Reducing Stress Concentrations in 3D Printed Parts
After lurking on this sub for the past few months, a common occurrence I have noticed in self-designed prints is components that have serious stress concentrations, especially those in load-bearing applications. Below are a few resources to help you learn what to avoid and what to shoot for when designing components to minimizing failures. Keep in mind, all of the following applies to materials and fabrication methods outside of 3D printing as well.
So, what is a stress concentration you ask?
As the name suggests, stress concentrations (sometimes called stress risers) are areas where stress is increased based on the geometry of the part. In nearly all applications stress concentrations are a bad thing, the main exception being when you want a part to break at a certain point. Well, what is stress then?
Without opening up too many cans of worms, stress is the amount of force per unit area. The ELI5 version is stress is what makes things break. Different materials have different resilience to stress and react differently to stress based on their material properties. Generally when 3D printing we are using plastic which has relatively weak stress characteristics (compared to, say, metals) so it is in our best interest to design components with minimal stress concentrations to have as few breaks as possible. In many 3D printing situations strength isn't of incredible importance, but keeping these things in mind at all times will only ever help your prints last longer and break less.
You may have noticed aircraft and ships have round doors, windows, and other features. This isn't just so they look cool. The rounded shapes provide minimum areas for stress concentrations and spread the stress out over a greater area. In any load-bearing situation we should be trying to minimize stress concentrations in our prints as well.
Generally the biggest things to avoid are sharp inside (concave) corners on parts, holes near walls, and grains that line up with high-stress points. Filets are your friend, and they should be on every inside corner. Even a small filet significantly reduces the stress in a corner. Make any holes you have in your parts well rounded on their inside corners, and all of this also goes for supports.
Sharp outside (convex) corners, in contrast, do not have the same effect, so keep those as sharp as you please.
The grain-esque structure of 3D prints also provides another avenue for stress concentrations to creep up. Each layer creates a small ridge between the previous layer which creates a small stress concentration. There are many ways to minimize the effects of these such as epoxying your prints afterwards, or various vapor baths depending on what material you are printing.
Hopefully this little bit of information helps you make prints that last longer and can hold a greater load. Happy printing!
Posted Mar 8, 2019, 6:06 PM UTC
Have to disagree with your last point on outside corners. Still the first point to fail on the outer part of a print. Also have to factor in internal stresses from additive manufacturing. Ever notice where parts split if there is bond failure between layers?
Chamfer or fillet everything if you can. Actually find chamfers to be better for anything in the Z as they provide more consistent wall thickness.