Scaling. The make or break equation, Why you should care
Hello from the Algorithmic Freelancers, the largest discord dedicated to theorycrafting for this game.
Like many of you I've been playing the game and watching all of the dev communication and interacting on Reddit. I care about this game and want it to thrive. Unlike many of you most of my 100+ hours has been killing a singular crab. Combined; our discord has number crunched most of what this game has to offer, we even number crunched the things with no numbers (looking at you combos). The following write up is based around our combined efforts and extensive game knowledge.
Basics of scaling
This game is level based and tier based at it's highest level. These are big picture things that affect everything about your javelin. Once you hit level 30 it becomes exclusively tier based and that is what I'll focus on.
Upon reaching level 30 every tier or rarity of gear has a set item level as follows: 30,32,34,36,45,47 . These levels affect scaling. Not only that but your highest level of equipped gear affects the scaling of your ult, combos, and melee.
As you can see everything is related to scaling. So why does scaling matter? It modifies the frequently used term "base damage". Now scaling is the only thing that affects base damage in the game. Luckily we have a formula for it.
Everything has a base damage, Usually a low number like 25 up to ult numbers that are in the realm of 1000. This essentially is your level one damage. Everything level 2 and above follows this formula
Scaled_Base_Damage = Base_Damage x Scaling_Constant ^ ( Item_Level - 1 )
this is true for everything in the game Also it's exponential
Firstly masterworks and legendary items break this rule and in the formula their ilvl is five less so 40 and 42 in the formula. And secondly the scale constant is proven to be 1.071.
for the rest of this post we assume you are using legendary gear. In this case we can simplify things to this formula
Scaled_Base_Damage = Base_damage x 17.15
every legendary gun does 17x more damage vs level one
every legendary ability does 17x more much damage vs level one
your combos do 17x more damage vs level one
your melee does 17x more damage vs level one
your ult does 17x more damage vs level one
this truly is the biggest factor affecting damage
Basics of Damage
So now that we have base damage we also need to include what modifies it to get the numbers we see in game. It's easy everything is additive
our formula is
Damage = Scaled_Base_Damage x ( 1 + sumof( Every_bonus_that_affects_that_item ))
The important thing to note is this.
The first +100% doubles damage. The second +100% (+200% total) will not double your damage as before The second +100% will net you a 50% increase over the +100%
The third +100% (+300% total) will give you this The third +100% will net you a 33% increase over the +200%
As you can see after +200% (a weapon inscription) you
a) will find anything under +100% to have little effect
b) no way of doing GM3 because after your initial +200% from the inscription there are no other big %'s
c) to double the damage from +200% you need another +300% or +500% total
How this Relates to Viability
Before they removed the numbers for GM 1,2 and 3 they were something like
+200% health for GM1 +400% health for GM2 +1000% health for GM3
So only Bioware knows the real numbers. But regardless we'll use these numbers to prove a point. Many of us have a Legendary weapon with a +200% inscription on it. Not accounting for suit bonuses. Take that weapon use it and get a feel for it.
In order for that weapon to feel the same in GM2 which has double the health of GM1 (theoretically if it's additive) you need to scrounge up +300% in suit bonuses
firstly since you already have used up the biggest bonus available you need to roll +damage on everything to even come close to 300%.
In the end a perfectly min-maxed build in in which you get +300% will feel like your base pistol in GM1
for GM3 (5x health of GM1) you need +1200% more damage in suit bonuses to make that weapon feel the same. Which is well impossible as it stands.
Additive bonuses are not viable in this system.
Solutions After Watching Today's Dev Stream
So I'm writing this post now because they talked about scaling, the context of course was related to melee and ultimate scaling but they also snuck in something about item levels and legendaries. Highest number mentioned was 67 so lets go with that.
Say a legendary was ilvl 67 or 62 in our scaling formula.
1.071 ^ 61 = 65.6
which is roughly 4x that of what we have currently (yay exponents) that's four times the base damage that we have currently
Now say we have that weapon with +200% damage as before, say its base damage was 100:
With the +200% it did 300 damage With another +300% it did 600 damage and for GM3 you would need +1200% to get 1500 damage
if they increased the item level here is how it would change:
base damage would now be 400 with the +200% it would be 1200 damage and to hit 1500 you would only need an additional +75% to hit 1500
Even if my math isn't exact this shows how them modifying scaling is the only way to make GM3 doable. It's either that or make Jav-wide inscriptions multiplicative.
In that case you would only need +400% in jav wide bonuses to hit 1500 damage. Which is doable but still very hard.
Some Math Examples
100 base damage with +200% inscription
300 = 100 x ( 1 + 2.0 )
400 base damage with +200% inscription
1200 = 400 x ( 1 + 2.0 )
Closing Remarks
Currently with all additive bonuses, we are unable to succeed in gm3 even with an endgame build. It appears Bioware has a good idea with increasing item level and in turn improving scaling but judging by the wording it appears they only want to modify ults and melee. I believe they should not only buff the scaling for ult and melee but rather everything. 67 item level would be a little overtuned but there is a middle ground between 47 and 67 that would make gm3 challenging but balanced.
the other option is making components and Jav wide inscriptions multiplicative. If this was done then Jav wide bonuses would be able to supplement the high local damage inscription instead of being dwarfed by it.
EDIT: devs I've done everything short of drawing a pentagram and slaughtering a goat, can we get word on how combo damage is calculated and word on everything being additive? u/benirvo
EDIT: thanks for the gold whoever gave it! It's my first one :)
Posted Mar 7, 2019, 1:48 AM UTC · edited