r/redesign•
cran

IDEA: Consider why the old reddit works so well before changing something

I tried the new reddit today and found it really hard to read. The large blue text of the old reddit serves a purpose. It makes the content the main thing you see. The new reddit is so cluttered with same-size/looking everything. It's like a basic phpBB website. Make things more unique. Not unique in the sense that everything has to have a same-sized/colored icon, unique as in: truly unique. Flirt with the crass if it makes the site more readable. Anger your repressive graphic design teachers! Everything doesn't have to be neat and tightly packed with a gazillion things to look at. Just the basics, given their own unique proportion corresponding to its usefulness and importance. We don't need icons to quickly change the layout right there in our face every single day. Make that something you change via preference somewhere deeply hidden away. Don't split the actual content up with arrows on the left and comment count on the right. Put them together and make them microscopic. The content is king! Bring it out! Lose the gray background filling in the space. Let it just be white ... it's unimportant and distracting!

Seriously ... bring the post titles out ... bigger, dominating, hide the small stuff.

Posted Mar 8, 2019, 1:34 AM UTC

3018
Droll_Papagiorgio•

Glad I'm not the only one. I can't stand the new Reddit.

12
snogglethorpe•

I think you may want to use the new one for a while before making any judgements....

7

I did, but while trying to figure out how to set up an email notification for when the page finished loading (maybe it'll finish loading this text post by the morning?) it got uncomfortably warm under my desk due to the CPU temps and the fans grew loud enough to wake someone up.

reddit.com is text and links (inc. links to images and multimedia). It should be a website progressively enhanced by minimal javascript; there is no reason for it to become a bloated javascript app that happens to look like a website, coming with several MB of JS so that I can read a text post.

I've recently switched to rtv and haven't looked back. Reddit is just plain text at its core; with rtv, I have keyboard shortcuts to open images and videos in an image viewer/video player, write comments in my favorite text editor, and send articles to my ereader.

6
Few_Purchase•

It's even more ridiculous - this basic almost-all-text site has been over-complicated to the point that they had to get the Chrome devs involved because it was exhausting GPU memory

8
CyberBot129•

It looks like they found a legitimate bug in Chrome. What's so bad about that?

3
Raptor007•

It should be a website progressively enhanced by minimal javascript; there is no reason for it to become a bloated javascript app that happens to look like a website, coming with several MB of JS so that I can read a text post.

It seems like every website has that problem these days. I browse with uMatrix to trim some of the crap, but it's disappointing how many pages won't render anything without miles of JS. Usually if I can't get it working by enabling scripts from a few domains, I give up and try another site.

1
TheChrisD:redditgold: Helpful User•

but it's disappointing how many pages won't render anything without miles of JS.

Hah, yea, that's a bit of a massive issue with the web these days. Can't browse half of the sites that appear in Google News on my phone because it just utterly fails to render because I have JS disabled for safety's sake (have had a few nasty experiences with rogue scripts trying to basically hijack phones before).

At least with sites like reddit and YouTube, there's dedicated apps...

1
Mashiki•

You mean besides it being a step back in terms of KISS? Something that multiple companies seem to be going through because there's an entire generation of UX/UI designers out there that weren't taught this fundamentally basic concept. That's not even counting on the other current flashy trend of new kids being hired with the mantra of "redesigns mean more eyeballs!" At which point the upper management in the company I work for said "At the expense of pissing off existing customers."

Look at it this way, Windows 8's UI disaster failed for a particular reason. Plex's UI disaster has failed for a particular reason. Slashdot's UI disaster failed for a particular reason. Digg's UI disaster failed for a particular reason. And so on. It wasn't an "end user problem."

4
kenabi•

Crap ui leads to product death at some point. The closer it gets to mystery meat, the faster it dies.

6
Mashiki•

True on that, just think though. There's someone that's signed off on it, including the geniuses that thought sticking "save" under 8 context menus was a good idea - because there was always some greater and important feature that just had to be at the top.

2†
hongkong_97•

ITT: Ugh I hate changes, I want my websites to remain outdated

7
cranOP•

The worst reason to change something is for change's sake. Just because something isn't new doesn't mean it doesn't work well. Understand what makes something work and preserve those things as you make it better. Don't just change things because they look old.

9
Mashiki•

How'd that work out for digg and myspace?

6
LaserRaisin•

Old reddit looks very mid 2000s

5
Blarg_III•

Yet it works better than most modern ones. Especially new reddit.

11
OPTCThunderbolts•

New Reddit barely works and is as ugly as a toothless hooker giving head.

0†
FidelisMundane•

Don’t fix what ain’t broke.

4
Boarbaque•

If it ain’t broke don’t fix it, especially when trying to fix it breaks it

2