored object, still about to be shown is "written on a chalkboard". Regarding the context that we will be given soon, I might be right.

​

Still I believe the dictionary explanation to be very agreeable to and very very correct, so I can totally see me just reaching at this point.

​

1
kslqlzzz•

Before telling you on what I believe to me 100% accurate on what the Censored item in Petscop 14 is...

If by 100% accurate you mean 100% confident then you’re gonna have a bad time. That picture being used as the main image, for instance... is dumb. You could find vague face shapes in most random images.

2
DrivenDustOP•

I'm not completely sure which picture you mean. But you mean the pic of the loading screen being marked for convenience, right?

I don't see how the shown picture in any way or form has to do with the 3rd censored item 'nor did I ever said it had to.

​

As I see it currently it's like this:

- I have completely no clue what the 1st item is; I wonder if it's even possible for us to find out

- Regarding the 2nd item, while I believe my explanation to be convincing, I can't be 100% sure on this at all; I just came to this conclusion by trying to recreate how we found out about what the 3rd item is

- The 3rd item: Come on! I really don't see how this couldn't be the case. Petscop gives subtle hints. I fear that some people wanna see or hear a "Oh the 3rd censored item is--!" While I saw some people here being optimistic about it, I doubt we'll ever see something like that.

4
Caylie_C𝚏𝚞𝚌𝚔𝚒𝚗𝚐 𝚓𝚒𝚕𝚕𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓•

I... I have no reason to believe this is wrong...

1
DrivenDustOP•

Do you mean it? lol

2
Caylie_C𝚏𝚞𝚌𝚔𝚒𝚗𝚐 𝚓𝚒𝚕𝚕𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓𝚓•

Yeah, I mean it

1