r/U2Band•
JamieAtWork

I was so wrong about Cedars of Lebanon

So, funny thing - It seems that the No Line on the Horizon cd that I bought when it came out ten years ago had a small but obvious defect on the last track. For years other U2 fans have been telling me how much they love Cedars, how it's such an amazing and beautiful song, and I've just sort of politely disagreed because I thought it sounded like complete crap. You see, the version of I'd been listening to had a really annoying off-beat click-track throughout the song, and the tempo would inexplicably slightly speed up or slow down, and I honestly just put it down to U2 trying to put an artsy finish on the very experimental album. I thought that the people who were professing so much love for it were just sort of being pretentious because they didn't want to admit that U2 had made a stinker and what I took as far and away their worst closing-track on any of their albums.

Well, I'm sitting here finally listening to my vinyl copy of No Line because I haven't had a good chance to just sit alone in a quiet space and listen to music since I got it, and what the hell!?! Cedars is pretty much a completely different song than the one I've been hearing for the last ten years - Different instrumentation getting through, consistent tempo, ungarbled lyrics. Holy crap! This song is amazing! One listen and I totally see what the rest of you have meant over the last decade, and I'm sorry that I misjudged your opinions.

Anyhow, just thought that was funny enough to share - I'm pretty much in total shock over how different the song actually is compared to what I thought it was. For ten fucking years! I can't believe it.

Posted Mar 6, 2019, 4:09 PM UTC

4421
Loading comments…